← Forum archive

Slayer/Brig Hide Revamp - Initial feedback and suggestions

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Terron
id figure your opponent would be at 0 bonus from agi when ur attacking him from "hidden". i dont think it should be hard to hit someone who doesn't know you are there. but thats my opinion lol. never seen assassin as much of a class but as more of a profession and in that line of work combat skills sneaking poisons and in certain cases armor would be most beneficial. trust me an orc with a battleaxe makes a fine assassin...
daedroth
One thing I find strange about slayers is that a max INT halfling and a max INT Human hide with the same skill (assuming they are the same level off course).

Options:
+/- for "size" (this would severely penalise horcs/sauria etc, unless it was just a + for small size or combined with below).
INT or AGL+INT/2 (whichever is better).

<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Dan
About slayers, I agree with Terron about it shouldnt be hard to hit someone who doesn't know you are there. Maybe they should have +1 agi when hidden, like the chanter fade buff.

On the other hand, regarding 1v1, a class that can round most of the meta shouldnt hit so often.

They can't just be spamming 600 dmg and hiding again.

So i think they damage should be adjusted in a way they kill most of the meta hitting x times, being x for sure bigger than 2, maybe 3 if they are very lucky.

Balance lies in if they can kill you in 2-3 rounds, they should die in 2 - 3 rounds as well.

I think it makes sense if their damage is higher against people with half hp or less, but should be reduced if people has higher than half hp. So they are finishers, they would have a role in group fights as well, if they time their attacks.

And they could hide again if they kill, but be tottally vulnerable if they don't, so you kinda force them to not spam that high damage attacks. That could be a problem in 1v1, so maybe give them medium armor back.
Terron
i think the emphasis on the "int" stat is almost entirely lost ingame atm. i mean sure, u dont want to have 10 int so monsters and normal dpsers like cavalier/ninja find you endlessly. but what i mean by this is why have 20 int or 22 or even 24. 24 int lasts 1.2 seconds vs an arcane watcher, and less vs some ranger pets. brig event is hideless basically, im sure a slayer class event will be hideless to.
isnt really much difference past 14 int imo. once u can outhide the general dpser populace you have enough int. going past that doesnt help you stay hidden from any of the other stuff. so all in all put in 14-15 int, avoid low wisdom, and prepare to get blown up every 3 seconds by watchers that you cant resist over and over. the only use for high int is lasting longer in hide and kill event.


slayer class has honestly just became a zerker. its just a class that the group with the largest numbers at the time can use to assert dominance over the weaker groups.
Hanibal
Put them back the way they were, no timers.

The only dmg penalty they should get should be determined by the race you choose to play, gobs/drows have lower str but higher wis/int, saurian/h-orc have a higher str potential but lower int/wis, thats what we call balance.

Currently your looking at a chanter with almost 200 ac with stoneskin and a watcher that searches for them where as before they had lower ac and had to use one stamina to search for themselves, that was also balance.

I read in this thread where a slayer could easily round any class i/g, im yet to see this on my own h-orc slayer, what you guys feeding yours?

Every class had a weakness and really the only weakness a chanter/DM had were slayers, now thats gone along with solo pkrs on their slayers poking ppl in the back.
Dan
Hanibal ive seen slayers doing 600+ bs on my chars, its simple math.

How many of the class/race meta have 1200+ hp?
Terron
they dont typically do that much now since buffs dont work the same. but they still do alot of damage and can be immune to death in alot of 1v1 situations.

was just too many "balance" implements at the same time. im sure there can be a happy medium just going to take a bit.
NiteHawk
Yeah I get they need tweaking, we're looking at it anyways.

id figure your opponent would be at 0 bonus from agi when ur attacking him from "hidden". i dont think it should be hard to hit someone who doesn't know you are there. but thats my opinion lol. never seen assassin as much of a class but as more of a profession and in that line of work combat skills sneaking poisons and in certain cases armor would be most beneficial. trust me an orc with a battleaxe makes a fine assassin...


This ain't the real life though. Having 0 AGI would pretty much mean insta hits. From a balance perspective that's would really mess things up with the current. It could be a easier chance to hit but I don't know if that's really the issue they're having at the moment.


----

Anyways, they're still top dogs in terms of damage but they're fairly squishy now. Right now slayers mostly hide to negate damage, which could be a bad/godo thing depending on who you're talking too. (I.E. It makes for a different style gameplay to actually use /hide however it also makes them immune to lower INT players as it's hard to search them out.) You could swap the timer to hide attack (DELAY) but that might be worse off for them in a gameplay perspective as they will have a window of 'attack' opportunity every time. Might be OK but then you'd probably nix the bonus spell damage and other things.


