New Guild and Boss Systems.
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Sorry heavily against alts and having to redesign the game.
I understand numbers are a bit low but Alts do nothing for the game besides artificially inflate numbers.
When we go to tablets/fb (which should be our main goal) it will work against us. It creates an unfair advantage for them and is off putting for the new players we should be trying to entice.
How would the game have to be redesigned if people were able to log more then one crit at a time?
When someone new starts playing a game and see's a player base sub 100 they arent going to bother wasting their time, the only time the game hits any descent numbers (30+) is when there is a special event and its still people only being active when bosses spawn, sitting idle and watching youtube vids isnt being active.
If this game goes to an app based game or fb i feel the current player base will dwindle even more, sure you will get new players but with no one around from the old player base to show them the ropes, fb sucks and anything involving a tablet would need major game update like i dont know graphics, text muds are best left for people using a computer. If this game does update to either of those above platforms there should be an option to still play on your puter at home, like a seperate server.
What attracted most ppl to Ember was it was similar to another game we all played, being an app and really limiting peoples time to playing even more i dont think is going to help.
i agree and disagree with this.
on 1 hand i cant stand alts, on the other the game isnt designed for tablets/fb. have you even seen games that are designed for those platforms? they are simple, you log in when you want, you dont miss special "keys" or anything. currently there is no way id play ember on a tablet, i wouldnt sit there drooling on it tappin the screen as fast as i can for drops or 1v1 events. dont like typing on tablets either. not to mention how annoying things like blind will be, i feel that skill is over utilized and infatuated already.
people would hammer bad reviews of this game on facebook the first week they couldnt log on and missed seta keys for a week or anything else. you know its true. theres realistically no way this game will perform on those outlets w/o bosses being available all day all the time via instance or the suggestion i had above.
id love to have the players, but the game itself cant support them. youd have to either give everyone keys for logging in or make bosses available 24-7. So basically, 1 way or another the game is getting revamped. so using the excuse of changing the whole game to allow alts isnt really an issue, since the game will need 100s of changes for FB/App anyway. but again i prefer 1 character at a time.
on 1 hand i cant stand alts, on the other the game isnt designed for tablets/fb. have you even seen games that are designed for those platforms? they are simple, you log in when you want, you dont miss special "keys" or anything. currently there is no way id play ember on a tablet, i wouldnt sit there drooling on it tappin the screen as fast as i can for drops or 1v1 events. dont like typing on tablets either. not to mention how annoying things like blind will be, i feel that skill is over utilized and infatuated already.
people would hammer bad reviews of this game on facebook the first week they couldnt log on and missed seta keys for a week or anything else. you know its true. theres realistically no way this game will perform on those outlets w/o bosses being available all day all the time via instance or the suggestion i had above.
id love to have the players, but the game itself cant support them. youd have to either give everyone keys for logging in or make bosses available 24-7. So basically, 1 way or another the game is getting revamped. so using the excuse of changing the whole game to allow alts isnt really an issue, since the game will need 100s of changes for FB/App anyway. but again i prefer 1 character at a time.
A lvl 25+ system would be awesome if you use a merit system close to what ffxi used for their max lvl plus system. And crafting best gear in game would benefot the current mwta.
@hanibal every single part of the game besides group oads is designed for one player. allow people to control more than 1 player and the difficulty of all monsters quests pvp interactions spawn rates drop rates etc needs to be adjusted.
From a build perspective alone it’s pretty much redoing the game. Well you say people already have the option to team with someone else but that 2 turns into 4 and so on. I’m not sure if you remember how that turned out in rok but inorder to have a somewhat challenging game for players we had to design the game for alts Then making it impossible to play solo.
Beyond that where does it stop 2 alts 3 alts unlimited?
You are thinking about yourself and no real “new” players. Any real new player that has to use 2-3 clients at once as soon as they start a game to survive/compete will never ever stay around.
Sorry I’m just very against alts it’s poor game design imo. If there is a problem with playing the game with a certain class then there needs to be a design adjustment. Not patch up by allowing Alts.
As for expanding to tablets I think it could be very easily done and unfortunately imo is the only way we will gain more players otherwise we will continue a gradual downward slope of active users. Yes 25+ and new classes and whatnot will help but imo we need new fresh blood and we could spend 100 hours a week marketing and spend $10000 and not get the amount of new users we could get from 1 hour of being on an App Store.
