← Forum archive

Why?

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Hanibal
Why do DeathMages suck hard now and why does Wither uneffect so much?

Is the spell broken or was that class seen as being to strong so were fixed?

I'm just curious because its become you cant play almost any class anymore expecting them to have certain strengths/weakness's versus other classes.
Snyper
The recent change to wither, if i remember right, was because wither was causing leech to hit 100% of the time and reducing the target MR by 450% or so? This event should provide info for NiteHawk to hopefully make a positive change to the class. Are you casting on high MR targets or average to low MR? Give situations and examples and help provide some info to make the class better <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Terron
i play a necro everyday. they suck. 16 wisdom is nearly impossible to hit steady enough for the pathetic damage to succeed. my dm is voltus and basically if i aint hitting 10-12 wisdom or riva characters i might aswell attack with my stick.

the class has 4 debuffs and most of the time ur dead before u even get em to stick, or your so wounded you cant afford not to leech. just play a chanter lol. my dm relies on high agi to sit there awhile, but the character will be outright worthless when all the former drake/saur/horc users switch to goblins dwarves and dark elves. this will happen, shredding 50 hps and 10 damage for huge buffs to mr.

its not about winning for me, the part that is most irritating is MR on this game. the formulas are sound in theory except i dont hit MR characters 3-5x out of 10 like the math shows. and my drake ninja sure isnt resisting 32/100.

i really think div is bugged atm. i hit 80% on any riva character regardless of wisdom. on the flipside of that earth divs are impossible to hit. ive missed an earth ele druid in cat form prolly 80+ leeches and landed 9 in the past 10 days. this doesnt happen neutral.

one thing ive noticed.
my damage is 111-136 nuetral
my damage is 122-159 with div
against div my damage is 99 - 120. however, i have never actually seen any successful hits on players with damage 99-110.
is MR's damage mitigation causing spell fails?
daedroth
i play a necro everyday. they suck. 16 wisdom is nearly impossible to hit steady enough for the pathetic damage to succeed. my dm is voltus and basically if i aint hitting 10-12 wisdom or riva characters i might aswell attack with my stick.

the class has 4 debuffs and most of the time ur dead before u even get em to stick, or your so wounded you cant afford not to leech. just play a chanter lol. my dm relies on high agi to sit there awhile, but the character will be outright worthless when all the former drake/saur/horc users switch to goblins dwarves and dark elves. this will happen, shredding 50 hps and 10 damage for huge buffs to mr.

its not about winning for me, the part that is most irritating is MR on this game. the formulas are sound in theory except i dont hit MR characters 3-5x out of 10 like the math shows. and my drake ninja sure isnt resisting 32/100.

i really think div is bugged atm. i hit 80% on any riva character regardless of wisdom. on the flipside of that earth divs are impossible to hit. ive missed an earth ele druid in cat form prolly 80+ leeches and landed 9 in the past 10 days. this doesnt happen neutral.

one thing ive noticed.
my damage is 111-136 nuetral
my damage is 122-159 with div
against div my damage is 99 - 120. however, i have never actually seen any successful hits on players with damage 99-110.
is MR's damage mitigation causing spell fails?


In levelling 2 new necros (same intelligence and only to 9th with both).
One was neutral div (human), the other... night I think.
Night div necro is helf, he fizzled/unaffected more than human neitral (and it seemed to be against div when it happened).happened).
Basically what I saw seems to corroberates this, but...
Maybe coincidence (esp, since its based on a small section of data <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> )...
Hanibal
The recent change to wither, if i remember right, was because wither was causing leech to hit 100% of the time and reducing the target MR by 450% or so? This event should provide info for NiteHawk to hopefully make a positive change to the class. Are you casting on high MR targets or average to low MR? Give situations and examples and help provide some info to make the class better <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />


I just thought Wither was suppose to help reduce MR but if its going to uneffect regardless of the char or npcs you are casting it on it seem's like a very useless spell, I agree you shouldnt hit 100% of the time or reduce the MR by that amount but in theory it should effect alot more then it uneffects and that seem's to be almost all the time.

