Area Capture System
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Really like the fact that you are thinking of things that take the game far beyond Rok's one dimensional gameplay. In some ways i really like the idea. I've always thought Rok would have done well with a town control type mechanism.
However I don't really like the ways you suggested implementing it because it seems to totally worsen the much needed guild diversity balances (ie it seems everyone would have incentive to join the biggest dominant guild to control all areas so they get exp bonuses etc)... Basically it's demoralising enough playing in a minor guild already where you get thumped day in day out at key battles, OADs, leveling etc - in my opinion adding a system that further messes up guild diversity like this will end up reducing competition rather than creating more (cos it will likely result in a 1 guild game with everyone else quitting - EO is prolly getting quite close to this already and many players have already quit/retired cos of the guild domination issue)
I think the overall idea could be really good though, but I think u need to make it work to PROMOTE guild diversity, not hinder it. Here is an example of how it could be helpful in promoting guild diversity:
[list]
- Step 1: Make levelling areas be all under the domain of closest town (eg logging area and Kakegi belongs to Canopia, dwarf mines belongs to drelvar etc.) and introduce a "town hall, castle, mayors office etc type room" to be the capture/control room for each town
- Step 2: Make the reward for holding the town say 1-3% of all gold given out from exping, quests rewards and any commerce done (ie buying/selling stuff from shops, auction house, healing at temples , maybe even bank deposit amounts etc) in that towns area each week (kinda like the guild tax)
- Step 3: each guild can only capture/hold 1 town at a time (ie they have to choose whether they would rather hold Huldar (for dreads), Arkan (for Ref and big cash leveling/quests), Seamoor (which has crap leveling cash but good cash from has the auction house) etc... This will promote Guild diversity cos it means that everyone joins Guild A will leave untapped cash sitting in other uncaptured towns that is potentially available for opportunistic ppl to gcreate and hold. Ie you limit how much benefit the biggest guild can actually get by restricting the reward to 1 town anyway. With this, you would probably go from 2-3 super guilds to as many guilds as there were capturable towns.
- Step 4: find a way to do the siege/capture that promotes active play. Eg it could be within game like charging into a town and storming the castle by killing any defending players/npcs (could be automated without need for event staff) ...Or you could try making it more formally structured by running weekly guild-wars event and first place gets first pick of town, 2nd place gets next pick etc (gives ppl incentive to actually do the event)
[/list:u]
The above is just an example. Step 3 is the crucial step/mechanism. Steps 1,2,4 are just ways you can also achieve other aims (eg steps 1&2 give reason for ppl to choose to hold Seamoor area etc, step 4 could help win promoting guild events etc)
Hope that helps. In any case I cannot stress enough the importance of promoting guild diversity rather than hindering it with a mechanism such as this!
However I don't really like the ways you suggested implementing it because it seems to totally worsen the much needed guild diversity balances (ie it seems everyone would have incentive to join the biggest dominant guild to control all areas so they get exp bonuses etc)... Basically it's demoralising enough playing in a minor guild already where you get thumped day in day out at key battles, OADs, leveling etc - in my opinion adding a system that further messes up guild diversity like this will end up reducing competition rather than creating more (cos it will likely result in a 1 guild game with everyone else quitting - EO is prolly getting quite close to this already and many players have already quit/retired cos of the guild domination issue)
I think the overall idea could be really good though, but I think u need to make it work to PROMOTE guild diversity, not hinder it. Here is an example of how it could be helpful in promoting guild diversity:
[list]
- Step 1: Make levelling areas be all under the domain of closest town (eg logging area and Kakegi belongs to Canopia, dwarf mines belongs to drelvar etc.) and introduce a "town hall, castle, mayors office etc type room" to be the capture/control room for each town
- Step 2: Make the reward for holding the town say 1-3% of all gold given out from exping, quests rewards and any commerce done (ie buying/selling stuff from shops, auction house, healing at temples , maybe even bank deposit amounts etc) in that towns area each week (kinda like the guild tax)
- Step 3: each guild can only capture/hold 1 town at a time (ie they have to choose whether they would rather hold Huldar (for dreads), Arkan (for Ref and big cash leveling/quests), Seamoor (which has crap leveling cash but good cash from has the auction house) etc... This will promote Guild diversity cos it means that everyone joins Guild A will leave untapped cash sitting in other uncaptured towns that is potentially available for opportunistic ppl to gcreate and hold. Ie you limit how much benefit the biggest guild can actually get by restricting the reward to 1 town anyway. With this, you would probably go from 2-3 super guilds to as many guilds as there were capturable towns.