This is what I do for a living I know the market I know how this works.
From a build perspective alone it’s pretty much redoing the game. Well you say people already have the option to team with someone else but that 2 turns into 4 and so on. I’m not sure if you remember how that turned out in rok but inorder to have a somewhat challenging game for players we had to design the game for alts Then making it impossible to play solo.
Beyond that where does it stop 2 alts 3 alts unlimited?
You are thinking about yourself and no real “new” players. Any real new player that has to use 2-3 clients at once as soon as they start a game to survive/compete will never ever stay around.
Sorry I’m just very against alts it’s poor game design imo. If there is a problem with playing the game with a certain class then there needs to be a design adjustment. Not patch up by allowing Alts.
As for expanding to tablets I think it could be very easily done and unfortunately imo is the only way we will gain more players otherwise we will continue a gradual downward slope of active users. Yes 25+ and new classes and whatnot will help but imo we need new fresh blood and we could spend 100 hours a week marketing and spend $10000 and not get the amount of new users we could get from 1 hour of being on an App Store.
This is what I do for a living I know the market I know how this works.
app store would be a great revenue service. i just dont see those people stickin to it if 5-10 people hoard every key in the game. we lose players over it already. and the truth of it is; we are losing those players and they have 20 yr familiarity to this "type" of game. newer people will be back to dragonvale or whatever play at your own pace game, by the end of the month. if they last that long.
app store would be a great revenue service. i just dont see those people stickin to it if 5-10 people hoard every key in the game. we lose players over it already. and the truth of it is; we are losing those players and they have 20 yr familiarity to this "type" of game. newer people will be back to dragonvale or whatever play at your own pace game, by the end of the month. if they last that long.
That’s the thing when you average a few 100 downloads a day even if 90% of people don’t stick you are still gaining tons of people each day.
Consider those 100 people or so I speak of a day as a very conservative number. I have games that are much more simple than ember and offline that did 5-10 k downloads EACH day for the first week or so. I know muds are somewhat a dying breed but we would also be one of the first to the tablet as well so.
Our biggest hurdle will be as you said keeping enough bosses keys etc spawning Quick enough. Honestly it might be rare to get to run an oad in the future if things are not instanced. Can you imagine 200-400 people on the server fighting over keys resources etc. a very good problem to have. Yes builders would have some work todo but a good problem to have.
yeah, it is the only future to obtain. just the game isnt going to be the same. most of the changes we need anyway, so its a win win.
always been interested in trying an offline version of a Mud aswell, although ive never seen one. turn based might work, but alts would be fun if it was just you.
always been interested in trying an offline version of a Mud aswell, although ive never seen one. turn based might work, but alts would be fun if it was just you.
@hanibal every single part of the game besides group oads is designed for one player. allow people to control more than 1 player and the difficulty of all monsters quests pvp interactions spawn rates drop rates etc needs to be adjusted.
From a build perspective alone it’s pretty much redoing the game. Well you say people already have the option to team with someone else but that 2 turns into 4 and so on. I’m not sure if you remember how that turned out in rok but inorder to have a somewhat challenging game for players we had to design the game for alts Then making it impossible to play solo.
Beyond that where does it stop 2 alts 3 alts unlimited?
You are thinking about yourself and no real “new” players. Any real new player that has to use 2-3 clients at once as soon as they start a game to survive/compete will never ever stay around.
Sorry I’m just very against alts it’s poor game design imo. If there is a problem with playing the game with a certain class then there needs to be a design adjustment. Not patch up by allowing Alts.
As for expanding to tablets I think it could be very easily done and unfortunately imo is the only way we will gain more players otherwise we will continue a gradual downward slope of active users. Yes 25+ and new classes and whatnot will help but imo we need new fresh blood and we could spend 100 hours a week marketing and spend $10000 and not get the amount of new users we could get from 1 hour of being on an App Store.
This is what I do for a living I know the market I know how this works.
Don't most people who can party to lvl and do quests have more the one person in the party now anyway? Whats the difference with partying with your own alts?
