Player Houses/Funding
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I am working on player houses first before guild houses, though the systems will be similar and most likely will be used for both, it's just that player houses obviously don't involve the guild wars system.
Standard player houses will be generic, nothing too fancy, and not customizable beyond some little things. They will have some sort of vault storage for items.
Custom player houses will allow full portrait changes, description changes, special rooms, and the like. They'll have heavier storage for vaults, and generally all rooms can become vault rooms if you feel.
Thing is, I want custom player houses to be something not really obtained through gold. Dare I say it, through actual funding. We currently are sinking in money to a server, and I'd honestly like to get a little coin that doesn't involve anything pay to win, as I think PTW games are terrible.
I am not sure how I'll do this yet though. For example, custom player houses could be something that you pay lets say, for a 3 months, or a year, or every month (though you can pay upfront or whatever.) I don't want it to be too crazy though. I do think it should be some sort of recurring but fairly cheap option.
I am also not sure if we should combine this with lets say, a package that boosts the amount of items you can hold in your vault, amount of items you can post to the auction, things like that. Things that would make your life alot easier. So it would be like Vault Space + House + Auction Posting Amount + Whatever other things, or keep them separate and let people choose what they want. What do people feel would be the best method? I'm still not sure how I'd reduce vault space if they find out after a year or whatever they don't want it anymore, but I'll think up something probably.
What do people think? I know it is a touchy subject and I want to get says. Obviously this doesn't mean its the ONLY way to get some things, at least the custom houses, but for sure vault space and other things are going to be something of a 'gold membership' type thing.
Furthermore. What would really be a good price? For the 'gold membership' or houses, or it all combined or whatever. I'm really up for opinions here.
Custom portraits, name changes, etc, will be coming soon as well, but that's for another topic too.
Standard player houses will be generic, nothing too fancy, and not customizable beyond some little things. They will have some sort of vault storage for items.
Custom player houses will allow full portrait changes, description changes, special rooms, and the like. They'll have heavier storage for vaults, and generally all rooms can become vault rooms if you feel.
Thing is, I want custom player houses to be something not really obtained through gold. Dare I say it, through actual funding. We currently are sinking in money to a server, and I'd honestly like to get a little coin that doesn't involve anything pay to win, as I think PTW games are terrible.
I am not sure how I'll do this yet though. For example, custom player houses could be something that you pay lets say, for a 3 months, or a year, or every month (though you can pay upfront or whatever.) I don't want it to be too crazy though. I do think it should be some sort of recurring but fairly cheap option.
I am also not sure if we should combine this with lets say, a package that boosts the amount of items you can hold in your vault, amount of items you can post to the auction, things like that. Things that would make your life alot easier. So it would be like Vault Space + House + Auction Posting Amount + Whatever other things, or keep them separate and let people choose what they want. What do people feel would be the best method? I'm still not sure how I'd reduce vault space if they find out after a year or whatever they don't want it anymore, but I'll think up something probably.
What do people think? I know it is a touchy subject and I want to get says. Obviously this doesn't mean its the ONLY way to get some things, at least the custom houses, but for sure vault space and other things are going to be something of a 'gold membership' type thing.
Furthermore. What would really be a good price? For the 'gold membership' or houses, or it all combined or whatever. I'm really up for opinions here.
Custom portraits, name changes, etc, will be coming soon as well, but that's for another topic too.
I think this is a great idea as long as you make sure it's tied to an account and bound there because otherwise it does become currency (which kinda defeats the purpose of not giving a player an advantage) if any of the extras are not tied to accounts players will simply buy a bunch sell for gold or pp and use that for items to become powerful etc. that might bring in more revenue at first but I think you might lose some players if they know there is a loophole to still get a big advantage in the game.
That said as a player and staff I'd support this. I think going the patreon route is the best idea. It's a monthly reward system that's auto withdrawn from the account and sets up diff rewards for different levels of membership. I believe it falls under donations so tax wise it's cheaper on you and even the people donating can write it off on their taxes <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />. I use the site for a few iOS Dev blogs and whatnot that I like to support so I know it's top notch.