Leech isnt powerful enough to be relied on alone, they kinda need every spell in their arsenal to be a viable pvp/pve character.

And as someone else mentioned, divs seem to be really bugged. I always thought if you had div on someone or something they would hit you for less damage then you hit it/them or at least less often, I mean whats the sense of having div if this isnt the case?

When I create a character its to give me an upper hand be it vs an npc or fighting pve, so if I know a lot of people are using Ice div I'm goign to train some Valkies or if certain bosses are night div I'm going to bring fire crits. From what I have noticed div doesnt seem to matter in many cases so all that time feels wasted.

Maybe this is why the numbers have dropped so much lately?

I don't know, most posts i throw up on here people look at as complaints, I'm just trying to wrap my brain around how this game is suppose to work because half the time it doesnt make sense. If we are trying to balance the game making one race/class weaker isnt balancing.

Every race/class should have a bane, ice is fire's, storm is ice's etc, just like chanters should eat saurians unless its a ninja then that should be a good fight....

End of rant.
daedroth
Hopefully when necro's get looked at they will be adjusted appropriatley <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Side note, I don't bother with wither for levelling, 20mp cost for 10% more damage... meh, not worth it.
NiteHawk
I'm fine disputing things, but I'm going to be upfront about everything. It isn't an attack, it's simply how the game is right now.

No spell has a 'harder pierce rate' bar what wisdom gives them. They are all the same. 12 wisdom is 68% hit rate on average without class/race bonuses. For NPCs its an extra 3 wisdom, so another 12% hit rate more. Right now wither gives an extra 3% hit rate around, about 8-15 damage, and lowers armor. It's meant more for PVP though and harder monsters. The numbers can be adjusted if they aren't enough obviously. I just need more data. Wither could also have a higher penetration though rather then normal. I.E. only takes into affect half MR rather then full as current. That's possible too for sure. If its 20MP right now that can be reduced too etc.

If you want to bring up divinity changes feel free. Divinities aren't broken though. Divinities give 10-15% damage on average depending on your shards equipped etc. This can obviously be adjusted if people feel it's too low. Divinities have NEVER given AGI bonuses or MR bonuses in this game, again something you can discuss in 'Core' as a separate topic, and probably is a good idea to get feedback about it. The divinities have been more damage only right now though, that's really it. Again this warrants a separate discussion and feel free to open one and poll it, I recommend doing it and getting feedback. I don't mind changing divinities to take into effect more if people feel it that way.

Also yes, thats exactly why I made the event Snyper, because I want some feedback on the spells. I can agree on some things like wither should maybe be more affecting in terms of how much lower MR does, etc.

---

Night div necro is helf, he fizzled/unaffected more than human neitral (and it seemed to be against div when it happened).happened).


Unaffects are all the same and is based on wisdom and level. So this is one of those just in your head or back luck things. RND and all that. Fizzle can slightly change based on race but this isn't a major thing. Unaffect does not based on any race or class.


one thing ive noticed.
my damage is 111-136 nuetral
my damage is 122-159 with div
against div my damage is 99 - 120. however, i have never actually seen any successful hits on players with damage 99-110.
is MR's damage mitigation causing spell fails?


MR doesn't do anything fancy like that. MR is a set 4% per wis, starting at 24% (though if your a zerker you get -8% for example on top of this, but generally its 24% and scales up for most). It starts off lower then AGI, and is a little higher as well at the end. It's literally very similar to AGI now and I know it's valid as I've tested it several times now. If you are fighting npcs, remove another -12% resists, similar to how AGI works again there.

However, your 'against div' damage would be higher if they didn't have a proper shard equipped on their armor or shield. Their negation starts at 10%, and if they don't have shard(s), it stays there. Wisdom still lowers some damage too. Similar to passive armor. I'm pretty sure it only removes around 5% now with high wisdom though, around. It's not a huge drop.


