Race Stat Changes
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
a pk ninja with less than a half % chance to hit 5 for 5 and still do less damage than an average slayer hitting 2x. im not saying a slayer cant be the best pker around and have major solo value, just at the moment its a tad excessive.
i didnt even say they need removed its just the game is 1 sided in their favor right now. the class can all be lizards and even kill their theoretical weakness. as chanters still cant round them and need to hit 7-8 times which can be 3+ rounds vs 10 wis.
for the time being a str brigand(x3) is plenty of damage, slayer is overkill. until theres more mage types(some with burst damage) and some other burst damage melee classes to offer competition slayer is way out of proportion.
Completely disagree.
- 1vs1 in a fair duel, a 25er slayer can be beaten by lots of classes (trust me i know)
- You are neglecting the level of the target, also. Its completely different when we are talking about a lvl 25 vs a lvl 16, or a lvl 25 vs a lvl 24 (mind you, lvl 24 sorcs can beat lvl 25 saurians, and not make it even close)
The reason you see many lizards is because people don't invest in enchanters - and therefore people don't invest in high MR slayers/ninja's, such as halflings. Its not a question of strength, i positively s*** myself when i see Xpose around, and i wont attack enchanter's (or elder druids).
... i positively s*** myself when i see Xpose around ...
Because he exposes himself!
HeeHee!
What? it's been a long day <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_redface.gif" alt=":oops:" title="Embarrassed" />
the reason noone selects mages is because they dont have a major dominance factor over every character including their weakness. its like selecting a gnome bard. you can obviously. youd undoubtedly kill about 9/10 mages you fight but it isnt enough to make you choose a magekiller when youd lose to 90% of the game.
slayers can die, the odds of hitting are technically in no melee attackers favor. it wasnt about them dieing really. it was about the success rate on popping off 2 backstabs or 3 in a row is significantly higher than other classes hitting 6-7x in a row to put out the same caliber of damage. i do believe they should do higher damage than the others, i also realize that when they do whiff it hurts a bit more to them than other classes.
its just about the overview of it all,
- party of 6 wandering gy, slayer sees a nub in party...yay. has a lil more than 16%+ variance chance to kill it automatically. then to top it off the other 5 cant even kill the slayer they have to run or all die aswell unless its 3+ mages....
-1100 hp or less level 25 walking around killing raiders pop pop 16% death no way to defend it. the slayer has a 0.4% chance to die to this melee character and thats saying the melee character hits 200*6 and the slayer doesnt leave if it misses. so whats the real odds? a big 0
the game is slayerville and noone can deny it. and here i thought this wasnt rok.
slayers can die, the odds of hitting are technically in no melee attackers favor. it wasnt about them dieing really. it was about the success rate on popping off 2 backstabs or 3 in a row is significantly higher than other classes hitting 6-7x in a row to put out the same caliber of damage. i do believe they should do higher damage than the others, i also realize that when they do whiff it hurts a bit more to them than other classes.
its just about the overview of it all,
- party of 6 wandering gy, slayer sees a nub in party...yay. has a lil more than 16%+ variance chance to kill it automatically. then to top it off the other 5 cant even kill the slayer they have to run or all die aswell unless its 3+ mages....
-1100 hp or less level 25 walking around killing raiders pop pop 16% death no way to defend it. the slayer has a 0.4% chance to die to this melee character and thats saying the melee character hits 200*6 and the slayer doesnt leave if it misses. so whats the real odds? a big 0
the game is slayerville and noone can deny it. and here i thought this wasnt rok.
its just about the overview of it all,
- party of 6 wandering gy, slayer sees a nub in party...yay. has a lil more than 16%+ variance chance to kill it automatically. then to top it off the other 5 cant even kill the slayer they have to run or all die aswell unless its 3+ mages....
-1100 hp or less level 25 walking around killing raiders pop pop 16% death no way to defend it. the slayer has a 0.4% chance to die to this melee character and thats saying the melee character hits 200*6 and the slayer doesnt leave if it misses. so whats the real odds? a big 0
the game is slayerville and noone can deny it. and here i thought this wasnt rok.
See this is where i disagree with you - and without actual hard stats, we will go back in circles because no one can prove to be right:
- Attacking a party of 6 lvl 16s that might happen. But i personally never did that and lived. At best, I once killed 3 levelers, but crucially - they stayed and fought. At lvl 20+... its rarely happens I land 2bs on anyone. Way less than 16% - again one has to account AC, AGI, etc.
- I beg to differ - I've tried 3 times to kill Preston at raiders (for example), and three times have i died. 1vs1, with or without pots, i just dont find it convincing that slayers are OP - and im fairly well equipped on mine.
