MR Changes
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
THere is a big change to how MR works and it needs some heavy testing. I doubt it is 100% right now and it might be too strong, or not strong enough. Most values I can now change without having to restart the server, so we'll try to balance that out now.
Pierce bonuses have been removed from staff weapons, we are going to do something different with weapons and give them damage bonuses instead. The damage bonus isn't in yet.
Please note: MR might now be fine, but damage might need tweaking now. We need to test it anyways.
So MR is based on the following, wisdom, class, and race. Wisdom is a big part of it still, and class/race are smaller modifiers. INT does not effect how well you pierce now. The pierce rate is based on simply your class/race/MR for a static value. This means INT effects duration, damage/heal, or how well a spell debuffs/buffs someone. So having a caster that is not a GNOME is now a thing, though if you want maximum damage and highest MR you would go for GNOME still. I can see other races with 20/21 int being a thing now though.
On top of this, wisdom passive damage removal was changed as well. It was far too much with high wisdom (something like 20-25% WITH 70% resistances is insane!). Wisdom damage negation starts at 11 wisdom and goes up. This means at 10 wisdom you are taking the full damage. If for some reason you have lower, you'll be taking 'extra' damage. The damage negation only removes about 10-12% now damage with his wisdom, which I think is fair enough for now but we will see.
Goblins got a nice boost. They should now be what they look like, fighters with good MR. 17 wisdom with 20% boost grants them around the same as having 21 wisdom so they obviously get a good bang per wisdom point there.
Elementals were changed a bit. I removed their spell damage bonus and set them with lower resistances. However, this doesn't mean they have bad resistances. An elemental knight with 24 wisdom is the same around as a half-elf knight with 22 wisdom.
Druids were also lowered in the MR scale to the lowest. I know that it loosk scary, but even with the nerf they still have one of the highest MR rates because most druids will have over 20 wisdom. Please remember that having 0.95 per wisdom point for example doesn't mean you are suddenly getting 0 MR. An elemental druid with 24 wisdom probably has the same MR as a half-elf knight with 20-21 wisdom. This means though that elemntal druids while being better at physical, will be a little weaker than its counterparts, though I don't think it's enough to seriously effect them in combat, but I thought a 80% MR rate with spell negation on a race that is meant for druids mostly was simply silly and ruined other options around it.
Please remember, that MR now scales differently too. We need to test everything.
MR Values are posted in the development blog. <a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=93">viewtopic.php?f=10&t=93</a>
I'll have more technical data later, heads killing though right now.
Pierce bonuses have been removed from staff weapons, we are going to do something different with weapons and give them damage bonuses instead. The damage bonus isn't in yet.
Please note: MR might now be fine, but damage might need tweaking now. We need to test it anyways.
So MR is based on the following, wisdom, class, and race. Wisdom is a big part of it still, and class/race are smaller modifiers. INT does not effect how well you pierce now. The pierce rate is based on simply your class/race/MR for a static value. This means INT effects duration, damage/heal, or how well a spell debuffs/buffs someone. So having a caster that is not a GNOME is now a thing, though if you want maximum damage and highest MR you would go for GNOME still. I can see other races with 20/21 int being a thing now though.
On top of this, wisdom passive damage removal was changed as well. It was far too much with high wisdom (something like 20-25% WITH 70% resistances is insane!). Wisdom damage negation starts at 11 wisdom and goes up. This means at 10 wisdom you are taking the full damage. If for some reason you have lower, you'll be taking 'extra' damage. The damage negation only removes about 10-12% now damage with his wisdom, which I think is fair enough for now but we will see.
Goblins got a nice boost. They should now be what they look like, fighters with good MR. 17 wisdom with 20% boost grants them around the same as having 21 wisdom so they obviously get a good bang per wisdom point there.
Elementals were changed a bit. I removed their spell damage bonus and set them with lower resistances. However, this doesn't mean they have bad resistances. An elemental knight with 24 wisdom is the same around as a half-elf knight with 22 wisdom.
