← Forum archive

PK system and XP

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Hollow
I was surprised to see XP loss was removed, I think it's important because leveling outside of arenas is better EXP but you aren't safe. It brings a certain risk.

I also enjoy the sickness system, it actually helps teamfights between clans over oads/keys decide a winner for the spoils. 25ers can't keep dying and running back into team battles and I love it.

But if you combine XP Loss with getting killed 10x in an hour than that maybe too much. I do like the timer idea but an hour is far too long and that would discourage PKing. We don't want to discourage PKing and teamfighting, we just want to make a window for the person leveling to maybe catch their breath, find a new area and get some EXP.

Maybe, an alternate route is to make leveling in arenas more fruitful so that when someone is getting destroyed, they can relax and grind some EXP in the arena. It wouldn't be as good but the current random monster system would need adjustment. I remember Donas Dobhar from RoK was always a hot spot and people would grind in the arenas to stay safe and gained XP and gold at a decent rate. I wouldn't say make it an extremely effective way to level but at least make it more appealing than hoping your next pull is a decent monster that you have div on.

It's a tough decision because on one hand, I like the challenge of overcoming PKers and persevering but on the other hand being camped in 3 different leveling spots for an hour isn't fun ever for the person being camped. Ultimately, it's up to the player as everyoner has different expectations for the game. Some people just like to level weird alts, some like to get 25ers and event, some like to get oad keys and form parties to gain more items, AND THEN some like to just run around pking which doesn't really help you in any of the three areas I just mentioned. Do some people really need to be told when to chill with the player killing? If you're over the age of 15, then you know right from wrong and you definitely know when too much is too much.

If the answer is yes, then I think having a timer where a certain player is immune to being PK'd for X amount of time after dying to another player outside of a duel is probably the best way to go, but maybe just give some people a chance to do the right thing, then if it's still an issue, handle up.

Edit: woulda replied sooner but i've gotta level g2g
NiteHawk
Very nice so far guys, I like the comments here. We'll see what we can do and I'll see what the best option is. It's hard to see what everyone will be 100% happy with but it does look like something should change.

When it comes to arena XP as well, what is a fair amount? It is currently 25% less experience in arenas, It was originally a lot lower, and obviously people leveled there and no one went outside when they realized because it was faster to kill one mob constantly and take the XP loss rather then go outside and have to move around and sometimes have 0 spawns outside when you kill super fast in a group of 5.

Should it be 15% perhaps? 10%? 20%? Maybe it could be based on how much kills in an arena per day? I.E You start off with 100% XP, but each mob you/your group kills in an arena drops the XP by 0.25% and then has a cap of 20%. Meaning you could go there to 'cool off' if a PKer is active for 20-30 minutes and then move out again without experiencing too much loss for that day.

Granted that could be slightly abusable if one person always takes the kill so it might have to be based on something else, but you get the drift.
Terron
as long as the gold is basically nothing and drop rates halved(null on special items) then arenas can be whatever exp. even 100% doesnt really matter. i just put almost 300m on a squire in under 7 hrs (and didnt choose the best div). i dont thing pking or exp rates matter, theres just no way you can get killed enough to not gain exp if you try. hit all the quests and stay killing. (ignore bitryn that place needs quest work)
Styx
Still think a pkers mask would be kewl, then makes pkwas identify be anonymous, have to wait till removed before entering a town, can add other interning effects that way, quest based so in order to gain the mask, ine muse kill a player for proof of killers mask.

Anonymous, so person identify us unknown

Penalty from the gods, you are unholy in killing a player. Must wait till the gods are back in your favor.

This way, no one knows who did it, other have chance to attack later.

Quest to add flavor, adds to pking in the game

Insert various other ideas

Ya i typoed a lot. It's late and tired.
Kruell
... have to wait till removed before entering a town...


