← Forum archive

Clerics and Armor

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
This has been something discussed apparently by alot of people in the background.

People are claiming clerics should only be able to use medium armor. Not just for a lore fact, but simply because they are a bit overpowered and the solution I feel isn't to nerf the HP a big deal.

What do people think about this? I understand it's a scary change, but I'm not changing anything yet. I'd like to know opinions on it, and what can be done that doesn't break how the game currently is. I don't want to see things like 'add a healing delay per' because it makes no sense in this sort of game.

But I am interested to know peoples take on this.

3 Day poll.
NiteHawk
To be upfront about it, what you'd lose is aabout 20-30 armor, Which is about 3-4 passive damage negation, and then also probably 8-12.5% deflection.

I say 8-12.5% because we don't have any OAD gear yet, so the difference is going to be less right now. It's probably more at 8% if we were to adjust at this time, but in the future with gear would be around 12.5%.
Folder
Kinda torn because if you're currently playing a priest this would suck for you, but the thing is they are very very strong still. When you see a priest in a mosh it's like welp game over unless priest is killed early by focus fire. Certainly that's a viable tactic and that should be part of the game, but I'm not so sure it's good that a priest can probably sit there and heal through 3 people spamming attacks on them. Obviously lucky backstabs kill them or if you manage to run them oom they can die.

Would like to hear what Kis and other priests have to say though <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />.
Satsujin
I agree that clerics should lose access to heavy armor. As they are now, they have the strongest healing spells, as well as access to the best AC, and all they lose out on is melee damage that's easily made up with magic damage given the lack of magic resistance a lot of race/class combos have. And they're currently the class to beat in PvP, since you have to run them completely dry on mana or limit their heals for them to die.

Lore wise (yes, I know, most people are sick of seeing me use the word lore lol), clerics shouldn't be front line fighters, like they would be in heavy armor. They're very much a support class, and should be equipped like one.
Thi
This is going to be a tricky one, be careful that on PVP Clerics/Priests are the FIRST target ever on any occasion, meaning they always get the short end of the stick and if you make them squishy they won't be fun at all, "be target, heal 4 times, use potion, wait 10 seconds, die.".

I don't really think we should be removing/changing their armor without proper testing/calculation on it, my take on it is, put 2 groups 6v6 and make them fight each other on more or so even odds, let's see how long a priest survives under that situation, then we might know if it requires balancing or not.

The examples of "survivability" we have are based on 10v6 where the 10 had a priest and she never died, of course she didn't cause the other 9 murdered quick enough or were winding down the enemy numbers too quickly, that's what I've seen on the moshes and fights I've witnessed.
Honzo
I honestly think they should wear LIGHT armor. Medium armor is still chain mail and stuff like that. I don't think I've seen many priests walking around in that. Usually ROBES haha. And Light helmet. You could give them an armor buff then kind of like stoneskin? Could call it Blessing of Protection or just "Protection"
NiteHawk
I honestly think they should wear LIGHT armor. Medium armor is still chain mail and stuff like that. I don't think I've seen many priests walking around in that. Usually ROBES haha. And Light helmet. You could give them an armor buff then kind of like stoneskin? Could call it Blessing of Protection or just "Protection"

If it was to be light armor, yeah I could see something like light armor and then also a spell to increase AC on top of that. Self buff spell.

Would give another class that actually uses light armor too.
Thi
I honestly think they should wear LIGHT armor. Medium armor is still chain mail and stuff like that. I don't think I've seen many priests walking around in that. Usually ROBES haha. And Light helmet. You could give them an armor buff then kind of like stoneskin? Could call it Blessing of Protection or just "Protection"

If it was to be light armor, yeah I could see something like light armor and then also a spell to increase AC on top of that. Self buff spell.

Would give another class that actually uses light armor too.

Maybe to not overlap with stoneskin, you might wanna consider a passive skill that increases armor, that would be awesome, sort of like an aura, I'd still be careful with the overall total armor, dropping it might make then hard to play pvp wise since they are first targets in any fight and being squishy will make fights too quick and too boring, I kinda like fights that last more than 3 rounds.
NiteHawk
I honestly think they should wear LIGHT armor. Medium armor is still chain mail and stuff like that. I don't think I've seen many priests walking around in that. Usually ROBES haha. And Light helmet. You could give them an armor buff then kind of like stoneskin? Could call it Blessing of Protection or just "Protection"

If it was to be light armor, yeah I could see something like light armor and then also a spell to increase AC on top of that. Self buff spell.

Would give another class that actually uses light armor too.

Maybe to not overlap with stoneskin, you might wanna consider a passive skill that increases armor, that would be awesome, sort of like an aura, I'd still be careful with the overall total armor, dropping it might make then hard to play pvp wise since they are first targets in any fight and being squishy will make fights too quick and too boring, I kinda like fights that last more than 3 rounds.


