Ciruin Credit Union
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Okay so here's how it works:
You have the ability to invest gold into a specific city's bank. To do so, you pay a fee each week or month based on a % of the gold you have. On top of that, there is a fee to store items in the bank's vault (say something like 10g per vaulted item). There is an item withdrawal fee if you withdraw from a different bank than the one you deposited it in (think ATM fees). You then get weekly or monthly dividends based on how well the bank does, which comes from the fees and is split between the "credit union members" (minus a small % that is kept by the bank). The trick is that you have to log in sometime during that week to collect your dividends.
The benefits:
- It discourages people from simply storing gold in the bank and moves the gold around. Loyal members who store more gold in the bank -
get bigger dividends.
- This is a good way to slowly reduce the amount of gold in the game and keep the economy stable.
- It encourages people to log in both to ensure they have enough gold in the bank for the fee and to collect their payment.
Considerations:
- If someone does not log in over an extended period of time and is unable to put more gold into their account to cover the fees, maybe the bank could repossess something from the vault stored in that bank (random). If they don't have anything in the bank's vault, their account is just closed.
Thoughts? This would obviously a pretty tall order, but I think it could create an interesting dynamic in the game. The surplus required to make it work would have to come from the vault fees. Otherwise, there would be no dividends (if you account for the bank's rake).
You have the ability to invest gold into a specific city's bank. To do so, you pay a fee each week or month based on a % of the gold you have. On top of that, there is a fee to store items in the bank's vault (say something like 10g per vaulted item). There is an item withdrawal fee if you withdraw from a different bank than the one you deposited it in (think ATM fees). You then get weekly or monthly dividends based on how well the bank does, which comes from the fees and is split between the "credit union members" (minus a small % that is kept by the bank). The trick is that you have to log in sometime during that week to collect your dividends.
The benefits:
- It discourages people from simply storing gold in the bank and moves the gold around. Loyal members who store more gold in the bank -
get bigger dividends.
- This is a good way to slowly reduce the amount of gold in the game and keep the economy stable.
- It encourages people to log in both to ensure they have enough gold in the bank for the fee and to collect their payment.
Considerations:
- If someone does not log in over an extended period of time and is unable to put more gold into their account to cover the fees, maybe the bank could repossess something from the vault stored in that bank (random). If they don't have anything in the bank's vault, their account is just closed.
Thoughts? This would obviously a pretty tall order, but I think it could create an interesting dynamic in the game. The surplus required to make it work would have to come from the vault fees. Otherwise, there would be no dividends (if you account for the bank's rake).
NO. Per request on discord
NO. Per request on discord+1
People will always find loopholes. All you are making the player to do for the most case is create storage alts that don't have any need for interest or gold interest. It wouldn't really work out and most people will just have a base of operations, probably in Seamoor.
If people logged in and realized they lost half their gold in interest because they left the game as well, I think thats more of a means to making players quit. I don't think a system like this would make players 'stay'. Rather, a banking system isn't a reason players would want to continue playing our game and logging in.
If people logged in and realized they lost half their gold in interest because they left the game as well, I think thats more of a means to making players quit. I don't think a system like this would make players 'stay'. Rather, a banking system isn't a reason players would want to continue playing our game and logging in.
People will always find loopholes. All you are making the player to do for the most case is create storage alts that don't have any need for interest or gold interest. It wouldn't really work out and most people will just have a base of operations, probably in Seamoor.
If people logged in and realized they lost half their gold in interest because they left the game as well, I think thats more of a means to making players quit. I don't think a system like this would make players 'stay'. Rather, a banking system isn't a reason players would want to continue playing our game and logging in.
I get that. I just see or want to see two things:
1. Some sort of passive income
2. We need something similar to houses in rok that forces people to log in and generate/pay gold to keep their stuff
Of course this is a super long shot and I'm sure there are some ways that this can be exploited that I haven't thought about.
Some ideas:
Currency Value changing - problematic since there is only gold.
The value of the currency based on how well the city is doing (but this would need some kind of trade/economy simulation), but it opens up the potential for quests (trade quests - escort/trade/raid for each of the cities - sadly it seems that all the cities are at peace and ruled from Aldernan).
Ack, nm.
Currency Value changing - problematic since there is only gold.
