Death sickness account wide?
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
And why that all of a sudden?
Did you get killed at an oad and wants to change the game bc of that or something?
Did you get killed at an oad and wants to change the game bc of that or something?
And why that all of a sudden?
Did you get killed at an oad and wants to change the game bc of that or something?
I know it's hard to believe, but this is brought up because I give a shit about the state of the game and I critically think about what is good and what is not. Go back under your bridge.
Re: what Terron is saying. For sure running back real quick is just as much a problem, but I think solving it via alt use is easier and more logical than changing all game areas. This affects dreads keys, seta, thanatos, refinery. It can affect anywhere really and no doubt future areas will be affected. I think it's good to think about fixing this now. Changing dreads is fine and all but to me that's kind of a small bandaid solution. I definitely don't like making trap squares intensely hard because people solo level and that would just be mean to them.
A battle shouldn't last forever. That was the intended purpose of the sickness. If a small group jumps a bigger group using tactics, and manages to actually get the upper hand, all would probably be lost just because the bigger group can swap alts (and have more alts to boot.). Any tactics are pretty much thrown out with the use of alt hordes, specially if the guild is larger. It shouldn't last forever and I can understand that 'the person who gets the most tired zombing' isn't really so fun. I'm not saying a battle can't last long either. Longer fights are OK.
I couldn't have said it better. This is exactly the problem - strategy is thrown to the wind and I think that is detrimental to the game. It's pretty fun to try and fight 4 or 5v6 and try to strategically win by using certain class combos, but it's all for naught when the larger group just pours back in.
SIGH, since I have to say this....this is 100% NOT MOTIVATED BY LOSING A FIGHT. Please try and think bigger than that. We won a fight at Seta today by zombie-ing and running alts forever until we won. Some people used 3-4 alts, and I think that's dumb as hell. I really think the game would be better off with death meaning something instead of just logging your next 25er that's 5 spaces away and full of pots.
in my honest opinion slayers remove strategy from the game as it is. all you need is priests and slayers and just wait for the pop pop.
most classes have an avg output of 270-320 dmg per round (potions heal 250 of it) so its a stalemate of luck until a slayer or 2 comes along and pops 700-1500 in a single round.
zombying is no where near as detrimental to strategy as a class running around with 2-3x the power of others.
then throw in the fact that debuffs barely last on 10 wis and cripple high wis for insane amounts of time.
the meta for the entire game is 10 wisdom atm. the 10 wis melee units are better, the 10 wis casters survive longer, weaker race melee can max chr instead of wis to be more competitive. your oad characters can select less wisdom so they are silenced/paralyzed for shorter duration. broken.
you want strategy..#delete slayers
most classes have an avg output of 270-320 dmg per round (potions heal 250 of it) so its a stalemate of luck until a slayer or 2 comes along and pops 700-1500 in a single round.
zombying is no where near as detrimental to strategy as a class running around with 2-3x the power of others.
then throw in the fact that debuffs barely last on 10 wis and cripple high wis for insane amounts of time.
the meta for the entire game is 10 wisdom atm. the 10 wis melee units are better, the 10 wis casters survive longer, weaker race melee can max chr instead of wis to be more competitive. your oad characters can select less wisdom so they are silenced/paralyzed for shorter duration. broken.
you want strategy..#delete slayers
in my honest opinion slayers remove strategy from the game as it is. all you need is priests and slayers and just wait for the pop pop.
most classes have an avg output of 270-320 dmg per round (potions heal 250 of it) so its a stalemate of luck until a slayer or 2 comes along and pops 700-1500 in a single round.
zombying is no where near as detrimental to strategy as a class running around with 2-3x the power of others.
then throw in the fact that debuffs barely last on 10 wis and cripple high wis for insane amounts of time.
the meta for the entire game is 10 wisdom atm. the 10 wis melee units are better, the 10 wis casters survive longer, weaker race melee can max chr instead of wis to be more competitive. your oad characters can select less wisdom so they are silenced/paralyzed for shorter duration. broken.
you want strategy..#delete slayers
I agree slayers need a weakness for all their power but I’m not sure what that is but maybe a very short para after a missed backstab or searched out.