I'm not exactly sure what you guys want though with MR. I honestly thing it's rather OK now and it's actually less resistant than previous in general. It's very similar to how AGi works now, and for the most case bar higher wisdom, its easier to hit than before, not harder. Before the AGI was probably 30% to 80% (not including class bonuses, which lowered zekers to around 25% and assassins to 27% with 10 MR), now its around 24% to 64% (again not including class bonues, which you remove a static 8% with zerkers and 4% with assassins as the lower, and ninjas get a bonus.) They also didn't get a extra -12 less MR if they were NPCS, that was added recently.

If anything damage is the thing that can be looked at, or making wither more useful, etc.


Again, DIV DOES NOT AFFECT MR. There is literally no code to make MR change based on divinity. It is 0% possible because the coding doesn't exist that even takes in a divinity bonus or divinity itself. I literally have not coded anything that does this but is not active, etc. The MR code is hard coded as well, so it's not like a script can muck it up or be different per script. Ain't no magic code fairies adding it on compile 8)


---

P.S. The numbers didn't drop because of divinities. The numbers dropped cause theres nothing to do. It's kind of silly to say that when the game was working for a good long time when we actually had content being produced constantly. We've had a huge drop in released content in the last few months, and I can't find enough people to take the roles, thus the game is fairly boring right now. I can't do everything on my own and the 3 builders that are actually doing stuff are getting burnt out. The game was doing super well the way it was, but I just think it gets boring fast. I'm not saying what is released isn't great, but we haven't had enough content and the current builders who are actually building are overworked. I made leveling a bit easy, but that was in mind of having level 25-50 but unfort isnt out yet.. Sometimes I wish I released that as well. Most people have a bunch of 25ers now/etc so theres no real grind anymore, and grind is an OK thing to keep players active, it gives a goal.
Terron
i dont think anything is broken in how it works. but magical spells are doing weird things with and against div. im 100% certain of this. it isnt just a random occurrance that happens once in awhile its been 2 weeks steady. my storm dm doesnt get resisted by riva characters very often, i would say 10-15% tops. and im even hitting constant 3.5/4 on elemental chanters of riva div. when you jump to the flipside of it every earth character of mediocre MR are completely invincible to me.

can you tell me the odds of 100 leeches and not hitting earth ele cat with 42% mr 91 of em?
an earth goblin guardian resisting all but 2 leeches in a 15 minute period at a late night thanatos? late night 3v2
hitting 30-40x in a row on an elemental riva chanter?
the odds of every successful hit on players against div never being 99-110 damage and always 111-120?

whats the odds of a taunted 23 agi ninja missing 71/85 on a 22 agi cav? that happened yesterday morning.

ive game tested for over half my life for huge games and mmo's. there is definitely something off with this.
NiteHawk
i dont think anything is broken in how it works. but magical spells are doing weird things with and against div. im 100% certain of this. it isnt just a random occurrance that happens once in awhile its been 2 weeks steady. my storm dm doesnt get resisted by riva characters very often, i would say 10-15% tops. and im even hitting constant 3.5/4 on elemental chanters of riva div. when you jump to the flipside of it every earth character of mediocre MR are completely invincible to me.

can you tell me the odds of 100 leeches and not hitting earth ele cat with 42% mr 91 of em?
an earth goblin guardian resisting all but 2 leeches in a 15 minute period at a late night thanatos? late night 3v2
hitting 30-40x in a row on an elemental riva chanter?
the odds of every successful hit on players against div never being 99-110 damage and always 111-120?

whats the odds of a taunted 23 agi ninja missing 71/85 on a 22 agi cav? that happened yesterday morning.

ive game tested for over half my life for huge games and mmo's. there is definitely something off with this.
¨

I'm 100% certain there is no issue involving divinities and MR, I literally just have had it output the values and there was no issues. I don't know what else to tell you here. RND is a bitch I guess. The formula doesn't even has a reference to divinity.

