← Forum archive

Never Ending Shard Hunt

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Sicx
We could forgo this whole area capture and do a Shrine situation. Guilds buy guild houses and then buy a Shrine for one of their rooms.
A.) This helps with players using gold.
B.) Doesn't have to apply to areas.
C.) Doesn't make guilds want to beat newbs up just for trying to lvl.

From there:
Every mob in the world has a % of a chance to drop a shard. There could be ..5 different types of shards.
A Broken Shard is here with you. [+1%]
A Cracked Shard is here with you. [+2%]
A Shard is here with you. [+3%]
A Glowing Shard is here with you. [+4%]
A Radiant Shard is here with you. [+5%]
Obviously the % to drop them is lower as their value increases. But should a mob randomly drop them, you should pick it up.
From there, you should bring that shard to your guild shrine and present it as an offering, increasing your guild's Blessing.

So we implement a "Blessing" system. Guilds don't necessarily have to fight each other and run newbs off their turf. Your guild would be blessed because your members are actively collecting shards to increase their Blessings.

Blessing lvl 10% = +1% Drop rate, +1% EXP Rate, +1% Gold.
Blessing lvl 20% =
Blessing lvl 30% =
Blessing lvl 40% =
Blessing lvl 50% =
Blessing lvl 60% =
Blessing lvl 70% =
Blessing lvl 80% =
Blessing lvl 90% =
Blessing lvl 100% = +10% Drop Rate, +10% Exp Rate, +10% Gold

Obviously make the drop rate for the shards rare, even for the lowest shard, but this keeps all clans happy and not looking for a reason to completely ruin other players gameplay by attacking smaller clans just for being in their area.

However, Blessings will be reduced by 1% every hour of server time...And say.. -10% at server reset?

**EDIT:
I would say that having starting cities for players and only allowing them certain gods per city would make this more lore friendly. As I've put it now.. we'll just call it blessings.. But if you created 3-4 STARTING CITYS.. we'd have a lot to work with.

We could then entertain the idea that some guilds only recruit people from a certain city, blah, blah, etc. Then transcending past guilds, but also allegiances unto one's city. You must then,
A.) Be loyal to your city
B.) Loyal to your guild
C.) Could help with roleplay aspects of the game.

Being a dick could then have you removed from your city. And if your guild requires you to be a citizen of your city, you could also be removed from that. Ex-communicated from everyone, accepting responsibility for your own actions.

This could open up CITY RAIDS. And also more roleplay diplomatic situations between players, guilds, citys.

Being an enemy of the state could mean that upon entry unto said city-state, you will be attacked by it's gate Guards. All of the cities in the game we have now could technically be.."Neutral" cities. We could just make 3 new starter cities for players right now. Each gets to pick 2 Gods/Divinities.

Starter city guards would be lvl 25 with OAD equipment. You'd need a force to get past them. At which point, if you did, you could wreck the city. Destroying it's town shops, etc. Leaving them to respawn at server reset time.

IF WE MAKE STARTER CITIES:
A.) Make a City chat channel.
B.) Ignore everything I said about guilds being able to get their own shards, and make it city wide, not guild wide. (Which would improve guild relationships inside their own cities)

**EDIT2**
Gator - Today at 8:09 PM
Add it to your post. Get the think tank snowballing it. It could be something that happens.
****
We could have a Guild War every 2 days. Using the same equation as above. Just so guilds within cities/or whatever, could still participate versus each other.
#1 Ranking Guild = 1%
#10 Ranking Guild = 10%
Folder
I quite like this idea. The first bit about shards I mean. It encourages people to do stuff and with the decay it's not just a permanent buff. It would feel rewarding when you get a shard and turn it in, like you're doing your part to help your guild.

Obviously it benefits larger guilds more though, that's the main issue. Could perhaps try and devise a system where it takes more shards the larger your guild is?


edit: I don't think this needs to take the place of anything, it can be its own thing.
Ohko
If it's possible to determine the number of accounts in the guild, we could then use this to make the decay faster based on that number. If not, then the more people you have online in the guild, the faster the decay. This will prevent people from afker so often too.
daedroth
If it's possible to determine the number of accounts in the guild, we could then use this to make the decay faster based on that number. If not, then the more people you have online in the guild, the faster the decay. This will prevent people from afker so often too.