I'm not thinking about myself, rarely do. I'm looking at it from a players view, not a builder, there are very few muds that do well where you can log only one character, I know because i have played alot of them, shit ive played games with graphics with unlimited character logins.
Do you know how unappealing lvling solo knowing nothing about a game is? Especially when you may only have a few hours an evening after work, the way games are evolving today its about how much you can get done in those few hours with the most enjoyment, not being on at X time of the day to run a key then being on again at Y time to do a boss.
Sure if your in a large guild who do keys and bosses everyday this is alright, you may still get something for helping when you can but for those who are sick of the drama and just want to do stuff whenever they end up quitting, im not saying raising the alt limit is goign to fix any of this but it might bring some of the ppl back who have left for this reason.
While I think the single character vs alts discussion is a good one, I think it’s best to keep it as a seperate discussion regarding core game dynamics. Same with all this tablet/app stuff (Terron has a point that there would need to be other major overhauls to make it playable under these platforms that exceed just keeping it to “no alts”). The key to fixing the game as it is now (ie single char at a time) is changing the guild system and loot system with that in mind. There was enough interest in the game without alts (500+ forum Accts etc)... but we failed to retain that interest (and drove ppl away) mainly cos of the poor guild system and loot system issues mentioned previously by many here and elsewhere. Let’s keep the focus on that topic and discuss the alts issue elsewhere methinks. Peace.
While I think the single character vs alts discussion is a good one, I think it’s best to keep it as a seperate discussion regarding core game dynamics. Same with all this tablet/app stuff (Terron has a point that there would need to be other major overhauls to make it playable under these platforms that exceed just keeping it to “no alts”). The key to fixing the game as it is now (ie single char at a time) is changing the guild system and loot system with that in mind. There was enough interest in the game without alts (500+ forum Accts etc)... but we failed to retain that interest (and drove ppl away) mainly cos of the poor guild system and loot system issues mentioned previously by many here and elsewhere. Let’s keep the focus on that topic and discuss the alts issue elsewhere methinks. Peace.
You are very right we have a retention problem for sure.
I think everyone can agree on that.
I dont think more content areas/oads is the answer either. While more oads and leveling spaces are nice it does it also works against us. less interaction because everyone is spread out. less competition at oads because there are more to do etc. also oads while nice you need level 25ers and in many cases a big guild (atleast 4-5 people to run with). you also have to get keys etc so it only serves certain time zones.
We need something that appeals to everyone imo and thats why im pushing a new class / 25+. I believe a new class really appeals to everyone. You dont need to be level 25, or have a big guild, or on at a certain time to fight over keys. This is something everyone can enjoy and it should snowball activity (more on leveling more play pk etc). I believe its something that would bring back old players as well as attract new players. These new players that do join will see other players their level leveling so retention of those should go up as well. It also has an indirect active effect that if we do the new class correct people will also need to level up counter classes etc. We also have a plan to make each div important for the class (so replay-ability will be high). While it wont last forever like 25+ it should give players something to do for a good while (hopefully a holdover until we can get 25+/crafting/tablet build in).
This is like dejavu. Introduction of the deathmage and minstrel class in rok. Level 25+ content what’s that gonna add extra hp and mp? Gonna redesign the game so it’s made to level up skills/spells after level 25 so it will scale with HP/MP and damge increases? The biggest downfall with trying to improve this game is a backwards way of thinking of ones self and progression when forgetting the overall future of the game. Nothing stopping anyone from reaching out to some of the more popular mud games out there and asking them what has kept them going aside from maybe pride issues.
DnD 5th edition I am in no way trying to put anyone down or to insult anyone but I think actually reading these books would help the game/builder understand more about game balance. More to a game that a nice script.
<a class="postlink" href="https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/BookIndex">https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/BookIndex</a>
DnD 5th edition I am in no way trying to put anyone down or to insult anyone but I think actually reading these books would help the game/builder understand more about game balance. More to a game that a nice script.
<a class="postlink" href="https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/BookIndex">https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/BookIndex</a>
This is like dejavu. Introduction of the deathmage and minstrel class in rok. Level 25+ content what’s that gonna add extra hp and mp? Gonna redesign the game so it’s made to level up skills/spells after level 25 so it will scale with HP/MP and damge increases? The biggest downfall with trying to improve this game is a backwards way of thinking of ones self and progression when forgetting the overall future of the game. Nothing stopping anyone from reaching out to some of the more popular mud games out there and asking them what has kept them going aside from maybe pride issues.