Druids were also lowered in the MR scale to the lowest. I know that it loosk scary, but even with the nerf they still have one of the highest MR rates because most druids will have over 20 wisdom. Please remember that having 0.95 per wisdom point for example doesn't mean you are suddenly getting 0 MR. An elemental druid with 24 wisdom probably has the same MR as a half-elf knight with 20-21 wisdom. This means though that elemntal druids while being better at physical, will be a little weaker than its counterparts, though I don't think it's enough to seriously effect them in combat, but I thought a 80% MR rate with spell negation on a race that is meant for druids mostly was simply silly and ruined other options around it.
Please remember, that MR now scales differently too. We need to test everything.
MR Values are posted in the development blog. <a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=93">viewtopic.php?f=10&t=93</a>
I'll have more technical data later, heads killing though right now.
P.S. Free reallocation will be on AGI update, not this one.
sounds good to me.
*waits for elemental lovers to come complain* <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
*waits for elemental lovers to come complain* <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Its only been 1 day (not even that) but wanted to give some feedback
Slayers with 10 wis no longer get hit 4/4 its more like 3/4 or 2.5/4 even (this means they stand an OK chance at a win vs caster)
Elemental elders now hit about 1/4 instead of 0.25/4 which it seemed (still no way to kill an elemental elder as a caster)
Human Ninja was about the same as elemental elders hit them about 1/4 maybe a bit less (this used to be slightly in favor of ninja but now its pretty set win for ninja)
I didnt get to test against a lizard or drake ninja but im assuming they have a slight advantage over chanters.
This isnt too worrying for chanters since they will be getting some more damage from staves as you stated.
I can see how the tables have turned race wise with int no longer accounting for penetration. Before people used gnomes because they had better penetration (hit more) and accepted they had the lowest health and didnt really work for oads. Now with everyone hitting the same penetration wise and only having slightly less damage I think its a better choice to take the extra 120-240hp to sacrifice a little damage.
Again the system isnt done maybe to make up for loss of penetration damage/buffs per int point will be a bit higher? maybe staff damage will be multiplied off int who knows.
Anyways just some feedback prob not too helpful since the system is incomplete. but if the goal was to narrow the MR range and nerf gnomes down a bit I think its mission accomplished.
I think its posted somewhere but could we get damage (blast) ac (stoneskin) and str (power) per int?
Slayers with 10 wis no longer get hit 4/4 its more like 3/4 or 2.5/4 even (this means they stand an OK chance at a win vs caster)
Elemental elders now hit about 1/4 instead of 0.25/4 which it seemed (still no way to kill an elemental elder as a caster)
Human Ninja was about the same as elemental elders hit them about 1/4 maybe a bit less (this used to be slightly in favor of ninja but now its pretty set win for ninja)
I didnt get to test against a lizard or drake ninja but im assuming they have a slight advantage over chanters.
This isnt too worrying for chanters since they will be getting some more damage from staves as you stated.
I can see how the tables have turned race wise with int no longer accounting for penetration. Before people used gnomes because they had better penetration (hit more) and accepted they had the lowest health and didnt really work for oads. Now with everyone hitting the same penetration wise and only having slightly less damage I think its a better choice to take the extra 120-240hp to sacrifice a little damage.
Again the system isnt done maybe to make up for loss of penetration damage/buffs per int point will be a bit higher? maybe staff damage will be multiplied off int who knows.
Anyways just some feedback prob not too helpful since the system is incomplete. but if the goal was to narrow the MR range and nerf gnomes down a bit I think its mission accomplished.
I think its posted somewhere but could we get damage (blast) ac (stoneskin) and str (power) per int?
Yeah i'll post it later.
Per int though if it was more then instead of raising the max we'd sacrifice the per point to start and scale it to the current max. For example if power gave 2str with 10 int and 4 str with 20 int. then I'd do 0.5 str with 10 int and 4 str with 20 int.
The pen loss doesn't really affect anything because the penetration rates are completely different. Everyone gained the same penetration, it was just fluff that wasn't needed atm and helped balanced out the rates by not having so many variables.
Just like races with physical theres going to be downsides of some races vs others now with this method rather then gnomes being the goto on everything.
