← Forum archive

Guild Changes/Party Changes?

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
yeah best remove guilds and party completely, make everyone move independently. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />


For the last 4 posts now I've said we aren't reducing guild sizes and I'm interested in other options. I'm not sure why you made three posts about guild sizes at this point. lol. You k there mate? 8)


lastly the drelvar mines oad, specifically the miner itself, needs changed. the thing is like unhittable by melee, which is fine. but it isnt really fine when you take a chanter and complete the whole thing in 29 seconds. it literally only takes 13 blasts to gather the delirium crystal. maybe its just knowledge of how these games work, or its because in the first week i pinpointed all the spawn points, etc. but the oad is supposed to detract from doing seta. and atm its basically taking me about 45 seconds on avg.


I'd probably hit up Lat or Lav on that one, if its solo that sounds fairly quick yeah.
Folder
I'm sure everyone is in agreement that we want a larger player base, 60 people would be pretty great. When we had 40ish the game felt quite alive, 60 would be nice.

My comment re: gmuds was said because I don't think this game is broken or anything along those lines. I do think the genre is niche, and I also think NH is doing everything he can to try and make it work. The clan embers are going to favor small guilds, so that's a boost for people who want to play in 1-2 man guilds. That said unless we rework all OaDs to be soloable I don't see how 1-2man guilds will ever be as successful (in terms of oads) as larger ones.

Terron has a point too, guilds merely facilitate easier communication. We have like 3 or 4 rogue guilds - well, shit, if you wanna work together and go get stuff DO IT. Make a party and use party chat, or use Discord. NH brought up dragon scales, pfffff. Half the dragon spawns we have 1-3 people dinking away at it. That's...not an unstoppable force.

I don't know what the solution is other than all the stuff I typed in my first reply (leaders working harder at running a guild and promoting a happy environment). I've directed many new players to other guilds and sadly it hardly ever works out. Not because of guild domination or because the game is broken, but because they did not like the environment (or they were never even answered by other guilds in the first place).

This is a game where the players have some responsibility to make it work, it can't all be on NH to design some magic system.

Or.....

We just need Vhexim back because he was one of the few people able to successfully motivate and coordinate others <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />.
daedroth
...We just need Vhexim back because he was one of the few people able to successfully motivate and coordinate others <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />.


BRING BACK VHEXIM!
Terron
@nitehawk

i dont have an answer for you on balancing friends. nor did i, when countless other muds i have played over the years fail. the reason is the same on every mud ive ever played. there is almost noone willing to put in the effort to be a leader. be it greed or whatever, very few people wanna sit through 300 oads to get other people equipped.

if anything silhouette has a stranglehold on players that actually try to be leaders. the sad truth of it is most of us are drawn to each other in silh because of our chill attitudes. i joined because of wayne and randy. if they didnt exist, i highly doubt i would have joined anything other than silhouette. not because they were OP or had great numbers(because they really didnt when i started). the sole reason from my pov is that noone in silhouette has ever told me to eat a dick, suck my hole, eat my ass, fk off, or any other debasing name. id rather be in a clan of 3 cool people than a clan of 40 assholes.

this game is pretty ez. you can get whatever you want really with dedication from 3 people and a little patience. if huge guilds have 10 on today they wont sooner or later. besides the fact there is nothing to lose by trying, except a few potions. make some new characters that arent focused on pvp, build something that has as much defense/hps as possible so 3 manning salamander is easier.

its really whatevs man, these people have the opportunity to shine at any moment and would rather piggyback. noone to blame but staff and you apparently. dont make shit easier for them when its already piss ez. i killed thantos alone last night, i solo'd treasure fiend a couple times now. its not that hard to succeed. they need to take the first step tho. log on and leave town.
Styx
Refinery oad is obviously to hard to even do without a large party, it needs a total revamp in order for people to do it more. And yes, take out some items and move them elsewhere.
Lissy
I think communication outside of guild is a big deal, and I really like Elvis's idea about announcing new players. I think it would be a step in the right direction.

I know that a completely open world chat has decided against in the past, but if I didn't have a guild to log on and type 'lvl?' into, I'd never play. I think part of the reason the game still exists is that Silhouette is a bigger guild, so when people disappear for a few weeks due to rl stuff, there are other people around to fill the gaps and for people to "come home" to when they log on again. Games like this are hugely social, and someone who last played when Tormented was a powerhouse would now log on to utter silence, especially with a large world map. I don't really have any solutions, but I think framing the problem as "how do we encourage the social aspect" rather than "how do we create more guilds" might be more useful.

the sole reason from my pov is that noone in silhouette has ever told me to eat a dick, suck my hole, eat my ass, fk off, or any other debasing name.