Furthermore, one thing is delivering 2bs in a row, another is inflicting damage - at 40% hit change, what are the odds I "wont" do damage? They are higher for a slayer than for a Ninja for sure.
I do get your point about the damage potential of enchanters - i'd actually focus on getting Necromancers to be the "magic damage" type class, but that is a separate discussion.
yes the 16% would be affected by ac, shield blocks, armor blocks, etc. but other classes deal with these 3 atleast 2x as often as backstab because its per attack. so any adjustment factor for slayer is twice as detrimental to a cav for example. if the 16% is amended to 10% via ac/shields etc. than the other melees range is lowered to almost impossibility.
slayers have a 50% greater chance to null a whole round. which is why they do die 1v1, which im not denying. if you stay for extra rounds. imho a slayer only dies if they want to.
personally i think ninja has more merit and magnitude to the whole game. however it is an extremely high rate of success for slayers regardless. it just furthers the imbalance of race because you dont want gnomes/lings because chances are a saurian/horc slayer kills you in 2 hits.
having said this, i dont want slayers nerfed or anything(they could use less survivability tho), unless its a temporary thing. because this is all the class has. i am just hoping for some competition for them before the game is all slayers and its already close.
slayers have a 50% greater chance to null a whole round. which is why they do die 1v1, which im not denying. if you stay for extra rounds. imho a slayer only dies if they want to.
personally i think ninja has more merit and magnitude to the whole game. however it is an extremely high rate of success for slayers regardless. it just furthers the imbalance of race because you dont want gnomes/lings because chances are a saurian/horc slayer kills you in 2 hits.
having said this, i dont want slayers nerfed or anything(they could use less survivability tho), unless its a temporary thing. because this is all the class has. i am just hoping for some competition for them before the game is all slayers and its already close.
"snipp"
There would be an easy way to do this - take out the slayer double hide (the new mechanic) thus making them useless for OADs.
Not sure if suggesting this would make you popular, though <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
all classes of any race should be useable at oads otherwise there is ultimately no reason to level many characters. level a cleric if you can do that, level an oad crit, level your RP character, level a pker done.
i would rather suggest making brigand an actual choice for pvp.
give brigand a large dodge bonus 5 - 10%, and a decent mr bonus 2.5 - 5%. that comboed with their smaller bs and ability to use bows and crit arrows could make them viable enough. aswell as keeping the medium armor.
slayers would downgrade 1 armor type and have a small penalty to hps (-4%) and lose shields.
then u have a smaller damage survivable backstab class and one that is a fanatical damage type.
i would rather suggest making brigand an actual choice for pvp.
give brigand a large dodge bonus 5 - 10%, and a decent mr bonus 2.5 - 5%. that comboed with their smaller bs and ability to use bows and crit arrows could make them viable enough. aswell as keeping the medium armor.
slayers would downgrade 1 armor type and have a small penalty to hps (-4%) and lose shields.
then u have a smaller damage survivable backstab class and one that is a fanatical damage type.
Both would be a bit much on brigand. My dark elf brig already does decent stabs and dodges well enough. to give him extra dodge AND mr i feel would make him far too good.
might be, still wont be a slayer. i still think thief should have a small mr and bonus dodge 5% to each atleast. monks have both and pretty high. not saying brigand buff wouldn't end up too much if it was 10%. it would have to be high enough to make a difference. however if youre saying your brigand is "plenty good" what does that make a slayer? too good?..
thief isnt a combatant by nature so the dodge can be reflected as a major avoidance such as diving or rolling out of the way. monks have dodge but i think it reflects their ability to deflect attacks or absorb them by making them glance off. ive been in martial arts for a long time "dodging" leaves you open. you can only roll your head back to avoid a cross so often before you get kicked in the teeth. just sayin.
the mr would reflect the thieves goal...robbing wizard towers of their magical items. that is the major aim of all thieves...the big score that earns retirement.
no matter what values the brigand would receive, it does bring the game more inline as some people would start using brigands a little more and slayers take a little hit to survival. might give some lings/gnomes some love when they dont die in 2 hits. lol
thief isnt a combatant by nature so the dodge can be reflected as a major avoidance such as diving or rolling out of the way. monks have dodge but i think it reflects their ability to deflect attacks or absorb them by making them glance off. ive been in martial arts for a long time "dodging" leaves you open. you can only roll your head back to avoid a cross so often before you get kicked in the teeth. just sayin.
the mr would reflect the thieves goal...robbing wizard towers of their magical items. that is the major aim of all thieves...the big score that earns retirement.
no matter what values the brigand would receive, it does bring the game more inline as some people would start using brigands a little more and slayers take a little hit to survival. might give some lings/gnomes some love when they dont die in 2 hits. lol
In terms of the half orc str, simply modifying how STR works would probably be a better idea. Not by much, but lowering their STR makes them pretty nil. Everyone would get the hit IMO, but you'd reduce the chance of two hits by a little, (not by much.)