As for high wis characters and having debuffs last way longer on them I agree it’s a bit backwards (hawk knows I feel this way) and even gives low wis characters more power but in theory high wis shouldnt get hit with debuffs very often. Even if you are getting hit half the time low wis characters do that length is killer. Than has extreme high int so everyone pretty much get hit with blind no matter what wis but again I think debuff timer should be the same for all wis and just the penetration should be the difference.
I would like to see he breakdown of hit rate and length of debuffs tho so I’m not just talking out of my ass.
Also what about a 1 second movement delay like how meteror ball worked when you have sickness?
And why that all of a sudden?
Did you get killed at an oad and wants to change the game bc of that or something?
Devil's Advocate: Your argument can be switched around you realise that yes?
I am ok either way. The way it is is silly, but I am not bothered. Change or not, I am fine either way.
Right now though, a lot of fights are determined by numbers and willpower.
Let's have a poll and hope no one is swayed by a temporary victory/defeat at the latest mass brawl they were involved in.
Also negative effect spells affecting crits with higher WIs is also silly, always thought this tbh, just did not have the energy to fight against it <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
their weakness should be a relative crappy hide ability and lower armor like light armor light helm( maybe even cloth) and some kind of endurance penalty like -5% hp and/or dodge loss. atm their only weakness lies to a chanter, in which a priest nullifies a chanter and 1-2 other dps every round, potion negates the 4th party members damage.
u could take the same party fight scenario and toss similar stated brigs in to replace the slayers and theyd still hit around 400-1100 in those rounds. that is still efficient enough to sway a group fight. slayer atm is 100% overkill. they out-damage bezerkers hitting 3 flurrys in 1 round and succeed at it 4-16x as often statistically. its nuts.
games fillin up with slayers better to fix it now than wait til 95% of us all use em.
id be open to help u test the exact times thannys blind etc work on characters.(or silence/paralyze from various oads)
if i recall, its about 45 seconds on a drake monk with 12 wis
20 wisdom halfling death mage was around 4m45s
22 wis gnome sorc level 23 was even worse, seemed to never end.
i can tell ya for certain silence ends on my 16 wisdom elf bard before any priest at seta
buffs have a set time so should debuffs imo. if u keep getting debuffed as a lizard theres always a dark elf or something else. time to stop bending the meta to low wis. equilateral triangle time.
u could take the same party fight scenario and toss similar stated brigs in to replace the slayers and theyd still hit around 400-1100 in those rounds. that is still efficient enough to sway a group fight. slayer atm is 100% overkill. they out-damage bezerkers hitting 3 flurrys in 1 round and succeed at it 4-16x as often statistically. its nuts.
games fillin up with slayers better to fix it now than wait til 95% of us all use em.
id be open to help u test the exact times thannys blind etc work on characters.(or silence/paralyze from various oads)
if i recall, its about 45 seconds on a drake monk with 12 wis
20 wisdom halfling death mage was around 4m45s
22 wis gnome sorc level 23 was even worse, seemed to never end.
i can tell ya for certain silence ends on my 16 wisdom elf bard before any priest at seta
buffs have a set time so should debuffs imo. if u keep getting debuffed as a lizard theres always a dark elf or something else. time to stop bending the meta to low wis. equilateral triangle time.
While I don't agree with the overall sentiment of this thread, why not just put a 60 second flag on players whenever they engage in PvP and not allow a logout until the flag is removed? TOS circumvention with multiple accounts.
Edit: Pretty tiresome when every thread destabilizes into a "this particular class needs 'x'". Stay on the god damned topic.
While casters have a few more options battle-wise, melee characters require minimal micromanagement. Why on earth would numbers not dictate a battle? Take the 10 least skilled players and pit them against the 5 highest skilled players. Those 5 players would lose 99 times out of 100.
Edit: Pretty tiresome when every thread destabilizes into a "this particular class needs 'x'". Stay on the god damned topic.
Right now though, a lot of fights are determined by numbers and willpower.
While casters have a few more options battle-wise, melee characters require minimal micromanagement. Why on earth would numbers not dictate a battle? Take the 10 least skilled players and pit them against the 5 highest skilled players. Those 5 players would lose 99 times out of 100.