Aye good idea. I think it'd work best if it was based on the amount of account holders online. I think that would be the fairest, I don't know about other guilds, but we have a lot of clannies who only twitch once in a while (hardly on in game).
Give shards a "HP" value. Each account member online drains a HP per tick or something.
Then its "wounds" level would affect its bonus.
New shards heal it?
JadeFalcon
Oooo me likes this!

The first though is that we can actually take our time to develop this - it sits nicely after NH has finished Guild houses and guild wars.
The concepts.. nothing comes to my mind that makes me defensive on this, barring the usual balancing issues of big vs small guilds.

On this, I guess we can tinker with %s and clan sizes (my suggestion instead of number of accounts, is average number of logged in people in a given period).
anthriel
I like ideas like this which promote active play (rather than idlers). I also like the follow up suggestions re making the rewards somehow scale to advantage smaller guilds rather than bigger ones. Such concepts are beneficial to bettering the depth and playability of the game. Keep em coming.
Sicx
This actually encourages helping newbs, etc, as well. As more mobs killed = more shards found. Even after you're lvl 25.. You still have a daily task to work towards.
daedroth
I thought my idea about giving shards HP would make it better for smaller clans (more online players means the shard is drained quicker), but then I realised it just made small and large clans equal (more online players means more chances to find more shards to top up the health of the shards).
If it was to be done this way and small clans were to be favoured then the drain could be exponential (but only by a small grade) instead of linear.
NiteHawk
This is pretty similar to guild wars. Just to throw it out there and explain how GW works. You'd have a vault, and mobs would have a chance to drop global shards that grant special bonuses around the world. Very low chance, and there would be a cap. I call them GLOBAL SHARDS to start, as a lame name.

They would grant bonuses and benefits. You'd probably have a maximum of X global shards you can hold. they would have expires as well.

A guild house would have two levels, the main housing area (aka the portion most guild members spend their time in, tav, healing rooms, etc) and then the dungeon area. You design it how you think is best, but the dungeon area would lead to the VAULT system. Guild members can venture in it freely, but others would have to explore and get to the end. There would be doors to bust down, NPCs, traps, etc all things that are upkeep costs and have an initial cost too. The goal would be to get in the vault and steal the global shards. I'm not sure about other things yet in terms of 'stealing' but certain shards are going to be too great to pass up. I don't think they can steal gold or items cause then players wouldn't use the guild houses, they would simply store gold/items on local accounts. So global shards are the way to go probably. This would be a huge cost sink though. It won't be cheap to make a good dungeon.

Obviously players cannot just raid whenever they want. Guilds would have set times they would be vulnerable. The bigger the guild, the more vulnerable time they have to deal with. The only thing the guild can do is set when these times occur spread out in 30 minute intervals (though you continue an interval to make longer ones.). So each VULNERABILITY POINT is 30 minutes. For example:
-GUILD A with 5 members has 1 vulnerability point. They set it at 8PM on Friday. So they are vulnerable from 8 to 8:30 on Friday.
-GUILD B with 10 members has 2 vulnerability points. They set one point at 3PM on Monday, and 6PM on Thursday, as that is when they probably will have the most people. So they are vulnerable 3-3:30 on Monday and 6-6:30 on Thursday.
-GUILD C with 15 members has 3 vulnerability points. They set all three points on Tuesday, one at 3, one at 3:30, and one at 4. This means they are vulnerable from 3-4:30 on Tuesday, all in one go.

Obviously you cannot just change your times on a whim, it would cost gold to do and it wouldn't take into effect that month for example. The amount of invul points is up in the air though, was just an example.

As for how global shards work, I am unsure yet. It could be that more guild members lessen the effects of the shards up to a certain amount (lets say minimum 50% or 70% or something) but each person in the guild is -1% effect on the shard up to that amount. This is not a set on stone thing though but might promote mid sized or smaller guilds from starting up as this plus the invul timer would be an effect. So someone with 5 members would have an effect of 95%. Someone with 10 members would have 90%. Someone with 20 members would have 80%. Someone with 100 members (no such thing but yeah) hits the minimum of 50%. The amount loss per member is debatable if we go this route.

Also, I keep saying player when we talk about negative effects, but I am referring to an account itself. So one player = his whole account.

------

Generally that's the idea of the guild war system. It's similar to your shrine system except that shrines probably can't be raided and their effects would probably be short term rather then long term. There is a possibility of both systems working together (Short term shrines and long term vaults) though. Not sure yet on that.