Now that you bring in AGI too I kind of question that too. RNG again, maybe need something other then RNG. That one has a even more basic formula which is literally agi and level really.

I mean, you could be the game tester and i'll test any claims, I got the formulas though and can make simulations of 1mil hits. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_neutral.gif" alt=":|" title="Neutral" />
Lateralus
As someone who runs koth and koth jr quite a bit I can assure you dms are the top 1v1 class in the game. They are the best hands down and we are starting the see the koth meta reflect that. More and more people are playing them and they win quite a bit as well as streak. Both in jr and reg. Now group pvp is a bit diff but I’m not sure how they can be “bad” when they are the top in atleast 1 form of pvp.
Terron
rng isnt 100% of the time. rolling 2 six siders or 1million siders in embers case is just one roll. you have a test server i imagine. use it with equips absorbs mitigation etc all at once. Rng wouldnt allow 1 millionth percentile anomalies very often let alone me seeing them 10+ times in 2 weeks and have it happen half of your ingame experiences.

character whoregasm elemental 10 19 20 21 21 14
level 1-8 sorc 2 unnaffects 5 fizzles. oops i was supposed to be a necro..
delete.
create.
character whoregasm elemental 10 19 20 21 21 14
level 1-8 necro 13 unaffects 47 fizzles.
Subject: Why?

i beg to differ on 1v1, its hard to say that when 60% of the equipped characters ingame have 10-12 wisdom. very rare to see more than 2 necros in an event. and they usually die to chanters unless they have div. i have alot of kills in koth as a dm, before update i killed every chanter except 2 times, after update no chanters die to me. and its not like im under equipped. is what it is i guess, ill be in the chanter/ high mr melee game soon so it wont matter. rip necro.
NiteHawk
rng isnt 100% of the time. rolling 2 six siders or 1million siders in embers case is just one roll. you have a test server i imagine. use it with equips absorbs mitigation etc all at once. Rng wouldnt allow 1 millionth percentile anomalies very often let alone me seeing them 10+ times in 2 weeks and have it happen half of your ingame experiences.

character whoregasm elemental 10 19 20 21 21 14
level 1-8 sorc 2 unnaffects 5 fizzles. oops i was supposed to be a necro..
delete.
create.
character whoregasm elemental 10 19 20 21 21 14
level 1-8 necro 13 unaffects 47 fizzles.
Subject: Why?

i beg to differ on 1v1, its hard to say that when 60% of the equipped characters ingame have 10-12 wisdom. very rare to see more than 2 necros in an event. and they usually die to chanters unless they have div. i have alot of kills in koth as a dm, before update i killed every chanter except 2 times, after update no chanters die to me. and its not like im under equipped. is what it is i guess, ill be in the chanter/ high mr melee game soon so it wont matter. rip necro.


Ah now this is a different story! You are correct about the spells though when you're leveling. Necromancer beam vs Sorceror beam is the same BUT necromancers beam is one level lower. It doesn't mean the max value is lower, but it takes one more level to hit max. This also means it's fizzle and everything else is one level higher to hit max! The max fizzle, which is 2% will still be achieved, but it would take a necromancer one level longer. Also for damage. In the end it's the same. At lower levels though, you will most likely feel it as I'm sure at level 1-4 the fizzle starts around 25-30% and decreases a good chunk each level. It's probably capped with good INT around level 8-12 depending on the class and int. 47 fizzles though is higher than normal even, its at best 5-10% more fizzle rate on start. The unaffects will be the same though. It's literally the 'SAME' script if you are using beam. It loads the same script, fires the same way, the only difference is
if entityBaseClass == "Necromancer" then levelAdd = 1 end
which goes towards fizzle and damage, but nothing more. unaffects are based on the defender only really.