I'm sorry I've neglected you. Please kindly go eat a dick.
daedroth
I think communication outside of guild is a big deal, and I really like Elvis's idea about announcing new players. I think it would be a step in the right direction.

I know that a completely open world chat has decided against in the past, but if I didn't have a guild to log on and type 'lvl?' into, I'd never play. I think part of the reason the game still exists is that Silhouette is a bigger guild, so when people disappear for a few weeks due to rl stuff, there are other people around to fill the gaps and for people to "come home" to when they log on again. Games like this are hugely social, and someone who last played when Tormented was a powerhouse would now log on to utter silence, especially with a large world map. I don't really have any solutions, but I think framing the problem as "how do we encourage the social aspect" rather than "how do we create more guilds" might be more useful.

the sole reason from my pov is that noone in silhouette has ever told me to eat a dick, suck my hole, eat my ass, fk off, or any other debasing name.


I'm sorry I've neglected you. Please kindly go eat a dick.


What about me Lissy? WHAT ABOUT ME! BLOODY FAVOURITISM!
anthriel
I get what most of you Silh guys are saying. I honestly do. But while I understand how the ideas you have expressed (eg playing with friends etc) are good for your game experiences within Silh, I just can't see how they actually translate to the game growing when not every new player can/should join Silh.

For example, firstly many of you say you were attracted to join same group cos of the cool, civilised ppl in it and warm family feel of the guild. That's great. Many newbies would love that and thrive if included in it. Many have already. But every newbie can't join your guild because you also all generally say you all love pvp and the game is boring without it. So who do you eventually fight then? If all the uncivilised, un-cool ppl are kept out of Silh (as daedroth suggests) then the alternative to Silh for any new player isn't going to be very attractive for them is it (as obviously you yourselves wouldn't like not being in Silh)? So what then? How does the game actually attract and retain new players when that new player logs on and realises 70%+ of players online are all friends from the one clan who have closed recruitment, spent months playing and equipping each other and are now looking for someone in the remaining 30% to pvp with? Pretty intimidating I'd say...


So having heard how the current incarnation of the game's guild system has been great for u guys, my question to many of the Silh posters in this thread is this: how does the game grow and retain newbies? Because the only answers to this i hear from you guys are some combination of the following:

1. It doesn't - cos it's 2018, Gmuds r unpopular and ppl who don't like the niche are going to leave anyway .... (Implication: just cater the game for the niche who stay and forget about trying to expand and attract)

2. Find some mystical newbies who are willing to "man up" and solo play unpopular Gmuds in 2028 (or play for hours with undesirable, uncivilised people), largely solo OADs like Thanatos etc (as Terron suggests), and dodge pvp attacks from 70% of active players in 1 guild looking to pvp with someone who isn't their friend etc. Hope these newbs somehow thrive enough to make friends with all the undesirable/uncool people and work hard for months in and out of game to unite them into a warm family environment of friends to provide Silh with a rival clan to pvp against. AND also hope that these people don't actually make friends with the nice/cool Silh ppl and end up liking them enough to want to join them??

That's not a lot of hope to go by imho. Or you can keep hoping that old players will return (an uncertain hope, depending on why they quit which may or may not be related to new content being released), that existing players will attract their friends to the game and rise up to compete, (which historically had happened eg Torm but fizzled for whatever reason, despite them already being ROK vets and not total newbs) or that inspirational leaders like Vhexim would rally some of the active ppl into competing (though from my few chats with him back when he was playing I felt like he stopped cos he wanted to compete by founding his own clan but found it too hard to do under the current system). So surely an incentive system like the one I suggested would help retain ppl like Vhex into successfully starting their own competing clans and give Silh someone to pvp with right?

Shrugs I just don't really see how it works both ways. If EO is to be a "game with friends" and one that "enjoys pvp" then people will need to learn to pvp against their friends. Otherwise it's probably going to either end up a 1 guild game (full of friends, but no competition... And therefore really a chat room with some minor things to occupy) or it's going to have to be one where friends can learn to compete/pvp against each other and still be friends. I can't really see a viable alternative that has been suggested.

Happy to be convinced otherwise by dazzling suggestions of how to attract/retain new players that don't involve dreaming about highly unlikely scenarios where individuals who desire to solo games themselves join/"man-up"/solo-everything... or large groups of friends (of the size to rival Silh) join and stick it out. Neither of those seems very likely to bank on.

Shrugs. Peace all.
Dan
I think big guilds should have advantage, but the game shouldnt be entirely food for them.

That's why i think the only thing you can do is put important content that guild doesn't matter.

But how do you do that without no-pk content? I don't think you can.

That's why i suggested global threat areas, where you have to work together to beat a threat.

