← Forum archive

Quality of Life Changes to /hide and Backstab Mechanics

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Tucker
Curious what the community thinks of redoing Hide, Sneak, and most importantly the /backstab mechanics.

As I understand it the concept of not being able to /hide in the same square twice was originally a balance mechanic rather than an immersion based change. Problem is this is balance by frustration essentially. This seems to be a strange fix since as we all know you will immediately move out and back into the square to repeat backstabs.

This mechanic is mildly annoying for PvP but really annoying for leveling and PvE. It seems like most players are in the same boat of dreading leveling Assassin's due to this mechanic. It drags mobs around every single turn, delays leveling, and is generally annoying as hell.

Builders are having to build cheeky fake room moving mechanics that instantly let you move out and back into the room without really leaving which is a clever work around but only applies to the room its built in. It is a great band-aid fix but why not just fix the core issue?

Proposed Changes:

Make backstab a 2 endurance command. It is a 2 endurance command that either attempts to crit for 4x or 3x depending on the class. (You could call it something else for the bow crit I guess too or even rename the mechanic to something to indicate a more general critical strike?)

This could potentially leave room to tinker with the /hide and /autosneak mechanics if anyone wanted to do so. It is weird that sneak and hide are both stealth mechanics that behave a bit differently but with /hide being unnecessary for backstab you could combine the functions into something sleeker like /sneak essentially replacing /hide at one endurance cost for sneaking in the room causing you to become hidden. /sneak could have directional triggers for sneaking costing endurance.

The whole hidden vs invisible mechanic seems very weird that you can be invisible via sneak or fade yet attacked. Thematically and with gameplay reasons it would make more sense to combine them into just one hidden feature and balance as needed. Sneak could actually be a hidden state that you have to search for to attack but costing an endurance per tile. Fade can be balanced easily as well (afaik the attacking without breaking fade thing was fixed).

Devils Advocate Arguments:

This would buff classes that use the backstab mechanic since they would now be entering one command instead of four and bumps their dps.


Simple: Nerf the endurance regen a touch for Assy/Slayers to mimick the changes. You could leave Thieves out of it and let them enjoy a small buff and I'd wager the community would be happy. You could ship this change with a nerfed endurance regen to the Assy/Slayer class or simply wait to see if the buff is impactful enough to deserve a small balance nerf.

What about locked down rooms that are build to prevent more than one backstab? This would break that mechanic. Staff/Builders might want certain Event, OAD, or Quest rooms to not allow backstab for balance reasons possibly.


There are so many ways to balance this that are all pretty simple. Events? Don't allow the class. If you prevent Slayers from backstabbing in an event they won't win or enter it anyway - just ban the class. Or use a room that doesn't allow for backstab commands. For OAD, quest, or event rooms you can simply balance it by making a room not allow backstab or making the Mob take reduced damage from backstab. This all can be determined case by case as is needed. I don't think backstab is that crazy op but if it is deemed so just balance it like any other mechanic.
Lissy
my biggest complaint about this is that you'd lose the tactical ability to hide on your last stamina point then backstab for one attack at the start of the next round. I think you could fix this more easily by just allowing /hide again in the same room, possibly making it have a failure option based on int or something. I'm not really convinced it needs fixing, but I haven't played my assassin enough to really have a perspective on this.
Tucker
by just allowing /hide again in the same room, possibly making it have a failure option based on int or something.


Yeah, that'd be a really good fix I kind of like the idea of /hide having a failure chance. You could actually use that as a balancing mechanic as I mentioned with like OAD rooms or event rooms having a higher failure rate than your average forest, sewer, cave, whatever. The rate could be like very low potentially 1-5% for 10int heroes but even less for higher int. That could scale with the custom rooms maybe multiplying the int stat success rate bonus or something. That'd be cool too since there's not much stat versatility for the class atm since they have like no MR to boost with wis and int only helps prevent being found.

Edit: It's definitely a QoL change but leveling Assy's is pretty annoying compared to the other classes mainly do to dragging mobs.
Tucker
Discussed to death. Check the forums.


Yeah, wild, it's almost like the mechanic sucks and people dislike playing the class as much with it as is <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />

The official word I'm seeing from the Hawk man is this:

I don't think I'd give slayers 4x + 10% without that delay though. The delay helps balance it out really, since you use two attacks, you get 4.5xish in damage as a return. (in general /hide then attack, but then 4x damage.)


Which I did mention as finding easy to balance with an endurance regen reduction (we know the mechanic exists due to the racial bonus humans have to increase that). Doing so and leaving Thief's alone would be a buff to them and I bet the community would like that as well.
daedroth
Which I did mention as finding easy to balance with an endurance regen reduction (we know the mechanic exists due to the racial bonus humans have to increase that). Doing so and leaving Thief's alone would be a buff to them and I bet the community would like that as well.