DnD 5th edition I am in no way trying to put anyone down or to insult anyone but I think actually reading these books would help the game/builder understand more about game balance. More to a game that a nice script.
<a class="postlink" href="https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/BookIndex">https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/BookIndex</a>
Glad you agree and remember how dm and zerker effected the playerbase that’s what we are hoping to see here as well. Far as I remember there were hundreds on and it really was refreshing for the game lots of players returned and it not only allowed people to level those new classes but changed the whole meta and other classes around those were leveled. Far as I remember numbers were up months and maybe even years after that it was a very big deal almost like an expansion. Also if you remember how zerkers and pacifist were added to nightmist it was a huge boost for that game as well.
Ideally we would start with 1 class and maybe a race here and go from there not saying it’s all we would need to do but a new class a year to refresh meta instead of hard changes to current classes would go a very very long way. We are able to shuffle meta without changing anyone’s fav class and so on.
As for 25+ not sure what that would entail. That is a much bigger project. Not sure on hawks ideas. Could there be leveling up of skills? Maybe although that gets complicated to balance pretty quick but maybe it would work 25+ idk. Again have not talked a ton about that but I do have something in mind for a new class and have shared it with hawk and other staff. Not to speak for him but I do believe it’s something somewhere on the list.
I think level 25+ should be perks/feats whatever you want to consider them. Like I said though, more of them than you can choose, so many games you can look at for ideas, fallout/DnD spring to mind. way different games, but decent ideas for perks.
DnD... im so so with that game. So many things I don't like about it, but with friends it is simple enough and fun, and I think some of the ideas in DnD would work here.
DnD... im so so with that game. So many things I don't like about it, but with friends it is simple enough and fun, and I think some of the ideas in DnD would work here.
Rok numbers...depends on when and how’ve many alts each player had 3 alts x 100= 300 players and I know for a fact that I could obtain 6 online with a proxy. NM the numbers could be similar. Short term goals short term success. 25+ skill trees? Put points into stealth and backstab to make them more powerful?
You get what I am saying tho.
Instead of adding stuff why not look at the current issues and fix those?
I suggested alts because it would fix the having to be in a big guild to do anything, level, do keys etc.
Now people will argue if you can log alts so can those people in big guilds, then add a room lock so only X amount of members from one guild can enter a key or boss room, you could still have those fights at bosses because when one member from a guild dies another would be able to enter or you may even have multiple battles going on in different places with people trying to get there.
If people were able to log on 1 maybe two alts a clan with 3 people could basically do anything a guild of 10 could do also that guild of 10 would probably drop with numbers because most of those people are only in there so they can better their gear. This is the only reason one super guild dies and another is born the same day.
Im not saying this will be a fix all but it might fix one major problem this game has had since day one.
I suggested alts because it would fix the having to be in a big guild to do anything, level, do keys etc.
Now people will argue if you can log alts so can those people in big guilds, then add a room lock so only X amount of members from one guild can enter a key or boss room, you could still have those fights at bosses because when one member from a guild dies another would be able to enter or you may even have multiple battles going on in different places with people trying to get there.
If people were able to log on 1 maybe two alts a clan with 3 people could basically do anything a guild of 10 could do also that guild of 10 would probably drop with numbers because most of those people are only in there so they can better their gear. This is the only reason one super guild dies and another is born the same day.
Im not saying this will be a fix all but it might fix one major problem this game has had since day one.
maybe the races arent balanced to begin with. why is everyone a goblin and dark elf? saurian kills you in 6 hits dark elf kills you in 6 hits maybe 7 if the previous 6 hit lowest range. goblin kills you in 6 hits, 7 if half of the hits are low range. dark elf gets 40 mr for free, goblin gets 30+ mr and free -10% negation for free. everyone is a dark elf and goblin. hmmm broken.
maybe stat ranges of 15 points maximum, cant be balanced. maybe this is why most games dont have stats like that anymore and do all advancement through skill trees and perks. generally speaking, adding a class or new race wont do much other than pile broken(if its viable alternative to goblin/dark elf) or junk (if its not) on top of an imbalanced system. same for class really. new class either slaughters 1v1 and is everywhere or it doesnt and wont get used, aside from pride boredom or gotta collect em all type deal.
this playerbase is obviously just done with additions that dont fix anything. atleast thats the general feel and opinions i receive ingame.
id love new classes, races, and content to, so dont take this as a negative. but we need some things balanced. oads/guilds being the top systems people dislike.