That said as a player and staff I'd support this. I think going the patreon route is the best idea. It's a monthly reward system that's auto withdrawn from the account and sets up diff rewards for different levels of membership. I believe it falls under donations so tax wise it's cheaper on you and even the people donating can write it off on their taxes <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />. I use the site for a few iOS Dev blogs and whatnot that I like to support so I know it's top notch.
Reserve me the penthouse suite, top floor. Hold back no amenities. $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ #biddingwar #weed$
Pay to buy options that don't effect gameplay other than "cosmetics" or shit like that, why not make a bit of coin to fund the game? As I said since the beginning I'm down for that and anyone that isn't should get copies of the bills and invoices for time spend coding and working on items etc. See if they wanna pay it
I'm glad you're looking at this, houses are needed and the game could do with a revenue stream.
It'd be good if server hosting, certificates, and your development time all had some funding coming in.
This is a big change, so here's a big thought out reply:
Donation Method/Amount
Patreon could be a good platform to use, there's a short video on the homepage that explains the concept:
<a class="postlink" href="https://www.patreon.com/">https://www.patreon.com/</a>
Upsides would be you're more likely to have repeat donors from that system, downside is it's going to be an unfamiliar concept to many, but it's getting more well known.
Maybe $10 USD a month could be a good level to set the bar at for the full range of perks you listed.
Maybe have different packages so $10 USD is just extra vault space, a few exp boost scrolls (similar to referral rewards).
$15USD could be the first tier plus a personal house plus extra auction house listings
I'm not sure if Patreon lets people donate more if they want to, but it'd be good to have that option there in case people are feeling generous and want to show their appreciation for everything you do.
Failing this, you could have a Paypal donate button, which would be familiar to more people but might be less likely to get repeat donors.
If you go the Paypal route then you probably want to set the membership period at 3 months. One month would be too short, whereas one year is too long and you'll end up with irregular income.
You could potentially have both methods but I would lean towards using only Patreon, however this is assuming they have a way people can allow larger one off donations? I couldn't find the info on their website, hopefully someone with experience can confirm/deny?
Potential Perks
Potential perks we could implement that aren't pay to win but are worthwhile:
-Name changes (maybe have a public record of this so people can't hide behind it)
-Description additions (either a preset list like ranger pets, or have to be approved but this eats time and won't be consistent)
-Picture changes (debatable whether just from the character creator or allowed for all pics including monster pics)
-Gender changes <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_eek.gif" alt=":shock:" title="Shocked" />
-Longer biography
-Rename an OAD (maybe reserve for for larger donations, or just some special conditions on it, maybe dont do this at all)
-Player Houses (like you mentioned)
-Play as monster mode <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" />
-Special once a month membership mosh where people get a choice of a temporary overpowered weapon, like say a div blade, or a bane on certain races. Items disappear outside the mosh. Everyone in the mosh gets boosted HP through a script (similar to what you did with that dog mosh?)
Mosh designed to be for fun/novelty only, if any reward then a novelty item with no playable value, maybe they spin a wheel to get a special junk item (tshirt, beggars cup, etc.)
Probably low amount of PP too?
-Novelty chat filters you can turn on, you have Swedish, Dog, how about Pirate? Maybe if you make public the syntax for this we can get some community created ones that can be implemented. However maybe hard code a time limit as this could easily get really annoying.
-In game vanity area, where all donors get some sort of statue or monument. The bigger your total donations the bigger your statue. People will like this as a dick measuring contest and it'll have no effect on gameplay.
-Chance to reclaim 1 unused name holder a month - conditions: not logged on in 3 months, character under lvl 16. The "old" character would be put in limbo and the old owner has the chance to rename the "usurped" character and continue using it, or they can just delete it if there was nothing of merit on there. If the new name isn't on a lvl 16+ within a week then it reverts to the original owner.
Would the character changes be done through scrolls? If so would you make them not able to be transferred to another account? People could potentially sell these to other players if allowed. Should we allow/deny this?
Expiring Memberships
As for what to do with vaults/houses when memberships expire, I don't think items should expire or become available to other people to snatch up the house as this doesn't seem very fair.
How about the items are put into a sort of limbo, where they can be withdrawn from the storage but you cannot deposit into the storage?