In terms of hit rate. 50% greater chance to null is 'technically' incorrect. If your dodge rate is 50%, just because you only have two attacks doesn't mean your overall hit rate goes down. I get where you are coming from but you're still hitting 50% of the time with only two attacks vs four attacks, but your still doing 4x damage.
Brigs will have traps and other things, though possibility of other little perks too vs slayers they aren't terrible IMO, they just need some more things, but rome wasn't built in a day. Thieves will be useful in the future, you can bet yourself on that, specially for guild wars and some other things.
Maybe the biggest problem is the 10% bonus they get from dual wielding which honestly is a pretty high bonus when it comes to backstabbing. Or maybe the delay per hide isn't enough. Maybe slayers need a small dodge reduction. Should have a slayer discussion somewhere else though.
A lot of things can probably be adjusted with formula adjustments for the racial changes based on statements and how everything should work, taking it slowly though.
In terms of hit rate. 50% greater chance to null is 'technically' incorrect. If your dodge rate is 50%, just because you only have two attacks doesn't mean your overall hit rate goes down. I get where you are coming from but you're still hitting 50% of the time with only two attacks vs four attacks, but your still doing 4x damage.
Brigs will have traps and other things, though possibility of other little perks too vs slayers they aren't terrible IMO, they just need some more things, but rome wasn't built in a day. Thieves will be useful in the future, you can bet yourself on that, specially for guild wars and some other things.
Maybe the biggest problem is the 10% bonus they get from dual wielding which honestly is a pretty high bonus when it comes to backstabbing. Or maybe the delay per hide isn't enough. Maybe slayers need a small dodge reduction. Should have a slayer discussion somewhere else though.
A lot of things can probably be adjusted with formula adjustments for the racial changes based on statements and how everything should work, taking it slowly though.
it is not technically incorrect run the math they have half the attack attempts and the hit rate stays the same. run the sim with 1000 attacks (22 agi vs 22 agi) see how often the slayer does 0 damage and how many times a bard hits atleast 1 out of 4. it will be a 50% greater whiff amount for the slayer. (as in 150% of 10 is 15 etc not a flat 50%.)
Furthermore, one thing is delivering 2bs in a row, another is inflicting damage - at 40% hit change, what are the odds I "wont" do damage? They are higher for a slayer than for a Ninja for sure.
it is not technically incorrect run the math they have half the attack attempts and the hit rate stays the same. run the sim with 1000 attacks (22 agi vs 22 agi) see how often the slayer does 0 damage and how many times a bard hits atleast 1 out of 4. it will be a 50% greater whiff amount for the slayer. (as in 150% of 10 is 15 etc not a flat 50%.)
Well yeah I get that bit but I still don't see it being valid fully because one hit of a slayer is more then double. Obviously in 1000 attacks with 40% base your looking at 400 out of 1000 attacks hitting, but for slayers it would be 200 out of 1000 attacks, but obviously because 500 of them are hiding. However since they deal 4x damage I'd rather be the one dealing half the hits but 4x the damage (though basing it off dagger damage which is a little lower on the base.) Of course this means they will have rounds where they fully miss 'more' but that doesn't mean they lose less fights because of it. Their multiplier makes up way more for it. It would like be saying that having a class that only has 10% HR but hits for 2k damage. Yeah he'd have several rounds he'd miss, but his damage makes up for it and in most cases he'll win.
I don't disagree that other classes couldn't get bonuses though.
Both would be a bit much on brigand. My dark elf brig already does decent stabs and dodges well enough. to give him extra dodge AND mr i feel would make him far too good.