We'd have to add in bypasses for the towns you have to go THROUGH though. Would suck to be stuck in Kakagi/Snailmint with no way to go to other areas. Almost as bad as being stuck in Karnath/Ant Hill
Terron
if u arent supposed to kill people there wouldnt be slayers ingame just pacifists and carebears. grow up, get out there and kill monsters. aw wait...u cant kill monsters thats horrible...log a carebear.
Lorelle
Seriously why is this even a thread?
Do you guys not remember the days being too scared to leave FM worried hammar blackblade wouldnone shot you?
Or more relivant Tyrargo hunting you across the map?
Come on PK is part of every good game, all you F1 macro bashers need to harden up. Bring back experience loss for deaths too
S0mveraa
Thought this was a place where we were supposed to throw out ideas, not blast people uselessly....en masse.
Kruell
...not blast people uselessly....en masse.

I heard that used to be the thing to do though.

Seriously why is this even a thread?

There has to be a ballance. There needs to be some kind of exp loss or else pking has no incentive. PKers can take it too far as well. I banned a couple people in RoK for abuse and I know several others who got banned for harassment. PKing isn't harassment, but people most often use PKing as a tool to harass someone. If you won't let someone leave town after killing them 4 or 5 times without taking a group of 5+ people to continue killing them AND you follow them into the arena and kill the monsters so they can't level... you are probably guilty of harassment. It was a huge problem in RoK and only a small problem here but people have a history of stuff like that. Every game has a Code of Conduct. Right now, Ember's is pretty bare bones. This discussion had to happen because the current system is unworkable and too open for issues.
Terron
arena harassment = banhammer. think that ones pretty self explanatory.

however, in ember right now, pking is barely a thing. and the minimal amount anyone actually pulls it off is hilarious. so people group up a few casters or slayers and go kill you. aww too bad. lets help them do it again and again by running to the EXACT same location and refuse to move because "they cant harass me forever"

at some point its not harassment people, you're just a fkin idiot. this is why you need to lose experience and take better effort in hiding or group exping. or go to an arena.
daedroth
arena harassment = banhammer. think that ones pretty self explanatory.

however, in ember right now, pking is barely a thing. and the minimal amount anyone actually pulls it off is hilarious. so people group up a few casters or slayers and go kill you. aww too bad. lets help them do it again and again by running to the EXACT same location and refuse to move because "they cant harass me forever"

at some point its not harassment people, you're just a fkin idiot. this is why you need to lose experience and take better effort in hiding or group exping. or go to an arena.


Well with the second point, I heard with the no exp loss to death there is no longer the 3 times killed in an hour limit, not sure if this is true or not. Is the 3 kills in an hour still in the ToS or not?
This needs to be verified in black and white to people because some people think it still exists and others don't and personally I cannot remember any mention of it being removed. This may be part of why people keep running back to the same spot "well they can only kill me three times and i'm not losing exp to death".
If it's not there anymore, and people know this, then yes there is an element of truth in what you say <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
I am happy there is no exp lose on death because I have a tendency of going afk in the wrong place at the wrong time, but it is also kind of sad that people still whine about being pk'd and there is all this drama, and sad that a no exp lose was introduced in the first place, the game loses something to me (although it would be nice for some penalty introduced to 25ths who fail or are pk'd).
Harassment is harassment though, that definitely needs stamping out.

How about a warning for new players that this is a pking game. I have already mentioned pk'ers getting some kind of notification they are away to attack a newbie (and others have mentioned other stuff along those lines).

I still remember getting pk'd in RoK, for me it actually added to the experience rather than detracted, but I guess we all be different eh.
Terron
i think the pk limit part was removed with experience loss.

however i think its a fair assessment that guilds invite members without ever telling new players the risks of joining a group with 75 enemies. truth is noone really pks, and they pk new people even less so. the only reason this is here is because noone knew who is who (noob from vet) at the start of this squire event.

periodically over the past year of no exp loss, chain pking rage fights would ensue, no complaints then. so why now? bullies got bullied back and out grinded.
JadeFalcon
I might be missing something, but i agree with piddy.

We dont need major overhauls to the pk system - what we need is a system that protects newbies.
Styx
Protect newbie

If an account does not have a level 25er, then no pk is enforced till account has lvl 25

Else xxx exp loss per nite hawk decision

Simple solutionright there ...