Edit: Pretty tiresome when every thread destabilizes into a "this particular class needs 'x'". Stay on the god damned topic.
To stop people doing alts, then comp id, and use exh bar for attacks, yes it would stop it, that way no fighting at all, nor the ability to move, which is what will then make peeps rage. There would only be 1 death penalty in this case. ** However, the time in between, based in the time lapse of the death penalty, should be lowered to reflect the ability to fight again. **
Problems associated with this is , as nighthawk stated, yes people will rage and become aggravated, from only sitting and waiting.
It would be a good thing to implement but on the other hand it's not in dire need of becoming put into the game, as other things are needing done first. However, this could be done at a later time.
Problems associated with this is , as nighthawk stated, yes people will rage and become aggravated, from only sitting and waiting.
It would be a good thing to implement but on the other hand it's not in dire need of becoming put into the game, as other things are needing done first. However, this could be done at a later time.
While I don't agree with the overall sentiment of this thread, why not just put a 60 second flag on players whenever they engage in PvP and not allow a logout until the flag is removed? TOS circumvention with multiple accounts.
Edit: Pretty tiresome when every thread destabilizes into a "this particular class needs 'x'". Stay on the god damned topic.
Right now though, a lot of fights are determined by numbers and willpower.
While casters have a few more options battle-wise, melee characters require minimal micromanagement. Why on earth would numbers not dictate a battle? Take the 10 least skilled players and pit them against the 5 highest skilled players. Those 5 players would lose 99 times out of 100.
I think when Daedroth said numbers he meant "alts running back", not just flat out numbers from the start? I'd agree with that. Obviously 10 winning against 5 is gonna happen, this isn't about that.
Plz to stop derailing thread with slayer talk. New thread for that plz friends.
While casters have a few more options battle-wise, melee characters require minimal micromanagement. Why on earth would numbers not dictate a battle? Take the 10 least skilled players and pit them against the 5 highest skilled players. Those 5 players would lose 99 times out of 100.
casters have almost no options they get to hit half orc/saurian/drake slayers and barbs that's about it. only up side is tht is the majority of characters ingame, but its forever overshadowed by priests heals because magic has no rounding power.
10v5 wouldnt be 99% if the tactics triangle was upheld on this game. ofc it will be 99 out of 100 if the entire party of 10 are entirely slayers and priests.
1)running back copious amounts of alts is garbage design but it is needed .
--otherwise were probably all done training as we already have 1 melee unit im sure
2)letting them run back to combat in 2.965 seconds is even worse design and this is not needed.
-lets break it down for ya
-- ktps are necessary in open free for all key/oad areas
----more ktps are necessary to keep zombies hindered and to remove the 3-5 second runbacks
- areas will need to be larger to fit a larger playerbase and more ktps someday
---might aswell do it now
-areas that require a key to enter each time do not need ktps or expiring keys
--theres only 3 options in these areas
----go with your party of 6 accepting the fact you may get jumped and die
----save keys to jump other guilds
----save up multiple sets of keys so you can oad with 2+ full parties to ensure victory.
irregardless of what acct timeout, spanky punishment this thread turns into, all of the above i said will need to happen eventually especially if the game achieves 2-3x the current player numbers. if you want to pimp slap zombies into concussion or slap account wide nerfs for playing the game. go right ahead, its just more to do that isn't really necessary.
the core of this thread is solid, addressing a problem is a good thing. the problem with it is, it is reading like you are trying to kick people who train daily, your most active users, right in the balls. and only doing this because they have more characters than players who spend an hour a night logging on for oad timers and never play outside of that really. i got friends on both sides of this. im just trying to come up with a solution that doesn't stiff one side of it, and i gave it to you.
Regardless, if its a 10 vs 5 to start. It shouldn't be endless. Obviously the 10 are probably going to win if they are all there to start. Numbers will define that. That is /life sometimes.
I mean, I am not sure what you mean either. Running back a X amount of times is fine, but there should be a limit. If it is a global sickness, it can work differently. I.E.
-You attack and die, you get a 4 minute timer on you but no sickness.
