DISCUSSION for KotH & Jr. KotH
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
hAHAHA you gotta be kidding me! I always get wrecked and last night I finally get lucky and half win something and you want to make me completely useless? Those fights I won with less than 100 health in almost all of them. It was complete luck. Leech is our damage spell it is what makes us unique from a hard hitting sorcerer. You allow us to hit twice with our only worthwhile damage? DMs are in no way close to OP. Whatever though if thats how this is going to be Ive got other games to play.
Also my heals are on average from 23 - 38 no way in hell I went from severe to healthy. Maybe if I had div they might have been 30-high 40's
Alright guys, I got some more input on this now that Chris is online and I want your opinions
First let me say I didnt know it only healed for that small amount (200hp per round max if all your leeches connect in a round) So everyone calm down and let's discuss this and figure out something in the middle.
My thoughts as well as a couple other staffers is what if we limit it per round rather than per fight? For instance 2 leeches per round? I would love some other ideas so we can pick what fits best.
I want to add Im actually on the fence on this. On one hand, it is your best spell and I believe, since people know when Koth is each week, they should bring an alt that well rounded and be prepared to fight any casters including DM's and their leech spell. (I did some testing myself today with my 20wis DE assassin vs a 23int Necro and I did damn good. He missed a lot on me. DE's high MR + 20wis is a nice counter to a necro <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" /> )
As for the JR. King of the Hill question about Assassins not hiding on their 3rd attack. The reason I said it's a rule is because it's a rule and will stay that way. If I started allowing it based on your argument that its part of their strategy then you could also ask why cant healers heal all they want or other classes buff as much as they want during the fight.
I would counter your question with a question of my own. Explain to me how hiding on the 3rd attack is a strategy in a straight up 1v1 dual? If you say to make them burn a stm pt by searching I would say wouldnt it be wiser to search during the first hide/backstab to maybe make the assassin trip up and fail the backstab?
What Im guessing is its because you want to continue to backstab nonstop rather then do a reg attack on that 3rd stm pt. In that case thats not what I want for under 25 KotH. I want it to be /hide/backstab/attack.
It's just how I designed this particular event. Everyone else has seemed okay with it and so far they've all said it's a fair event. I cant just go changing how it works everytime someone thinks it should be different then it would be in a constant state of change.
First let me say I didnt know it only healed for that small amount (200hp per round max if all your leeches connect in a round) So everyone calm down and let's discuss this and figure out something in the middle.
My thoughts as well as a couple other staffers is what if we limit it per round rather than per fight? For instance 2 leeches per round? I would love some other ideas so we can pick what fits best.
I want to add Im actually on the fence on this. On one hand, it is your best spell and I believe, since people know when Koth is each week, they should bring an alt that well rounded and be prepared to fight any casters including DM's and their leech spell. (I did some testing myself today with my 20wis DE assassin vs a 23int Necro and I did damn good. He missed a lot on me. DE's high MR + 20wis is a nice counter to a necro <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" /> )
As for the JR. King of the Hill question about Assassins not hiding on their 3rd attack. The reason I said it's a rule is because it's a rule and will stay that way. If I started allowing it based on your argument that its part of their strategy then you could also ask why cant healers heal all they want or other classes buff as much as they want during the fight.
I would counter your question with a question of my own. Explain to me how hiding on the 3rd attack is a strategy in a straight up 1v1 dual? If you say to make them burn a stm pt by searching I would say wouldnt it be wiser to search during the first hide/backstab to maybe make the assassin trip up and fail the backstab?
What Im guessing is its because you want to continue to backstab nonstop rather then do a reg attack on that 3rd stm pt. In that case thats not what I want for under 25 KotH. I want it to be /hide/backstab/attack.
It's just how I designed this particular event. Everyone else has seemed okay with it and so far they've all said it's a fair event. I cant just go changing how it works everytime someone thinks it should be different then it would be in a constant state of change.
Please post any questions or discussions in this thread. The other thread is meant for announcing winners each week. Thank you
Well with that philosophy in mind, to keep it fair.
Slayers 1 backstab per round
Ninjas 2 hits with staff then switch to hands per round
Sorcs 2 blast per round
Elder two hits with transformed then switch to regular
I mean if you want it to be fair by gimping abilities then gimp them all. I didn't realize this was going to be like RoK where Ninja, Slayers, and Elders are the only viable choices for events. That is the path we are headed down. OMG something other than one of the master classes did good in ONE event out of the many that has been held better make it pointless to use that class, don't wanna disrupt the holy trinity.
This crap is retarded.
Slayers 1 backstab per round
Ninjas 2 hits with staff then switch to hands per round
Sorcs 2 blast per round
Elder two hits with transformed then switch to regular
I mean if you want it to be fair by gimping abilities then gimp them all. I didn't realize this was going to be like RoK where Ninja, Slayers, and Elders are the only viable choices for events. That is the path we are headed down. OMG something other than one of the master classes did good in ONE event out of the many that has been held better make it pointless to use that class, don't wanna disrupt the holy trinity.
This crap is retarded.
I agree here I really hate how we have to gimp classes for 1v1 events. Honestly necros might own low wis characters but they are not going to beat anything with 17+ wis most the time.