The issue however that falls flat with your shrine system vs the area capture system is you don't promote people PVPing for areas, so I don't see the removal of the area capture system. However, if we change how all the systems work for what bonuses they give they could work in harmony.

Area Capture System. Whoever owns the area gets a tax of 2% of any gold killed in that area. Each guild can hold lets say 3 max.
Shrine System. Short term boosts for XP, drop rate, gold. These shards drop more often than not and I'd propose only one item drop, not several different. The more that you throw into your shrine, the better bonuses you gain. So let's say each shrine shard you drop gives you 1% XP/1%Gold/0.5% drop rate. Something like that. Up to a max. Not raidable.
Guild Wars System. Long term boosts for pretty much many things. Raidable.


Though the shrine/guild war system is pretty similar, not sure if it would be too much. I wouldn't mind calling the guild wars global shard vault a 'Shrine' though. Thus they'd raid and attempt to capture global shards from the shrine instead. Reason being is it might be too much to have two similar systems in effect. But again I can see both systems working.


I don't really like the starter cities thing and I think it makes alot of confusion, specially with how the world scales now. It would have to be far larger to support and you need to move things to ensure players level in proper areas. I don't think we have the numbers to warrant it right now and what you are doing are splitting up newbies into different areas which hurts interaction. This would literally kill new player experience IMO if they don't see anyone. It's bad nuff as it is atm.
daedroth
Some ideas:
Combine the global shard idea with this one:
Different kinds of shards give different kind of bonuses.
I think fairest way is to give the shards HP (as I have already said below) amount of guild members online drains the HP of the shard.
Rarer shards have more HP (and/or better bonuses).
You can use a shard to top up the HP of the shard you have in place in your guild house or to replace the bonus of the shard that is in the Guild House (HP of shard changes to the mean of the two shards involved in this case).
Shard HP wound level dictates bonus.

Gold:
Clan gold can get sacked (# * number of enemy that make it through, maybe a percentage - but to a maximum number). This could be affected by Guild Size (smaller clans lose less money).
How to avoid exploitation of this (as in guild just moving their gold away into accounts)?
Make guild money only usable for guild items. You cannot withdraw the gold (you can still put in gold as normal).
Make the cost of stuff"rent" come of daily (at reset).
Can rooms be damaged (cost gold to repair)?
If guild bank gold goes into negative (because of the "rent") the clan loses all benefits and rooms are destroyed to cover the cost - full value of room is not recovered; as in only 50%? of the room cost is used to cover the debt, the rest disappears) until the clan gold is put into a positive value.

Meh, just ideas.
NiteHawk
The HP system is a good idea and I will probably use it. I like it as it makes larger guilds work a bit more which is good in any system. For guild wars though it would have to be ALOT of HP. If we base it off 30d or 90d originally, then the shard needs to expire at that time with a average amount of members. I.E.
8 member online AVERAGE is the base at any given time (Let's say.).. And you want the shard to -1HP every minute. SO:

A shard will lose about 11,520HP per day at that average. If you want a 30D shard then 345,600HP.

This means smaller guilds if they manage to hold the shard, the shard will last longer. A guild with 4 members online average would be 60D. A guild with 2 members online is 120D. Obviously they probably won't hold a shard very long with only 2 members though.


For the guild war system, the rooms themselves won't be damaged, but if someone breaks down a door you'd have to repair the door, yeah. Same with dead NPCs. There will be an easy way to 'repair all' though.



Clan gold can get sacked (# * number of enemy that make it through, maybe a percentage - but to a maximum number).


Why use guild gold vaults then? People won't store gold in guilds anymore and will simply make a account that handles the gold and give access to all leaders. If there is a lossless way people will do it.
daedroth
... Why use guild gold vaults then? People won't store gold in guilds anymore and will simply make a account that handles the gold and give access to all leaders. If there is a lossless way people will do it.

Then make Guild Bank separate totally. As in you can only get gold into the clan guild through clan tax rate. That way the gold would only be use-able for guild stuff and you could only get gold through the guild tax so there would be no way to avoid gold loss.
If there is no money in the guild then the guild will have no bonuses (no rooms, no shard etc). Guild house is de-activated.

Options:
No Guild house (or a de-activated one due to no money in the guild bank), you cannot raid another guild until guild is up and running.
You need a room to hold raid money (you can only get money from a raid if you have this room).
Raid gold goes to guild bank, because it is "guild gold" which is un-usable for anything other than guild stuff.
You can put gold into the guild bank, but there is a conversion fee.
You can take gold out of the guild bank, but... you guessed it, there is a conversion fee.
NiteHawk
... Why use guild gold vaults then? People won't store gold in guilds anymore and will simply make a account that handles the gold and give access to all leaders. If there is a lossless way people will do it.

