Necromancer/Death Mage
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I understand where you are coming from Reaper and I do agree. That being said, I think sap should be baseline anyways for both casters. I agree that Necromancers do need something though, but definitely not in the form of an upgraded pet. The blind just for -2 agi might be nice if it could last as long as sap maybe? I've always been under the idea that necromancer or death type mages are damgae over time classes. Would there be a way to put in a decent dmg fast DoT spell? Like X dmg over 2 rounds total? Maybe you could change blind to have a 50% miss chance instead? I do agree the heal is much too low though, half would be an increase.
However, it could perhaps be that other classes need nerfed to be brought in line. I still don't understand why Monks get super high MR, an extra attack, extra natural armor, extra base dmg, an extra +2 agi effectivenss(I think I read that?), AND they can pretty much always get a +1 stat with no penalty. I guess it seems like the check for characters viability is "Can it beat a monk? If not, then what CAN?" Probably why most ppl are playing monk ^_^.
What kind of ideas for spells did you have in mind, NiteHawk?
However, it could perhaps be that other classes need nerfed to be brought in line. I still don't understand why Monks get super high MR, an extra attack, extra natural armor, extra base dmg, an extra +2 agi effectivenss(I think I read that?), AND they can pretty much always get a +1 stat with no penalty. I guess it seems like the check for characters viability is "Can it beat a monk? If not, then what CAN?" Probably why most ppl are playing monk ^_^.
What kind of ideas for spells did you have in mind, NiteHawk?
I have a few suggestions to make the necro a little better.
Overall- I think the heal needs to be increased. I'm not suggesting it be OP or anything, but right now it is very marginal. It's ok for mobs but for pvp its not very good. I think it should be around 50% of the damage.
Utility- we really don't have much
Rot - this is an ok skill
Blind- this is almost worthless for pvp as it is completely negated by simply moving. If this spell was changed to last a finite amount of time it would make the necro useful. For instance you would be blind and have -agi for like 5 seconds.
Its really the lack of utility that kills us. I get that we are a slightly tougher but less damage sorc, I'm good with that. Yet, we need something. I think adjusting blind would do wonders for our viability.
Another idea I had is removing sap from the sorcs and giving it to necros. Right now sorcs have airwalk, invis, Ming, enchant, sap. If sap were changed to the necro class it would make sorcs the buffers and the necros the debuffer. This gives us more party viability, also it makes sense.
Anyways just my opinion/ suggestions and ideas.
Blind does give you negative AGI. It can't really make misses without modifying the game hugely. If it gave more AGI loss it would have to be for a 'very' short period.
There is an issue because everyone is running around though with monks. Monks vs spell casters is the weakness in all honesty (every class has its strength and weak classes to fight against, though monks need some work.). Pre-crash when people were actually testing, necros were a bit of a worry because they were actually really good at staying alive. We had the heal higher, but it ended up making the class not killable when they healed. I can see about raising it a little though in the near future. 50% would be too high though.
I can't give you spell listings just yet for nercos though. But defo don't base it off fighting monks. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" /> I don't think they should necessarily have the same utility spells though. They should be different.
Yeah I understand wanting their spells to be different. I was just thinking about it more like a "All healers get Curel and Ray" type of deal XD but I guess the same could be said for stoneskin and beam. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> What about this as an idea? Instead of Stoneskin give them BONE ARMOR which is similar but can deal dmg when attacked? Think "Thorns" concept. So for instance for every attack or spell they land they could take like 50 dmg? Would that be too crazy? XD. Guess that doesn't really up their survivability much though. Don't Necros have a DoT spell right now? Or better yet...why not give them a DOT LEECH on top of leech? Even if it was small. Like leeching 50 hp -once- per round and deal 50 dmg(obviously), one time cast, but only lasts X rounds? That way you could up their survivability and be able to tune the numbers to keep them in line. It'd give them a little boost of heal/dmg/survivability without changing LEECH to do more dmg or heal. Sorcs are supposed to be more dmg, less survivability right? And necros leech is the middle of the pack dmg, between beam and blast right? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
I'm fine with what blind does. The problem is that way that it works makes it borderline useless. If I cast blind on someone they get their agi back instantly just by moving one square and back. I think it should last for a certain amount of time and not disappear by moving.
I think their survivability would be fine with a small boost to leech healing. I'm not upset about their damage or even their survivability. The problem is they have no useful utility with the way blind currently works.