- Step 4: find a way to do the siege/capture that promotes active play. Eg it could be within game like charging into a town and storming the castle by killing any defending players/npcs (could be automated without need for event staff) ...Or you could try making it more formally structured by running weekly guild-wars event and first place gets first pick of town, 2nd place gets next pick etc (gives ppl incentive to actually do the event)
[/list:u]
The above is just an example. Step 3 is the crucial step/mechanism. Steps 1,2,4 are just ways you can also achieve other aims (eg steps 1&2 give reason for ppl to choose to hold Seamoor area etc, step 4 could help win promoting guild events etc)
Hope that helps. In any case I cannot stress enough the importance of promoting guild diversity rather than hindering it with a mechanism such as this!
- Step 2: Make the reward for holding the town say 1-3% of all gold given out from exping, quests rewards and any commerce done (ie buying/selling stuff from shops, auction house, healing at temples , maybe even bank deposit amounts etc) in that towns area each week (kinda like the guild tax)
That is a pretty good idea. Prob not things like bank deposits though, that's a bit extreme IMO. Things like Eld said as well could help out (unlocks certain shops etc). Long as it's not game changing stuff. I.E. back room of the magic shop having potions that are +5 HP or +5MP more then what they currently sell.
- Step 3: each guild can only capture/hold 1 town at a time (ie they have to choose whether they would rather hold Huldar (for dreads), Arkan (for Ref and big cash leveling/quests), Seamoor (which has crap leveling cash but good cash from has the auction house) etc... This will promote Guild diversity cos it means that everyone joins Guild A will leave untapped cash sitting in other uncaptured towns that is potentially available for opportunistic ppl to gcreate and hold. Ie you limit how much benefit the biggest guild can actually get by restricting the reward to 1 town anyway. With this, you would probably go from 2-3 super guilds to as many guilds as there were capturable towns.
While I really like this idea, it's a bigger system, but I think it's a fairly good system overall. The thing is though there are really only 3 ish 'good' l cities to capture, which are the higher level areas that people spend level 23+ on. The gold difference will be greatly higher and to me the issue is that the bigger guilds will hold them, resulting in way larger gold amounts then other areas. Sure, you could capture Canopia/etc but alot of cities are often passed fairly quickly and obviously have lower amounts. I don't think it would be any more guild diverse. I am fine with the 1 city limit in this case though.
I also think a town capturing system in this sense is a very good idea, and I do want to implement it (and will tbh). But I think this is a weekly thing you can do to raid it or at least at maximum once a day vulnerability timer. I'm for it if people are good with it, but I did really want a system that is more 'active' too on top of this, where changes can happen more often than not. Obviously holding a city it probably shouldn't change holders all the time, maybe once a day maximum or once a week. I think its very cool though.
However, for general areas, you could also take some ideas you talked about here. For example, if people disagree with XP/Gold boosts, area capturing could simply involve what you said here. Having an area means that you gain 1% total gold of any leveling earned to the guild bank of the area holder for example. You can also obviously have a maximum area limit which I still wanted in the other system too, so that one guild can't take ALL the areas, but it would have to be more then 1 area. Or it could be a mix of both with a cap on how many small areas you can take. I want these to change more often then not, something to do rather constantly, even if its a few minutes a day. They shouldn't be free capture, there should be a invul timer once you capture it, but these should be alot faster paced than city holding and require alot less effort. I.E: 1-4 hours.
- Step 2: Make the reward for holding the town say 1-3% of all gold given out from exping, quests rewards and any commerce done (ie buying/selling stuff from shops, auction house, healing at temples , maybe even bank deposit amounts etc) in that towns area each week (kinda like the guild tax)
That is a pretty good idea. Prob not things like bank deposits though, that's a bit extreme IMO. Things like Eld said as well could help out (unlocks certain shops etc). Long as it's not game changing stuff. I.E. back room of the magic shop having potions that are +5 HP or +5MP more then what they currently sell.
- Step 3: each guild can only capture/hold 1 town at a time (ie they have to choose whether they would rather hold Huldar (for dreads), Arkan (for Ref and big cash leveling/quests), Seamoor (which has crap leveling cash but good cash from has the auction house) etc... This will promote Guild diversity cos it means that everyone joins Guild A will leave untapped cash sitting in other uncaptured towns that is potentially available for opportunistic ppl to gcreate and hold. Ie you limit how much benefit the biggest guild can actually get by restricting the reward to 1 town anyway. With this, you would probably go from 2-3 super guilds to as many guilds as there were capturable towns.
