Thieves and Stealing
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I heard about stealing in arenas, I think it should not be allowed mainly because they cannot be killed there. I fixed this now.
However outside of arenas is free game.I lowered stat restrictions and people choose to only have 10 int, that is their fault. If you want to catch a thief, you need INT. It is INT VS AGI in this case. They are going to win if you are a 'dumb character' just because I removed the restrictions. It is your doing that is, if you want it or not. Maybe other stats are more important to you when it comes to 'extra stats' etc.
There are other areas to level or mobs to kill that have drops rather then gold. Some areas are great for thieves, others are terrible. Just like undead areas vs cleric/pally. I think thieves are meant to be played as they are. Bank your gold often, don't run your gold too far up. etc. We are working on making sure gold is more available but for now it is what it is.
However, I am curious. What do people think is a good amount of GOLD to steal vs NPCS and vs PLAYERS per attack? I never really had a set guide though. Right now I believe it is around 500 gold at level 25.
Thanks.
However outside of arenas is free game.I lowered stat restrictions and people choose to only have 10 int, that is their fault. If you want to catch a thief, you need INT. It is INT VS AGI in this case. They are going to win if you are a 'dumb character' just because I removed the restrictions. It is your doing that is, if you want it or not. Maybe other stats are more important to you when it comes to 'extra stats' etc.
There are other areas to level or mobs to kill that have drops rather then gold. Some areas are great for thieves, others are terrible. Just like undead areas vs cleric/pally. I think thieves are meant to be played as they are. Bank your gold often, don't run your gold too far up. etc. We are working on making sure gold is more available but for now it is what it is.
However, I am curious. What do people think is a good amount of GOLD to steal vs NPCS and vs PLAYERS per attack? I never really had a set guide though. Right now I believe it is around 500 gold at level 25.
Thanks.
Oh boy, my favorite topic, thieves and how everyone thinks they suck! /s
Okay, as someone who mained a thief on ROK for many years and intends to main one on Ember, there are many more solutions to this than people seem to think there are. Some of them don't even require making friends.
The first and simplest solution is to make friends with someone who's playing a thief. Let them get the experience for stealing gold, you both get the kill experience, you split the gold. Everybody wins. For those of you who can't or don't want to make friends, you can also do this by yourself, just requires logging alts back and forth a lot. That way, you're the one who wins, because you get both all the gold and the experience.
The second solution is to level places that aren't friendly towards thieves, better known as places where you're going to get primarily vendor trash instead of gold. You'll have to go back to town more often, but from there you can bank your gold, and you're going to be safer from thieves in the long run, because you won't be carrying any easily stealable gold around while leveling.
The third solution, which I will preface by saying this option is my opinion as a player instead of me speaking as a member of staff, is to suck it up, PK the thief if you see them, and stop whining about a game mechanic.
Okay, as someone who mained a thief on ROK for many years and intends to main one on Ember, there are many more solutions to this than people seem to think there are. Some of them don't even require making friends.
The first and simplest solution is to make friends with someone who's playing a thief. Let them get the experience for stealing gold, you both get the kill experience, you split the gold. Everybody wins. For those of you who can't or don't want to make friends, you can also do this by yourself, just requires logging alts back and forth a lot. That way, you're the one who wins, because you get both all the gold and the experience.
The second solution is to level places that aren't friendly towards thieves, better known as places where you're going to get primarily vendor trash instead of gold. You'll have to go back to town more often, but from there you can bank your gold, and you're going to be safer from thieves in the long run, because you won't be carrying any easily stealable gold around while leveling.
The third solution, which I will preface by saying this option is my opinion as a player instead of me speaking as a member of staff, is to suck it up, PK the thief if you see them, and stop whining about a game mechanic.
very much part of the game set a macro for the thief and be ready! or make a thief and steal from them this is the way to go. Great to see pvp starting up love it!
People are making non-int characters now that its not required thinking they never need it.
It HELPS with stuff like this greatly. I am still working on the formula but even now higher INT will make them fail alot more often. But having 10 int characters means you will pretty much always get thieves stealing on you successfully. I know not all classes can have tons of int, but even 'some' will help.
Obviously level does effect it too. If they are too high level then obviously it's easier for them, but I doubt they will thieve non high level areas as it's not really profitable. Right now everyones around the same level I assume.
It HELPS with stuff like this greatly. I am still working on the formula but even now higher INT will make them fail alot more often. But having 10 int characters means you will pretty much always get thieves stealing on you successfully. I know not all classes can have tons of int, but even 'some' will help.
Obviously level does effect it too. If they are too high level then obviously it's easier for them, but I doubt they will thieve non high level areas as it's not really profitable. Right now everyones around the same level I assume.