And it should give good drops for everyone participating, so smaller guilds wouldnt mind that much about bigger guilds have number for everything.
daedroth
... blah blah blah ...
Shrugs. Peace all.

Love the way you end a posting filled with witticisms and digs, the irony is delicious.
anthriel
... blah blah blah ...
Shrugs. Peace all.

Love the way you end a posting filled with witticisms and digs, the irony is delicious.


I do apologise if anyone is offended by my posts. It is not my intention to personally attack anyone (not NH, not staff and not Silh members). I sometimes just feel the need to proverbially "shout louder" to be heard when I'm so often outnumbered on the boards with my alternative views. So "peace all" is my way of saying that I mean goodwill towards all and welcome friendship with anyone who doesn't bear grudges against me for my alternative thinking.
JadeFalcon
I do not think guild or party changes are needed.
What you need is mechanics that nullify the "big" party/ "big" guild advantage.

This i think can be addressed with two things:
- Randomize OAD (and OAD keys) timings. This will throw a monkey wrench at "heavy planning" guild, and give a chance smaller guilds by chance have enough time to muster enough people before the big guild even wakes up. Coordination in a big guild is harder, after all.
- Make more 3 man OAD's, with lots of small keys instead of a big key. For example, Seta is a 3 man in theory, but because there are only two "open" keys, it devolves into a big fight that we always win.

Fundamentally, as other people said - the issue is the base of players. I mean, I keep telling folder to recruit everyone not because i want us to be super powerful (actually i do too), but when I imagine some player sitting in a clan all by himself.. he is going to quit. There is a critical mass problem here. This is a social game, so people need to socialize. There are no guild or party or mechanics change that can address this.

Edit:
Plus what Dan said. I dont see why we cant have high level areas where we are forced to play with each other. Even OAD areas with NoPK, NoParty system, that drop stuff randomly..
Lissy
I get what most of you Silh guys are saying. I honestly do. But while I understand how the ideas you have expressed (eg playing with friends etc) are good for your game experiences within Silh, I just can't see how they actually translate to the game growing when not every new player can/should join Silh.


I think you're missing my point, though. I don't think this is a Silhouette issue. I joined Silhouette because I was invited to the game by a friend who was in Silhouette. I stuck around because the guild is active, and being in an active guild is basically the only way to interact with people. Making this guild less active would just drive away players like me. If there were 40 people playing at any given time and 30 of them were in Silhouette, that would be a problem and there would be a reason to look at guild balance. If, as there are right now, there are 9 people online and 4 of them are in Silhouette, 4 are in Empire, and 1 is in Revolution, the whole guild balance issue becomes a red herring. IMO, the problem becomes keeping people entertained by being able to interact with others outside of the guild system.

For example, firstly many of you say you were attracted to join same group cos of the cool, civilised ppl in it and warm family feel of the guild. That's great. Many newbies would love that and thrive if included in it. Many have already. But every newbie can't join your guild because you also all generally say you all love pvp and the game is boring without it. So who do you eventually fight then? If all the uncivilised, un-cool ppl are kept out of Silh (as daedroth suggests) then the alternative to Silh for any new player isn't going to be very attractive for them is it (as obviously you yourselves wouldn't like not being in Silh)? So what then? How does the game actually attract and retain new players when that new player logs on and realises 70%+ of players online are all friends from the one clan who have closed recruitment, spent months playing and equipping each other and are now looking for someone in the remaining 30% to pvp with? Pretty intimidating I'd say...


Again, this is a population issue, not a Silhouette issue. If 70% of the game is 15 people, the solution isn't to make the game less fun for those 15 people in hopes of recruiting 15 more before they quit from boredom like people from smaller guilds.

Happy to be convinced otherwise by dazzling suggestions of how to attract/retain new players that don't involve dreaming about highly unlikely scenarios where individuals who desire to solo games themselves join/"man-up"/solo-everything... or large groups of friends (of the size to rival Silh) join and stick it out. Neither of those seems very likely to bank on.

Shrugs. Peace all.


I mean, I don't have any dazzling suggestions that are sure to work, but you don't either. You have an idea that probably wouldn't impact very much, because this game is *super social* more than anything else, and almost everyone who plays is a casual gamer who wouldn't be interested in leaving friends to get prestige points/incentives. I'm glad you're offering ideas, but I think boredom is a bigger reason for attrition than inability to get high powered items (especially since high powered items generally aren't as high powered in this game as they were in RoK).

I like recruitment incentives. I like Elvis's suggestion about making a world broadcast when a new account logs in. I like global chat, so new players aren't just dumped into a noob area (even with a much better tutorial than RoK ever had) to figure out the game mechanics and possibly get bored/overwhelmed before they ever interact with another player. I think adding incentives for hanging out in one area (similar to Tavern of Terra) might be helpful, as might dumping new players into Tavern of Seamoor or somewhere theoretically more populated.