While I really like this idea, it's a bigger system, but I think it's a fairly good system overall. The thing is though there are really only 3 ish 'good' l cities to capture, which are the higher level areas that people spend level 23+ on. The gold difference will be greatly higher and to me the issue is that the bigger guilds will hold them, resulting in way larger gold amounts then other areas. Sure, you could capture Canopia/etc but alot of cities are often passed fairly quickly and obviously have lower amounts. I don't think it would be any more guild diverse. I am fine with the 1 city limit in this case though.
I also think a town capturing system in this sense is a very good idea, and I do want to implement it (and will tbh). But I think this is a weekly thing you can do to raid it or at least at maximum once a day vulnerability timer. I'm for it if people are good with it, but I did really want a system that is more 'active' too on top of this, where changes can happen more often than not. Obviously holding a city it probably shouldn't change holders all the time, maybe once a day maximum or once a week. I think its very cool though.
However, for general areas, you could also take some ideas you talked about here. For example, if people disagree with XP/Gold boosts, area capturing could simply involve what you said here. Having an area means that you gain 1% total gold of any leveling earned to the guild bank of the area holder for example. You can also obviously have a maximum area limit which I still wanted in the other system too, so that one guild can't take ALL the areas, but it would have to be more then 1 area. Or it could be a mix of both with a cap on how many small areas you can take. I want these to change more often then not, something to do rather constantly, even if its a few minutes a day. They shouldn't be free capture, there should be a invul timer once you capture it, but these should be alot faster paced than city holding and require alot less effort. I.E: 1-4 hours.
Sounds interesting and fun - as long as it promotes guild diversity. Imho i think the game dynamic is unfortunately past the point where you can introduce a system that still benefits a dominant guild and just limit their ability to control everything ... I think whatever system goes in will have to actively promote guild diversity and competitiveness for smaller guilds. Otherwise it will just be another reason for 'the rich to get richer' and the 'poor' to feel dis-empowered (leading to more drama and demoralised ppl and eventual quitting, rather than the desired excitement). Peace
Moved to my own post, as it differs greatly.
<a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1846">viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1846</a>
<a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1846">viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1846</a>
Sounds interesting and fun - as long as it promotes guild diversity. Imho i think the game dynamic is unfortunately past the point where you can introduce a system that still benefits a dominant guild and just limit their ability to control everything ... I think whatever system goes in will have to actively promote guild diversity and competitiveness for smaller guilds. Otherwise it will just be another reason for 'the rich to get richer' and the 'poor' to feel dis-empowered (leading to more drama and demoralised ppl and eventual quitting, rather than the desired excitement). Peace
Many systems will favor the high end guilds, even the town capture system as the best towns will be captured by the bigger guilds. So no matter what it poses a problem. The only system I see so far that don't 100% benefit the bigger guilds would be the GW system (Posted an example on Sicx's post <a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1846">viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1846</a>). But even still bigger guilds will have easier times donig things, it's hard to contest that unless there maybe is some sort of limit to how many can enter or defend. Maybe giving smaller guilds an easier time to defend/capture though, not sure yet.
I do like area capturing. I do like town capturing. I think we can do both with a similar system and limit how many you can capture, as you said one town is probably enough. For areas, it depends, 2-3 areas probably.
Area capturing can use what you talked about, giving 1-2% of gold to whoever owns the area. No other bonuses needed. Simple and good.
Town capturing can give bonuses inside that town as you talked about as well. The town itself should still be 'usable' by anyone, but the guild holder should have some benefits.
Having a cap on areas should allow at least some smaller guilds to hold some areas. I will prob start at 3 but then if there becomes a thing where we have a lot of guilds, we can reduce it to 2, then 1.
For warnings the system is a bit different than before so it poses a problem on how warnings should be. No longer is it a guild can capture a ton of areas, so maybe they should get a warning when it is captured, but not during or at maximum, when it's neutral. Tough to say.
... Area capturing can use what you talked about, giving 1-2% of gold to whoever owns the area. No other bonuses needed. Simple and good.
Do you mean. Player A kills a beasty, player A's guild takes their % and then the area holder gets their %?
As in:
You killed the bandit scout, you get # gold, your clan gets # tax gold, clan AlhpaOmega get # tax gold.
I likes.
... Area capturing can use what you talked about, giving 1-2% of gold to whoever owns the area. No other bonuses needed. Simple and good.
Do you mean. Player A kills a beasty, player A's guild takes their % and then the area holder gets their %?
As in:
You killed the bandit scout, you get # gold, your clan gets # tax gold, clan AlhpaOmega get # tax gold.
I likes.
Yeah obv you can't set tax for areas, and it would be a very low amount, 1-2%. But still something you'd want to upkeep to earn gold. Specially with GWs coming in and the gold needed for building there.
