← Forum archive

Weapon/Armor Listing

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Drasp
I always wondered about this with RoK. Is there any way to make it so that one can view weapons and armor at the store to see what classes can equip said weapon prior to purchase? I suppose the eventual wiki update for all weapon listings would nullify this anyways, but just curious if there is a way to streamline it so that it is all in-client.
Aieron
There's something to be said against having everything well documented like that. It forces players to buy and test out items themselves.

Not sure which way I lean, but I do like self-exploration.
NiteHawk
Should at least be able to look over items and see what type it is. I think values can be hidden, and should be. 8)
Lateralus
I'm all for values being shown on items at the store and inventory as well as a /library system that allows you to search and items stats and info.

I don't think there's and reason to hide item stats from a playe. is it really player friendly for a player to have to buy and test out an item to see what it is or if they can even use it?

When you buy a computer at a store do you wanna know the specs or just buy it then test it out and then return it for half price of its not what you want?
Aieron
I'm all for values being shown on items at the store and inventory as well as a /library system that allows you to search and items stats and info.

I don't think there's and reason to hide item stats from a player. is it really player friendly for a player to have to buy and test out an item to see what it is or if they can even use it?

When you buy a computer at a store do you wanna know the specs or just buy it then test it out and then return it for half price of its not what you want?



While listing stats/power is far more convenient, it removes a layer of social interaction and breaks immersion. At best an armorsmith could give suggestions on what weapons/armor are best in a certain area, but they wouldn't know how it'd compare to something 2 towns over. I'd likely have it so NPCs/area lore guides a player to the next logical gear for them. This is more organic than having a masterlist of items with stats.
Lateralus
I'm all for values being shown on items at the store and inventory as well as a /library system that allows you to search and items stats and info.

I don't think there's and reason to hide item stats from a player. is it really player friendly for a player to have to buy and test out an item to see what it is or if they can even use it?

When you buy a computer at a store do you wanna know the specs or just buy it then test it out and then return it for half price of its not what you want?



While listing stats/power is far more convenient, it removes a layer of social interaction and breaks immersion. At best an armorsmith could give suggestions on what weapons/armor are best in a certain area, but they wouldn't know how it'd compare to something 2 towns over. I'd likely have it so NPCs/area lore guides a player to the next logical gear for them. This is more organic than having a masterlist of items with stats.


I mean I can see that but sooner or later these stats are going to be on the wiki or other websites so why have the extra steps for a player? Just thinking of most current games I dont really know of any that hide stats from players and take an extra step to make it more complicated.

That said it really doesn't bother me because I know where I can go to find these resources most new players I feel would expect these kind of player friendly features and would be confused why they arnt in.
Lateralus
I'm all for values being shown on items at the store and inventory as well as a /library system that allows you to search and items stats and info.

I don't think there's and reason to hide item stats from a player. is it really player friendly for a player to have to buy and test out an item to see what it is or if they can even use it?

When you buy a computer at a store do you wanna know the specs or just buy it then test it out and then return it for half price of its not what you want?



While listing stats/power is far more convenient, it removes a layer of social interaction and breaks immersion. At best an armorsmith could give suggestions on what weapons/armor are best in a certain area, but they wouldn't know how it'd compare to something 2 towns over. I'd likely have it so NPCs/area lore guides a player to the next logical gear for them. This is more organic than having a masterlist of items with stats.


I mean I can see that but sooner or later these stats are going to be on the wiki or other websites so why have the extra steps for a player? Just thinking of most current games I dont really know of any that hide stats from players and take an extra step to make it more complicated.

That said it really doesn't bother me because I know where I can go to find these resources most new players I feel would expect these kind of player friendly features and would be confused why they arnt in.
daedroth
Well, if you want immersion...
Think of old Diablo (first one), you killed creatures, the more you killed the more info you got on them. Could make items like that (and even the beasties <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" /> ), the more you use them the more info you get on them, although in this game its just really attack value... so after youve used it X amount of times you know how good it is compared to other items. I mean the player could do this... but, it can be annoying to some people (ive done this in the past, yeh, it gets annoying, esp, if your changing level mid test).

Othewrwise, I agree with Lat.
Aieron
I'm all for values being shown on items at the store and inventory as well as a /library system that allows you to search and items stats and info.

I don't think there's and reason to hide item stats from a player. is it really player friendly for a player to have to buy and test out an item to see what it is or if they can even use it?

When you buy a computer at a store do you wanna know the specs or just buy it then test it out and then return it for half price of its not what you want?



While listing stats/power is far more convenient, it removes a layer of social interaction and breaks immersion. At best an armorsmith could give suggestions on what weapons/armor are best in a certain area, but they wouldn't know how it'd compare to something 2 towns over. I'd likely have it so NPCs/area lore guides a player to the next logical gear for them. This is more organic than having a masterlist of items with stats.


I mean I can see that but sooner or later these stats are going to be on the wiki or other websites so why have the extra steps for a player? Just thinking of most current games I dont really know of any that hide stats from players and take an extra step to make it more complicated.

That said it really doesn't bother me because I know where I can go to find these resources most new players I feel would expect these kind of player friendly features and would be confused why they arnt in.


Let's list every monster eppd, ksb, lvl, and divinity too then since they'll be on a wiki anyways. Might as well start with the game fully mapped too since you can find maps on wikis eventually.