Edit: OH! One thing that I think would actually impact my interest in being in a guild... Right now, I only level in parties because there's zero benefit to leveling solo the way there was in RoK. Back then, I'd only level solo so even if there was nothing "going on" I felt entertained. I think maybe adding some incentive to leveling alone (bonus KSB or something), that might be a helpful way to keep people around who aren't part of a large group all the time. This would only help people like me who actually enjoy leveling as a way of turning our brains off, though.
daedroth
... Edit: OH! One thing that I think would actually impact my interest in being in a guild... Right now, I only level in parties because there's zero benefit to leveling solo the way there was in RoK. Back then, I'd only level solo so even if there was nothing "going on" I felt entertained. I think maybe adding some incentive to leveling alone (bonus KSB or something), that might be a helpful way to keep people around who aren't part of a large group all the time. This would only help people like me who actually enjoy leveling as a way of turning our brains off, though.

I prefer to solo level because of the way I level, not many people level the slow way I do <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
I know that means I level even slower but meh, I'm usually watching a movie or chatting in discord to clannies, so it does not bother me.
So yes, make solo levelling more attractive to me, pwetty pwease!
Ohko
Fundamentally, as other people said - the issue is the base of players. I mean, I keep telling folder to recruit everyone not because i want us to be super powerful (actually i do too), but when I imagine some player sitting in a clan all by himself.. he is going to quit. There is a critical mass problem here. This is a social game, so people need to socialize. There are no guild or party or mechanics change that can address this.


This is a problem that can't be addressed by inviting everyone into Silh. We stopped recruiting becase then we'll become what Lis mentioned above that we would be 70% of the population. We try to let the other guild recuit these members, and if they're not happy in the other guild than it's not our problem. Staff have broadcasted a few times that there are new players that a looking for a guild and Silh have refrained from recruiting them unless they remain guildless for a few days.

I think Elvis's suggestion on the new player broadcast and global chat will help with retaining new players. Global chat will keep the social aspect of the game active and hopefully help retain the player population.
Terron
there should only be 6 guilds.

pyron guild
nox guild
terra guild
voltus guild
riva guild
nethys guild


or you could, in the future, add racial and div based content. this would promote wacky builds like inverno's saurian healer. there could definitely be some fun with div/race wars and oads etc. and this promotes socialism with new people. help boost character training/needs and item wants/needs.
daedroth
there should only be 6 guilds.

pyron guild
nox guild
terra guild
voltus guild
riva guild
nethys guild


or you could, in the future, add racial and div based content. this would promote wacky builds like inverno's saurian healer. there could definitely be some fun with div/race wars and oads etc. and this promotes socialism with new people. help boost character training/needs and item wants/needs.


Damn that'd be funny. I kinda like the idea (for the novelty factor)... but eh yeh (the novelty would wear off)...

Let's run with this idea <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />


Factions: Make a few factions based on race (I think the Elder Scrolls Online has this yeh?) or even Div (but not so keen on this one).

Possible Faction Layouts:

Dwarf, Gnome, Halfling, Elemental (not so sure these guys should be here maybe switch Drakes with Ele's where appropriate),

Dark Elf, Half Orc, Goblin, Saurian,

Elf, Half Elf, Drake,

Humans can go into any faction (us humans be sluts).

Ah what fun there would be!

If serious, the only downside is the breaking of clans (and clan equilibrium), which is the main problem in the first place.
Other problems:
Who would become leaders of the factions (this might only work with staffy leaders. Imagine the events that could be run through this, could be some interesting ones. Shame about the extra work for staffys though eh)?
Division of the spoils of war (I can imagine the angst already).

Anyways, time to look busy at work.
Peace all.
Terron
i think each race should have a champion player imo. could flip back to lats idea on characters receiving points etc for monster kills/oads/pks etc and have the server autoselect players as a race champion based on highest points.

i dont really think we need to break current guilds but it would be nice(i think) if sometimes you had to cooperate outside of your guild. be it just an event ran div vs div or a racial locked oad. could eventually lead to equipment thats locked to a certain divinity or race.

the basics of the game should remain how it is. however currently theres barely any fluctuation in characters. they are basically the same 3 mage builds same few monks same cavs etc. people have leveled some rarities ofc, but they just aren't used often. racial content and divinity content would open up a chance to use everything even melee gnomes.

that being said, i do however, believe that racial and divinity based content should be somewhat difficult. moreso than normal stuff. in this, by locking each oad/instance/event to 1 of each class per "fight". atleast in a racial duel or war it shouldnt be 6 gnome chanters vs world.

theres 144 character options and 6 divs, id actually like it if all of that was explored.