For anyone who hasn't followed the system, no fear, I will short summary it here on how it currently is.
Guilds will be able to capture zones. Zones are one or more areas (If they are too small area wise we combine them). You can capture an zone by killing the Control Shard in that zone. Once you kill the control shard, it takes 2-4 hours for it to respawn, AKA you will at LEAST hold the area for 2-4 hours. You will gain certain bonuses which mostly involves guild gold to be used for guild houses/etc. You can hold 2-3 zones maximum and 1 city maximum. Cities will have a longer respawn time (12 or 24 hours), and be harder to capture. Easy system.
I have some questions though on this, looking for the majority here.
For basic zones:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? Aka your safety window after killing the control shard. 2 hours, or 4 hours? Mind you, we want them to be passed back and forth fairly often.
2. Should there be a warning when the monster HP is low (20%-25%), or no warning at all to the guild who owns the zone? Or maby simply when they lose the zone?
3. Should everyone be known in what areas guilds have with a command like /gzones? The benefit of this is you can target guilds, but the negative of this is that it might mean that people might get mad and say 'I DON'T WANNA LEVEL IN AN AREA THAT IS HELD BY XXGUILDXX', even though it makes very little difference to their leveling experience.
4. Instead of /gzones, should whomever owns the zone be displayed on the mob? Aka looking the mob over to view what guild has it. This means you won't see who owns it until it is spawned.. But you can technically attack it then and there, so might be OK to display.
5. How much HP do we think is a good starter? Mind you I will be tweaking this, but I am thinking 10k to start.
6. Should the mob heal to full after 5 minutes of not being attacked, or should the defenders need to actually cast heal/aid on it?
For city capture:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? 12 hours or 24 hours?
2. I think city capture should have a warning though. When should this happen? 50% HP?
3. Should this be globally announced when someone is attacking? Aka 'BLAH IS ATTACKING CITY A' meaning others can join in too?
I will also make a discord addition that at least gives info when a zone is taken over. So like a news feed. Not sure on what info it will have yet, depends on what we want released to the public on capture time.
Guilds will be able to capture zones. Zones are one or more areas (If they are too small area wise we combine them). You can capture an zone by killing the Control Shard in that zone. Once you kill the control shard, it takes 2-4 hours for it to respawn, AKA you will at LEAST hold the area for 2-4 hours. You will gain certain bonuses which mostly involves guild gold to be used for guild houses/etc. You can hold 2-3 zones maximum and 1 city maximum. Cities will have a longer respawn time (12 or 24 hours), and be harder to capture. Easy system.
I have some questions though on this, looking for the majority here.
For basic zones:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? Aka your safety window after killing the control shard. 2 hours, or 4 hours? Mind you, we want them to be passed back and forth fairly often.
2. Should there be a warning when the monster HP is low (20%-25%), or no warning at all to the guild who owns the zone? Or maby simply when they lose the zone?
3. Should everyone be known in what areas guilds have with a command like /gzones? The benefit of this is you can target guilds, but the negative of this is that it might mean that people might get mad and say 'I DON'T WANNA LEVEL IN AN AREA THAT IS HELD BY XXGUILDXX', even though it makes very little difference to their leveling experience.
4. Instead of /gzones, should whomever owns the zone be displayed on the mob? Aka looking the mob over to view what guild has it. This means you won't see who owns it until it is spawned.. But you can technically attack it then and there, so might be OK to display.
5. How much HP do we think is a good starter? Mind you I will be tweaking this, but I am thinking 10k to start.
6. Should the mob heal to full after 5 minutes of not being attacked, or should the defenders need to actually cast heal/aid on it?
For city capture:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? 12 hours or 24 hours?
2. I think city capture should have a warning though. When should this happen? 50% HP?
3. Should this be globally announced when someone is attacking? Aka 'BLAH IS ATTACKING CITY A' meaning others can join in too?
I will also make a discord addition that at least gives info when a zone is taken over. So like a news feed. Not sure on what info it will have yet, depends on what we want released to the public on capture time.
For anyone who hasn't followed the system, no fear, I will short summary it here on how it currently is.
Guilds will be able to capture zones. Zones are one or more areas (If they are too small area wise we combine them). You can capture an zone by killing the Control Shard in that zone. Once you kill the control shard, it takes 2-4 hours for it to respawn, AKA you will at LEAST hold the area for 2-4 hours. You will gain certain bonuses which mostly involves guild gold to be used for guild houses/etc. You can hold 2-3 zones maximum and 1 city maximum. Cities will have a longer respawn time (12 or 24 hours), and be harder to capture. Easy system.