TBF that is something no one mentioned before in earlier discussions (I never thought of it; my thoughts were attack delay, but stamina regen slow might work) and I think it sounds good.

Or I did until I remembered the mechanics as is. Jump out, jump in backstab. The slower stamina regen wouldnt matter... let me see if i can explain it right.
Without some kind of delay to the attack mechanic an assassin would get off two x4 damage attacks quick, does not matter if the attack costs 2 stamina, they would still get of the attacks very quickly without the in/out hide stabbity bit. They would just take longer to act again. Does not sit well imo.
Combining the /sneak /hide does not quite work either. You would sneak 4 squares then be exhausted.

Its an annoying mechanic I agree. It is just hard to think of a way that would be fair to all.

Previous discussions (happy reading, or not... you better read though I had to look back for these <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_evil.gif" alt=":evil:" title="Evil or Very Mad" /> ):
<a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1374">viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1374</a>
<a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1093">viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1093</a>
I am sure there was more... probably are, I just give up for now.

I think this:
Backstab has a cool down, before it can be used again.
Do not need to move out/in, but still need to /hide (argument against that is no one has a chance to /search you out, but you need to be extremely luck or have lightning fast reflexes to do that anyway; or assassin user is really slow) or it just does less damage - but then you lose the chance of rounding someone (unless they are lower level or already wounded) or (again) slight delay between /hide and the attack (to simulate the out/in bit).
Flank/critical attacks chance for every normal attack (or flank/critical hit always, but consume 2 stamina and do less damage than backstab). This would be handy if the in/out mechanic is kept and you are in a locked room.
Tucker
You bring up a really good point about the lack of delay between the two backstabs. It would really increase the chance of people getting rounded since there's less chance to heal or pot up between backstabs.

Adding a delay to the stamina regen like you mentioned would keep the dps the same but it would be applied in a tight burst rather than spread out with a bit of response time. I do like the idea of maybe just adding a small delay .5-1 second? I'm not sure how quick a player can go east, west, /hide, and attack but i'd imagine its pretty damn quick so the delay wouldn't have to be a lot. Paired with removing the need to leave the room that might be a really good compromise to balance and the qol fix.
daedroth
You bring up a really good point about the lack of delay between the two backstabs. It would really increase the chance of people getting rounded since there's less chance to heal or pot up between backstabs.

Adding a delay to the stamina regen like you mentioned would keep the dps the same but it would be applied in a tight burst rather than spread out with a bit of response time. I do like the idea of maybe just adding a small delay .5-1 second? I'm not sure how quick a player can go east, west, /hide, and attack but i'd imagine its pretty damn quick so the delay wouldn't have to be a lot. Paired with removing the need to leave the room that might be a really good compromise to balance and the qol fix.


There have been many times I have saw an idea that sounded good, then i thought, wait a minute what about... also there have been many times I have posted "great ideas" only for someone to point out flaws, and I am thinking oh yeh... I never thought of that *hides* <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />.

Anyway, yeh the slight delay would reflect the in/out time and give someone a chance to /search. So it would roughly be the same in the end.

Sadly... due to the fact this has been debated several times in threads, it does not look like it is going to be changed (or it would have been by now... maybe... I mean NH did mention going through each of the classes and reviewing them; as he has with rangers, so maybe still hope!).
Tucker


Sadly... due to the fact this has been debated several times in threads, it does not look like it is going to be changed (or it would have been by now... maybe... I mean NH did mention going through each of the classes and reviewing them; as he has with rangers, so maybe still hope!).


It seems like being such a common point of discussion would indicate that the community would like to see this mechanic changed. I've seen a lot of the same sentiment that this class is frustrating to level and PVE which can be remedied by removing the limitation hiding in a room more than once and then balancing in whatever way is agreeable and easy to implement.

Like I mentioned the mechanic was born out of a terrible balancing decision (made like 13~ yrs ago?) . The fact that the game is under new ownership with new development means we can balance the game in more user friendly and elegant changes. Lowering skillcap things for the sake of usability is one thing - but this limitation has never even had the benefit of upping skillcap, just being annoying lol

Edit: Like you said though if this gets revisited hopefully its clear from community response that they would like to see it changed and that it shouldn't be too tricky to balance after removing
Tucker
Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I like it just how it is with hiding and stabbing.


Hiding and stabbing is fine its more the force movement that people dislike that could be changed. I was just making a suggestion tas an example of how it could be balanced there's multiple fairly simple ways to remove moving out/in a room without screwing up balance on Slayers. Builders have been putting in work around rooms like in Dreadlands and Raider Leader room that clearly show the forced movement mechanic sucks and is being built around instead of just fixing the core problem.
Eld
Before i was strongly in favour of this being changed so you didn't have to move off the square to stab.
My favoured way of balancing it was so there was a delay after each /hide and each /backstab, i went into a buncha detail on this on the previous thread linked above.


However...