To put it bluntly why would anyone want a necro in their party? They just need something to give them some type of usefulness in the game other than just to themselves. For a party there is nothing a sorc with a health pot can't do better.
If they fixed blind though, that gives them something at least.
To put it bluntly why would anyone want a necro in their party? They just need something to give them some type of usefulness in the game other than just to themselves. For a party there is nothing a sorc with a health pot can't do better.
If they fixed blind though, that gives them something at least.
I'm fine with what blind does. The problem is that way that it works makes it borderline useless. If I cast blind on someone they get their agi back instantly just by moving one square and back. I think it should last for a certain amount of time and not disappear by moving.
Huh? The agi loss or blind doesn't vanish when moving. It can also last longer depending on the class it's shot on. I believe on high wisdom it could be a few rounds before it removes. It's -2 agi already too.
The idea for BLIND on top of the AGI LOSS is also if the people rely on their map as well, (which honestly 90% of people use the minimap like mad) they will get really confused, and it's often easier to PK them since they don't know directions or where they are at. People will generally panic, and they don't know if you are on the square or not with them. So they'll have to either attempt to run by memory, or spam attack hoping things land.
More WIS means harder changes to penetrate, but when it does, it lasts longer. This goes for any negative spell, sort of like how ROK was, but only negative spells.
I modified the heal amount to be a different leech percentage now. Instead of /4. It is between /3 and /4. So the min is the same, but the max can be higher. I'm not sure how this will play out yet.
Interesting. So it sounds like blind does or is supposed to do exactly what I'm asking for. I tested it with someone last night and he said when he moved a square and back his agi instantly returned to normal, even when I cast it less than a second before. Either something is wrong or i was being trolled...haha If blind actually works like you said then necros are fine and I retract my previous posts lol.
Interesting. So it sounds like blind does or is supposed to do exactly what I'm asking for. I tested it with someone last night and he said when he moved a square and back his agi instantly returned to normal, even when I cast it less than a second before. Either something is wrong or i was being trolled...haha If blind actually works like you said then necros are fine and I retract my previous posts lol.
Cast it on yourself and test? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
If they are half orcs and you are a lower level, the actual round rate won't be so much though, for example.
LMFAO. I didn't know Blind blacked out the map. That is hysterical. I love you NiteHawk. *presents ring*
LMFAO. I didn't know Blind blacked out the map. That is hysterical. I love you NiteHawk. *presents ring*
It's a good way to stomp people who use the map/directional in any case without knowing their area. Can be a scary spell.
If they are half orcs and you are a lower level, the actual round rate won't be so much though, for example.
Ah, does that mean that spells affect half orcs as they did in old rok (as in, good or bad they do not last as long, and I guess that will affect dwarfs as well - as in it is linked to their regen rates)?
If they are half orcs and you are a lower level, the actual round rate won't be so much though, for example.
Ah, does that mean that spells affect half orcs as they did in old rok (as in, good or bad they do not last as long, and I guess that will affect dwarfs as well - as in it is linked to their regen rates)?
Good spells do not get reduced rates.
Bad spells do. The duration on low wisdom characters is lower. It will impact high wisdom characters a good deal more. Specially spells like BLIND and the like. Wisdom is typically a blessing and a curse. I'd say it's better to take more though over less. But having low wisdom could be good in different situations.
Ah ok, cheers.
I still think we need a healing boost from leech. I know you said you buffed it a small amount but it feels like I'm healing for less now.
This is against neutral div. I am an Elf with 22 int.
____________________________________________________________________________________
You cast leech at a risen, but she is unaffected!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
You cast leech at a risen for 103 points of damage!
You leeched 25 hit points!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
You cast leech at a risen for 132 points of damage!
You leeched 44 hit points!
You are too exhausted.
You are too exhausted.
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
>>> Sage <<<: onyx plate and helm
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
You cast leech at a risen, but she is unaffected!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
You cast leech at a risen for 115 points of damage!
You leeched 28 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen, but she is unaffected!
You cast leech at a risen for 115 points of damage!
You leeched 28 hit points!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 90 points of damage!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 134 points of damage!
You cast leech at a risen for 103 points of damage!
You leeched 25 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen for 110 points of damage!
You leeched 27 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen for 115 points of damage!
You leeched 28 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen for 127 points of damage!
You leeched 42 hit points!