I have some questions though on this, looking for the majority here.
For basic zones:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? Aka your safety window after killing the control shard. 2 hours, or 4 hours? Mind you, we want them to be passed back and forth fairly often.
2. Should there be a warning when the monster HP is low (20%-25%), or no warning at all to the guild who owns the zone? Or maby simply when they lose the zone?
3. Should everyone be known in what areas guilds have with a command like /gzones? The benefit of this is you can target guilds, but the negative of this is that it might mean that people might get mad and say 'I DON'T WANNA LEVEL IN AN AREA THAT IS HELD BY XXGUILDXX', even though it makes very little difference to their leveling experience.
4. Instead of /gzones, should whomever owns the zone be displayed on the mob? Aka looking the mob over to view what guild has it. This means you won't see who owns it until it is spawned.. But you can technically attack it then and there, so might be OK to display.
5. How much HP do we think is a good starter? Mind you I will be tweaking this, but I am thinking 10k to start.
6. Should the mob heal to full after 5 minutes of not being attacked, or should the defenders need to actually cast heal/aid on it?
For city capture:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? 12 hours or 24 hours?
2. I think city capture should have a warning though. When should this happen? 50% HP?
3. Should this be globally announced when someone is attacking? Aka 'BLAH IS ATTACKING CITY A' meaning others can join in too?
I will also make a discord addition that at least gives info when a zone is taken over. So like a news feed. Not sure on what info it will have yet, depends on what we want released to the public on capture time.
1) Prefer 4 hours. 2 hours goes by fast!
2) I think a warning at 25% could encourage PvP so I vote for this. Assuming the mob has enough HP of course.
3/4) I prefer 4.
5) I don't know the HP of monsters. Is 10k more than something like Mort has? I think it should be enough HP that it takes a few minutes to kill, so people can mobilize to defend if desired.
6) Defenders should have to heal it - we want to encourage people getting out there. Self heals don't encourage that.
For city captures:
1) Hard to say. I'll pick 12 hours for now but may need to see this in action.
2) 25-50%, again assuming the mob has enough HP to mobilize a defense.
3) Might get spammy at 12 hours. Again kinda hard to say without seeing it in action but my first guess is to say the warning at 25-50% HP to the owning guild is enough.
Overall this sounds quite fun, looking forward to it.
Healing it sounds good but if a lobbies lvl 10 cleric gets to healing at 30k exp per heal this will be op. Fair warning on setting exp on stone to be little or nothing
Healing it sounds good but if a lobbies lvl 10 cleric gets to healing at 30k exp per heal this will be op. Fair warning on setting exp on stone to be little or nothing
Heal is based on level, so if the level is low on it but we mark up the AGI very high it should solve it. For example.
A level 25 beating a level 1 means the level 25 gains 24*2.5 hit rate. So 60% bonus. Adding 27 AGI to its AGI value will make it similar to a level 25. so 27+whatever agi you want it to be. Same difference.
I do think it should dodge anyways, due to high agi characters vs low agi characters. Would be meaningless to use a high agi character even more so.
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? Aka your safety window after killing the control shard. 2 hours, or 4 hours? Mind you, we want them to be passed back and forth fairly often.
2. Should there be a warning when the monster HP is low (20%-25%), or no warning at all to the guild who owns the zone? Or maby simply when they lose the zone?
3. Should everyone be known in what areas guilds have with a command like /gzones? The benefit of this is you can target guilds, but the negative of this is that it might mean that people might get mad and say 'I DON'T WANNA LEVEL IN AN AREA THAT IS HELD BY XXGUILDXX', even though it makes very little difference to their leveling experience.
4. Instead of /gzones, should whomever owns the zone be displayed on the mob? Aka looking the mob over to view what guild has it. This means you won't see who owns it until it is spawned.. But you can technically attack it then and there, so might be OK to display.
5. How much HP do we think is a good starter? Mind you I will be tweaking this, but I am thinking 10k to start.
6. Should the mob heal to full after 5 minutes of not being attacked, or should the defenders need to actually cast heal/aid on it?
For city capture:
1. How long should it take until the mob respawns? 12 hours or 24 hours?
2. I think city capture should have a warning though. When should this happen? 50% HP?
3. Should this be globally announced when someone is attacking? Aka 'BLAH IS ATTACKING CITY A' meaning others can join in too?
I will also make a discord addition that at least gives info when a zone is taken over. So like a news feed. Not sure on what info it will have yet, depends on what we want released to the public on capture time.