I could see people taking advantage of this though, as many items sit in my storage for a long time before i withdraw them for usage. However, does that matter?
Maybe put a time limit on this so they have to withdraw within 3 months before the items expire or get automated listed on the auction house?
Maybe not allow them to access the items until they subscribe again, but not sure how i feel about this...
Housing Access/Location
How would we want to limit access to houses? Would buying a membership give you keys you could then duplicate? Equippable keys that come SBed? Would it be account based? Could you give other people access? Are you able to drag people into the house?
Can people who are dragged into the house pick up items, or are they prevented unless they have a key?
Until clan houses are put into game people will look to see if they can use player houses for the same purpose, do we want to allow that or prevent that?
Also, if we want clans to later on risk their items/gold in clan houses during guild wars (I'm not sure this is the intention?) then we need to make sure they cant just use a player house to get around that mechanic.
Leading on from this, where will the location be? Will all houses be in one town? Will there be a choice of towns? Will players be able to request special locations in the wild?
Will this depend on donation amount?
It'd be good if server hosting, certificates, and your development time all had some funding coming in.
This is a big change, so here's a big thought out reply:
Donation Method/Amount
Patreon could be a good platform to use, there's a short video on the homepage that explains the concept:
<a class="postlink" href="https://www.patreon.com/">https://www.patreon.com/</a>
Upsides would be you're more likely to have repeat donors from that system, downside is it's going to be an unfamiliar concept to many, but it's getting more well known.
Maybe $10 USD a month could be a good level to set the bar at for the full range of perks you listed.
Maybe have different packages so $10 USD is just extra vault space, a few exp boost scrolls (similar to referral rewards).
$15USD could be the first tier plus a personal house plus extra auction house listings
I'm not sure if Patreon lets people donate more if they want to, but it'd be good to have that option there in case people are feeling generous and want to show their appreciation for everything you do.
Failing this, you could have a Paypal donate button, which would be familiar to more people but might be less likely to get repeat donors.
If you go the Paypal route then you probably want to set the membership period at 3 months. One month would be too short, whereas one year is too long and you'll end up with irregular income.
You could potentially have both methods but I would lean towards using only Patreon, however this is assuming they have a way people can allow larger one off donations? I couldn't find the info on their website, hopefully someone with experience can confirm/deny?
Potential Perks
Potential perks we could implement that aren't pay to win but are worthwhile:
-Name changes (maybe have a public record of this so people can't hide behind it)
-Description additions (either a preset list like ranger pets, or have to be approved but this eats time and won't be consistent)
-Picture changes (debatable whether just from the character creator or allowed for all pics including monster pics)
-Gender changes <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_eek.gif" alt=":shock:" title="Shocked" />
-Longer biography
-Rename an OAD (maybe reserve for for larger donations, or just some special conditions on it, maybe dont do this at all)
-Player Houses (like you mentioned)
-Play as monster mode <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" />
-Special once a month membership mosh where people get a choice of a temporary overpowered weapon, like say a div blade, or a bane on certain races. Items disappear outside the mosh. Everyone in the mosh gets boosted HP through a script (similar to what you did with that dog mosh?)
Mosh designed to be for fun/novelty only, if any reward then a novelty item with no playable value, maybe they spin a wheel to get a special junk item (tshirt, beggars cup, etc.)
Probably low amount of PP too?
-Novelty chat filters you can turn on, you have Swedish, Dog, how about Pirate? Maybe if you make public the syntax for this we can get some community created ones that can be implemented. However maybe hard code a time limit as this could easily get really annoying.
-In game vanity area, where all donors get some sort of statue or monument. The bigger your total donations the bigger your statue. People will like this as a dick measuring contest and it'll have no effect on gameplay.
-Chance to reclaim 1 unused name holder a month - conditions: not logged on in 3 months, character under lvl 16. The "old" character would be put in limbo and the old owner has the chance to rename the "usurped" character and continue using it, or they can just delete it if there was nothing of merit on there. If the new name isn't on a lvl 16+ within a week then it reverts to the original owner.
Would the character changes be done through scrolls? If so would you make them not able to be transferred to another account? People could potentially sell these to other players if allowed. Should we allow/deny this?
