← Forum archive

Making Bards Better

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
I think bards are kind of shortchanged. Let's fix that.

Bards have five spells.
Power - Gives them strength (4-5)
Int - Grants them intelligence. (1-2)
Absorb - Grants them spell damage reduction. (10-15%)
Armor - Grants them armor (20-25?)
HP - Grants HP per tick.

I think that the songs are fine but they are too separate. What I propose is>
Power - Grants strength and intelligence (3-4 str, and 1int plus maybe 5 spell damage).
Absorb - Grants them armor and spell damage reduction (same as above just mixed).
Speed - (NEW) Grants everyone 1 AGI and -1 second off their exhaust timer...
HP - Grants HP per tick, more out of combat.


HP would be unique. Let's say it grants 40-50 HP per tick to all members (seem ok?). Then out of combat you would get x3 that, so 120-150HP per tick. Or maybe even x4.

The reason why power grants less strength is because I want to make it so sorcs POWER spell is stacklable with this, thus making both useful in any situation. I would also lower the power spell on sorcs to 2-3.

The speed one might be too strong and not needed. I might ignore that one. There is an issue with that cause of druids haste. It would mean with haste and that, you attack 2 seconds faster per round. While that doesn't sound like alot, well, it's alot, specially if your are a healer. So I think Either ignore that, or reduce it to something like 0.5 seconds, or just plain give +2 agi instead. Could also give something like 0.25 seconds, which isn't alot but it would help ensure your party is always attacking first in most cases.

The above changes might be too strong, feel free to comment on everything.



-------


The final thing I want to add is that spells are effected by instrument and charisma. They both need to be good to get the values above. How should we line this up? Right now it's about half and half. But maybe charisma should be more important (75% charisma/25% instrument?)


Maybe instrument instead could boost overall MP, back up to normal levels, or do other things. (I.E. You start with 0.5x manapool, with a level 25 instrument you'll be at around 1x mana). What do you guys think?
Kawasaki
I think the remixed songs would make it a lot easier to pick which song to play, right now its hard to decide if I want to play str or int, all depending on who is in the party.

I would love the amount of healing to go up to at least 30-40HP per tick so that sounds like a good change as well, I think making it x3 or x4 out of combat might make it so that you don't need potions or a dedicated healer as much so maybe only x2 with that option.

I would like the position of the bard hideout to be moved as well, right now to get your instrument at level 8 you have to run through areas that are designed for much higher areas, but for rangers to get their bows/arrows they just have to walk down to canopia where they are already heading to start leveling up.
NiteHawk
I think the remixed songs would make it a lot easier to pick which song to play, right now its hard to decide if I want to play str or int, all depending on who is in the party.

I would love the amount of healing to go up to at least 30-40HP per tick so that sounds like a good change as well, I think making it x3 or x4 out of combat might make it so that you don't need potions or a dedicated healer as much so maybe only x2 with that option.

I would like the position of the bard hideout to be moved as well, right now to get your instrument at level 8 you have to run through areas that are designed for much higher areas, but for rangers to get their bows/arrows they just have to walk down to canopia where they are already heading to start leveling up.


Pretty sure the instruments there are higher level though. I mean I can move it but then we cant expect all hideouts to be in the canpoia area.

I agree with the healing, maybe x2 is enough.
Kawasaki

Pretty sure the instruments there are higher level though. I mean I can move it but then we cant expect all hideouts to be in the canpoia area.

I agree with the healing, maybe x2 is enough.


I was thinking closer to Bitryn instead of all the way up near Turenyara.

i got my 8 instrument in canopia
I never checked the store I figured I had to get it at the hideout, I will check the other stores and see if they are there as well if they are I will remove my complaint about the location <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
NiteHawk

Pretty sure the instruments there are higher level though. I mean I can move it but then we cant expect all hideouts to be in the canpoia area.

I agree with the healing, maybe x2 is enough.


I was thinking closer to Bitryn instead of all the way up near Turenyara.

i got my 8 instrument in canopia
I never checked the store I figured I had to get it at the hideout, I will check the other stores and see if they are there as well if they are I will remove my complaint about the location <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />



Yes all stores should have instruments.
Folder
New songs sound great. I'd suggest ditching the -exhaust timer part of speed and make it +2 agi (possible would need to be nerfed to +1 if it's too strong). People will love bards.

Also please only x2 out of combat healing, as Dustin said it would mean they can level for pretty much free if it were higher.

