← Forum archive

MR Changes

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Styx
You would have to do racial adjustments. That way it can be tweaked more so.

Humans could be changed by battle stamina timer perhaps? I donno but they should be a better for all around anything. Which goes back to racial adjustments.

Lings are dodgy then it's either agi buff or racial. Perhaps an ac bonus for lings? To make up for the lower end.

If you make a 23 wis gnone I will have a nice 24 wis gnome elder..
Lateralus
If you give humans 2x +1 or a +2 they become better in all cases than half elves instantly.



Well you'd be spending that extra 5-7 pool points to do so meaning halfelf would be more balanced but a +2 str barb that doesn't care about mr might be better.


Honestly we can do all this chatting but with some light analytics we could look at current classes and race combos to give us a clearer picture of what's used. I know it's on the todo list but might be worth checking out for race changes. It won't give the whole picture I mean just because a lot made halfling pallies when the game started thinking they would be good like rok doesn't mean they are good here.
daedroth
Eh... had an... "idea"... for lack of a better word.
Although I think it is no different than the +1 END.
Humans (possibly halflings) could be considered divinely blessed (or some crap). 13 Base CHR (cant go lower - costs no points)?
Nah... idea sucks because of CHR based classes (esp. with lings); because then it would be like an extra 3 stat points for free...
*whistles and walks away slowly*

Hey! Wouldnt it be funny if races had minimum stats based on the maximum a stat can be?
*runs away*
Tucker
So the two stats that every single class needs is Agi and End - and those stats will be maxed out for every single non-troll crit. Agi has a range of 19-23 and End has a range of 17-23. You can see where the problem lies here - sure you can buff Gnomes and Lings with racial bonuses but it'll be very very difficult to balance with 900 hp.

Overlaps or balanced problems that would happen as a result of this change can be fixed with things like tweaks to racial traits to keep things balanced but the change probably should happen. Also, yeah the agi changes will help lings out but I wouldn't expect much change. The big benefit will be to Ling Elders since they have like 26 agi or something crazy when morphed. They'd have to be nerfed in some small way with the buff to 18 end and the agi buff - lets not forget though they still have 18 str and only 960 hp after that happens - if you drop their usable points or nerf them in some way to racial bonuses it'll be enough.
NiteHawk
So the two stats that every single class needs is Agi and End - and those stats will be maxed out for every single non-troll crit. Agi has a range of 19-23 and End has a range of 17-23. You can see where the problem lies here - sure you can buff Gnomes and Lings with racial bonuses but it'll be very very difficult to balance with 900 hp.

Overlaps or balanced problems that would happen as a result of this change can be fixed with things like tweaks to racial traits to keep things balanced but the change probably should happen. Also, yeah the agi changes will help lings out but I wouldn't expect much change. The big benefit will be to Ling Elders since they have like 26 agi or something crazy when morphed. They'd have to be nerfed in some small way with the buff to 18 end and the agi buff - lets not forget though they still have 18 str and only 960 hp after that happens - if you drop their usable points or nerf them in some way to racial bonuses it'll be enough.


Yeah and you can't just change Hp per end point as that would buff all other ENDs up to the max which isn't what is needed. You can't also just put super AGI on, specially because some races actually have END and AGI together with decent STR. Makes it fairly terribad to do. It might be better to take a look at all races and see what the best option is for all of them.
Styx
This keeps leading back to racial adjustments to give the slight tweaking needed

And why give ac bonus for a dwarf with 23 end? Not enough health already?

Why Im saying lings ac bonus and or agi bonus

With all the differences might be better to just race bonus stuff.
NiteHawk
I'm pretty much deciding if the current system is OK or if we should do INT vs WIS. The only issue with INT vs WIS is that you are putting INT with two stats, which is the damage and also hit rate unlike others which have STR and AGI split up for damage and hit rate. This means by picking lower INT it's like picking both a lower str/agi class with no benefit on either side. If I could I might of put another stat in when we started but thats is overly complicated now and far too much work to do so it is what it is right now.

Right now with current slayers a saurian slayer with 10 wis has 75% hit rate, saurian knight with 10wis is about 70%, and a gnome enchanter with 22 wis has 27% hit rate. A knight with a 2.5% MR race (middle ground) Knight would have 45% with 17 wis, 48% with 18 wis, etc. Int doesn't matter right now.