1. 4 hours, dont want to be killing a mob over and over again
2. Yes, Warning. This will incentivize fights.
3. Yes, there should be a way to know who owns what
4. See above
5. 10k? That is soloable by a 25er...just seems little, in my opinion. Will this mob fight back? Or just be a dummy? And please, dont call it "control shard", just make something that makes sense for the area - a mob like "canopia fairy" or soemthing
6. im agnostic on this. If its low HP, it will die fast. If its high HP, then defenders should heal it.. but i dont have a strong view
For city capture:
1. 24 hours
2. Yes, a warning at 50% so we can all go and fight
3. Yes! oh lord the fights!!
#6 Have it regen like a player in a temple and be healable.
Dumb thought, what if the "control shard" or even the city's banner flag, aka capture the flag, was to close to temples, so peeps can easily just keep running back.
If this happened to a priest and died the 3 times. Would we still be able to kill the priest or would death immunity kick in? Even a lvl 24 cleric , pked 3 times by clannies elsewhere, run in and heal it, can we still kill them after 3 time death penalty ?
Level lock entry to 16 plus btw, that would be annoying if lvl 15 attacked and nothing could be done.
Just thinking on placement of its area and abuses.
10k hp, way to weak, figure dammage of party of 6 attackers, 450 dammage per toon per round, times 6. And that's being low if berzerker are at flurry. As maximum dammage output.
If this happened to a priest and died the 3 times. Would we still be able to kill the priest or would death immunity kick in? Even a lvl 24 cleric , pked 3 times by clannies elsewhere, run in and heal it, can we still kill them after 3 time death penalty ?
Level lock entry to 16 plus btw, that would be annoying if lvl 15 attacked and nothing could be done.
Just thinking on placement of its area and abuses.
10k hp, way to weak, figure dammage of party of 6 attackers, 450 dammage per toon per round, times 6. And that's being low if berzerker are at flurry. As maximum dammage output.
@Styx. Just make the room full PK like dragon rooms.
id start with 100-125k hps. noone wants a 2 minute war...this isnt grenada.
control shards could just be a set of random oad monsters. by random i mean if theres say 12 control shard spawns 1 of the 12+ oad bosses spawn there so it isnt the same one on repeat. they could be a variant like "tainted ember guardian" or "tainted ember rhinoceros" whatever you want. be nice to have a good mixture of bosses to hit that uniquely diversify magic, hardcore melee, and bring mr into play a bit. also be nice if guilds cant just lock down an area by making "specific builds" to crush the one area, it just cant happen if the bosses spawn in random areas and seldom spawn in the same "control" area.
just be nice if one day you have to stab a spell-warding wisp to control canopia, then the next day its something else entirely, like a 10000 armor blackguard.
control shards could just be a set of random oad monsters. by random i mean if theres say 12 control shard spawns 1 of the 12+ oad bosses spawn there so it isnt the same one on repeat. they could be a variant like "tainted ember guardian" or "tainted ember rhinoceros" whatever you want. be nice to have a good mixture of bosses to hit that uniquely diversify magic, hardcore melee, and bring mr into play a bit. also be nice if guilds cant just lock down an area by making "specific builds" to crush the one area, it just cant happen if the bosses spawn in random areas and seldom spawn in the same "control" area.
just be nice if one day you have to stab a spell-warding wisp to control canopia, then the next day its something else entirely, like a 10000 armor blackguard.
id start with 100-125k hps. noone wants a 2 minute war...this isnt grenada.
control shards could just be a set of random oad monsters. by random i mean if theres say 12 control shard spawns 1 of the 12+ oad bosses spawn there so it isnt the same one on repeat. they could be a variant like "tainted ember guardian" or "tainted ember rhinoceros" whatever you want. be nice to have a good mixture of bosses to hit that uniquely diversify magic, hardcore melee, and bring mr into play a bit. also be nice if guilds cant just lock down an area by making "specific builds" to crush the one area, it just cant happen if the bosses spawn in random areas and seldom spawn in the same "control" area.
just be nice if one day you have to stab a spell-warding wisp to control canopia, then the next day its something else entirely, like a 10000 armor blackguard.
Approve of the different mob types, would be nice. +1 for tainted ember rhinoceros <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />
Different types can come next after we do a test on how everything works.
100k might be too high though, I'm not sure. The idea isn't to hold the control shard for a long time. It shouldn't take 15 minutes to kill one control shard, otherwise it will be tedious and boring. 10k is too little, I agree. Maybe 50k-60k to start. Flame Salamander for example is around 100k.
Yeah I know the 'control shard' name is fairly bad, but I'm open for starting suggestions. I do not think we should have random mob names that confuse players. You don't want newbies bothering with this to be honest. It DOES need to be a understandable name, and variations in the future could be a thing, I.E. 'Blue Control Shards' might be better at tanking magic, etc. Feel free to give me another basic name though that makes sense on what it is. Different mob names will be bad IMO and confusing to new players, which we don't want. It needs to be understandable and simple.