Blast is 7.8474 damage per int point at level 25 not including div bonuses. So 180 damage with 23int, 156 with 20int. To me that seems fair though. With around 14% div bonus as the current max it becomes 8.867562 per point, so 204 damage with 23 int and 177 damage with 20 int.
Technically that's more lost then most physical based weapons. Something we might wanna do is give them a little more damage at 23 int but we'd need to look at it.
Elemental Druid with 23 wisdom has a HR of 38%. so in between 1 and 2 hits per round i guess that one would be. 24wisdom is 35%.
Per int though if it was more then instead of raising the max we'd sacrifice the per point to start and scale it to the current max. For example if power gave 2str with 10 int and 4 str with 20 int. then I'd do 0.5 str with 10 int and 4 str with 20 int.
The pen loss doesn't really affect anything because the penetration rates are completely different. Everyone gained the same penetration, it was just fluff that wasn't needed atm and helped balanced out the rates by not having so many variables.
Just like races with physical theres going to be downsides of some races vs others now with this method rather then gnomes being the goto on everything.
Blast is 7.8474 damage per int point at level 25 not including div bonuses. So 180 damage with 23int, 156 with 20int. To me that seems fair though. With around 14% div bonus as the current max it becomes 8.867562 per point, so 204 damage with 23 int and 177 damage with 20 int.
Technically that's more lost then most physical based weapons. Something we might wanna do is give them a little more damage at 23 int but we'd need to look at it.
Elemental Druid with 23 wisdom has a HR of 38%. so in between 1 and 2 hits per round i guess that one would be. 24wisdom is 35%.
So having a caster that is not a GNOME is now a thing, though if you want maximum damage and highest MR you would go for GNOME still. I can see other races with 20/21 int being a thing now though.
rather then gnomes being the goto on everything.
I'm unsure which of us is disconnected with the reality of recent enchanter trends but i really dont see gnomes as being the race of preference for enchanters at all... in fact most of the ppl who i know with gnome chanters i believe made them early on (probably thinking of RoK game dynamics) and i rarely see a gnome sorc created nowadays (most ppl will create an Ele now)....
i personally have a gnome enchanter... and there isnt a day that goes by playing it that i dont wish i made the chanter with a 20/21 int race instead... and i'd do almost anything to be able to change its race into something with more HP (and happily sacrifice +1 INT/WIS to achieve that - because there is little point in doing marginally more damage if you die in 1 round from groupfight targeting or OAD double-taps before you can damage anything).
Just wanted to voice my opinion on this as you appear (to me) to be operating under the misunderstanding that gnomes are the race of choice for enchanters when really most veteran players appear to have already realized that 20/21 int chanters were "a thing" (purely because of the importance of HP in EO) long before these MR changes.
All i can say is that I hope the free respecs we finally get when AGI is changed will allow for race changes because otherwise i'm just hazarding a guess that there's going to be a lot of discouraged players out there...
... blah blah blah ...
Yeh I don't think gnomes are the go to race for chanter anymore either. Even when they were though, I never made a gome sorcy.
Made one recently ironically though <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Yea unfortunately it's looking a bit rough for gnomes they didnt really make a anything good besides chanters/necros (high wis gnome druids used to be a thing but elemental made that a no factor)
Int doesn't matter a ton for most healing spells so we don't see gnome healers.
Int isn't huge for hide so we don't see gnome thieves or slayers anymore really.
For casters now with pen loss they really only do +8 damage a hit and a fraction of buff power over elf while elf has +1 end and +1 agi.
Or as suggested above you can lose 1int and have an elemental with 180 more hp.
I do like that everyone will have pen and things will be more useful but maybe int should matter a bit more for pen that was lost on that high int or maybe gnomes should be looked at because they somewhat just lost their only somewhat good class and even that was just slightly above average. I agree most initially made gnomes thinking they would have a big spells bonus like rok I think even before this update I'm not sure they were the race of choice for sorcs like elementals are for druids or half orcs are for slayers.
Int doesn't matter a ton for most healing spells so we don't see gnome healers.
