← Forum archive

Druid/Elder Druid

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

anthriel
Yeah idk how I feel about that either. Call me biased as a Slayer main. But I play a lot of Druid as well. I would be more interested in a pet for the Druid than being able to cast FF while morph'd that could totally change the balance in just about ANY group fight or 1v1. Especially if they can FF multiple times in events. It would make them the automatic go to class.

Edit note: As another suggestion. What about a /forage command? I'm this big ass Bear or Cat creature right? Why can't I eat some tree saplings for mana or dig around into a fallen tree trunk for grubs and health?


As someone who is a Druid main and loves Druids I prolly don't think it's necessary to have them be able to cast anything during morph ... Of course being able to FF in morph would be a great benefit to them but I'd rather see more nuanced developments for them - such as a pet like Adramelk suggested (it's annoying to solo level them), a skill to either track or break track while morphed, or perhaps most of all a tweak to bear form and /roar so it's actually useful for something (let's face it, pretty much no one uses bear in pvp or pve)
daedroth
Bear form should be stronger and tougher than cat form.
Cat form should be more agile/quicker.
I still find it strange that the cat forms are stronger than the bear form.
NiteHawk
Bear form should be stronger and tougher than cat form.
Cat form should be more agile/quicker.
I still find it strange that the cat forms are stronger than the bear form.


Well I can readjust the FF thing.

In any case bear was meant to be the tank, and cat the dps. Forage and other things like that have already been talked about. I don't think /roar is generally bad as it is something to soak up DPS for your team. Maybe it's just that alot of areas you don't really 'need' a tank right now.

For pets, it's kind of up in the air on that, I don't really think they need one. Unless we rework bear form as a pet would obsolete the tank form and DPS wise I think they're pretty OK. With a proper weapon they're just under cavaliers in cat form. Bear form could have some reworking for damage/etc but I still think it has its uses.


I'm not sure how I feel about splitting up AGI and STR and nixing the tank idea. If that was the case it would be bear with higher damage, no agi gain or -1,-2 agi, vs a cat with a decent amount of agi points with a middle ground damage boost. Then I could see the pet being something.
NiteHawk
Even if pets for druid was allowed, the chr if the pet modifier

How many druid went 10 chr? Lol


It's still a damage soaker. Just like all pets.
Folder
If you make that FF change I suggest allowing hiding class to hide while FF'd to balance it out, otherwise elders are simply too strong. But I think it's just not needed anyway, my opinion.

Cat form is stronger because STR is the damage modifier, it's not for lore reasons lol. Sometimes things need to not make sense in a realistic way for them to work in the game environment. If Bear form did more damage and also took less damage why would anyone ever use cat?
daedroth
... Cat form is stronger because STR is the damage modifier, it's not for lore reasons lol. Sometimes things need to not make sense in a realistic way for them to work in the game environment. If Bear form did more damage and also took less damage why would anyone ever use cat?

Because bear would have less agility, get him more and hit things less often. Sorta dwarf vs ling I guess.
Reaper
I'm all for making bear form the dominate form. This is just because I like the bear form better. That being said, please do not split up the stats. It would make elders a not so good at anything class I think. Cat form is the only form that stands a chance in pvp, and even that loses more often than not. If you change anything keep the cat like it is and give the bear the same str. This would be a tradeoff of agi for end/ac but make them both useful. You could even modify the end/ac gain to be lower if you felt that would be too good.
Lateralus
On the topic of druids is there any point not to make an elemental druid atm?



Unmorph Cat Bear
Str 14 31.99 27.493
Agi 19 22.78 21.596
Ac 38 78 104
End 20 20 23.0336


Pretty much the best in every aspect (since agi doesnt matter much atm). As a player im not sure why id make anything besides an elemental.
Styx
Already nerfed dwarf , which race you want ? There will always be something on top, that's why people don't make lings any cause the Dodge got needed so no point to make lings. Unless it's for role play name value

BTW gnome is 2nd in dammage but has better agility. But since agi changes of ling vs high str eh you know
NiteHawk
On the topic of druids is there any point not to make an elemental druid atm?



Unmorph Cat Bear
Str 14 31.99 27.493
Agi 19 22.78 21.596
Ac 38 78 104
End 20 20 23.0336


Pretty much the best in every aspect (since agi doesnt matter much atm). As a player im not sure why id make anything besides an elemental.



I mean, I dunno if I really agree with you. Lings deal overall more damage because of HR. 25.3 agi and 26.2 str.

27.4 is about 147-196
26.3 is 142-189

So it's 5-7 damage more per hit.

AGI wise, 22.78 to 25.3. You're looking at 5.04% more dodge and 5.04% more HR.

There is a question about END, but that is more of the races fault I think, but doesn't really affect cat form. But yeah missing HP could be the link on why elementals feel better to use. Maybe they should have a base of 19 END.
Reaper
Oh gods pls don't nerf the elementals. I'm already 0/8 in 1v1 fights. The last thing I need is less health. Plus nerfing elemental health is horrible considering how bad their other stats are aside from making them druids that is.
anthriel
On the topic of druids is there any point not to make an elemental druid atm?



Unmorph Cat Bear
Str 14 31.99 27.493
Agi 19 22.78 21.596
Ac 38 78 104
End 20 20 23.0336


Pretty much the best in every aspect (since agi doesnt matter much atm). As a player im not sure why id make anything besides an elemental.



I mean, I dunno if I really agree with you. Lings deal overall more damage because of HR. 25.3 agi and 26.2 str.