Brigs don't really have a dodge bonus so your basing it's dodge with no bonuses.
yeah nh thats what i was saying before. they get basically a huge advantage with metaphoric 3-4 hits for the price of 1, even at half attacks. they dont have to roll 4 successful attack rolls for 500-600 damage like a bard/cav etc would. JF was using the fail rate as an influential saying the complete round failure rate more than makes up for it. in certain situations yeah, it probably does, in others theres no way. the fail rate for a single round is 36% (0 hits).
that wasnt my issue at all. my issue was with just the 16% chance to land both w/o real repercussions. JF says he doesnt really attack mages but in reality he can try to kill them for free and if he fails, and mage stays around, he can just drink a potion and leave(mage cant round him). if you are on a slayer and take the gamble and stick around that's a choice not a statistic. 16% isnt overly great odds to stick around after you start getting blasted.
in the situation half hits on a slayer is a benefit 1 attack roll for 4x damage vs 4 attack rolls for similar output. this isnt supposed to be turning into a nerf slayer rant, id just like some reasonable competition. slayers may wiff 36% of rounds but what can round them in 4 stamina? nothing. so its always a free chance.
that wasnt my issue at all. my issue was with just the 16% chance to land both w/o real repercussions. JF says he doesnt really attack mages but in reality he can try to kill them for free and if he fails, and mage stays around, he can just drink a potion and leave(mage cant round him). if you are on a slayer and take the gamble and stick around that's a choice not a statistic. 16% isnt overly great odds to stick around after you start getting blasted.
in the situation half hits on a slayer is a benefit 1 attack roll for 4x damage vs 4 attack rolls for similar output. this isnt supposed to be turning into a nerf slayer rant, id just like some reasonable competition. slayers may wiff 36% of rounds but what can round them in 4 stamina? nothing. so its always a free chance.
You keep forgetting about time delay for a slayer. Each round a slayer loses a SLIGHT amount of time. Slayer needs to move, victim can just stand there and spam (or run).
Also, as I have said before, they SHOULD have the best potential for rounding/quick killing, the hint is in the class name.
Also, as I have said before, they SHOULD have the best potential for rounding/quick killing, the hint is in the class name.
yeah nh thats what i was saying before. they get basically a huge advantage with metaphoric 3-4 hits for the price of 1, even at half attacks. they dont have to roll 4 successful attack rolls for 500-600 damage like a bard/cav etc would. JF was using the fail rate as an influential saying the complete round failure rate more than makes up for it. in certain situations yeah, it probably does, in others theres no way. the fail rate for a single round is 36% (0 hits).
that wasnt my issue at all. my issue was with just the 16% chance to land both w/o real repercussions. JF says he doesnt really attack mages but in reality he can try to kill them for free and if he fails, and mage stays around, he can just drink a potion and leave(mage cant round him). if you are on a slayer and take the gamble and stick around that's a choice not a statistic. 16% isnt overly great odds to stick around after you start getting blasted.
in the situation half hits on a slayer is a benefit 1 attack roll for 4x damage vs 4 attack rolls for similar output. this isnt supposed to be turning into a nerf slayer rant, id just like some reasonable competition. slayers may wiff 36% of rounds but what can round them in 4 stamina? nothing. so its always a free chance.
I think mages still have a good upper hand against them though, even if they manage to get in a pot or two, 3-4 hits on a saurian I would assume is between 550-720 damage easily they'd have to deal with. Of course the slayer will get chances to actually beat the mage, but I think in most scenarios it's not the case. Mages can also easily reduce damage with sap (-160 to -176 damage to backstabs) which would prevent double tapping.
But yeah that is true, slayers 'normally' do have a chance to round. I do agree with you that slayers do get a pretty heavy amount of damage 'potential' in one round. Things like duel wielding giving a damage bonus obviously had stronger effects than they really should. I still do think they should be the leaders in damage, and deal higher damage than normal, but even without that 10% they would for example.
They don't have many 'negatives' right now in terms of how they work. Maybe DW'ing needs another looking at, maybe slayers need less HP, maybe the damage is actually okay but succession backstabs in the same round should have a slightly less chance of hitting two in a row. NOT saying this is what is going to happen guises, I'm just throwing out ideas. I do think that they are a bit overpowered though. Of course they are going to lose from time to time. That's what happens in a random chance game sometimes, that's how it goes.
Slayers should probably be discussed elsewhere though, though I intend on bringing up all classes and seeing what we can do for slight improvements in the nearish future.
Again, I still want slayers being as they pretty much are now, heavy hitters and good ambushers, that's what makes them unique. There are probably other ways to balance how classes work too.