-You attack again and die, your timer resets, no sickness.
-You attack a third time and die, your timer resets again, and you get -1 or -2 across all stats.
-Etc now, probably after the fourth time its not worth a anything to go back.
The benefit of the above however is that you can swap alts and the sickness will still stick, but since you get two or three free deaths, alts work fine here. It gives a limit to how long the fight will be though, even if it's 'fairly' long.
I am not saying you should never be able to swap alts, I obviously know that is a thing and should be. But you should have means to the fight ending. That is what sickness was meant to do, even before.
---
I am aware about other things said in this thread, I'd wait for the update right now coming.
I mean, I am not sure what you mean either. Running back a X amount of times is fine, but there should be a limit. If it is a global sickness, it can work differently. I.E.
-You attack and die, you get a 4 minute timer on you but no sickness.
-You attack again and die, your timer resets, no sickness.
-You attack a third time and die, your timer resets again, and you get -1 or -2 across all stats.
-Etc now, probably after the fourth time its not worth a anything to go back.
The benefit of the above however is that you can swap alts and the sickness will still stick, but since you get two or three free deaths, alts work fine here. It gives a limit to how long the fight will be though, even if it's 'fairly' long.
I am not saying you should never be able to swap alts, I obviously know that is a thing and should be. But you should have means to the fight ending. That is what sickness was meant to do, even before.
---
I am aware about other things said in this thread, I'd wait for the update right now coming.
take that idea and factor in a playerbase of 100+ and its obliterated. 7-8 guilds smashing each other, youre definitely going to have to die more than 3x. faster spawning ktps and more of em helps with no players or 1000.
take that idea and factor in a playerbase of 100+ and its obliterated. 7-8 guilds smashing each other, youre definitely going to have to die more than 3x. faster spawning ktps and more of em helps with no players or 1000.
I agree but, we don't have 100+ players. We can adjust as we progress. Once a system is in place it is easy to change numbers.
it seems like a waste of your time. with 100+ players everyone will want it to be endless, noone will want to die and sit for 5 minutes waiting. the areas will need to be enlarged and have more paths and more ktps in the future, that is inevitable unless we stay at 43 players forever, or the gear obtained in the areas becomes worthless trash.
your altnutkick system can just as easily wait as much as a map change. however the map change is 100% needed with more players, the nutkick system most likely isnt needed at all with alot more players, larger maps, and more ktps.
your altnutkick system can just as easily wait as much as a map change. however the map change is 100% needed with more players, the nutkick system most likely isnt needed at all with alot more players, larger maps, and more ktps.
Well, I think even with 100 players online you'd still need a limit of some sort. Maybe only 2 minutes wait time but I'd still think something would be added to prevent unlimited battles. I do agree with the map expanding, and that's defo if we get more players though.
Honestly a simple logoff timer of 1 minute might be the easiest thing on death/unsafe area, though dunno how people would feel about that.
Honestly a simple logoff timer of 1 minute might be the easiest thing on death/unsafe area, though dunno how people would feel about that.
I have like 12 25ers and access to an awful lot more. I don't enjoy alt switching forever to win a fight. I still want my alts to use for other fights/oads/eventing. They aren't useless man, you keep saying that like it's fact but that's just your opinion.
Same as it is my opinion that the necessity of alt stacking to win fights is bad. Atm you -will- win fights if your team of 6 has 4 alts each and can cycle through them quickly as needed. We seem to be on the same page in that this is an issue, but I don't think adding ktp rooms everywhere and anywhere is smart design.
Another thing to consider is that some people only have 1 or 2 25ers. They are less valuable in the current situation and that's not a good thing. I think it is discouraging for someone like that when the rest of their team alt changes and they are stuck waiting or going back with sickness.
I think a logoff timer is a possible solution. It would only need to be after death though, not in any unsafe area.
Same as it is my opinion that the necessity of alt stacking to win fights is bad. Atm you -will- win fights if your team of 6 has 4 alts each and can cycle through them quickly as needed. We seem to be on the same page in that this is an issue, but I don't think adding ktp rooms everywhere and anywhere is smart design.