Well no I would base it around medium armor I think, but have them use light.

It could simply be like ninjas armor is really. Passive. I don't think lowering the AC to 70 or 80 will effect that fights too much though.
roxxgui
I dont know, i dont believe they are this hard to kill honestly , i get focused very fast on moshes and die relatively quick when dodge fails or when div isnt favorable.
And i dont know how it will happen but will i lose all enchants, blesses and soulbound i used on my heavy armor and farm another medium one?

I dont like big changes on classes but thats just my opinion.
Kismet
Noooo, what's going to happen to my onyx plate and dope AC if everyone outvotes against heavy armor!?

Just kidding. Not that I care that much for a reason I'm about to mention.

For RP purposes I'm actually not against clerics wearing robes as long as they get something nifty to compensate. Say, a new spell?

Suggestion: Aegis. "You feel an aura of divine guidance!"
Perhaps make it increase damage absorption or increase block rate with shields? Also, I think it would be more fair if the buff is more effective when cast on the self, or maybe other clerics or paladins since they are poor fellow clergymen/women who already suffer a /protect penalty.

Anyways, it's my final two cents. Probably. *Disappears into otherworldly realms.*
Lateralus
I honestly think they should wear LIGHT armor. Medium armor is still chain mail and stuff like that. I don't think I've seen many priests walking around in that. Usually ROBES haha. And Light helmet. You could give them an armor buff then kind of like stoneskin? Could call it Blessing of Protection or just "Protection"


Yea I know I am a bit late and not sure how I missed this but this is how it works in most games and how I think it should work here. No reason for them to have 3x the healing of other classes and the top ac. As you can see they are pretty much unkillable. They should be glass healing cannons like mages are glass damage cannons imo
Folder
I don't really think they should be glass per se, but somewhere in between glass and unstoppable healing machine would be good <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />. Light armor + self buff sounds up to the equivalent of about medium armor seems good to me. Also fits thematically, and an added bonus is another light armor class.
Honzo
I don't really think they should be glass per se, but somewhere in between glass and unstoppable healing machine would be good <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />. Light armor + self buff sounds up to the equivalent of about medium armor seems good to me. Also fits thematically, and an added bonus is another light armor class.



Yea I know I am a bit late and not sure how I missed this but this is how it works in most games and how I think it should work here. No reason for them to have 3x the healing of other classes and the top ac. As you can see they are pretty much unkillable. They should be glass healing cannons like mages are glass damage cannons imo


I agree with both of yall on this. Just nerfing them to light, then giving them a badass buff to put them in between medium and ungodly seems perfect! Priests or the typical cleric class always has some kind of meaningful buff and it just seems to fit the character right. Not just with the Priest but all of the classes seem to be coming together really well. There has been so much discussion and thought put in to this stuff. I'm proud of everyone, not that it means much, but this is no easy endeavour! GJ to everyone who put in ideas, testing, and of course builders! Without NH though this wouldn't have ever happened! Thanks again for working so hard dude. Seriously. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Styx
A cleric is a healer, I don't know many surgeons who wear full battle armor while performing surgery lol

But I can see the cleric gaining extra blessing from his or her God for more of something else

But I'd go with cloth armor and use a spell of God's protection for enemies, so armor would be same
Mujahideen
A cleric is a healer, I don't know many surgeons who wear full battle armor while performing surgery lol

But I can see the cleric gaining extra blessing from his or her God for more of something else

But I'd go with cloth armor and use a spell of God's protection for enemies, so armor would be same


I agree, I think it should be cloth but they should have a pretty long buffer spell for extra AC that they can only cast on themselves.
Honzo
Good news guys, it's already in the game!! Go try it out!! <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Lateralus
A cleric is a healer, I don't know many surgeons who wear full battle armor while performing surgery lol

But I can see the cleric gaining extra blessing from his or her God for more of something else

But I'd go with cloth armor and use a spell of God's protection for enemies, so armor would be same


I agree, I think it should be cloth but they should have a pretty long buffer spell for extra AC that they can only cast on themselves.


Ended up going with light instead of cloth (may not fit rp wise atleast how other games do it). Kind of did it to give a little more usefulness to light (only monks wear). but yea otherwise thats the idea a small buffer brings their light up to medium amounts i believe
NiteHawk
Yeah they needed some armor removal. They too strong otherwise. In future though if it's too low we simply add more AC to aegis.
roxxgui
Eh i really dont understand the process of this, people voted to keep it as it is.

My armor is just unusable now , money and time wasted i guess. I created a cleric to be like in D&D a heavy armored class, with a shield, that deals low damage and heals.

This change is pretty lame in MY OPINION, guess ill have fun with some other class if i gather the patience to level it....or stop playing in worst case cenario.
It was fun while it lasted.