In regards to not having a timer, I mean, that sounds like the you want your cake and to eat it too. The real issue is that slayers have a 4.5x damage bonus DW'ing plus a hide mechanic. When comparing it to others, /hide + attack is two attacks, so the actual damage is 2.25x , because they are using daggers you can probably remove some of it and say that they get 1.75-2x damage more than others for doing literally nothing. Yeah, your zerker/etc can do high damage too, but it's no where as consistent as slayers. I honestly just wanted to nerf their damage multiplier but no one was having that before. Also, on top of the heavy damage they could just constantly move and hide again.

I'm not sure what the real route is here yet, there is a lot of opinions on this and what to do at the moment.

In terms of the INT, 20 int does matter for NPCs finding you like the watcher. It also does matter for players searching. It's a linear increase, it doesn't have 'a falloff'. So if that 15INT was good, then 20INT will be all that better. A HO/Saurian will struggle to fight against a sorc more then others because of the lack of INT though in any case.
Terron
it may be linear, but its ineffective the way things are built. i play 3 hiders 24 20 and 11 int. 11 sucks flat out pve. 20 cant hide vs anything in the caster department considering almost every caster is 22-24 int its rough. then when u factor in watchers and stuff u cant hide at all. and noone can hide from a 30 int bird pet with 5-9 infravision spamming 3 attacks every 5 seconds.

now when u take 24 int hider into a large group situation it tends to just look like; autosneak in, hide, get blown up, retreat, drink pot, autosneak in, hide, get blown up, retreat, drink pot, hide outside, and wait for stam. repeat over and over.

in most cases i dont even have time to look over 2 people before a watcher reveals my ass. but wait this isnt even the best part, this is only with 1 watcher, what about 2 3 or even 5. no class should spend 15 mana to instafkover a whole class or 2. i say this because and only because i have max hide, there is no way to get better. idc if watchers spot me some but if 24 int doesn't last a whole second might aswell just log on the 11 int guy it tends to play out the exact same.
daedroth
Eh... I can't verify the watcher thing, I used it when alt was 23rd? Gnome sorcy vs Master Burglar, it never triggered once, but that's not pvp (and the master burglar would have been higher level right?, ? INT but probably high).

If Watcher is a problem, why not make the watcher a high INT pet (INT = to caster INT -#) that does not explode on discovering a hider, but auto hits/attacks for lower damage? It's HP could be lowered too?
NiteHawk
Eh... I can't verify the watcher thing, I used it when alt was 23rd? Gnome sorcy vs Master Burglar, it never triggered once, but that's not pvp (and the master burglar would have been higher level right?, ? INT but probably high).


Yeah I have to disagree too. It was tested and it doesn't find 23 inters all the time. I can grab the formula later on for averages but when I tested it with a few people it was struggling harder with 23 inters. Yeah if you have 4-5 watchers, then it will find easier defo, and for sure low inters though. I don't really see that as a problem though. Someone brings one type of class, bring a counter type sort of deal.

Anyways I do know it's again a little heavy on the side of nerfs on slayers, not saying that they don't need a little touchups on the better side either just depends on how we do it. I don't really think giving them a AGI boost to attacking is really a good idea though. I'm not ruling it out, but regardless they still are high damage dealers even without it. It might make them fairly strong in 1vs1 though which might just be another 180 again.
daedroth
AGL bonus to hit would make sense, but yeh it would be unbalancing.
Could go the other way though. AGL, maybe also WIS: as in just a generic defence bonus vs next attack (which would likely never get used due to double hiding).
Look on it as the surprise factor.
That would be a little bonus and less unbalancing.
JadeFalcon
Eh... I can't verify the watcher thing, I used it when alt was 23rd? Gnome sorcy vs Master Burglar, it never triggered once, but that's not pvp (and the master burglar would have been higher level right?, ? INT but probably high).


Yeah I have to disagree too. It was tested and it doesn't find 23 inters all the time. I can grab the formula later on for averages but when I tested it with a few people it was struggling harder with 23 inters. Yeah if you have 4-5 watchers, then it will find easier defo, and for sure low inters though. I don't really see that as a problem though. Someone brings one type of class, bring a counter type sort of deal.