Int isn't huge for hide so we don't see gnome thieves or slayers anymore really.
For casters now with pen loss they really only do +8 damage a hit and a fraction of buff power over elf while elf has +1 end and +1 agi.
Or as suggested above you can lose 1int and have an elemental with 180 more hp.
I do like that everyone will have pen and things will be more useful but maybe int should matter a bit more for pen that was lost on that high int or maybe gnomes should be looked at because they somewhat just lost their only somewhat good class and even that was just slightly above average. I agree most initially made gnomes thinking they would have a big spells bonus like rok I think even before this update I'm not sure they were the race of choice for sorcs like elementals are for druids or half orcs are for slayers.
Yeh, when the AGL changes, give gnomes an extra AGL point <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Small and dodge they become!
Yeh, when the AGL changes, give gnomes an extra AGL point <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Small and dodge they become!
This could help... though id probably still want to change away from gnome if i possible... The other option is to raise their racial profile to allow 23 int and 23 wis (before the +1).... making them even more into a "glass cannon" race (i mean Horcs have 24 str so why not have a race with really high int/wis... esp if they are pansys who fall over and die easily).... still probably wouldnt choose em again tho
Yeh, when the AGL changes, give gnomes an extra AGL point <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Small and dodge they become!
This could help... though id probably still want to change away from gnome if i possible... The other option is to raise their racial profile to allow 23 int and 23 wis (before the +1).... making them even more into a "glass cannon" race (i mean Horcs have 24 str so why not have a race with really high int/wis... esp if they are pansys who fall over and die easily).... still probably wouldnt choose em again tho
Adding wisdom would overshadow and make elementals useless, int though might be a thing now for them.
Adding wisdom would overshadow and make elementals useless, int though might be a thing now for them.
I disagree that Gnomes with 23 wis would make Elementals useless... I think Eles would still be the race of choice over gnomes for both sorcs/necros and Druids purely because of their +3END leading to so much higher survivability (esp in group fights and OAD parties which is the majority of end game activity).... There at least there would be a more equivalent trade for players to consider (rather than the current obvious choice for Ele).. In fact I'd probably suggest the addition of Elementals disrupted the previous spellcaster norm of having to accept that high int/wis came at cost of HP... Meaning now by choosing Elementals you can have your cake and eat it (esp in the case of Druids where morph more than adequately covers the Str/Agi weakness of the Ele race)
Honestly talking about END I feel that the lowest END should probably be 18 and not 17. It's a bit tough to make both END points matter but also having that huge 17 end to 23 end gap thats tough to balance. For example Gnomes would be +1 end and +1 int. Still lower on the scale but yeah. Though this could overshadow somewhat and I haven't put much checking into other races at the moment for it. Toppled with the AGI potential changes that would probably help dodge a bit (more tweaks than a major change) might help overall.
Honestly talking about END I feel that the lowest END should probably be 18 and not 17. It's a bit tough to make both END points matter but also having that huge 17 end to 23 end gap thats tough to balance. For example Gnomes would be +1 end and +1 int. Still lower on the scale but yeah. Though this could overshadow somewhat and I haven't put much checking into other races at the moment for it. Toppled with the AGI potential changes that would probably help dodge a bit (more tweaks than a major change) might help overall.
Absolutely. The only two races that hits are gnomes and lings and I think both are seriously overshadowed by better races for virtually every possible class and rarely used to much success. Both gnomes and lings will benefit more than other classes from the agi change but +1 end to each would make them both viable I think without making either overpowered.
This will be great when I start to use my hairy footed plump alts!
So tender and delicious. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />
I have one gnome too, not plump, not tasty, scrawny and stringy.
So tender and delicious. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />
I have one gnome too, not plump, not tasty, scrawny and stringy.
Honestly talking about END I feel that the lowest END should probably be 18 and not 17. It's a bit tough to make both END points matter but also having that huge 17 end to 23 end gap thats tough to balance. For example Gnomes would be +1 end and +1 int. Still lower on the scale but yeah. Though this could overshadow somewhat and I haven't put much checking into other races at the moment for it. Toppled with the AGI potential changes that would probably help dodge a bit (more tweaks than a major change) might help overall.