No, control shards won't fight back. They are placed in areas where newbies can wander in and you don't want them randomly dying. The main purpose is PVP not PVE.
You should test the system. Getting killed too many times in a row will make your sickness delay very long. Anyone healing someone who is in PVP (a tag when you attack a player) gets marked as PVP, thus cannot ever be death immune. It was a add awhile back when someone pointed it out about healing, so any positive spells cast on someone who is in combat ensures that person casting the spells is marked to PVP, or at least, that's how it should work, and pretty sure there isn't any issues there. Death immunity doesn't work if you fight back in any scenario, so death immunity is not commonly activated unless you aren't fighting back, I.E. leveling.
There is an obvious issue of they could temple in that city, but I think with the death immunity (and we can make a longer timer) It will be OK. Obviously though there needs to be a point in which combat should stop, I just don't know yet and it probably won't be around for the first few days of release until we test and see how everything works first.
In the cities area though they CAN have defenses if needed, or attack back. I think their is little chance of newbies attacking there so those areas can be done however we really want to be. I figure it will be a throne room with a king or queen. I.E. King of Revolution, or something like that.
--
I might start off only with areas only first, than cities next. Just to get a feel of how it works though.
Pretty much. I think it needs to be similar but allow XP loss to prevent zombing even further though.We'll see though.
My biggest concern is this when it comes to warnings. City warnings are obviously OK, but we don't want players to get sore over it. With what everyone is saying a warning at low HP (25%) is OK, and having the name of the guild in the description is OK too. That way at that point it's pretty much 'X CONTROLS THIS, BUT WE CAN TAKE IT'. Rather than 'X CONTROLS THIS, WE KNOW THIS, WE REFUSE TO GO THERE'. Obviously the people that defend and lost will have knowledge, but it's more transparent overall. The gold siphon'd is fairly low and doesn't need announcing either.
-------
Edit:
For the sickness thing there could also be a way after lets say 3 deaths in a row to lock them out. It's not possible yet but it's an idea. Thus a attacker or a defender after 3 deaths cannot enter the room until their sickness is gone.
Or better yet, a system where after you die 3 times in a control area, you cannot enter the room again for another hour or something. There needs to be a stopping point/break point for players though. Probably would have to be account based though. If a guild got hindered for at least an hour it gives some breathing room. Maybe should even be longer, like two hours.. Says? Remember that you will potentially have to defend 2-3 times cause different zones.
100k might be too high though, I'm not sure. The idea isn't to hold the control shard for a long time. It shouldn't take 15 minutes to kill one control shard, otherwise it will be tedious and boring. 10k is too little, I agree. Maybe 50k-60k to start. Flame Salamander for example is around 100k.
Yeah I know the 'control shard' name is fairly bad, but I'm open for starting suggestions. I do not think we should have random mob names that confuse players. You don't want newbies bothering with this to be honest. It DOES need to be a understandable name, and variations in the future could be a thing, I.E. 'Blue Control Shards' might be better at tanking magic, etc. Feel free to give me another basic name though that makes sense on what it is. Different mob names will be bad IMO and confusing to new players, which we don't want. It needs to be understandable and simple.
No, control shards won't fight back. They are placed in areas where newbies can wander in and you don't want them randomly dying. The main purpose is PVP not PVE.
If this happened to a priest and died the 3 times. Would we still be able to kill the priest or would death immunity kick in? Even a lvl 24 cleric , pked 3 times by clannies elsewhere, run in and heal it, can we still kill them after 3 time death penalty ?
You should test the system. Getting killed too many times in a row will make your sickness delay very long. Anyone healing someone who is in PVP (a tag when you attack a player) gets marked as PVP, thus cannot ever be death immune. It was a add awhile back when someone pointed it out about healing, so any positive spells cast on someone who is in combat ensures that person casting the spells is marked to PVP, or at least, that's how it should work, and pretty sure there isn't any issues there. Death immunity doesn't work if you fight back in any scenario, so death immunity is not commonly activated unless you aren't fighting back, I.E. leveling.
There is an obvious issue of they could temple in that city, but I think with the death immunity (and we can make a longer timer) It will be OK. Obviously though there needs to be a point in which combat should stop, I just don't know yet and it probably won't be around for the first few days of release until we test and see how everything works first.
In the cities area though they CAN have defenses if needed, or attack back. I think their is little chance of newbies attacking there so those areas can be done however we really want to be. I figure it will be a throne room with a king or queen. I.E. King of Revolution, or something like that.