I probably need to make a good system that gives statistics throughout the day before I actually do things like this though. Things like who did the killing, who died, average damage per race/class, blahblah. Proper statistics would help alot though it's a good task to do on it's own.
the initial round is all that matters imo. the slayer can attempt pk and run their ass off if they want, 0 chance of death. i think it sucks because atm they have no competition at all. no class will have the upperhand unless a slayer user decides to stick around. "assassins" have technical flaws in almost every game. mostly because they take the finesse aspect away so clumsy drooling half orcs can somehow hide in plain sight and make no sound in chainmail... but most problems become apparent especially if they are the only class available to round someone. same could be said about any class that would 4/4 16% of the time (22 agi vs 10 agi would be 16.7%)
anyhow, whats up with proposal 19? was it victorious or not?
anyhow, whats up with proposal 19? was it victorious or not?
the initial round is all that matters imo. the slayer can attempt pk and run their ass off if they want, 0 chance of death. i think it sucks because atm they have no competition at all. no class will have the upperhand unless a slayer user decides to stick around. "assassins" have technical flaws in almost every game. mostly because they take the finesse aspect away so clumsy drooling half orcs can somehow hide in plain sight and make no sound in chainmail... but most problems become apparent especially if they are the only class available to round someone. same could be said about any class that would 4/4 16% of the time (22 agi vs 10 agi would be 16.7%)
anyhow, whats up with proposal 19? was it victorious or not?
I think removing hp maybe 5-15% would be great for balancing. Would make agi more important and give casters a bit more upper hand on them.
Agree here but should prob just get those race changes in asap then take a look at assassins and other classes. I'm assuming we are going with 19 too?
the initial round is all that matters imo. the slayer can attempt pk and run their ass off if they want, 0 chance of death. i think it sucks because atm they have no competition at all. no class will have the upperhand unless a slayer user decides to stick around. "assassins" have technical flaws in almost every game. mostly because they take the finesse aspect away so clumsy drooling half orcs can somehow hide in plain sight and make no sound in chainmail... but most problems become apparent especially if they are the only class available to round someone. same could be said about any class that would 4/4 16% of the time (22 agi vs 10 agi would be 16.7%)
anyhow, whats up with proposal 19? was it victorious or not?
I haven't done much of the math like him but I generally have to agree with Terron's insights re slayer burst damage making them decent even against natural enemies (eg mages) and the tactical choice to run away and/or hide if they fail meaning most enemies simply can't easily catch an opportunistic slayer that wants to hit and run (getting free attempts to pk/round with little risk to themselves).
Some possible solutions would be:
1. Introduce a magical burst damage spell of some kind (I like this idea cos it helps low HP mages be more viable in group fights)
2. Penalise failed backstab abit more (eg immediate exhaust like failed steals on thief or increased cooldown for rehiding etc).... Not sure how this would work
3. Reduce slayer survivability via formulas (tho they prolly still can run/hide well so not sure how effective this is)
4. Reduce slayer damage output somehow (don't like this one entirely myself, I'd rather have other classes find ways to find/catch/kill them better if they do want to fight back)
5. Scale backstab hitrate proportionately to agility... Ie if they have 4x damage then make agility 4x as important for landing backstab??
In any case I also agree we should implement the best decided race changes and then deal with the class balancing issues ppl have raised (eg horc slayers, Ele Druids, brigands etc) as next step.
I haven't done much of the math like him but I generally have to agree with Terron's insights re slayer burst damage making them decent even against natural enemies (eg mages) and the tactical choice to run away and/or hide if they fail meaning most enemies simply can't easily catch an opportunistic slayer that wants to hit and run (getting free attempts to pk/round with little risk to themselves).
Some possible solutions would be:
1. Introduce a magical burst damage spell of some kind (I like this idea cos it helps low HP mages be more viable in group fights)
2. Penalise failed backstab abit more (eg immediate exhaust like failed steals on thief or increased cooldown for rehiding etc).... Not sure how this would work
3. Reduce slayer survivability via formulas (tho they prolly still can run/hide well so not sure how effective this is)
4. Reduce slayer damage output somehow (don't like this one entirely myself, I'd rather have other classes find ways to find/catch/kill them better if they do want to fight back)
5. Scale backstab hitrate proportionately to agility... Ie if they have 4x damage then make agility 4x as important for landing backstab??
In any case I also agree we should implement the best decided race changes and then deal with the class balancing issues ppl have raised (eg horc slayers, Ele Druids, brigands etc) as next step.
That idea is similar to mine, but instead of BS scaling with agi, i think it should scale with current stam, like 1 stam = 70%, 2 stam = 80%, 3 stam = 90%, 4 stam = 100% of current BS damage.
Every sucessfull BS should make them exhausted, and missing BS should consume only 1 stam point.
That way they will still able to do what they do, try again for lesser damage if they miss, what makes sense since the target is now aware of his presence, or choose to run for a better later opportunity.
But now with risks that may be more fair trade off with their power.
Guys feel free to make a slayer or whatever class suggestion tread and move stuff over there but lets keep this to race if possible. Creeping up on a month now with races in limbo we got enough to figure out with just races atm.