27.4 is about 147-196
26.3 is 142-189

So it's 5-7 damage more per hit.

AGI wise, 22.78 to 25.3. You're looking at 5.04% more dodge and 5.04% more HR.

There is a question about END, but that is more of the races fault I think, but doesn't really affect cat form. But yeah missing HP could be the link on why elementals feel better to use. Maybe they should have a base of 19 END.


Isn't the correct comparison for Cat actually 32 STR (Ele) vs 26ish STR (Ling)?

My general observation tends to agree with Lat etc... Elemental is probably premier choice due to Agi being less significant, combined with high END/WIS potential of Elementals and how low INT (15 and under) don't tend to suffer much for it compared to elves/gnomes who invest in 17-18 INT...

In general the scaling of how much wisdom affects a Druid morph probably means a high wis Elemental can cover all their racial weaknesses (low Agi and Str) while still enjoying their racial strengths (higher End for spellcaster race)

That's my perception anyway
Lateralus

I mean, I dunno if I really agree with you. Lings deal overall more damage because of HR. 25.3 agi and 26.2 str.

27.4 is about 147-196
26.3 is 142-189

So it's 5-7 damage more per hit.

AGI wise, 22.78 to 25.3. You're looking at 5.04% more dodge and 5.04% more HR.

There is a question about END, but that is more of the races fault I think, but doesn't really affect cat form. But yeah missing HP could be the link on why elementals feel better to use. Maybe they should have a base of 19 END.



I think you are right this is more of an issue of agi and end balance i believe. Just looking at the stats you would say hmm more damage and almost 3agi compared to 3-4 more end seems like halflings might have the advantage but its not really the case. Im not saying elementals should have less but maybe look at how agi fairs? right now everyone knows agi doesnt matter much so pretty much everyone is making dwarfs for pretty much every class besides druid (elementals there) because agi doesnt matter much and wis needs to be high.
Reaper
I actually see where NH is coming from on the agi. If you make it matter too much it would just be reversed. Everyone would just play halflings. I think it does need to be increased, but it has to be a careful increase.


The biggest factor in a fight seems to be just plain luck. I tried to attack someone on my elemental elder and missed 10/12. I witnessed a HO slayer round 3 people in a row. I've missed 5 backstabs in a row on a 23 agi de vs a 19 agi HO. I think it is scenarios like these that make people believe agi isn't important. If you have a 8% better hit rate it sounds nice on paper, but there is still a 92% chance your gonna get hit or miss the same as the other guy. If he gets a ton more health and str or Mr...that 8% doesn't sound so great.
anthriel
I guess regarding the observations on Elementals in light of the other thread on dodge/hitrate/Agi, the reason they are probably the premier choice for Druid is because wisdom is their highest stat and they an still retain decent End despite pumping it. For gnomes who excel in Intelligence and halflings who excel in Agility, their +1 max in these stats over other races usually causes them to suffer penalty in End... Elementals suffer the penalty instead in Str and Agi, which is then more than adequately compensated for by the high Wis effect on their morph... So you end up with a super Str, decent Agi char with decent End, all due to the single stat of Wisdom. That is the reason Elemental Druids are premier/popular - because of the scale to which wisdom currently affects morph gain.

I'm not suggesting to nerf/change anything etc... Just pointing out that as a race/class combo under current mechanics they largely manage to cover almost all weaknesses whereas other classes are prone to having at least 1 remain (ie an Elemental Druid in morph have 24wis for MR, 22+ Agi for HR/dodge, 32 Str for damage and 20 End for HP etc and out of morph can still cast spells reasonably ok with 15int cos INT doesn't seem to matter that much). If this was to be balanced then the scaling of Wis on morph might need to bee re-examined but this would likely affect other races of Druid adversely too... It's probably just the fact that they can access 24 Wis and retain decent End that makes them so good as Druids
Lateralus
Speaking of the 32 str.

Now that we can do decimal values for str can we just have str actually show what it is on morphed druids instead of an weirdly inflated number that doesn't really represent what the damage is and makes power useless on them?
daedroth
Speaking of the 32 str.

Now that we can do decimal values for str can we just have str actually show what it is on morphed druids instead of an weirdly inflated number that doesn't really represent what the damage is and makes power useless on them?

Aye, the STR thing is weird.
It would be better if the increase to STR from morph was less, but meant more.
NiteHawk
Speaking of the 32 str.

Now that we can do decimal values for str can we just have str actually show what it is on morphed druids instead of an weirdly inflated number that doesn't really represent what the damage is and makes power useless on them?

Aye, the STR thing is weird.
It would be better if the increase to STR from morph was less, but meant more.


Doesn't work like that, not a damage multiplier for no reason and honestly makes 0 sense to have 60 str druids. What a mess.

Now that we can do decimal values for str can we just have str actually show what it is on morphed druids instead of an weirdly inflated number that doesn't really represent what the damage is and makes power useless on them?


That's what AD is for. Why is power useless on them? Str will display what their current STR is, it's gonna stick to how it is. AD shows your average damage. I'm not even sure what you mean by that anyways, it is their STR; its not a random number? Making str display differently regardless for no reason is a hassle to adjust as the system doesn't work like that anyways.

Honestly, I think it's fine, its one decimal point, part of strength. if 1 strength gives you 6 damage, then 0.5 strength gives you 3 damage. Bonus strength is the same with spells, songs, etc. If I remove it from one, it removes from all. There is no damage multiplier bonus that happens on morph, and never will be.