Then make Guild Bank separate totally. As in you can only get gold into the clan guild through clan tax rate. That way the gold would only be use-able for guild stuff and you could only get gold through the guild tax so there would be no way to avoid gold loss.
If there is no money in the guild then the guild will have no bonuses (no rooms, no shard etc). Guild house is de-activated.

Options:
No Guild house (or a de-activated one due to no money in the guild bank), you cannot raid another guild until guild is up and running.
You need a room to hold raid money (you can only get money from a raid if you have this room).
Raid gold goes to guild bank, because it is "guild gold" which is un-usable for anything other than guild stuff.
You can put gold into the guild bank, but there is a conversion fee.
You can take gold out of the guild bank, but... you guessed it, there is a conversion fee.


Possibly, maybe when there is more of a use of gold yeah.
Terron
i like most of this the bonuses the hp thing etc. dont really like the "Set" times for raiding guilds. makes it 100% pointless. why do you need npc monsters and doors if you set it up for when u have 17 members online. how many times do you think a guild of 5 is going to run in and commit suicide. a small guild wont even hold a shard either , 3 slayers would end that. the npcs would have to be ktp and smash 800s or a large guild will just run em right over. let alone you can just make a surrogate guild with a defend time before the real guilds time, then hop the active members and gold over to the surrogate after its defend time is up then hop back and use a good shard for 6 days of free use.

id prefer a wager system.
guild A representative bets 50k and these 2 shards saying they can beat your dungeon with X members.
guild B representative agrees to the deal with 50k and these 2 shards on the line with X members.

each guild can set up a dungeon and staff an build a guild war portal square. where clan rep can type the command to accept a challenge and set the game in motion.

basically guild A's rep types /challenge guild name , wager 50,000 gold 2 shard of power , characters 6(must be a founder/chairman)

Guild B's rep can type /accept

both teams are teleported to the dungeon when team leaders type /begin challenge

smaller guilds would just have smaller bets and probably less characters for awhile, but can still participate.
daedroth
More Thoughts:

De-Activated Guild house costs half the cost to buy a guild house to re-activate.
The amount of raided gold you can get is determined by the amount of accounts in clan and how many enemy clan lived (max of 6).
Repeat raids in a set period of time nets you dminishing returns.
daedroth
More More Thoughts:

Remove the window of time to raid.
Introduce a HP cost to the shard and a gold cost based on each person sent on the raid. Maybe make it so that you get "warped in" and this costs.

Possible Problems:
Making the reward to raid potentially better than the costs to raid:
The gold gain from raiding is based on the amount people accounts in the Guild being raided (so it may not be worth raiding a small clan if you are a large clan) and the # of raiders left at the end.
Shard can be looted (but it loses a HEAP of HP; this could be based on # of account of raided guild vs # of account of the raiding guild and/or make it so that the HP recovered is based on # of raiders left). Could even make it like the picking up of a scale. Obviously yet again, it would need to be tilted so that large clans raiding small clans get less reward (cost could outweigh the reward if you send too many people) than a small clan raiding a large clan.
Off course a small clan raiding a large clan should be in trouble (too much defences).
This would potentially mean you will be better off or worse off than before you started (as a raider), especially if you are a large clan raiding a small clan.
However if that was to be done this way, there should be some kind of message before you start a raid "this guild is substantially smaller than your guild", "this guild is slightly larger than your guild", some kind of indicator to give you a general idea of the size difference between the guilds ("mine is bigger than yours" pun potential here).
NiteHawk
i like most of this the bonuses the hp thing etc. dont really like the "Set" times for raiding guilds. makes it 100% pointless. why do you need npc monsters and doors if you set it up for when u have 17 members online. how many times do you think a guild of 5 is going to run in and commit suicide. a small guild wont even hold a shard either , 3 slayers would end that. the npcs would have to be ktp and smash 800s or a large guild will just run em right over. let alone you can just make a surrogate guild with a defend time before the real guilds time, then hop the active members and gold over to the surrogate after its defend time is up then hop back and use a good shard for 6 days of free use.

id prefer a wager system.
guild A representative bets 50k and these 2 shards saying they can beat your dungeon with X members.
guild B representative agrees to the deal with 50k and these 2 shards on the line with X members.

each guild can set up a dungeon and staff an build a guild war portal square. where clan rep can type the command to accept a challenge and set the game in motion.

basically guild A's rep types /challenge guild name , wager 50,000 gold 2 shard of power , characters 6(must be a founder/chairman)

Guild B's rep can type /accept

both teams are teleported to the dungeon when team leaders type /begin challenge

smaller guilds would just have smaller bets and probably less characters for awhile, but can still participate.