I missed something that made all defending characters to stealing level 8 on the rolls. It probably made thieves alot easier to steal on ALOT of things, and also on players. My bad guys, sorry.
It should be fixed now.
It should be fixed now.
Stealing is pretty fking hard now o.o. With 23 agi lvl18 it seems way harder to steal than it was. Only talking about pve here.
I was using goblin outpost for decent stealing but now it's mad hard to stay alive because of all the failed steals. Poo.
I was using goblin outpost for decent stealing but now it's mad hard to stay alive because of all the failed steals. Poo.
Yeah, it definitely got much harder. On the one hand, hopefully people will stop their bitching now, but on the other, now I can't run around and out thief the thief from before, so booooooooooooo.
Yeah, it definitely got much harder. On the one hand, hopefully people will stop their bitching now, but on the other, now I can't run around and out thief the thief from before, so booooooooooooo.
Well, before was a broken mechanic as the thief could always steal 100% due to the broken formula. You can't steal from higher level monsters if they are well over you. So you can't just make a level 15 character and go steal from level 23 npcs. It's not like ROK where you could just loot from everything and run out with a weak character though.
As I said, someone 20 agi vs 20 int is about 60% steal rate. 20 agi to 16 int is 70, 20 agi to 12 int is about 80, and 20 agi to 10 int is about 83-84%. This is IF level is the same. I don't think the rates are horrible, and it forces you to pick and choose, rather then just going gunho on everyone. Smarter people are going to catch you.
I can see about raising the rate a little, but I don't think it's terrible.
I made it a little bit easier but also made level less impacting. It still impacts but it might help out.
local attackRoll = Random.Number(0, (attackerLvl/2) * attackerAgi * 0.2)
local defenderRoll = Random.Number(0, (defenderLvl/2) * defenderInt * 0.14)
lets say I have 22 agi thief and they have a 16 int paladin, both level 20
Steal Roll = 0 to 10 * 22 * 0.2 = 44
Defender Roll = 0 to 10 * 16 * 0.13 = 20.8
The chance (done 5000 rolls) is 77.7% chance to steal. (Used to be 70%)
----
Same thing, 10 int roll now.
Steal Roll = 44
Defender Roll = 13
Chance: 85.5%
----
22 AGI vs 16 INT, but the thief is 5 levels higher. (25 vs 20)
Steal Roll = 0 to 12.5 * 22 * 0.2 = 55
Defender Roll = 0 to 10 * 16 * 0.13 = 20.8
Change: 82.5%
----
22 AGI vs 16 INT, but the thief is 5 levels higher. (25 vs 20)
Steal Roll = 0 to 12.5 * 22 * 0.2 = 55
Defender Roll = 0 to 10 * 20 * 0.13 = 26
Change: 76.7%
Changes are now in effect now. Give it a whirl now and see. This means that:
A. Thieves should still a good deal on lower intelligence characters, but you might want to avoid gnomes and such (just like PVP, pick your targets).
B. Level is less important by half. So that a level 20 vs level 25 won't be 100% now as long as they have high int. It makes agi vs int more important though.
What do people think of these rolls? Too much? To little? I think it's fair overall, may need some small tweaking.
local attackRoll = Random.Number(0, (attackerLvl/2) * attackerAgi * 0.2)
local defenderRoll = Random.Number(0, (defenderLvl/2) * defenderInt * 0.14)
lets say I have 22 agi thief and they have a 16 int paladin, both level 20
Steal Roll = 0 to 10 * 22 * 0.2 = 44
Defender Roll = 0 to 10 * 16 * 0.13 = 20.8
The chance (done 5000 rolls) is 77.7% chance to steal. (Used to be 70%)
----
Same thing, 10 int roll now.
Steal Roll = 44
Defender Roll = 13
Chance: 85.5%
----
22 AGI vs 16 INT, but the thief is 5 levels higher. (25 vs 20)
Steal Roll = 0 to 12.5 * 22 * 0.2 = 55
Defender Roll = 0 to 10 * 16 * 0.13 = 20.8
Change: 82.5%
----
22 AGI vs 16 INT, but the thief is 5 levels higher. (25 vs 20)
Steal Roll = 0 to 12.5 * 22 * 0.2 = 55
Defender Roll = 0 to 10 * 20 * 0.13 = 26
Change: 76.7%
Changes are now in effect now. Give it a whirl now and see. This means that:
A. Thieves should still a good deal on lower intelligence characters, but you might want to avoid gnomes and such (just like PVP, pick your targets).
B. Level is less important by half. So that a level 20 vs level 25 won't be 100% now as long as they have high int. It makes agi vs int more important though.
What do people think of these rolls? Too much? To little? I think it's fair overall, may need some small tweaking.