__________________________________________________________________
On average I'm being healed for under 30hp a hit on neutral div at lvl 25. This seems a little low to me, we already get some relatively bad damage. I'm not even pushing for a damage buff though. We get a heal with our damage and it should be lower than a sorcs for sure. I just wish the heal was a little more useful. In PVP against a class with moderate MR I may land 1 or 2 hits a round. So if the stars align perfectly I may get 88 health back. More realistically, I will prob get 50 or so assuming I hit twice. It really makes Death Mages pretty weak in comparison to the other classes.
_________________________________________________________________________________
Just for testing and reference this is me having div on the mob
____________________________________________________________________________________
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger for 156 points of damage!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 116 points of damage!
You leeched 38 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 130 points of damage!
You leeched 43 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger for 182 points of damage!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 144 points of damage!
You leeched 48 hit points!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger and misses!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 123 points of damage!
You leeched 30 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 136 points of damage!
You leeched 34 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 150 points of damage!
You leeched 37 hit points!
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger and misses!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 130 points of damage!
You leeched 43 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 144 points of damage!
You leeched 48 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
_____________________________________________________
This is me against div
__________________________________________________
You cast leech at a bone archer, but he is unaffected!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 80 points of damage!
You leeched 20 hit points!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 99 points of damage!
You leeched 24 hit points!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 87 points of damage!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 108 points of damage!
You leeched 36 hit points!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 103 points of damage!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 97 points of damage!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 94 points of damage!
You leeched 23 hit points!
You cast leech at a bone archer, but he is unaffected!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 103 points of damage!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 103 points of damage!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 80 points of damage!
You leeched 20 hit points!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 90 points of damage!
You leeched 30 hit points!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 90 points of damage!
You leeched 22 hit points!
This is against neutral div. I am an Elf with 22 int.
____________________________________________________________________________________
You cast leech at a risen, but she is unaffected!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
You cast leech at a risen for 103 points of damage!
You leeched 25 hit points!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
You cast leech at a risen for 132 points of damage!
You leeched 44 hit points!
You are too exhausted.
You are too exhausted.
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
>>> Sage <<<: onyx plate and helm
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
You cast leech at a risen, but she is unaffected!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff and misses!
You cast leech at a risen for 115 points of damage!
You leeched 28 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen, but she is unaffected!
You cast leech at a risen for 115 points of damage!
You leeched 28 hit points!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 90 points of damage!
A risen attacks you with her bone staff, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 134 points of damage!
You cast leech at a risen for 103 points of damage!
You leeched 25 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen for 110 points of damage!
You leeched 27 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen for 115 points of damage!
You leeched 28 hit points!
You cast leech at a risen for 127 points of damage!
You leeched 42 hit points!
__________________________________________________________________
On average I'm being healed for under 30hp a hit on neutral div at lvl 25. This seems a little low to me, we already get some relatively bad damage. I'm not even pushing for a damage buff though. We get a heal with our damage and it should be lower than a sorcs for sure. I just wish the heal was a little more useful. In PVP against a class with moderate MR I may land 1 or 2 hits a round. So if the stars align perfectly I may get 88 health back. More realistically, I will prob get 50 or so assuming I hit twice. It really makes Death Mages pretty weak in comparison to the other classes.
_________________________________________________________________________________
Just for testing and reference this is me having div on the mob
____________________________________________________________________________________
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger for 156 points of damage!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 116 points of damage!
You leeched 38 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 130 points of damage!
You leeched 43 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger for 182 points of damage!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 144 points of damage!
You leeched 48 hit points!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger and misses!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 123 points of damage!
You leeched 30 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 136 points of damage!
You leeched 34 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 150 points of damage!
You leeched 37 hit points!
A rotting dead attacks you with his bone dagger and misses!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 130 points of damage!
You leeched 43 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead for 144 points of damage!
You leeched 48 hit points!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
You cast leech at a rotting dead, but he is unaffected!
_____________________________________________________
This is me against div
__________________________________________________
You cast leech at a bone archer, but he is unaffected!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 80 points of damage!
You leeched 20 hit points!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 99 points of damage!
You leeched 24 hit points!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 87 points of damage!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 108 points of damage!
You leeched 36 hit points!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 103 points of damage!
You attempt to cast a spell, but it fizzles out!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 97 points of damage!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 94 points of damage!
You leeched 23 hit points!