I know you want the game to be welcoming to new players, but you do that by making it fun/engaging/organic. I agree that sitting around attacking monsters with various weapons just to test damage levels isn't fun nor a good experience for new or old players alike. Players should be able to learn about monsters, items, areas, etc by researching the Academia or exploring and talking to players/NPCs.

I'd argue that most games now that offer stats on weapons/spells/etc do so because there is another level of complexity that requires that basic information to even get started. For instance, you see stats in games like Dark Souls because you have a character build / playstyle that changes based on gear. This isn't the case in the kind of game Ember is, imo.

That said, I'd enjoy a masterlist so that I can be lazy and put less effort in. ^.^
Lateralus
I don't think that should all be available but really? Players just waste gold then find out they can't even equip an item? Sorry it's just bad design imo. It would be one thing if you could get a full refund but atm you get about half back.

Sit back and take a look at the game. It's an added complexity for what? Make it more difficult because things should be hard? I know you have to draw the line somewhere but there's a reason successful games are successful and I don't know of any that hide details like this for the sake of making things harder on a player. Tell me a good successful game that does this that enhances the player experience and I'll listen. until then this is just an old Rok system that gives vets an advantage and is uninviting to new players.
daedroth
No matter what happens a person should know if they can equip something or not (although I think Nitehawk mentioned this will be implemented, right click examin on an item before you buy). I am fairly sure a sorcerer would know "theres no point me buying that sword, boy it sure is pretty but id probably hurt myself more than the enemy. As for that suit of full plate armour, sure is shiney and what great protection, shame I wouldnt be able to cast anything while wearing it, how the hell do you put it on anyway?".
I still think after using an item enough you will be able to judge how good it is, simply through use (probably a pain to implement, itd be kind of like the old rok weapon master system - but account linked for convenience? Not realistic, but what a nightmare it would be to keep track of for each character on the account, lets just assume their all friends or at least share information with each other).
You would be able to hold the weapon, a few practise swings, "ok this sword is balanced, its bloody sharp... looks durable, made from that new metal thats meant to be far more durable than steel".
Same with monsters, but it should not be complete information. You would start to know, "ok that creature does not like fire, that creature can take around 4 hits from my sword, its hard to hit, hits hard..." hard to do this without numbers since different characters will have different stats/levels/divs. Be a bitch to implement me thinks.
Ive lost my train of though... kids, gotta love em.
Too much information, too little... GL guys!
Aieron
I don't think that should all be available but really? Players just waste gold then find out they can't even equip an item? Sorry it's just bad design imo. It would be one thing if you could get a full refund but atm you get about half back.

Sit back and take a look at the game. It's an added complexity for what? Make it more difficult because things should be hard? I know you have to draw the line somewhere but there's a reason successful games are successful and I don't know of any that hide details like this for the sake of making things harder on a player. Tell me a good successful game that does this that enhances the player experience and I'll listen. until then this is just an old Rok system that gives vets an advantage and is uninviting to new players.


Woah, I was talking weapon/item power not whether they can/can't equip it. I agree saying what armor type things are is important.

Added complexity? You mean having a player told by an NPC that the forest nearby has a hidden legendary sword? Encouraging them to explore and play while also intuitively suggesting that the sword is better than that town's storebought?! I'm in NO WAY suggesting to make it 'complex'. I'm saying it can be built to be intuitive/organic. Ideal World, players don't need to know exact weapon values that a builder puts in. The weapon's power should be apparent by how/where it was found in the World.

As for claiming that it's an old RoK adage, A LOT of games are reverting to the core philosophy that players need to spend time in game to gain knowledge about core gameplay mechanics. They are even gating it behind character progression so that wikis can't let players bypass this step. (Chronicles of Elyria). It doesn't benefit vets more than new players if the information is presented properly in game. In RoK it benefited vets because we had to test weapons by hitting things for hours. I'm not suggesting we do this. In fact, I'm vehemently against how RoK was with regards to figuring out weapon strengths, monster divs, etc.
daedroth
Either way peeps, lets sit back and drink some tea, take breaths and count to ten <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Drasp
I feel like the item information and if it could be equipped should be shown. I'm not sure I care if a weapon's attack power or armor's AP should be shown. On RoK, I tried to never check out an online listing for weapon power, instead I always just wanted to discover things for myself. That being said, for those just starting out the game, having guidance on what to buy would be solid. You could have NPC shopkeepers in the stores of Seamoor that could have scripts to guide the player a little.

If we decided that it is realllllly desired to have some form of weapon level involved, then there is always the idea to add level restrictions to certain weapons
NiteHawk
I added a simple weapon or armor type on examine now (I.E. This is heavy armor.), you can also examine items in stores now by rick clicking the button and clicking examine.
Lateralus
@Keith I guess as long as it's possible for the player to know if the item is useful for them in some way it's all good. Roks system of buy then test to find out, lookup on wiki or know because you are a vet wasn't good imo.

If your suggesting there is some npc that can somehow know what a player is using and make suggestions on what they can buy that would be great and a very cool feature. As a player I pop over to wiki and look what to buy next so it sounds like added complexity on the code and build side over just showing the stats and difference (compare your equipped to shop item) but it would be more immersive.

what would you suggest for when a player gets a dropped item and they need to make a choice if they wanna equip it and bind it to themselves to test if it's any good for them? Maybe use the academia to research and there it could show stats?
Drasp
In my mind, I was thinking you could have script triggered by simply saying your class at the first weapons/armor shop. Armorer could just say something like "What class are you?" then "Ahh, a knight you say? Always in the heat of battle, your kind. For you, I would recommend blah blah."