EDIT: if you notice what i posted above. i specifically stated "NO" damage increases for 25+. this isnt the first rodeo ive been to.
maybe stat ranges of 15 points maximum, cant be balanced. maybe this is why most games dont have stats like that anymore and do all advancement through skill trees and perks. generally speaking, adding a class or new race wont do much other than pile broken(if its viable alternative to goblin/dark elf) or junk (if its not) on top of an imbalanced system. same for class really. new class either slaughters 1v1 and is everywhere or it doesnt and wont get used, aside from pride boredom or gotta collect em all type deal.
this playerbase is obviously just done with additions that dont fix anything. atleast thats the general feel and opinions i receive ingame.
id love new classes, races, and content to, so dont take this as a negative. but we need some things balanced. oads/guilds being the top systems people dislike.
EDIT: if you notice what i posted above. i specifically stated "NO" damage increases for 25+. this isnt the first rodeo ive been to.
I see what you did there hue hue hue.
(Mainly @Lateralus) I’d love to have some new classes etc but I don’t think that adding a new class (or even the entire lvl 25+ system) is anything but a short term solution (temporary interest generated, then eventually crushed by the oppressive guild/loot issues if those remain unfixed). It’s a “nice to have” but not until the guild system (and possibly the loot system to some degree) are fixed imho. The key to retaining players is making the guild system have more options, less factionalism etc and the loot system to support this (ie ways to progressively improve loot without needing to get involved with the drama of superguilds trying to always have the biggest posse available to stomp everyone else). Until that happens, the scores of once passionate players (even guild leaders - which we want more of!) etc will just stay away having already been burned by the current broken guild/loot system.
I believe the problems with Ember retaining players can be boiled down to simple terms. People can't agree on the type of game they want it to be. I've heard a bunch of people say we need more pvp. Some people argue for more content, others say we need less to force more pvp. Right now the game is geared toward die hard players who grind away for hours a day. The main focus on things seems to be pvp (for instance, the thief class event focused on brute force fights with no attention to their main stealth ability). Areas and events are geared towards big groups/guilds where casual players don't stand a chance. Changing the fundamental system behind the game isn't required to fix these things, there are other ways we can go forward to actually manage to retain people.
1 PVP focus. It needs to end. I know a lot of people love the PVP aspect of the game but really it's time to quit pushing for more PVP. More PVP won't make the game viable in the long term. The lack of ability to play the game without PVP may be hurting the game. I have spoken to a lot of people who have gotten tired of the constant fighting in every aspect of the game. Everything centers around PVP, and as a PVP enabled game a certain amount is expected but we may have gone overboard in catering to a few at the expense of the many. This doesn't mean PVP should be removed, it means there needs to be some things in game that aren't subject to PVP for people who have no taste for it or simply don't like the attendant drama.
2 Casual Play desired. Not everyone can devote several hours a day or one whole day a week to playing the game. Sometimes people want to log on for 20 minutes and do something. Right now, you have to be really lucky in the 20 minute window you log on to do something other than level a character. With some people having 20+ lvl 25ers, there is nothing desirable to gain from leveling. It's time to put more stuff in game for people who have only a casual desire to play. If that means putting in dozens of mini-bosses in game so be it. Personally, I'd like to have an area with mini-bosses spawning hourly that drop decent gear but that disappear if they aren't killed in time. Throw in more "walkers" in leveling areas and you end up with a reason for people to log on and run around looking for stuff. Once crafting is introduced, having the "bosses" drop materials would be a good way to balance these out and give another pathway of attaining items as well as something casual players can do without needing a large guild.