Expiring Memberships
As for what to do with vaults/houses when memberships expire, I don't think items should expire or become available to other people to snatch up the house as this doesn't seem very fair.
How about the items are put into a sort of limbo, where they can be withdrawn from the storage but you cannot deposit into the storage?
I could see people taking advantage of this though, as many items sit in my storage for a long time before i withdraw them for usage. However, does that matter?
Maybe put a time limit on this so they have to withdraw within 3 months before the items expire or get automated listed on the auction house?
Maybe not allow them to access the items until they subscribe again, but not sure how i feel about this...
Housing Access/Location
How would we want to limit access to houses? Would buying a membership give you keys you could then duplicate? Equippable keys that come SBed? Would it be account based? Could you give other people access? Are you able to drag people into the house?
Can people who are dragged into the house pick up items, or are they prevented unless they have a key?
Until clan houses are put into game people will look to see if they can use player houses for the same purpose, do we want to allow that or prevent that?
Also, if we want clans to later on risk their items/gold in clan houses during guild wars (I'm not sure this is the intention?) then we need to make sure they cant just use a player house to get around that mechanic.
Leading on from this, where will the location be? Will all houses be in one town? Will there be a choice of towns? Will players be able to request special locations in the wild?
Will this depend on donation amount?
Not "realistic" but I think a useable item to teleport you to/from your house, unless you don't mind cluttering up city maps with houses.
Only useable in the city where the portal item is linked?
When you leave your house you end up in the square you warped from.
Optional: Portal item has a recharge time.
As I said, this is only suggested to avoid cluttering up city maps, and having to navigate mazes to get to your house; a convenience thing.
Only useable in the city where the portal item is linked?
When you leave your house you end up in the square you warped from.
Optional: Portal item has a recharge time.
As I said, this is only suggested to avoid cluttering up city maps, and having to navigate mazes to get to your house; a convenience thing.
As eld and some of the others have chimed in there are lots of little features and things we could add for revenue and patreon handles and organizes that easily with flexible donation levels. It can even integrate into discord / forums to add perks there and show player donation levels as a kind of achievement some could even say it's a marketing tool. You have diff levels and memberships which give bronze, silver gold etc status could be $1 up to custom amounts of anything.
Not a lot of people think about this either but when you are donating a monthly amount getting email reminders thanking you for your donations it keeps people active as well. You could make a case that something like this could even bring numbers up and keep them up.
Not a lot of people think about this either but when you are donating a monthly amount getting email reminders thanking you for your donations it keeps people active as well. You could make a case that something like this could even bring numbers up and keep them up.
I vote for all of the above.
I'll reply to this more in a couple days when I am around. Eld made some good points I wanna touch up on. Dae however brought up a point. Do we want it to be like you own a plot of land in a city OR do we want it more so its automated. For example you'd buy a house in Seamoor and you can enter it through a portal or some sort of way that doesn't keep requiring the map to expand. It would have to prob be something like 'enter house 512' and if you have the keys you'd go in.
That way theres no real requirement from build and players won't have to trek 1000 squares to get to a house they have access too.
Similar if we go apartments too for standard houses. I get that treking to your door might be cool, but entering the apartment complex and doing 'enter apartment 111' would bring you to your apartment would allow less of map mess etc.
However if we do want houses more realistic like ROK where you walk the house streets to your house theres going to probably be a limit though we can accommodate it for now unless we get larger. I obviously don't want cities being overrun by houses.
Being able to warp to your house from any city might be too much easy mode dae. Maybe I am wrong, but that would mean instead of a key you'd get some sort of warp scroll or something that works like that. The only issue is I 'don't' want ease storage for gold. If clan houses are similar we'd need to figure something out for that so its not a free gold pass or the clan houses can actually be built in the world anywhere. Dunno yet on that, taking ideas.
That way theres no real requirement from build and players won't have to trek 1000 squares to get to a house they have access too.
Similar if we go apartments too for standard houses. I get that treking to your door might be cool, but entering the apartment complex and doing 'enter apartment 111' would bring you to your apartment would allow less of map mess etc.