I don't see why guilds would accept any fights from anyone bigger than them. I also don't see why larger guilds would even bother risking their global shards when they're full up. No one would fight often and if you have the maximum global shards which will probably be a count of three, you wouldn't fight unless you're lacking shards or know you're going to win. But then the people you are fighting are mostly full up on shards, thus they wouldn't accept.

let alone you can just make a surrogate guild with a defend time before the real guilds time, then hop the active members and gold over to the surrogate after its defend time is up then hop back and use a good shard for 6 days of free use.


I don't really understand what this means exactly. Why would they make a surrogate guild in this scenario? Are you thinking actual defenders can't defend their keep? They'll be able to defend without hopping though. I honestly don't really think gold should be used as a 'steal' and it should only be based on global shards with the set time system. Otherwise smaller guilds would just be over-run. With shards only you'd at least prevent larger guilds from doing it constantly as they'd probably have full shards, but would expect to be attacked themselves. Doesn't mean smaller guilds couldn't band up, etc. There could be though a gold fee to 'enter' the raid based on your guild size vs their guild size like dae stated. There also could be a maximum raid amount per guild. Let's say only 6 can defend, and 6 can attack.

why do you need npc monsters and doors if you set it up for when u have 17 members online.


NPCs could possibly be ignored/not used, but without doors or some sort of locks you're literally just running to the vault area and end gaming it. Even with your system or the set times, you need obstacles. Otherwise it's literally just a run to the vault.
Terron
if there isnt a way to limit alt usage for clans small vs big itll just be a team mosh except staff isnt there to even the teams, 3-5 noobs run in get smoked by 24 backstabs and roundhouses. wash rinse repeat.

why would you need npcs doors etc, you would want the smaller guilds to run right to the end as fast as possible so your 17 member team can just rape their faces as much as possible lol. its like a team of anteaters where the ants relentlessly attack w/o any hope of winning.
and guess what..we didnt even use a shard this week we just wanted to gorge on meaningless ants.
daedroth
if there isnt a way to limit alt usage for clans small vs big itll just be a team mosh except staff isnt there to even the teams, 3-5 noobs run in get smoked by 24 backstabs and roundhouses. wash rinse repeat.

why would you need npcs doors etc, you would want the smaller guilds to run right to the end as fast as possible so your 17 member team can just rape their faces as much as possible lol. its like a team of anteaters where the ants relentlessly attack w/o any hope of winning.
and guess what..we didnt even use a shard this week we just wanted to gorge on meaningless ants.


I know you like to write, but try to learn to read what others write.
Terron
and you should probably realize other people have a greater scope of understanding the mechanics of these features than you do. i have helped design a few mmo's and all of them have problems with a raid clan feature. you cant name 1 game in existence that doesnt, because there isnt one. if the clan gets to a point its so large they cba to even care, they cant lose anyway. if they have a shard they will defend it, if they dont they will defend a nonexistent shard, they will just sit there in a group of 20 1x a week and slaughter, just to humor themselves. because it is actually funny. you lose no exp, you lose no gear, you dont lose character rank or standing, you will respawn right in your own guild house, you will run back if you even managed to die. guilds will leave vault empty on purpose. some wont even defend if they are small, and just except 6.x days of use on a shard or just sell them.

then 1 miraculous occasion the server merges to destroy Top guild A, they log on in droves, and when they get to the vault...wha?!! its empty. they all logged on us. someone leaked our attack plans... this happens on games with 4 million players. how do you actually expect it not to with 45.

the only way this is working is with a system of alt use attacker attacks with 5, defender defends with 5(defender uses npcs to help(useful like this, not useful in 20v6)
locked gold so people cannot remove it from guild and it actually be able to be stolen.
some sort of ranking system to actually add value to the system
and a random timer that just goes off (globally announced) when you have X accounts with 25ers online to defend.(stop idling <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />)
or some sort of RP system where teams can try to conquer your dungeon for fun.(future builder training)

other than that its just a grief system.