Anyways I do know it's again a little heavy on the side of nerfs on slayers, not saying that they don't need a little touchups on the better side either just depends on how we do it. I don't really think giving them a AGI boost to attacking is really a good idea though. I'm not ruling it out, but regardless they still are high damage dealers even without it. It might make them fairly strong in 1vs1 though which might just be another 180 again.



AGI boost to defence against melee attacks.
You dont give them more damage (which you dont want)
You dont have to upgrade their armor (which you just changed)
You solve the problem you want (that they die way too fast)
Terron
i dont really think dieing too fast is a slayer/brig problem. infact if i was to use a saurian of any class the brigand/slayer is likely to live the longest just from the poor ass hides they do get off in time. its a racial problem and a system imbalance.

u have casters killing no mr in 5-6 stamina (this is fine)
you have high mr melee basically immune to casters (this is also fine considering the above)
you have low mr beat sticks with barely an ounce of benefit over high mr dark elf/goblin (this isnt fine when compared to the previous 2)

any lizard doesnt really survive long enough to make an impact in group fights if casters are present. saurian is a pispoor choice in the current game when even npcs are slaughtering low wisdom. just pick a damn goblin lol even a goblin with 10 wisdom is loads better with just racial negation (also broken)

imo slayers and zerks kinda just swapped places. zerk is more steady damage and more resilient and slayer is basically reserved for the larger group to use to blast a small group to pieces even faster, mainly because smaller groups cant afford to search and have too many weakpoints.

if u want to just roam the globe on slayers again you will have to use a bit more daft. sacrifice your +1 and use lings/goblins elves gnomes and dark elves. the class is still extremely viable, just not so much if u have no mr. also the slayers strongest point before update was the mere fact that there were several slayers at every fight. so rolling in on a solo elf probably isnt going to work.
Styx
I don't know if it's been suggested or not, but if we modified the /search so if on finding an assy or thief, the steady classes, they can't immediately rehide and have a penalty to hide.

In thought, if you found someone holding a dagger your stareing right at them, they shouldn't be able to rehide and know they will get attacked.

This will improve the abilities of high int classes, and make the slayer stat choices even harder, high int to hide or more wis.
daedroth
I don't know if it's been suggested or not, but if we modified the /search so if on finding an assy or thief, the steady classes, they can't immediately rehide and have a penalty to hide.

In thought, if you found someone holding a dagger your stareing right at them, they shouldn't be able to rehide and know they will get attacked.

This will improve the abilities of high int classes, and make the slayer stat choices even harder, high int to hide or more wis.


The problem is, some people think they (assassins) have been nerfed enough. I haven't used a slayer enough to judge (haven't got one right now, and when I did I was never good at using them to their full potential).

The problem with realism is balance, too much realism can be pretty damn unbalancing.
anthriel
Maybe this:
1. Leave damage as is (differentiation as a killer class)
2. Add class +2 dodge agility (like monks) per Jadefalcons suggestion. (Helps survive melee but doesn’t help against caster weakness)
3. Add a %fail on hide for both slayer n brig (dependant on int)... this negates both attack and defence if you fail hiding (ie you use up additional stam and can’t double bstab that round or you may end up exposed at end of round instead of rehiding) and it makes int worth something in 1v1 “no double hide” type events like the upcoming thief TGC. I’m not talking big amounts but maybe base 20int = 94% hide success and its +/- 2% for every int point higher/lower... hence a 24 int gnome has 102% success rate to hide (ie buffer even if smashed by a knight) and a 10int horc/saur has 84% success rate to hide.
4. Possibly add some anti-party type disadvantages (discussed previously in diff thread - eg can’t hide in parties which would make it harder for them to get heals if they went solo etc) if still needed to further balance groupfight hax

Shrugs
daedroth
Imagine this.
You use all your stamina (damage multiplied appropriately) on a back stab attempt (basically if you hit you will likely kill something, this will likely lead to rage (to lessen one shotted rage could make it 1/2 to full multiplication damage, so two stamina is x2 to x4 damage, 3 stamina is x3 to x6 damage, 4 stamina is x4 to x8 or 1/2+1 so x3 to x4, x4 to x6, x5 to x8 or some such), but if you miss you will be vulnerable).
You cannot hide again until your combat timer clears (so anything that resets your combat timer means no hiding, which means no backstabing, run away and try again?) maybe + some time.
Something like the above has been discussed before and its been nae.
Normal attacks have a chance of critical hit (an assassin knows where to hit for best effect).