Absolutely. The only two races that hits are gnomes and lings and I think both are seriously overshadowed by better races for virtually every possible class and rarely used to much success. Both gnomes and lings will benefit more than other classes from the agi change but +1 end to each would make them both viable I think without making either overpowered.
I would love to see Lings and Gnomes get a much needed +1 END boost to get them more viable... But I do wonder if doing so might unbalance or make some other races useless (eg Elf - which I mainly see used for casters or bards). For example right now there is an Agi/End trade off between Elf and Ling when making a bard ... This would be removed in favour of Lings if they get +1 End. Similarly with sorcs/necros, Elf benefits over Gnome with +1 End and +1 Agi... If you made the Gnomes equal to Elves in End, it might mean you could take Gnome and +1 Agi to finish up with a caster that overshadows the best possible Elf one.
Basically Gnomes do need a fix of some sort to make them more viable... But if their base End is what is being tinkered with, then I think the 18 End races will probably also need to be looked at to ensure they are still viable. This is why I suggested upping Gnome INT/WIS instead... It's much easier to balance Gnome verses Ele and see it as an Int&Agi vs End tradeoff for same Wis (due to the relative importance of End). However if NH is willing to rebalance all the 17&18 End races then I do think upping Gnome and Ling End would definitely make them more playable.
This is why I suggested upping Gnome INT/WIS instead... It's much easier to balance Gnome verses Ele and see it as an Int&Agi vs End tradeoff for same Wis (due to the relative importance of End). However if NH is willing to rebalance all the 17&18 End races then I do think upping Gnome and Ling End would definitely make them more playable.
Balancing with Wis would literally only help the class be a better Elder though. It would be virtually meaningless to every other potential gnome class (necro, priest, chanter, pally?). That also would make them way too strong as elders.
It would definitely require a re-balance for gnomes and likely for lings but I doubt it would have to be too big. For Gnomes you could maybe just lower their usable stats by 3-4 (including the one that would go toward the extra end point). For lings maybe lower usable points by 2-3 (including the extra end point).
Gnomes, Humans, and Lings are definitely the worst classes in my eyes right now and this would help two of them for sure - there will inevitably be some balance damage to the classes that Gnomes or Lings might replace but that could be balanced by some slight buffs down the line to races that fall by the wayside I think.
I dunno what the fuck to do with humans tbh maybe just give them even more usable stats and some passive buffs or something odd. In practice the class could make excellent Paladins but there are so many better races for pally's when compared to them.
I think giving them 18 end maybe overshadows other races a bit?
Don't get me wrong I agree halflings gnome and human could use some love but idk if end is the way to go.
I could see + int on gnomes they are rather small and dodgy maybe an agi? Idk
I think halflings will already get a buff from agi changes maybe give them a few more pool stats? Maybe race based dodge?
Human might be cool to give them two +1s
Say for 5 pool points you could have a +2?
Idk just kinda tossing ideas out
Don't get me wrong I agree halflings gnome and human could use some love but idk if end is the way to go.
I could see + int on gnomes they are rather small and dodgy maybe an agi? Idk
I think halflings will already get a buff from agi changes maybe give them a few more pool stats? Maybe race based dodge?
Human might be cool to give them two +1s
Say for 5 pool points you could have a +2?
Idk just kinda tossing ideas out
I agree with Lat - AGI is the way to go, not END.
Also, can they be boosted by non stat buffs, like greater MR, better Pot timeout, etc.?
Also, can they be boosted by non stat buffs, like greater MR, better Pot timeout, etc.?
I did think, but what about the 18 END races... then the 19 END races... then the...
Tricky one eh <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Humans: Maybe allow them two +1's or as Lat suggested a +2?
Gnomes/Ling: +1 AGL or Flat +% to dodge.
Tricky one eh <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Humans: Maybe allow them two +1's or as Lat suggested a +2?
Gnomes/Ling: +1 AGL or Flat +% to dodge.