However if we do want houses more realistic like ROK where you walk the house streets to your house theres going to probably be a limit though we can accommodate it for now unless we get larger. I obviously don't want cities being overrun by houses.
Being able to warp to your house from any city might be too much easy mode dae. Maybe I am wrong, but that would mean instead of a key you'd get some sort of warp scroll or something that works like that. The only issue is I 'don't' want ease storage for gold. If clan houses are similar we'd need to figure something out for that so its not a free gold pass or the clan houses can actually be built in the world anywhere. Dunno yet on that, taking ideas.
Wrote this this morning and only clicking send now:
Would also be nice if there were ways to pimp your house out.
Not sure what form this would take, couple of ideas :
-Different room types i.e. special mana regen rooms, a basic shop
-Different room images
-Some kind of customisable furniture? not sure how this would actually be implemented
Maybe you'd get more customisable options based on higher donation amounts or based on having donated for a longer period.
Would also be nice if there were ways to pimp your house out.
Not sure what form this would take, couple of ideas :
-Different room types i.e. special mana regen rooms, a basic shop
-Different room images
-Some kind of customisable furniture? not sure how this would actually be implemented
Maybe you'd get more customisable options based on higher donation amounts or based on having donated for a longer period.
... Being able to warp to your house from any city might be too much easy mode dae. Maybe I am wrong, but that would mean instead of a key you'd get some sort of warp scroll or something that works like that. The only issue is I 'don't' want ease storage for gold. If clan houses are similar we'd need to figure something out for that so its not a free gold pass or the clan houses can actually be built in the world anywhere. Dunno yet on that, taking ideas.
Well I was thinking an amulet and only from the city where you decided your house would be. But something else you said made me think of something else I half thought of.
Have a square in each city with a landlord. This will be where you "buy" your home (this square will represent an apartment block). You could go to the landlord of the city where you wanted your home to be and get the house from him/her. The landlord could also give out other information related to the housing. It is also from there you could "warp" to your house. Maybe even by just using a key? Key will warp you to the house it is assigned to. Sb'd to user off course. Could have a message "You walk through the apartment to your room." "You have arrived at your house."
As for the key cutting etc, well whatever. Caveat to the person handing out their keys, your choice; no crying if they give a copy to a person who then loots your house. Tell the police!
I think the houses should come with a cellar that has a giant rat in it.
Ye lazy bastardos.
No warping to your house. Walk there, like everyone else.
For me to buy a house, it needs to give me advantages i cant find anywhere else.
- Extended vault
- Access to all my gold
- a garden that gives me special potions once every week, or something to that effect
- A crafter that gives me items every week (very small % of actually getting something worth it)
Yes we can buy this for IRL cash.
I'd also buy custom descriptions and images.
Also, perhaps we can have a "trade in" shop where you put in your regular oad, and it comes back with your own personal description (for gold).
Whatever you might decide, it needs to be automated, though. You cant risk getting swamped with people sending you money, then asking for stuff, you'd probably get too much on your hands.
You should also run a "funding marathon" similar to what Wikipedia runs.
And so forth.
No warping to your house. Walk there, like everyone else.
For me to buy a house, it needs to give me advantages i cant find anywhere else.
- Extended vault
- Access to all my gold
- a garden that gives me special potions once every week, or something to that effect
- A crafter that gives me items every week (very small % of actually getting something worth it)
Yes we can buy this for IRL cash.
I'd also buy custom descriptions and images.
Also, perhaps we can have a "trade in" shop where you put in your regular oad, and it comes back with your own personal description (for gold).
Whatever you might decide, it needs to be automated, though. You cant risk getting swamped with people sending you money, then asking for stuff, you'd probably get too much on your hands.
You should also run a "funding marathon" similar to what Wikipedia runs.
And so forth.
Wrote this this morning and only clicking send now:
Would also be nice if there were ways to pimp your house out.
Not sure what form this would take, couple of ideas :
-Different room types i.e. special mana regen rooms, a basic shop
-Different room images
-Some kind of customisable furniture? not sure how this would actually be implemented
Maybe you'd get more customisable options based on higher donation amounts or based on having donated for a longer period.