How long are the ticks for healing? 40-50 sounds ok but I'm not sure of the tick rate.
Thi
I'd say leave Bards gimped so Dustin has a harder time leveling, but that's just a personal bias. <3

Never paid much attention to bards so I can't help you there.
Kawasaki
I'd say leave Bards gimped so Dustin has a harder time leveling, but that's just a personal bias. <3

Never paid much attention to bards so I can't help you there.


I love you too Thi...
NiteHawk
New songs sound great. I'd suggest ditching the -exhaust timer part of speed and make it +2 agi (possible would need to be nerfed to +1 if it's too strong). People will love bards.

Also please only x2 out of combat healing, as Dustin said it would mean they can level for pretty much free if it were higher.

How long are the ticks for healing? 40-50 sounds ok but I'm not sure of the tick rate.


5s.
Fluffy
I feel it would make more sense if they were grouped differently, Let me know what you think

Int/Wis

Str/ << not sure what to pair this with unless you put agi here and took out attack delay.

Agi/ -attack delay

Hp/armor

Hp Regen/ small mp regen

Would allow you to focus on what you wanted to buff in parties and help regen in the downtime . I feel this would help bring Bards more in line with other classes and make them a more desired class for parties.
Folder
To me the idea of buffing int/str is that you're doing a damage boost regardless of who is in the party. Also buffing wis and druids = ?

I'm not much of a fan of the exhaust delay because this is druid's signature thing, and stacking them would be pretty crazy.
Honzo
I was hoping you'd go a different direction myself. Putting the Strength buff with Armor to improve their solo capability while also giving more buff options. Then you could move int on to the magic resistance absorb(both are magic related, while armor and strength are physical). Int just doesnt give any benefit to a bard so you'll only gain little strength for the purpose of allowing another class to be able to buff - why not just have it as an alternative so that having a bard could fill the role as well. Then again that gets in to homogenizing classes. The heal being bumped up to 50 seems good to me. Weapons are going to scale dmg higher and you're not going to be able to increase the healing much since its only 25% instrument contribution. While we're talking about instruments, they have a dmg rating but do they actually affect weapon dmg? Should it? idk. Just my 2c. I just want to make sure that they are viable solo too, if anything for pvp. Right now their group viability seems okay, they just cant do multiple buffs. It can often times feel really boring. It's nice when you can throw out some nice heals, deal some good dmg and can amp up others or give some protection though. I also disagree with giving bards haste. I think that its a nice thing for druids to have. Kind of like how rangers have pets, or barbarians can rage, or monks roundhouse. Adding the other instance to bard would cause balance issues too like you've already thought about.
NiteHawk
I am probably going to linch the AGI one for now. I think it's going to be a problem overall to balance if I have to start giving out 2AGI and all that. It might make some races a bit op too if you sit with one in there.. Let's skip that.

Instruments aren't damage, they are used for spell boost as I wrote above. They do not effect weapon damage and never well. Just a typo that needs to be adjusted but not right now.

INT will boost the heals of your bard though, but yeah, that is the only thing.

Anyways...

It's going to either be:

STR/INT, because both do damage boosts.
SPELL NEGATION/ARMOR because both boost tank.

Or

STR/AC - boosts physical
SPELL NEGATION/INT - boosts magical.

And at the moment, HP on it's own.

In any case both ways seem fine to me, but I'll go with what people think is popular. What do you guys want/think then? I see option one being more useful solo, but option two being more useful in parties. I will not be giving both options to them though.

There is no way we will be giving them a MP regen. MP is supposed to be hard/sought out.

+++

For instruments, I was thinking of nitching the whole idea of them granting song power too. For some reason people don't really understand how they work, and then don't understand it's both charisma and a good instrument that you need. Instead I was thinking that instruments can boost their overall MP, or maybe something else, and leaving the instrument entirely charisma based so its more simple. I am not sure yet though.

In terms of time to change, it's going to be a little.
Thi
I'd say leave Bards gimped so Dustin has a harder time leveling, but that's just a personal bias. <3

Never paid much attention to bards so I can't help you there.


I love you too Thi...

I got your back man <3 Always!
NiteHawk
Is it possible that bards can heal everything in party, including the spawns?

That's what their song does already I would figure.
Kawasaki
From what I have seen it doesn't seem to heal the golem spawns or anything but it might be that they get attacked more often than others.