← Forum archive

Is 24 STR too much on Half-Orcs

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
Pretty easy ask.

Is 24 STR too much on half orcs? With 25 STR (+1), OAD weapon (brill) with 4% ember and DW'ing, they deal around 601-748 damage. Which is probably high. 24 STR with the same above values is 577-718. Still high but it does help.

Obviously I know it's scury to lose STR if we do modify, but I'm trying to see what people think for the sake of proper balance in this game so that all races are useful. I still see 24 STR being useful, but I am feeling like 25 STR is just too high.
JadeFalcon
I don't think so. I do not think currently Half Orcs are overpowered, my experience of fighting them is fair.
Snyper
I feel the gap between sauri and orc is too wide when deciding slayer class. I obviously have a sauri slayer but it's because of nostalgia. But had I not mained a sauri previously my choice would have been orc for the giant damage. Yes, agi, I know, but in the hit or miss slayer game, when you do land that stab, do you want to dink? Or DONK! This also comes from me waiting for an orc slayer to be finished being leveled by someone so I do have an interest on both sides of the fight. I vote 23 (24 +1).
Folder
Yes probably too much. -OR- the issue is STR scaling. Same thing in the end but orc slayers and zerkers are pretty intense.

Orc slayers in particular, I mean. God damn sometimes lol. It does make interesting gameplay in a way but yeah it does "feel" a bit much at times.

I say this as I am lvling an orc barb fyi.
NiteHawk
Yes probably too much. -OR- the issue is STR scaling. Same thing in the end but orc slayers and zerkers are pretty intense.

Orc slayers in particular, I mean. God damn sometimes lol. It does make interesting gameplay in a way but yeah it does "feel" a bit much at times.

I say this as I am lvling an orc barb fyi.


I mean the obvious change if that was the case to change the formula would be that 24str is like current 25str now. Though that hurts all races too, just to state. (obviously lower str is less hit).

I guess you could increase the min too but then obviously per point of STR matters less. Already it's only around 10 damage with the zerkers per STR.
Folder
I meant more along the lines of the diffence between 18 and 24 str is pretty vast. Whether the answer is to remove a str or change the way str scales (which also affects power buffs) is similar.

I would never consider a slayer with under 20 str, as an example. That isn't necessarily 100% game breaking but that is how we are set up atm.
Terron
personally, it depends i didnt vote. 748 damage is 1 hell of a smash. if you completely ignored magic i dont think half orc loses enough melee statistics to warrant that power. i still feel like there should be a 24 spot for every stat however chr etc doesnt fit past 23. i tend to think a loss of an agility and endurance point would fit horc better balance wise.

plenty of classes/races have nil magic resistance. having 22 end makes it not matter near as much as a saurian or ranger etc. its not a real deterant like having melee penalties for that power.

dwarves should be the hardiest melee unit, not shared with horc. dwarves also sit at 19 agility, i dont feel like they sac enough melee stats for the extra ac and huge resilience to damage across the board. perhaps dwarf needs an agility and wis penalty 19 on both, and horc should be 23 18 21 15 15 15 and dwarf likewise sit at 21 18 23 17 19 16.

overall i lean a little towards yes, but that being said, id hate for you to have to undo it later if 10 magic classes existed.
Folder
Agreed it is not black and white omg nerf orcs they killin everythang. In a way I think they make a case for using chanters and sap which is great.
Hanibal
I voted yes, I have a horc, 24 str 20 agi. Doesn't hit or dodge worth a **** but when he does hit for max it's a bit overpowered.

It be hard to adjust now for those who went 25 str, maybe adjust weapon damage, or make 23 with 24 being max?
NiteHawk
Other alternative is to make 25 str same as current 24 str in damage, so about -6 to -10 damage loss depending on class then scale everything so that 18 str is still the same. Might be a possibility. Would indirectly reduce elemental druids overpowering issue too a little.
-Z-
I got mixed feelings about this, I think you could possibly do diminishing values after a certain point for str stat. I don't really want to vote on this until the dex update though. It could work itself out with H/O Slayers AND H/O Zerkers getting nailed more (low agil) for the trade off in the top tier burst dmg. Btw, I do not own a H/O Slayer nor a H/O Zerker which would be the main focus of nerfing the 25str. As far as Elders go, think if you slightly adjust the scaleing for wis to str% gained upon morph might help balnce elders. Mainly Ele Druids.
Styx
I mark yes based on horc being 19 agi and if agi changes come then huge dammage amounts to adjust would be needed.

However, if dwarf is 19 agi also then str should be adjusted high to help compensate as a lower agi , high end race
Folder
I mark yes based on horc being 19 agi and if agi changes come then huge dammage amounts to adjust would be needed.

However, if dwarf is 19 agi also then str should be adjusted high to help compensate as a lower agi , high end race


I don't know what this means lol. Dwarves can not have more STR, otherwise they are just better versions of orcs because they have all kinds of damage negation.

Definitely on the fence here and Z has a good point about the agi changes. We may wanna see how that plays out before also donking str.
Styx
Just comparing str vs end vs agi values, yes there is a lot of adjustments for dwarf race though, I need sleep lol

Edit it would give dwarf as a more viable option for elder.
killa
aren't you already making agi matter more soon, whats the point of making horcs weaker then adjust agi and make them hit less. what would be the reason to even make them anymore. why not roll out the agi update first then see how they are and revisit this then..
killa
home boy with regular ass gear got a 10 streak in KOTH last week and won with a saurian slayer... don't nerf horcs lol
anthriel
I vote no. High Str is all horcs got going for them as a race to differentiate from others. They don't hit or dodge often. If u close the Str gap then I suspect most will simply choose saurian (much better hitrate for slayer for only -1 str) or dwarf (much better MR etc for similar END). In other words I think nerfing them will only lead to less race/class build diversity going forward and/or probably leave players feeling burned if no compensatory race change is offered for those holding a Horc.
Lateralus
I vote no. High Str is all horcs got going for them as a race to differentiate from others. They don't hit or dodge often. If u close the Str gap then I suspect most will simply choose saurian (much better hitrate for slayer for only -1 str) or dwarf (much better MR etc for similar END). In other words I think nerfing them will only lead to less race/class build diversity going forward and/or probably leave players feeling burned if no compensatory race change is offered for those holding a Horc.


I mean they also have the highest end and hp recovery rate so they have more than just str going for them.

I don't think it's a bad idea to wait for the agi update to take another look but yea they are pretty good.

They are op as slayers maybe top tier zerker / monk / knight as well but at least those classes have comp. ho slayer is def the best slayer by far.