Furnature could be npcs or something just so it looks fancy, dunno <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Room images kinda will let them pick whatever but we should have a nice list of rooms.
Different room types were planned but stores are prob gonna be clan houses only.
Ye lazy bastardos.
No warping to your house. Walk there, like everyone else.
For me to buy a house, it needs to give me advantages i cant find anywhere else.
- Extended vault
- Access to all my gold
- a garden that gives me special potions once every week, or something to that effect
- A crafter that gives me items every week (very small % of actually getting something worth it)
Yes we can buy this for IRL cash.
I'd also buy custom descriptions and images.
Also, perhaps we can have a "trade in" shop where you put in your regular oad, and it comes back with your own personal description (for gold).
Whatever you might decide, it needs to be automated, though. You cant risk getting swamped with people sending you money, then asking for stuff, you'd probably get too much on your hands.
You should also run a "funding marathon" similar to what Wikipedia runs.
And so forth.
I'm not sure anything donated can be seen as being automated. I'm here most of the days so it's NP to deal. I will however make it painless for me with one command line process per request that sets up everything.
I'm not sure about the access to all gold. Maybe only in THAT location you can withdraw from all vaults to that current cities bank, but it wouldn't be that you can access all your gold everywhere. I don't like universal banks but if its only in one location it might be OK. There might be abuse in that though where people share to get universal banks so that might not be a good idea, unless that portion is only locked to the person who bought the house's account. Something like that.
I think the whole 'one spot to enter any house' would suffice though, but would be per city. So if you owned house 100 then you'd type enter 100 or enter house 100. something like that. Keeps the maps less messy, and still allows for it to be only per city etc.
Like Trump Tower. 1 Entrance. You got a key (apt number) amulet or somethin. You can give keys away whatever to friends. Trust the friends you give to, maybe they have access to all maybe not, maybe they access all but vault requires a password. Per city. Choose your city of residence <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Whatever nobody cares wtf I say anyone nobody even responds lol blah blah blah. at least ill buy shit if its for sale in game, tho
Just had an idea that might be cool, bare with me.
This could either apply to player houses, clan houses or both.
I've been thinking of ways we could introduce horde/onslaught/etc. modes from Gears of War/Battlefield and ways we can introduce raiding of houses.
I'm also thinking of how in FTL and AC Black Flag you breach other people's ships and spoken about this on Discord a bit.
How about players could pimp their houses and turn it into a challenge for other players to breach it.
They'd have a series of options for defences, maybe they unlock more with larger donation amounts.
They could choose monsters in certain rooms, they could have reinforced doorways, an automated catapult, traps, etc.
The defending player chooses the reward bounty at the heart of their house that a player gets if they defeat it.
Players would have to pay gold to attempt the gauntlet and if they lose the defender gets it.
Or maybe have a trophy system similar to clash of clans where more defences/breaches gives you a higher trophy count.
This could also be done for guild houses, maybe the attackers could have monsters on their side too to increase the difficulty and as a way of balancing between stronger/weaker guilds.
It's obviously important to avoid pay to win, so if we offer different defences as a donation perk then these should either be cosmetic, or they should be obtainable in other ways.
This could either apply to player houses, clan houses or both.
I've been thinking of ways we could introduce horde/onslaught/etc. modes from Gears of War/Battlefield and ways we can introduce raiding of houses.
I'm also thinking of how in FTL and AC Black Flag you breach other people's ships and spoken about this on Discord a bit.
How about players could pimp their houses and turn it into a challenge for other players to breach it.
They'd have a series of options for defences, maybe they unlock more with larger donation amounts.
They could choose monsters in certain rooms, they could have reinforced doorways, an automated catapult, traps, etc.
The defending player chooses the reward bounty at the heart of their house that a player gets if they defeat it.
Players would have to pay gold to attempt the gauntlet and if they lose the defender gets it.
Or maybe have a trophy system similar to clash of clans where more defences/breaches gives you a higher trophy count.
This could also be done for guild houses, maybe the attackers could have monsters on their side too to increase the difficulty and as a way of balancing between stronger/weaker guilds.
It's obviously important to avoid pay to win, so if we offer different defences as a donation perk then these should either be cosmetic, or they should be obtainable in other ways.