After playing a slayer more i do kinda like that slayers are different from other classes, and i think this is something we need to make sure every class has, so there's a bit more variety to attacking rather than the same command each time.
Tucker
Before i was strongly in favour of this being changed so you didn't have to move off the square to stab.
My favoured way of balancing it was so there was a delay after each /hide and each /backstab, i went into a buncha detail on this on the previous thread linked above.


However...

After playing a slayer more i do kinda like that slayers are different from other classes, and i think this is something we need to make sure every class has, so there's a bit more variety to attacking rather than the same command each time.


I mean I feel like thats going in the wrong direction with it but so long as every classes is equally annoying it'll be fine. For Monks to RH they have to open command prompt and telnet to the server IP. Maybe for Enchanters to cast stoneskin they could copy paste a java popup from one text field to another <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Clerics could unequip and requip their weapon before each rd perhap!
Lateralus
Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I like it just how it is with hiding and stabbing.


Yea me too. I think most areas have added up down rooms if not bosses should have them. It takes a bit of skill to play an Assassin which I like.

Maybe for the people who don't want to hide and backstab they could have another 2 action attack called stike that did 2.5-3 damage.
Tucker
Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I like it just how it is with hiding and stabbing.


Yea me too. I think most areas have added up down rooms if not bosses should have them. It takes a bit of skill to play an Assassin which I like.

Maybe for the people who don't want to hide and backstab they could have another 2 action attack called stike that did 2.5-3 damage.



I don't think moving right left is too high skill for people <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" /> Slayers aren't an especially high skill class - higher than Monk, Knight, Barb or pure melee fighters, but I'd say just about any casting class (save druid maybe) is much higher skill.

I wanna repeat that the focus of my suggestion isn't to remove /hide but to remove the forced movement restriction. Changing /hide was a balance suggestion for after you remove the forced movement restriction, but there are other ways to balance it without removing /hide at all.

The issue that needs fixed is that there is zero reason for the move restriction to exist. It doesnt make lore sense and isn't necessary for balance reasons. It slows down and is annoying with leveling and PVE and either forces builders to redesign rooms or makes the class shit for OAD'ing
Folder
PREACH IT TUCK.

I said all this before, as have others. We are "used" to the back and forth shit but it still feels dumb. Ruins the class on a number of squares, feels clunky, and is basically only there because of nostalgia. We can do better imo.
daedroth
Yea me too. I think most areas have added up down rooms if not bosses should have them. It takes a bit of skill to play an Assassin which I like.

Maybe for the people who don't want to hide and backstab they could have another 2 action attack called stike that did 2.5-3 damage.


But there shouldn't need to be those kind of up down rooms... it is just silly that it needs to be added, and implemented, so that one class can use its main attack otherwise that class cant be used well in that area.
Either the mechanic of backstab should change, and/or as you, me and many others have stated, there should be an alternative to backstabbing that keeps assassins competitive in the times where they cant move (or in certain cases are lagged - yeh it still happens depending on your isp/computer etc).
Miach
I'm going to add something very serious here and it plays into everything.

When a Slayer is forced to move in and out, it gives a chance for others to detect him through looking around and forces him to use autosneak to remain undetected when moving, which can burn up and cause an exhaust round.

The movement mechanic is needed for backstabbing, it does so much more than just re-hide when you REALLY think about it.

So no, I am not in favor of changing Slayers. They need to be a little harder to play, and, to be quite honest, I still find them easy.

The up/down rooms are not so bad, and not hard to implement.

You're narrow focusing on the backstab mechanic and not thinking about the whole picture and how that movement affects a variety of interactions regarding the Slayer.
Tucker

You're narrow focusing on the backstab mechanic and not thinking about the whole picture and how that movement affects a variety of interactions regarding the Slayer.


I'm literally only focusing on the movement. The movement is the thing people want to see changed. As I've mentioned any other mentioned potential changes are thrown out as balancing options after removing the restriction.

When a Slayer is forced to move in and out, it gives a chance for others to detect him through looking around and forces him to use autosneak to remain undetected when moving, which can burn up and cause an exhaust round.


What? I actually am not sure what you're trying to describe here. The only incentive a Slayer has to autosneak is for the first backstab right? After that he is visible from his attack and by looking at the room or the list of units in the room to the right. Why would he then leave autosneak on when leaving and reentering the square for his second backstab of the round?

I suppose if you're fighting with hit and run style tactics you'd want to leave it on i.e. a mosh or fighting outnumbered. Sure the forced movement removal would make Slayer's exh less often in this situation but wouldn't Slayer's just turn it off before out/in movement anyway? It's easy to macro and costs no stamina to toggle.

The movement mechanic is needed for backstabbing, it does so much more than just re-hide when you REALLY think about it.


The movement mechanic is not needed for backstabbing. Why would it be? You're right when I REALLY think about it drags mobs around the map making playing the hero annoying as shit compared to literally any other class. It also makes them useless in any locked room without a fake ladder, when I REALLY think about it.