Fizzle does change depending on spell, and normally for the 1-8 level spells like cure/etc you will see a priest work it's magic more than a druid or paladin would. You might not hit the cap with low INT then it might be a differ story. But most have been balanced for what the average INT is. Blast and Leech might scale slightly differ BUT they both have the same cap, which is 3%.

I'll gladly take a couple level 25 characters and output their MR rates via copying them completely and running a test to output what % of MR the defender has vs whatever necro/sorc/etc has.

Before the update you Necro vs Sorc must of been like 80% MR rate battles though. It could be due to lower MR, not higher, and the offset of having lower MR and lower damage isn't enough to offset the sorcerers higher MR. but again, that's not what we're talking about yet. Unless your saying div effects the MR too again here, thus I'll gladly test some test characters of your liking and output what MR rates they are getting.

It is 100% impossible that divinity effects MR. There is NO REFERENCE TO IT. This doesn't mean that something else could be at play, spell bonus, class bonus, race bonus, level, and wisdom are the only effectors really.


rolling 2 six siders or 1million siders in embers case is just one roll.


What? I'm talking about rolling 2 six siders vs rolling 1million six siders. Only rolling twice will NOT give you the proper average. It's like tossing a coin only twice. The variance should be 50% but if you only do it twice, some people will get 100%, some people will get 0%. If you toss it 1million times, the HIGH chance is that the average will probably be around 45% to 55%, most closer to 50%.


Anyways Hani's post was about MR not effecting which is 100% opposite of what your stating, but for divinity cases, he'd be right on that and it's open for discussion if people want to see that. Though it should be a separate post in core.
Terron
his topic is about why they suck. especially concerning debuffs. characters die in 7-9 hits. wither is sacrificing a hit for extra damage on the next few but takes 10 hits to balance out. debuffs should just hit easier like pierce through 2-3 wisdom or they barely get used. imo wither is better served because the hits u do after get an extra 10 or so hp gain.

the necro vs chanter thing is easily explained. chanters kept 10% free magic dodge necros lost their 8%

id gladly log on and show you leech vs whatever div you want. if it is all just rng then your rollers spread is far too high. shouldnt see 74% mr characters get scorched 40x straight or 42% mr characters resist 80%. id also like to test it vs taunt. and taunt in general. if this stuff happened once i wouldn't bother mentioning. but since its been static i did. i dont think div is wrong i think all mitigation is doing it.
NiteHawk
chanters kept 10% free magic dodge necros lost their 8%


No, chanters don't have it either. For bonuses only paladins 4% and monks 8%. Rest don't apply. If it's stated anywhere it needs to be fixed, but they also lost their MR bonus. (also verified in the actual class file with 'SpellResistBonus=0') Wiki needs some heavy editing though 8(

Debuffs having a easier time to hit is an option, but I feel like things like SAP shouldn't really need it. Wither yeah prob a good idea, etc.

I'm not sure what else to say about the div stuff though, I'd prefer getting a couple chars and then just making it leech 1 million times to get the proper % though on certain chars that you claim.

Edit: Pushed it away form the wiki until it can get updated and using the actual race/class file in game, updated the posts to do with stats in Races/Classes now too.
Terron
i dont look at wiki really, im pretty sure it is stated on the character creator mage 10%. ill double check

Sorcerer
Important Stats
Intelligence - Power and duration of your spells
Wisdom - Amount of MP you have and your resistance to hostile spells
Agility - How often you dodge
Endurance - How much HP you have
Charisma - Minor HP and MP gains

Ease of Play: Medium
Survivability: Medium
DPS: Medium-High
PVP Value: High
PVE Value: High
Armor: Cloth, Light Helmet
Weapons: Staves, Wands
Attack Increments: 4, 14, 25
Needed EXP to 25: 350 million
20% MP increase
10% MR increase

Skills
Beam - mid level damaging spell
Blast - high level damaging spell
Fade - target becomes invisible, but can still be attacked
Golem - summons a golem of your divinities element to help you
Hover - target avoids traps and won't be followed by monsters
Imp - summons a imp pet to help you.
Power - increases the target's strength
Scribe - enscribes a blank scroll with a level dependant enchantment
Stoneskin - increases the target's armor
Hanibal
i beg to differ on 1v1, its hard to say that when 60% of the equipped characters ingame have 10-12 wisdom. very rare to see more than 2 necros in an event. and they usually die to chanters unless they have div. i have alot of kills in koth as a dm, before update i killed every chanter except 2 times, after update no chanters die to me. and its not like im under equipped. is what it is i guess, ill be in the chanter/ high mr melee game soon so it wont matter. rip necro.