You cast leech at a bone archer, but he is unaffected!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 103 points of damage!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 103 points of damage!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 80 points of damage!
You leeched 20 hit points!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 90 points of damage!
You leeched 30 hit points!
You cast leech at a bone archer for 90 points of damage!
You leeched 22 hit points!
Overall my issue is do you think leech is meant to be something you heal all the time with, and being unable to kill? You should still have to use potions. Basing this off level 25 you will be healing an average of probably 160 per round. I don't think you see the reality of being able to deal 130-140 average damage and also heal for about 160 per round. It's about two cures worth of healing per round. That means in PVP at level 25 you will pretty much mop up non-wisdom players (which is ok) because you are both getting healed and damaging at the same time. It might not sound like alot, but an average of 3-5 round battles is going to be 480 to 800 healed on you... Mopping them up is okay, but being fully healed throughout the whole situation is not. It makes me wonder if it was raised, it would be far too op. You are going to be running around with necromancers that can't die in a general situation.
Not to be a dink, but fighting against div to me is a goofy thing to do, and that data can often be ignored unless there is some flaw with it. You should be aiming to fight with div at least in PVE.
This is not saying that they don't need more different spells. I think they could do with some other spells though.
Not to be a dink, but fighting against div to me is a goofy thing to do, and that data can often be ignored unless there is some flaw with it. You should be aiming to fight with div at least in PVE.
This is not saying that they don't need more different spells. I think they could do with some other spells though.
I don't think they need a buff to their max heal. I think they need a buff to the min is what I was trying to get at. I in no way want to be OP or dominate all other classes. I just felt from playing a death mage that getting heals in the 20's against neutral div was a bit lackluster.
In pvp though unless they have 0 mr i certainly don't get 160 hp back. I might get that if its against div with 0 mr or a super lucky round with no unaffects or fizzles and good rolls on the heal.
Despite what my urging may sound like, I am not unhappy with death mages as they are. This is just my observations from playing one.
If you feel that they are ok how they are and working as intended I wont argue the point. Also more spells in the future would be awesome.
In pvp though unless they have 0 mr i certainly don't get 160 hp back. I might get that if its against div with 0 mr or a super lucky round with no unaffects or fizzles and good rolls on the heal.
Despite what my urging may sound like, I am not unhappy with death mages as they are. This is just my observations from playing one.
If you feel that they are ok how they are and working as intended I wont argue the point. Also more spells in the future would be awesome.
I don't think they need a buff to their max heal. I think they need a buff to the min is what I was trying to get at. I in no way want to be OP or dominate all other classes. I just felt from playing a death mage that getting heals in the 20's against neutral div was a bit lackluster.
In pvp though unless they have 0 mr i certainly don't get 160 hp back. I might get that if its against div with 0 mr or a super lucky round with no unaffects or fizzles and good rolls on the heal.
Despite what my urging may sound like, I am not unhappy with death mages as they are. This is just my observations from playing one.
If you feel that they are ok how they are and working as intended I wont argue the point.
Mm right now it's based on a percent of the damage you do. I can understand increasing the min a little but I'm trying to think if it's easily possibly. I understand what you mean though in general.
What about this? Instead of leech always stealing life, give it a % chance albeit large(50%) to STEAL the amount done from the target. That is VERY death mage like mechanic and would feel AWESOME when you do get it. You can change the message to something other than the regular leech message. It would make death mages feel great!
I've gave a new spell called wither.
It does two things.
1. Increases spell damage by a set 5-12 at level 25. Depends on intelligence. You'll be your own and other spell casters best friend.
2. Decreases armor. The more base AC (not including spells) the user has, the more AC he will lose. The loss is dependent on intelligence as well, and does stack with FF. I might need to tweak FF or this spell though. It's not a huge loss though regardless.
The spell damage boost does help too, as it increases your overall leech rates too, etc. Has the same toughness to break through their resistance as a debuff spell like FF or sap however.
It does two things.
1. Increases spell damage by a set 5-12 at level 25. Depends on intelligence. You'll be your own and other spell casters best friend.
2. Decreases armor. The more base AC (not including spells) the user has, the more AC he will lose. The loss is dependent on intelligence as well, and does stack with FF. I might need to tweak FF or this spell though. It's not a huge loss though regardless.
The spell damage boost does help too, as it increases your overall leech rates too, etc. Has the same toughness to break through their resistance as a debuff spell like FF or sap however.