--
I might start off only with areas only first, than cities next. Just to get a feel of how it works though.
@Styx. Just make the room full PK like dragon rooms.
Pretty much. I think it needs to be similar but allow XP loss to prevent zombing even further though.We'll see though.
'I DON'T WANNA LEVEL IN AN AREA THAT IS HELD BY XXGUILDXX'
My biggest concern is this when it comes to warnings. City warnings are obviously OK, but we don't want players to get sore over it. With what everyone is saying a warning at low HP (25%) is OK, and having the name of the guild in the description is OK too. That way at that point it's pretty much 'X CONTROLS THIS, BUT WE CAN TAKE IT'. Rather than 'X CONTROLS THIS, WE KNOW THIS, WE REFUSE TO GO THERE'. Obviously the people that defend and lost will have knowledge, but it's more transparent overall. The gold siphon'd is fairly low and doesn't need announcing either.
-------
Edit:
For the sickness thing there could also be a way after lets say 3 deaths in a row to lock them out. It's not possible yet but it's an idea. Thus a attacker or a defender after 3 deaths cannot enter the room until their sickness is gone.
Or better yet, a system where after you die 3 times in a control area, you cannot enter the room again for another hour or something. There needs to be a stopping point/break point for players though. Probably would have to be account based though. If a guild got hindered for at least an hour it gives some breathing room. Maybe should even be longer, like two hours.. Says? Remember that you will potentially have to defend 2-3 times cause different zones.
While I like the idea of capturing both areas and cities, I don't know if the map is actually big enough to warrant both. I would probably say do city capture and assign areas to be under the domain of cities (eg guild holding Arkanmaw city controls reward/tax from the city as well as associated areas such as refinery and Arkan grasslands; guild holding Huldar controls rewards/tax from fort and dread-lands; guild holding drelvar controls reward/tax from city and dwarf mines etc) and for certain areas where there is no viable city (eg the entire wastelands where the closest city linwood is a dump, then invent an area capture for that area eg near the ringleader/raider chief/raiders vale).... Otherwise people may feel like capturing certain areas is 'meh' for the effort involved... Eg if the rewards for holding refinery area are huge but rewards for holding Arkan city is small then ppl might CBF ever contesting for the city (let alone smaller/lamer areas like the cemetery or ruined tower)
Then along with this, also keep the 1 guild per city limit to encourage guild diversity. Yes, the big 3 guilds will likely control Arkan, Huldar and Wiken (or Seamoor depending on how much commerce/reward/tax the auction house generates, or Drelv depending on how much reward/tax gem cutting generates), but then at least they can't expand their domains/dominions any further than that, leading to an incentive for opportunistic players and smaller guilds to hold canopia (for newbie leveling income from logging camp & Kakegi) or bitryn (including cemetery, Karnath mines and ant hill), or even turenyara (incl kings road, seta and ruined watchtower) etc.
Basically I am proposing to group areas under city capture so that you can package them together well enough to make ppl actually give a crap to mobilise and capture. Not all packages will be of same worth, but by limiting each guild to holding 1 city anyway you encourage guild diversity and the dominant guilds will still get the best packages as their rewards. Otherwise I envision a whole lot of work to set up area captures in places that yield very little reward and most players will feel they CBF to waste gold/pots to even contest it (or that some areas will be so valuable that ppl will not bother capturing cities, making city capture useless)
That's my 2 cents. Peace.
Then along with this, also keep the 1 guild per city limit to encourage guild diversity. Yes, the big 3 guilds will likely control Arkan, Huldar and Wiken (or Seamoor depending on how much commerce/reward/tax the auction house generates, or Drelv depending on how much reward/tax gem cutting generates), but then at least they can't expand their domains/dominions any further than that, leading to an incentive for opportunistic players and smaller guilds to hold canopia (for newbie leveling income from logging camp & Kakegi) or bitryn (including cemetery, Karnath mines and ant hill), or even turenyara (incl kings road, seta and ruined watchtower) etc.
Basically I am proposing to group areas under city capture so that you can package them together well enough to make ppl actually give a crap to mobilise and capture. Not all packages will be of same worth, but by limiting each guild to holding 1 city anyway you encourage guild diversity and the dominant guilds will still get the best packages as their rewards. Otherwise I envision a whole lot of work to set up area captures in places that yield very little reward and most players will feel they CBF to waste gold/pots to even contest it (or that some areas will be so valuable that ppl will not bother capturing cities, making city capture useless)
That's my 2 cents. Peace.
That's my 2 cents. Peace.
What he said.