← Forum archive

Is 24 STR too much on Half-Orcs

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Rael
If I remember correctly you did the calculations saurian vs orcs. saurian's came out on top a good amount. I will say a geared out orc is intense at times but I do not think it needs changed and definitely not before the agi update goes in.
Eld
I voted "yes" but this is a fine balancing act.
A lot of it depends on the agi changes, and a lot of it depends on what the other races get.

I still think we need to do attack simulations based on current stats, see what is currently overpowered, and then change only what is absolutely necessary.

25 str on any class that has an attack modifier seems pretty great at the moment though
NiteHawk
If I remember correctly you did the calculations saurian vs orcs. saurian's came out on top a good amount. I will say a geared out orc is intense at times but I do not think it needs changed and definitely not before the agi update goes in.


This is the problem.

People are comparing it to saurians for everything, and I have in the past as well admittedly. The issue is to do with saurians being more OP then HO in the most case. That's why in my racial changes post I am trying to keep Saurians where they are at rather then beefing them up cause they shouldn't be.

I suppose the fine balancing act is if we realize it's too much afterwards I simply change the damage formula instead as I talked about. I want to keep changing stats too much though. Though thinking about it, looking at a 22/22/19 saur vs a 23/19/22 HO, damage wise they are pretty close, putting it at 24 was an OK choice but maybe the formula effects too much per point.

In any case we can review it afterwards then and we'll leave it for now. I get the poll is sliding on yes but I also agree with people on waiting until we see how everything plays out.
daedroth
I got mixed feelings about this, I think you could possibly do diminishing values after a certain point for str stat. I don't really want to vote on this until the dex update though. It could work itself out with H/O Slayers AND H/O Zerkers getting nailed more (low agil) for the trade off in the top tier burst dmg. Btw, I do not own a H/O Slayer nor a H/O Zerker which would be the main focus of nerfing the 25str. As far as Elders go, think if you slightly adjust the scaleing for wis to str% gained upon morph might help balnce elders. Mainly Ele Druids.


+1 Vote to -Z-
Wait and see how the new changes are. Most races are getting a HP increase and then theres the slight AGL modifier... so it may balance out anyway.
The druid WIS modifiers can also be adjusted if Ele is still considered OP.
I think it is pointless to vote until the new changes have been in effect for a while.
Terron
im still on the fence on this one, playing my horcs i love the str, but yeah they definitely dont outweigh the 23 str saurians ive used.

without magic involved horc dwarf saurian and drake all have too much going for them

basically imo the outlook i have after playing them is:

horc too resilient and sacrificing almost nothing to get that much power
saurian hits way too often to warrant that kind of strength and not have 17 end
drake above average str and dex with slightly above average HPs (because chr is the dump stat)
dwarf sacrifices 1 agility to be a defense god...

in that scenario id expect to see:
horc -1 agi (as it sits current, not with agi change) -1 end
saurian -1 agility -1 end
drake -1 end
dwarf -1 agi , -1 wis

again that reflects a world w/o magic.

i kinda still feel that drake saur and horc especially would deserve to keep the OPness if magic classes had more options. i feel like its pointless for you to change things like this unless it is causing more grief for players than fun. because it might not be an issue if something else was changed, namely agi and more magic classes.
NiteHawk
You gotta go with the premise that magic will be more of a thing in the future I would say, they do need to be better then other races with MR as they don't have that going for them, and eventually they'll be zapped by the magic beats down them easily.
Dan
You gotta go with the premise that magic will be more of a thing in the future I would say, they do need to be better then other races with MR as they don't have that going for them, and eventually they'll be zapped by the magic beats down them easily.


But that is not a good thing.

Casters having an advantage is ok, but hos should have a chance.
Folder
they do. 9-11% chance to hit 2 backstabs in 1 round. hey! nobodies perfect lol


^exactly, they do have a chance by virtue of idiot damage when they land hits. If orcs could go toe to toe with magic users why would anyone ever roll high wis melee? They have to get cooked most of the time.

Also yeah, the more I think about it orcs need that str otherwise everyone just makes lizard/drake. We'll see how current race changes pan out though.
Terron
i meant that as a good thing. i mean yeah its low odds. but i bet a gnome melee fighting a horc melee is even lower odds. gnome melee is likewise mostly immune to wizardry. round and round, part of the fun.
Dan
What the hell are you guys talking about?

Who said slayer?

I said HOs should have a chance.

Cavs, zerkers, ninjas, all of them.
Terron
they do, it isnt a chanters fault you didnt pick 14 wisdom 20 agi or even 15 wisdom. i mean that would definitely increase your odds. even if it is impractical

i think the underlying idea is for you to excel with a broader base of characters opposed to making everything have high chance to succeed
Folder
What the hell are you guys talking about?

Who said slayer?

I said HOs should have a chance.

Cavs, zerkers, ninjas, all of them.



I think we're all on the same page here. Orcs need their STR because magic hurts them badly, if they lose that STR advantage (and magic becomes more popular) then people would just stick to higher MR / higher AGI races.
Lateralus
I think option 19 as nitehawk posted should help solve this a bit. With that option you are going to have to choose either 25 19 22 10 12 10 (25str and 12wis) or you are going to have to give up a str to get the full 14wis.

See the problem is 22end and 14 or 13 wis isnt exactly chanter food. thats atleast 3 maybe up to 5 rounds that it takes to kill you. In that time you are getting 6-10 backstabs off and only need to hit 2. You actually stand a pretty good chance at winning with how the magic pen works. Dropping them a pool points helps this a bit.
Terron
i can see man's point tho. 6-10 "backstab"'s isnt exactly a half orc problem.

essentially backstab hits 4x for 1 attack roll, meanwhile a barb, monk or cav have to overcome 4 separate attack rolls. i know the damage potentials are different for each class, but you see that single swat attackers have to basically overcome a casters superior agility 4x as often. in a perfect round a slayer hits 8x metaphorically.

i think the str doesnt need lowered because its a misplaced bi-product of the backstab skill. horc is just the scapegoat because of the high damage and because goats are cuter than horcs.
Dan
See the problem is 22end and 14 or 13 wis isnt exactly chanter food. thats atleast 3 maybe up to 5 rounds that it takes to kill you. In that time you are getting 6-10 backstabs off and only need to hit 2. You actually stand a pretty good chance at winning with how the magic pen works. Dropping them a pool points helps this a bit.



If that 22 END and 14 or 13 is really a good fight against a caster, and a 12- is probably dead, then i would agree with the changes.
Lateralus
See the problem is 22end and 14 or 13 wis isnt exactly chanter food. thats atleast 3 maybe up to 5 rounds that it takes to kill you. In that time you are getting 6-10 backstabs off and only need to hit 2. You actually stand a pretty good chance at winning with how the magic pen works. Dropping them a pool points helps this a bit.



If that 22 END and 14 or 13 is really a good fight against a caster, and a 12- is probably dead, then i would agree with the changes.


I am not saying its really good but im saying lower wis plus agi mattering more plus pretty much all caster races getting a small hp bonus does even things out a bit and if it doesnt we can always make adjustments. Look this is coming from someone who has 0 half orcs so its not like im sticking up for them because i want my stuff to be good i just think we need to let all the other adjustments play out a bit before we nerf harder.