I don't really have a certain solution just kind of sucks we have to gimp classes.
I don't really have a certain solution just kind of sucks we have to gimp classes.
Y'all gotta realize Cere is just trying to balance things. He's not out to get you.
IMO DM's have to use leech, it's their only decent damage spell. I think as Lat said they are going to do very very well against low wis, but they can lose same as a sorc against targets with solid MR. It's the way the game goes. I'm pretty sure that if you make them use beam (or whatever their low lvl dmg spell is) that they would be unable to compete.
Leave it the way it was, see if DMs dominate. I don't think they will, and frankly I think that if they do it's not a 1v1 rule that needs to be changed but it'd be leech itself that needs changing (although a bandaid 1v1 change in the meantime would be fine).
IMO DM's have to use leech, it's their only decent damage spell. I think as Lat said they are going to do very very well against low wis, but they can lose same as a sorc against targets with solid MR. It's the way the game goes. I'm pretty sure that if you make them use beam (or whatever their low lvl dmg spell is) that they would be unable to compete.
Leave it the way it was, see if DMs dominate. I don't think they will, and frankly I think that if they do it's not a 1v1 rule that needs to be changed but it'd be leech itself that needs changing (although a bandaid 1v1 change in the meantime would be fine).
I have to agree here, don't handicap the classes... well I guess you have to handicap clerics from simply healing all the time but other than that...
A high int should beat a low wis the majority of the time. Don't like it? Then make a ling ninja or elf elder.
A lizard ninja I think will beat an elder and ling ninja so it all works out.
Rock Paper Scissors.
A high int should beat a low wis the majority of the time. Don't like it? Then make a ling ninja or elf elder.
A lizard ninja I think will beat an elder and ling ninja so it all works out.
Rock Paper Scissors.
Well with that philosophy in mind, to keep it fair.
Slayers 1 backstab per round
Ninjas 2 hits with staff then switch to hands per round
Sorcs 2 blast per round
Elder two hits with transformed then switch to regular
I mean if you want it to be fair by gimping abilities then gimp them all. I didn't realize this was going to be like RoK where Ninja, Slayers, and Elders are the only viable choices for events. That is the path we are headed down. OMG something other than one of the master classes did good in ONE event out of the many that has been held better make it pointless to use that class, don't wanna disrupt the holy trinity.
This crap is retarded.
I agree with you here. Leech is a DMs only viable attack spell, and you can now only use it twice before having to use the spell you start the game with. After weeks of events being dominated by ninjas and slayers there is one good round of a DM and the world changes the rules. If you performed like this several weeks in a row we should be having this conversation, but a DM had one good week and you snag a nerf.
When the world makes nothing but low wis characters a caster coming through and wrecking us shouldn't be nerf worthy.
reaper really no reason to get upset, I was willing to discuss this as I do not know a lot about DM's lol
So after listening to everyone's argument, we will leave DM's as they were and people will have to start taking into account they may face one and take the proper steps to counter it <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Great discussion for the most part, #gettingshitdone2017
So after listening to everyone's argument, we will leave DM's as they were and people will have to start taking into account they may face one and take the proper steps to counter it <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Great discussion for the most part, #gettingshitdone2017
Nod, thanks Cere. People get bent out of shape easily but at the end of the day we're all a small community that can and should discuss things.
I don't do 1v1 with low wis characters precisely for this reason.
I don't do 1v1 with low wis characters precisely for this reason.
It was hard not to be a little upset by the initial rule change. You just said the rules were changed, there wasn't really a discussion.
What bothered me the most was just that I always get annihilated in events. The one time I somewhat win one instantly rules get changed so that I never even stand a remote chance. Basically you rendered my chosen class useless in all future events.
I mean I'm a very laid back person but hard to not be annoyed by that. Regardless, I'm glad that I still have somewhat of a chance. Thanks for reconsidering.
What bothered me the most was just that I always get annihilated in events. The one time I somewhat win one instantly rules get changed so that I never even stand a remote chance. Basically you rendered my chosen class useless in all future events.
I mean I'm a very laid back person but hard to not be annoyed by that. Regardless, I'm glad that I still have somewhat of a chance. Thanks for reconsidering.
Well technically I had discussed it with the other staffers, but the players opinion should matter too. So thats why I made this post for future discussions as well as current <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Look so after winning KoTH last night I noticed a few people thought the rules unfair. Here I will put my suggestion and a few comments.
I will start off by saying that everyone I faced had horrible MR aside from Kyon who was very close to killing me. Drakeblood, 2 x Saurians, and a goblin. Reviewing the log none of them would have killed me even without the healing of leech. With that being said I just want to calm the unfair talk in that specific KoTH.
Now DM's can't very well not use their main damage ability in a fight. So, if people find it unfair, and I will not dispute that, then here is my suggestion.
The heal we get back is pretty low. Also it is not guaranteed especially from someone with high MR. So my suggestion would be we get a damage spell that does not heal, but is better than beam. We get two rounds of leech and then we use the new spell. With div this would put us pretty close to a pally heal on average if all 8 attacks hit. Without div it would prob be a little under.