I agree, I havent won a koth on my DM since the update and I never use or used wither when I did win it 4 times.
NiteHawk
i beg to differ on 1v1, its hard to say that when 60% of the equipped characters ingame have 10-12 wisdom. very rare to see more than 2 necros in an event. and they usually die to chanters unless they have div. i have alot of kills in koth as a dm, before update i killed every chanter except 2 times, after update no chanters die to me. and its not like im under equipped. is what it is i guess, ill be in the chanter/ high mr melee game soon so it wont matter. rip necro.


I agree, I havent won a koth on my DM since the update and I never use or used wither when I did win it 4 times.


You do know that wither was reducing MR by 380% right? AKA it would be like setting someones AGI to 0 and hitting them. I guess that it could be possibly better, but obviously DM's were OP with a spell that shattered everything. I'm sure we can find a happy medium though there.

Ah yeah Terron thanks for that spot. I will adjust it ASAP. They did lose their bonus thought too, just to state.
daedroth
Blah blah blah.

Either way, no harm in testing the MR and taunt thing to set everyone's minds at ease (with actual alts and no simulations).
But who will volunteer and who will attest?
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
NiteHawk
Blah blah blah.

Either way, no harm in testing the MR and taunt thing to set everyone's minds at ease (with actual alts and no simulations).
But who will volunteer and who will attest?
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />



I don't understand why we can't use actual coding from the server and do X amount of tests. You guys can't get enough data unless you are going to test 10k-100k hits minimum to get a decent average. It's not even a simulation in the sense of 'paper simulation'. It's literally going to be using the script/etc, and just outputting the MR values/Damage rather than hitting the target directly and losing HP, thus you spam attack to get the hits.

I can literally do everything like it was a real fight, not a paper simulation, but on a global scale, with actual characters, and output all the data.

If you guys want to blahblahblah and ignore it feel free. You guys can do what you want in the end.. If you guys want to sit and test with 10k-100k hits or so, that is alright as well, just more work on your part. I'm again offering solutions to test this, as I said before it could be something else causing issues if that's the case with alts as I am 100% certain it is not divinity. I'm not trying to hide stuff, and if things are faulty, I'd gladly fix it. Through my tests, they were fine, but maybe alt combination of attacker vs defender might shed more stuff, but I didn't get any real data yet.

I've also said we can take a look at certain things, and I will be taking a look at things like wither, damages, etc, so I'm going to take a step back from the post now as we are going in circles unless test data is needed, otherwise feel free to setup something on your own and output the data.

Anyways Hanibal, you have some valid points but you need to see if people will support them. I would again suggest making a post about divinity and having MR work with AGI/MR (seriously dude, do this in CORE as a separate post. I think it warrants a individual post. Try to bring up some suggestions on how much AGI/MR should change too.). For necromancers, I will take a look at a certain few spells like wither. I think making it pierce easier is not a bad idea, as well as looking at the SR reduction to see how we can do it, need to do some tests though first before that.
daedroth
NOT EVERYTHING CAN BE EXPLAINED BY SCIENCE!
There are mysteries out there... <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_ugeek.gif" alt=":ugeek:" title="Uber Geek" />

Actually one of the questions I was going to ask was if the simulation used every variable (as in normal scripts/abilities/classes/div etc, so it was just like real combat anyway) rather than just a number cruncher without all the scripts.