The other option was to make INT vs WIS similar to AGI VS AGI with smaller increments. This however means you'd need a base and then go from there. I.E. Right now AGI is 40% with 2% (2.25% soon) per AGI difference. So at most you'd see 19 agi vs 24 agi, being 5 AGI difference, or 10% (11.5% with new changes). Thus your hit rate is 50% and your dodge rate is 30% in that situation. Obviously WIS is not maxed out often so it might work to do it INT vs WIS but I do worry that it again makes races without high INT worthless.

Basically what you could do is something similar. Let's say INT vs WIS. Base is 30% with 3% reduction per point difference.. If you have 22 int and the person has 17 wis, then that is 5 difference and the hit rate is 45%. If your attacking a half orc with 10 wis it would be a difference of 10 points, so a hit rate of 60%. The issue obviously is when you have higher wisdom. If your a 23 wisdom char vs a 19 int char, thats 12% less, so hit rate is only 28%. You can reduce/increase the 3% or the base of 30% but then someone is screwed because of the high wisdom difference.

The problem with this is you screw one side of the spectrum. Either you screw up high resistance, low resistance, or the middle men. For example if you do 40% base with 3% reduction, it means that a half orc with 10 wisdom is 76%, which would be OK, but then your middle men with 17 wisdom also have 55% hit rate, which is 10% more then current and closer to the original system that everyone complained about more than current.

If you do 35% base with 2% reduction, means that 17 wis is 45%, which is where it is at now for middle men. But then 10 wis is only 59% hit rate. This also means that a 18 int vs 22 wis is 27% hit rate, which is kinda low like it is currently.. Problem is, by raising it, now you are again ruining the middle men wis. Bit annoying. Specially when you have lower INT etc then you're effecting it even more. In this scenario 18INT vs 17WIS would be 37% hit rate. Pretty low.

To me, there is too much variation and I don't think you can use this system as people claim you can it similar to AGI vs AGI. It would be like using the current AGI vs AGi system if people sometimes picked 10 AGI as the normal in some cases. Obviously it wouldn't work out for them and it's hard to balance such a large variation. We already know that having a hit rate of almost 90% was far too high as it was before. I haven't really been able to find a proper/good formula that's linear and that really makes sense though maybe someone has an idea.

----------

The other solution is to balance it through damage and duration which I think would work too. Making the points matter more could be a thing. It just depends on what players thoughts are for how high their damage should be to start with lets say BLAST at 23 INT, vs BLAST with 22 INT, then 21 INT, etc, in a linear fashion again.

I don't think there is any issue with wisdom/race/class being the deciding factor on a static resistance value IMO.. There is just too much variance if using the INT vs WIS method, plus lower/higher INT mucking it up either more if you aren't using close to max INT.
Folder
INT v WIS is crap, the current methodology of using WIS works better and is easier to balance imo. The scale can be adjusted easily, if needed. Not sure any adjustment is needed atm though.
NiteHawk
INT v WIS is crap, the current methodology of using WIS works better and is easier to balance imo. The scale can be adjusted easily, if needed. Not sure any adjustment is needed atm though.


I agree, was just bringing it up since it was brought up a few times on why it's hard to balance. The scaling can be changed for sure if it's too low or high, or per point of wis, etc
Terron
INT v WIS is crap, the current methodology of using WIS works better and is easier to balance imo. The scale can be adjusted easily, if needed. Not sure any adjustment is needed atm though.


I agree, was just bringing it up since it was brought up a few times on why it's hard to balance. The scaling can be changed for sure if it's too low or high, or per point of wis, etc


int vs wis summary:

hit rate base 40%

INT:
int adds 1.25% to hit chance all the way to 20

21+ int adds a 2% /int flat chance to hit with spells
(this is after the formula for hitting, similar to how 5% to hit works on a cav/knight)

characters under 16 int receive a 2% hit rate penalty per int under 16 to a max of 10% with 10 int

WISDOM

wisdom raises dodge 1.25% all the way to 20 then 2% per point after that

characters under 16 wis receive a 2% less chance to dodge spells per wis under 16 to a max of 10% at 10 wis