The problem with that is the spell is pretty much pointless for anything other than KoTH. So it is kind of a weird thing.
My last comment is maybe it doesn't even need changing. The fact is other than Kyon, which was an unaffect war, no one really has had MR that I have fought. I'm suggesting this based on a few people who thought it unfair and I'm trying to be reasonable about it.
I will start off by saying that everyone I faced had horrible MR aside from Kyon who was very close to killing me. Drakeblood, 2 x Saurians, and a goblin. Reviewing the log none of them would have killed me even without the healing of leech. With that being said I just want to calm the unfair talk in that specific KoTH.
Now DM's can't very well not use their main damage ability in a fight. So, if people find it unfair, and I will not dispute that, then here is my suggestion.
The heal we get back is pretty low. Also it is not guaranteed especially from someone with high MR. So my suggestion would be we get a damage spell that does not heal, but is better than beam. We get two rounds of leech and then we use the new spell. With div this would put us pretty close to a pally heal on average if all 8 attacks hit. Without div it would prob be a little under.
The problem with that is the spell is pretty much pointless for anything other than KoTH. So it is kind of a weird thing.
My last comment is maybe it doesn't even need changing. The fact is other than Kyon, which was an unaffect war, no one really has had MR that I have fought. I'm suggesting this based on a few people who thought it unfair and I'm trying to be reasonable about it.
... My last comment is maybe it doesn't even need changing. The fact is other than Kyon, which was an unaffect war, no one really has had MR that I have fought ....
I go with that.
It is the rock, paper, scissors that is a part of the game.
Without div being factored, a chanter/DM SHOULD eat something with low MR. Unless that something can deal out enough damage before its hit points run out.
Saurias/Drakes/Horcs (and goblins are just that awkward in between) have their physical power. You choose them for that, not their magic resistance.
I don't think the problem is DMs, I think it's that all magic is a bit too strong. I was the goblin that fought you and yeah I expect to lose cause its against div, but a goblin ninja w/ 16 wis should have halfway decent MR, right?
Sorta feels like anything less than 20 wis and you're pure fodder for casters. I'm not suggesting a huge shift but it does feel a bit off at times.
Sorta feels like anything less than 20 wis and you're pure fodder for casters. I'm not suggesting a huge shift but it does feel a bit off at times.
Im currently working on a dwarf barb with 19wis on top of their 8% MR to test, also going to try out DE/HE with max wis to see how they fair. Will revisit this.
I could see maybe adding the spell reaper spoke of, but I also believe one should come to a fight prepared to possibly face a DM or any caster for that matter.
I can also see where all magic seems a bit op currently. I to have a gobby (ninja) with 16wis that does half way decent against a caster, but still dies 9/10 times.
I could see maybe adding the spell reaper spoke of, but I also believe one should come to a fight prepared to possibly face a DM or any caster for that matter.
I can also see where all magic seems a bit op currently. I to have a gobby (ninja) with 16wis that does half way decent against a caster, but still dies 9/10 times.
Yea I'm not really sure how stats work. On Reaper in a 5 fight test with a HO slayer I was killed 4 out of those 5 times. Twice I was rounded. One fight I unaffected 5 times on 10 Wis. I think it's pretty much a roll of the dice on hits and unaffects. Higher stats is a higher chance to get a better roll, but that doesn't mean you still can't get crappy rolls in a row.
I guess as far as anything under 20 wis goes it's kind of like having 16 agi vs someone with 22 agi. Sure there is a better chance you will dodge than if you had 10, but the chance is still pretty low. I could be wrong on this, pure speculation.
I guess as far as anything under 20 wis goes it's kind of like having 16 agi vs someone with 22 agi. Sure there is a better chance you will dodge than if you had 10, but the chance is still pretty low. I could be wrong on this, pure speculation.
Yea I'm not really sure how stats work. On Reaper in a 5 fight test with a HO slayer I was killed 4 out of those 5 times. Twice I was rounded. One fight I unaffected 5 times on 10 Wis. I think it's pretty much a roll of the dice on hits and unaffects. Higher stats is a higher chance to get a better roll, but that doesn't mean you still can't get crappy rolls in a row.
I guess as far as anything under 20 wis goes it's kind of like having 16 agi vs someone with 22 agi. Sure there is a better chance you will dodge than if you had 10, but the chance is still pretty low. I could be wrong on this, pure speculation.
Well now we're veering off, but IMO...
Orcs are crazy good because of their HP. Casters are OP in general. Wisdom doesn't seem to mean much until 20. 1v1 is pretty much all luck based, bigger fights where heals are involved are a different story.
I do think DMs having an extra spell that is basically Leech without the leech is a bit redundant, since its only use would be for stuff like KotH.
if it comes to implementing this new spell, it could be made less redundant if there is a significant difference in its mana cost.
beam = 2 mana
leech = 5
new spell = 3 would make me use this one on PVE, as long as I have a healer with me or while i'm at full hp. given its damage equals leech's.
beam = 2 mana
leech = 5
new spell = 3 would make me use this one on PVE, as long as I have a healer with me or while i'm at full hp. given its damage equals leech's.