3 Why are we here? Simply put, we need an immersive Lore. I take some responsibility for this since I've been working on Lore. Learning all the new stuff that has been put in over the last 2 years and then shoehorning it into a single cohesive lore structure isn't easy. Once we have a Lore base, we need to stick to it and build areas to play to it. We also need quest lines that take players through the story as well as giving them "perks" for completing milestones along the way. Think of the reputation system in World of Warcraft, we could easily use something like that for Ember. Once we have a set Lore, we can have a Questmaster to work on massive story lines where the players get to influence the world and help shape how things evolve.
4 The GRIND! It would help to fill in the grinding gaps. Once you hit level 20ish you start hitting large gaps in the quests forcing you to instead result to grinding away on killing certain monsters in order to hit max level. I believe we need to allow players other pathways to getting their characters finished without having to result to mindlessly wandering the wilds killing things. We could put more repeatable quests in as well as expanding the quests to be cross-zone, much like the dailies.
5 Toxicity. Ever read the Terms of Service and Code of Conduct from other games? We have people who play this game who would be banned quickly from other games for being a detriment to the game. Wizards of the Coast and Blizzard both have expansive CoCs and they deal with players who are a detriment to the game rather harshly. I have a confession, I had an account banned for life from Blizzard for violating their CoC. Not sure what I did as all they will tell me is I violated their terms, but after it happened I had to rebuild from nothing and made sure I didn't do anything in violation of their rules. Make it painful to break the rules, or make other people not want to play, and you will learn to play nice.
1 PVP focus. It needs to end. I know a lot of people love the PVP aspect of the game but really it's time to quit pushing for more PVP. More PVP won't make the game viable in the long term. The lack of ability to play the game without PVP may be hurting the game. I have spoken to a lot of people who have gotten tired of the constant fighting in every aspect of the game. Everything centers around PVP, and as a PVP enabled game a certain amount is expected but we may have gone overboard in catering to a few at the expense of the many. This doesn't mean PVP should be removed, it means there needs to be some things in game that aren't subject to PVP for people who have no taste for it or simply don't like the attendant drama.
2 Casual Play desired. Not everyone can devote several hours a day or one whole day a week to playing the game. Sometimes people want to log on for 20 minutes and do something. Right now, you have to be really lucky in the 20 minute window you log on to do something other than level a character. With some people having 20+ lvl 25ers, there is nothing desirable to gain from leveling. It's time to put more stuff in game for people who have only a casual desire to play. If that means putting in dozens of mini-bosses in game so be it. Personally, I'd like to have an area with mini-bosses spawning hourly that drop decent gear but that disappear if they aren't killed in time. Throw in more "walkers" in leveling areas and you end up with a reason for people to log on and run around looking for stuff. Once crafting is introduced, having the "bosses" drop materials would be a good way to balance these out and give another pathway of attaining items as well as something casual players can do without needing a large guild.
3 Why are we here? Simply put, we need an immersive Lore. I take some responsibility for this since I've been working on Lore. Learning all the new stuff that has been put in over the last 2 years and then shoehorning it into a single cohesive lore structure isn't easy. Once we have a Lore base, we need to stick to it and build areas to play to it. We also need quest lines that take players through the story as well as giving them "perks" for completing milestones along the way. Think of the reputation system in World of Warcraft, we could easily use something like that for Ember. Once we have a set Lore, we can have a Questmaster to work on massive story lines where the players get to influence the world and help shape how things evolve.
4 The GRIND! It would help to fill in the grinding gaps. Once you hit level 20ish you start hitting large gaps in the quests forcing you to instead result to grinding away on killing certain monsters in order to hit max level. I believe we need to allow players other pathways to getting their characters finished without having to result to mindlessly wandering the wilds killing things. We could put more repeatable quests in as well as expanding the quests to be cross-zone, much like the dailies.
5 Toxicity. Ever read the Terms of Service and Code of Conduct from other games? We have people who play this game who would be banned quickly from other games for being a detriment to the game. Wizards of the Coast and Blizzard both have expansive CoCs and they deal with players who are a detriment to the game rather harshly. I have a confession, I had an account banned for life from Blizzard for violating their CoC. Not sure what I did as all they will tell me is I violated their terms, but after it happened I had to rebuild from nothing and made sure I didn't do anything in violation of their rules. Make it painful to break the rules, or make other people not want to play, and you will learn to play nice.