Haven't tested PVP, but going through PVE there's a definite difference between before the fixes and after them. I'm failing much more often against creatures higher level than I am. Which is frustrating, but not so much that I'm gonna give up on my thief, so I would say it's effective. Will get back to you on PVP results when I get bored and start robbing people instead of things.
I'm advocating for thieves because I think they are underpowered. There's no class specific bonus/skill except for rob. Perhaps increased dodge or effect after successful rob should be implemented. I also think that auto-exhaust after failure of robbing is too crippling for a thief. Please consider. Thank you!
-Robin, Gnome Thief
-Robin, Gnome Thief
I'm advocating for thieves because I think they are underpowered. There's no class specific bonus/skill except for rob. Perhaps increased dodge or effect after successful rob should be implemented. I also think that auto-exhaust after failure of robbing is too crippling for a thief. Please consider. Thank you!
-Robin, Gnome Thief
At lower levels you will have trouble, that is true. You cannot expect to rob from high level monsters though either successfully. If you did play ROK, it was easy to rob from everything regardless of level, it was a bit weird in that regard. But in this game you can't be level 15 running and robbing everything in the wiken (level 22) area. Having high agi makes it easier to snatch as well. Robbing from high INT monsters would be harder as its a THIEF AGI vs DEFENDER INT roll check. So robbing from dumb mobs (often not casters) of your level is a good choice.
They will be getting some skills but it's a little in the back for now. Their damage is 'ok' when backstabbing, its set to 3x, while assassins default is 4x. But the intentions of thieves was that they were going to have some extra skills such as trap setting and other things as that. The robbing that auto-exhausts is really the only way to stop them from robbing you, otherwise it would be far to easy to rob everything with no issues, rob fails , you run off, wait, try again. It is more of an issue with PVP though then PVE.
Good to hear future plans for skills. I did play ROK and the ultimate balance for them then was the 200 mill lvl 25. @ 300 mill and rob as the only bonus, they become meh. Looking forward to the traps and other skills. Thanks for the quick reply!
-Robin, Gnome Thief
-Robin, Gnome Thief
Have we looked at exp from robbing recently? It seems quite low to me. I'm not sure what the numbers are but I receive approximately 1-3x the xp I receive when attacking the mob on another character of similar level. For example @ lv21 on a monk I can receive between 5-10k per hit on an appropriate level mob. When stealing I get about 10-30k per mob. There is no killshot bonus when robbing, so overall the exp rate is far slower than other classes that are soloing or grouping.
Grouping thieves are fine I think, less damage so less exp coming in but at least the killshot bonuses are there. But this is a thief we're talking about, we are supposed to steal right? I think robbing exp should be at least equivalent (if not better) than grouping xp,e specially considering you might rob an area like Karnath and those mobs can sit there the rest of the day untouched (so you only get to rob them once a day is my point).
Opinions?
edit: stealing xp would probably be fine on higher lvl mobs with 200g on them, but that's very rare. More higher gold mobs would help but whether you balance around that or not is another story.
Grouping thieves are fine I think, less damage so less exp coming in but at least the killshot bonuses are there. But this is a thief we're talking about, we are supposed to steal right? I think robbing exp should be at least equivalent (if not better) than grouping xp,e specially considering you might rob an area like Karnath and those mobs can sit there the rest of the day untouched (so you only get to rob them once a day is my point).
Opinions?
edit: stealing xp would probably be fine on higher lvl mobs with 200g on them, but that's very rare. More higher gold mobs would help but whether you balance around that or not is another story.
There's some detail in the post above but some more data:
walker guardian
start xp - 86,151,318
finish xp - 86,179,181
107 gold stolen = 260 xp per gold
Shadow Skeleton
start xp - 86,212,252
finish xp - 86,221,334
129 gold stolen = 70 xp per gold
This is on a lv22 thief with 23 agi. I full rob any mob, I think max robs are in the high 400s? But no mob has that much anyway. Walker guardians are solid stealing xp and shadow skeletons suck. I can clear out Karnath mine and not even make 1mil xp, whereas 1mil xp on a melee character rolls in at around 6 minutes and also KEEPS rolling because mobs are respawning. With robbing once you do it that room is useless to you until it's cleared. If I could get 10mil in an hour on my thief that would at least be similar to grinding xp, but then I'd also not be able to keep going still so that's worth keeping in mind.
I assume gold xp is a function of whatever xp amount is assigned to the mob, right? And gold xp is set at a multipler of that? To make it competitive it needs to be at least doubled from what it's at now, probably tripled tbh. Robbing every mob in the GY gives me about 1mil xp right now...and takes me 20 some minutes. As I mentioned in that same time a melee character will make 3x what I do they get to keep going. Don't increase gold on mobs obviously, that's not the issue.