The value of the currency based on how well the city is doing (but this would need some kind of trade/economy simulation), but it opens up the potential for quests (trade quests - escort/trade/raid for each of the cities - sadly it seems that all the cities are at peace and ruled from Aldernan).
Ack, nm.
Passive income. Lol nu.
Houses are already at work. So are clan houses. Both however do require monthly fees and will be buildable. Houses might have 2x2 or 3x3 depending on how we do it. Clan houses will require alot of gold, have unique rooms, and with the global ember/clans wars, will probably require rebuilding from attacks from time to time.
I have a post about Clan Wars somewhere in Core you can probably read about it.
Houses are already at work. So are clan houses. Both however do require monthly fees and will be buildable. Houses might have 2x2 or 3x3 depending on how we do it. Clan houses will require alot of gold, have unique rooms, and with the global ember/clans wars, will probably require rebuilding from attacks from time to time.
I have a post about Clan Wars somewhere in Core you can probably read about it.
Promoting banking in a fantasy rpg, bad idea
or we can get that poker room done so I can start just taking all you guys gold
or we can get that poker room done so I can start just taking all you guys gold
yesplz
If we do a bank can I take out a 1 mill loan, payable on the 2nd tues of next week?
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
I do think this idea as merit in approaching the "gold issue" in a different angle.
We always worry about "taking gold out of the economy", but why not work on making sure only appropriate amounts of gold enter the economy?
Currently it is possible to farm items for gold, which sell for a pretty sum. Shouldnt we "nerf" those, since many of those items serve to nothing except to make gold?
We always worry about "taking gold out of the economy", but why not work on making sure only appropriate amounts of gold enter the economy?
Currently it is possible to farm items for gold, which sell for a pretty sum. Shouldnt we "nerf" those, since many of those items serve to nothing except to make gold?
I do think this idea as merit in approaching the "gold issue" in a different angle.
We always worry about "taking gold out of the economy", but why not work on making sure only appropriate amounts of gold enter the economy?
Currently it is possible to farm items for gold, which sell for a pretty sum. Shouldnt we "nerf" those, since many of those items serve to nothing except to make gold?
The issue is right now I think the gold is at an OK place for general players. Granted we nerfed alot of higher end OAD gold cash cows that were a problem, but I don't think the gold is too far off. Honestly theres not many people who had 'a super ton' of gold and the people that do often play far more than others, and actually build on gold. If the gold was limited even further you would struggle to level and buy potions. We had alot of issues back than and I think it's at a good point now. When you actually are a potion whore too, you might spend 5k-10k on pots just for one run when your the person keeping everyone alive. It adds up for them though anyways.
There is nothing to use it on end game. There will be, houses, clan houses (which is gonna eat alot.) custom things, that will be rather expensive and should suck out alot of gold.
The economy isn't bad to be honest, the game has been up since the wipe for about a year now and I don't think the gold levels are too far off what they should be. You can't balance the game off people who play the game for hours and hours a day though.
Hmm..
Maybe we should think about a gold distribution system where people who play more often and more effectively (thus have more gold) have to pay a tax of some sort that is used to help people who refuse to dedicate time or energy to the game. Giving to those people might motivate them to go out and earn for themselves.
I'm tired of seeing the good players who dedicate countless hours every day to the game make up the top 1% when it comes to the economy. The rest of us want shiny toys too.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Maybe we should think about a gold distribution system where people who play more often and more effectively (thus have more gold) have to pay a tax of some sort that is used to help people who refuse to dedicate time or energy to the game. Giving to those people might motivate them to go out and earn for themselves.
I'm tired of seeing the good players who dedicate countless hours every day to the game make up the top 1% when it comes to the economy. The rest of us want shiny toys too.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Suddenly i smell the presence of left-leaning-beta-male-Marxist-tree-hugging-globalist-Jew-black-female-non-white-libtard-hitlary lovin'-socialist-islamofascist-godless-Eurotrash-gender traitors around here.
Damn you all to hell.
Damn you all to hell.
Suddenly i smell the presence of left-leaning-beta-male-Marxist-tree-hugging-globalist-Jew-black-female-non-white-libtard-hitlary lovin'-socialist-islamofascist-godless-Eurotrash-gender traitors around here.
Damn you all to hell.
That was quite a mouthful. No pun intended.