Another thing to consider is that some people only have 1 or 2 25ers. They are less valuable in the current situation and that's not a good thing. I think it is discouraging for someone like that when the rest of their team alt changes and they are stuck waiting or going back with sickness.
I think a logoff timer is a possible solution. It would only need to be after death though, not in any unsafe area.
i like the death log off timer idea, typically i wait til sickness has worn off anyway.
what i mean by having alts being worthless is if u have access to bard/priest a couple slayers/heavy dps, a chanter, and a high resist character you have ultimately no reason to train new alts. especially if you cant run the extras in to fight anyway.
account sharing already eliminates the necessity for each player to train support/oad help opposed to borrowing. this is also why accounts need to lock to the first pc/ip that logs onto them each day.
it isnt only about zombying there has to be some sort of server longevity purpose to keep training. otherwise why dont we just start at level 25 with white equips and log on at oad timers, wage war to better our gear, and log off.
as dumb as it is to kill the same person 5 or 6 times until you fail and die yourself, its just as dumb to level a bunch of characters to 25 just to use your original 25er for every fight and quite possibly everything else entirely. its also dumb just playing at reset 4 7 9 for a few minutes each day persevering through countless oads for a max of 5-7 extra armor. maybe some sort of upkeep cost for 25ers or forced reallocation after X amount of time. content seems more adequate to prevent zombying, isnt as much of a deal if every oad timer had 4-5 solo oads, a large oad, and a few 3-4 person oads all at the same time.
this game has little to do besides train, this thread wants to accomplish making that even more pointless. the problem has been addressed and all the reasonable solutions have been mentioned. guess its up to development to decide how essential training should be.
what i mean by having alts being worthless is if u have access to bard/priest a couple slayers/heavy dps, a chanter, and a high resist character you have ultimately no reason to train new alts. especially if you cant run the extras in to fight anyway.
account sharing already eliminates the necessity for each player to train support/oad help opposed to borrowing. this is also why accounts need to lock to the first pc/ip that logs onto them each day.
it isnt only about zombying there has to be some sort of server longevity purpose to keep training. otherwise why dont we just start at level 25 with white equips and log on at oad timers, wage war to better our gear, and log off.
as dumb as it is to kill the same person 5 or 6 times until you fail and die yourself, its just as dumb to level a bunch of characters to 25 just to use your original 25er for every fight and quite possibly everything else entirely. its also dumb just playing at reset 4 7 9 for a few minutes each day persevering through countless oads for a max of 5-7 extra armor. maybe some sort of upkeep cost for 25ers or forced reallocation after X amount of time. content seems more adequate to prevent zombying, isnt as much of a deal if every oad timer had 4-5 solo oads, a large oad, and a few 3-4 person oads all at the same time.
this game has little to do besides train, this thread wants to accomplish making that even more pointless. the problem has been addressed and all the reasonable solutions have been mentioned. guess its up to development to decide how essential training should be.
what i mean by having alts being worthless is if u have access to bard/priest a couple slayers/heavy dps, a chanter, and a high resist character you have ultimately no reason to train new alts. especially if you cant run the extras in to fight anyway.
Similar to what Jake said, each 25er I own have their use in different scenario. I don't want to be fighting the same fight for 30+ minutes, limiting the number of times someone can log another alt to a fight needs to happen.
account sharing already eliminates the necessity for each player to train support/oad help opposed to borrowing. this is also why accounts need to lock to the first pc/ip that logs onto them each day.
Off topic, but this is not an ideal solution if people plays ember on multiple PCs. I personally play daily on my laptop and main PC, both at home.
Honestly a simple logoff timer of 1 minute might be the easiest thing on death/unsafe area, though dunno how people would feel about that.
At first I was against the logoff death timer, but thinking about it more it might be a reasonable solution to the alt hordes that we see. I do like the account death sickness as well, but that might be a more complicated solution than we currently need.
I mean I can literally adjust it now with little change on death.. One line of coding. Similar system to when you pick up the crimson scales and the longer timer effect. What would be a good base to start with? 1 minute? Can be adjusted anyways. Could also be based on number of in a row deaths. I.E. 1 minute, 1 minute 30 seconds, 2 minutes (max)