Failure rate : Well I don't know how it's determined but on the same lvl22 thief (23 agi) I can and often do fail stealing from mobs in Karnath Mine 3-4 times in a row. I don't have a hard data set for you but I imagine it could be figured out based on whatever formula you're using. It just feels really bad sometimes, I'd suggest either making it more based on level (because I've noticed no difference between failures at 20-22 when stealing from the same mobs in Karnath) or just lowering it all around, but I think it being more level based makes sense and feels more rewarding. I've been robbing Karnath since about 18 and it should feel pretty easy now that I'm 22, but it doesn't.
Hopefully this makes sense, I'm balls tired right now.
walker guardian
start xp - 86,151,318
finish xp - 86,179,181
107 gold stolen = 260 xp per gold
Shadow Skeleton
start xp - 86,212,252
finish xp - 86,221,334
129 gold stolen = 70 xp per gold
This is on a lv22 thief with 23 agi. I full rob any mob, I think max robs are in the high 400s? But no mob has that much anyway. Walker guardians are solid stealing xp and shadow skeletons suck. I can clear out Karnath mine and not even make 1mil xp, whereas 1mil xp on a melee character rolls in at around 6 minutes and also KEEPS rolling because mobs are respawning. With robbing once you do it that room is useless to you until it's cleared. If I could get 10mil in an hour on my thief that would at least be similar to grinding xp, but then I'd also not be able to keep going still so that's worth keeping in mind.
I assume gold xp is a function of whatever xp amount is assigned to the mob, right? And gold xp is set at a multipler of that? To make it competitive it needs to be at least doubled from what it's at now, probably tripled tbh. Robbing every mob in the GY gives me about 1mil xp right now...and takes me 20 some minutes. As I mentioned in that same time a melee character will make 3x what I do they get to keep going. Don't increase gold on mobs obviously, that's not the issue.
Failure rate : Well I don't know how it's determined but on the same lvl22 thief (23 agi) I can and often do fail stealing from mobs in Karnath Mine 3-4 times in a row. I don't have a hard data set for you but I imagine it could be figured out based on whatever formula you're using. It just feels really bad sometimes, I'd suggest either making it more based on level (because I've noticed no difference between failures at 20-22 when stealing from the same mobs in Karnath) or just lowering it all around, but I think it being more level based makes sense and feels more rewarding. I've been robbing Karnath since about 18 and it should feel pretty easy now that I'm 22, but it doesn't.
Hopefully this makes sense, I'm balls tired right now.
New skill for Thieves
/Bypass
Thieves should become immune to Kill to Pass mobs. Not only this would give them a huge tactical advantage, they would also become very dangerous at certain OADs as dropstealers. You know, because they could steal stuff. BEcause that is what they should do.
/Bypass
Thieves should become immune to Kill to Pass mobs. Not only this would give them a huge tactical advantage, they would also become very dangerous at certain OADs as dropstealers. You know, because they could steal stuff. BEcause that is what they should do.
New skill for Thieves
/Bypass
Thieves should become immune to Kill to Pass mobs. Not only this would give them a huge tactical advantage, they would also become very dangerous at certain OADs as dropstealers. You know, because they could steal stuff. BEcause that is what they should do.
I could see something like a negative type taunt when more than one player is on square but if it's only you they'd focus on you like normal, as you'd be the only check.
i think he means a skill to move past the hold effect
not actually being immune to the monster lol
something like you hide then attempt an evasion attack( no damage). if the attack hits you gain the ability to evade that monster for 1s per int.
not actually being immune to the monster lol
something like you hide then attempt an evasion attack( no damage). if the attack hits you gain the ability to evade that monster for 1s per int.
Even something simple like a /evade and if you fail you get brought out lose all Stam like a steal. Idk stuff for after update but yea I think he was meaning like a move to get past.
New skill for Thieves
/Bypass
Thieves should become immune to Kill to Pass mobs. Not only this would give them a huge tactical advantage, they would also become very dangerous at certain OADs as dropstealers. You know, because they could steal stuff. BEcause that is what they should do.
I like this idea as a natural boost to thieves doing what they should do. I don't think they should be completely immune to KTP mobs such that they could run circuits around dreads in seconds, but they should have a skill that allows them to have a %chance (eg based on INT) to escape a KTP mobs square without having to kill it (allowing them a faster getaway). I'd even be interested to see such a skill work on weird para mechanics like picking up a dragon scale etc (eg another class may be para for 30sec but a thief may have skill that allows them to escape sooner if their /escape or /bypass skill procs).
That being said, if this was implemented there may eventually need to be something that can combat this skill so that there is a chance to catch an escaping thief (eg changes to FF or Sight to detect them, or some kinda skill to lasso a thief attempting to escape with your loot lol). Peace