TESTS
10 int vs 10 wis = 40%
20 int vs 10 wis = 52.5% + 4.75 = 57.25% *(Defender adjustment: 47.5*0.1 = 4.75)
24 int vs 10 wis = 52.5*1.1=57.75 +4.75 = 62.5% *(Defender adjustment: 47.5*0.1 = 4.75)
20 int vs 24 wis = 32%
24 int vs 24 wis = 32* 1.1 = 35.2%
24 int vs 20 wis = 40* 1.1 = 44%
24 int vs 17 wis = 43.75*1.1 = 48.125%
20 int vs 17 wis = 43.75%
17 int vs 20 wis = 36.25%

overall 35.2-62.5

RACIAL MR:

racial mr can be changed to reflect direct damage reduction from spells.
(you can adjust mr on races easily to reflect what you want. if you want a gnome to survive 2 more magical hits than a dwarf go ahead.
if you want a goblin to survive 3 more shots than a helf go ahead) you can actually accomplish this with a sim and no player input and its easily adjustable

spell negation remins the same

(attacking Mages spell damage * Racial MR variable - negation = damage received)
Folder
We did have this whole argument before and figured it was simpler and made more sense to balance with just WIS being the modifier. Let INT determine damage, like STR does.
Terron
it could work wis vs wis but it kinda makes the system an oval especially with dwarf. either way its flawed doesnt matter what you choose. characters are forced to run no wis to compete or flat out period on some races, its not like a 25 int enchanter would be forced to run 12 agility to be a fireball badass. 10 wis exists 10 agility doesnt

what i put above kept the hit rates pretty similar across the board as far as magic vs melee, the mages will get hit more often slightly so 1/4 isnt a constant thing, and 10 wis gets hit a little bit less. but atleast NH can balance the damage and racial variables dealing with magic with just his simulator. weapons can be introduced with a bonus to damage ect, it just got turned into a similar system to melee.


MH posted he couldn't make it fair for magic users and both types of melee, i just did a pretty balanced system that can be balanced with just his sim and changing racial mr. all depends if he wants to code those bonuses and penalties or just keep stats flat 10-max.
NiteHawk
it could work wis vs wis but it kinda makes the system an oval especially with dwarf. either way its flawed doesnt matter what you choose. characters are forced to run no wis to compete or flat out period on some races, its not like a 25 int enchanter would be forced to run 12 agility to be a fireball badass. 10 wis exists 10 agility doesnt

what i put above kept the hit rates pretty similar across the board as far as magic vs melee, the mages will get hit more often slightly so 1/4 isnt a constant thing, and 10 wis gets hit a little bit less. but atleast NH can balance the damage and racial variables dealing with magic with just his simulator. weapons can be introduced with a bonus to damage ect, it just got turned into a similar system to melee.


MH posted he couldn't make it fair for magic users and both types of melee, i just did a pretty balanced system that can be balanced with just his sim and changing racial mr. all depends if he wants to code those bonuses and penalties or just keep stats flat 10-max.


It's not linear though. I really don't like non linear systems and won't use them as I know how players get confused and frustrated over systems that aren't easy to follow. The system needs to be easy, it needs to scale proper and make sense to people. The formula for INT and WIS should stay the same from 10 to 2x in any situation. At least, that's how I feel anyways.
Terron
the stats aren't linear.
expecting a linear result and system wont ever work correctly in that scenario. linear stats work in a 2 tier combat system, 1 mage selects to boost int for damage another character selects wisdom as a counter. 1 fighter selects str for damage the other selects end/agi to survive that damage. flat rates no stat having magnitude or wealth over another. you didnt leave an adequate range for statistics to expect linear equations to work for everything. magic has 2x the range of melee currently. it may not matter now but will later.

lets say u added a burst damage mage tomorrow, the scope of that would be they can round lizards and chew horcs up in 5-6 stam. they would be used heavily. so heavily to counter whats the current top. however that leaves balanced races even further behind because magic hits them still and they still cant beat lizards so youd have lizards vs burst mages and that's it. you see the flaw is noone selects characters that dont have an 85% dominance rate over other characters. thats why they pick saurians and horcs over humans and elves.
why pick an elf knight when it has 10% chance to win vs current top melee and maybe 45-55% chance to beat various magic users.

so i go back to the stats arent linear so how can the character systems and characters themselves be. something will always be left out of whack. but its your game do whatever, if everyone uses the same 3 builds over and over there's balance in that to.