PK immunity & How well it really works.
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I just wanted to ask now that it has been in, for the PK immunity as I know some people been upset / quit over being PKed. Being PK'ed several times in a row can be tough and I'm wondering how the PK immunity system is working. Obviously:
1. You have to die 3 times in an hour for PK immunity to activate. You are then immune for 1 hour.
2. It does not matter WHO kills you, any death counts towards the ticker. So if they die by any alt it counts towards the 3 deaths.
3. You cannot fight back, otherwise immunity doesn't work on you. Fighting while you are immune also removes immunity.
4. You actually have to be killed for it to count, not just being attacked.
5. If you heal someone who has a PVP flag on them (Person has PVP attacked in the last minute or two) you lose immunity.
6. Some rooms are except. Event areas, key areas, oad boss areas, etc.
It's a pretty basic system but maybe the amount of deaths or PK deaths per X hours need to be adjusted. I think an immunity of one hour is OK however and that does not need changing.
I've heard of some people being upset over it, specially some new players who left the game. Right now new player retention is pretty hard. Getting killed 3 times every hour specially if they are being targeted is tough on someone. I understand that sometimes the person being PK'd can be less than nice in pages, but I think it still warrants an ask on adjustment as we're trying to find ways to keep new players WITHOUT having to add things that simply won't work well, like non-pk areas, which would (to me) simply destroy the game.
Also, the system might not even be triggering enough, I.E. someone might die three times to players, but all three deaths occurred within 2 hours, not 1 hour, thus they don't get immunity. Most of the times if they run off they don't get killed several times, but I don't know how to really combat that other than adjusting the amount of hours PKs are stored for immunity to trigger. Obviously there is still that issue where being hunted for hours and not dying is a thing, but how do players actually deal with that instead of getting sick of the game or stressed? Do we tell them to level in an arena until 25 because someone has it out for you?
I understand that PK'ing is a part of the game, it will always be apart of the game. What I want however is a fair system for both sides. I was thinking either reduce the amount of kills to 2 per hour (which I don't think would work still.) or maybe increase it to 'you have to die 3 times in 3 hours for PK immunity to activate'. And obviously the other rules would still apply. Right now I don't think the system really does much because no one dies that much normally.
If anyone has any other suggestions that don't involve a non PK area feel free to suggest here.
1. You have to die 3 times in an hour for PK immunity to activate. You are then immune for 1 hour.
2. It does not matter WHO kills you, any death counts towards the ticker. So if they die by any alt it counts towards the 3 deaths.
3. You cannot fight back, otherwise immunity doesn't work on you. Fighting while you are immune also removes immunity.
4. You actually have to be killed for it to count, not just being attacked.
5. If you heal someone who has a PVP flag on them (Person has PVP attacked in the last minute or two) you lose immunity.
6. Some rooms are except. Event areas, key areas, oad boss areas, etc.
It's a pretty basic system but maybe the amount of deaths or PK deaths per X hours need to be adjusted. I think an immunity of one hour is OK however and that does not need changing.
I've heard of some people being upset over it, specially some new players who left the game. Right now new player retention is pretty hard. Getting killed 3 times every hour specially if they are being targeted is tough on someone. I understand that sometimes the person being PK'd can be less than nice in pages, but I think it still warrants an ask on adjustment as we're trying to find ways to keep new players WITHOUT having to add things that simply won't work well, like non-pk areas, which would (to me) simply destroy the game.
Also, the system might not even be triggering enough, I.E. someone might die three times to players, but all three deaths occurred within 2 hours, not 1 hour, thus they don't get immunity. Most of the times if they run off they don't get killed several times, but I don't know how to really combat that other than adjusting the amount of hours PKs are stored for immunity to trigger. Obviously there is still that issue where being hunted for hours and not dying is a thing, but how do players actually deal with that instead of getting sick of the game or stressed? Do we tell them to level in an arena until 25 because someone has it out for you?
I understand that PK'ing is a part of the game, it will always be apart of the game. What I want however is a fair system for both sides. I was thinking either reduce the amount of kills to 2 per hour (which I don't think would work still.) or maybe increase it to 'you have to die 3 times in 3 hours for PK immunity to activate'. And obviously the other rules would still apply. Right now I don't think the system really does much because no one dies that much normally.
If anyone has any other suggestions that don't involve a non PK area feel free to suggest here.
Yes it sucks getting pked over and over. I personally love open world pvp but dont even bother unless I know that person is not a new person. I think beefing up anti pk is fine too but you have to keep in mind some people play this just for pking / pvp we dont wanna lose those guys either.
I think the above seems fine but then again I don't mind getting pked.
I think the above seems fine but then again I don't mind getting pked.
Remove pk immunity/remove pk exp loss.
a level 25 can suicide kill a boss that can figuratively drop level 25 equipment. a level 7 cant die to a mosquito without being penalized for it. i don't think much else needs said about it.
personally i dont pk levelers because if i did, its 100x more likely theyll pk my leveler aswell. id rather eliminate the downward spiral.
pking is part of the game so it need to be available. however, it is being left as a grieving tool. i dont think pkers roam the earth to grief people, but dropping 40 minutes of exp sucks for everyone. some peoople only play an hour or two a night. pks are devastating like that.
a level 25 can suicide kill a boss that can figuratively drop level 25 equipment. a level 7 cant die to a mosquito without being penalized for it. i don't think much else needs said about it.
personally i dont pk levelers because if i did, its 100x more likely theyll pk my leveler aswell. id rather eliminate the downward spiral.
pking is part of the game so it need to be available. however, it is being left as a grieving tool. i dont think pkers roam the earth to grief people, but dropping 40 minutes of exp sucks for everyone. some peoople only play an hour or two a night. pks are devastating like that.
What terron said.
No exp loss on PKing, and i even daresay no loss of items or gold. Death sickness is enough.
I'd just put, for "punishment" sake, a slight change in description after being pk'ed, something along the lines of "x is reeling from defeat"
No exp loss on PKing, and i even daresay no loss of items or gold. Death sickness is enough.
I'd just put, for "punishment" sake, a slight change in description after being pk'ed, something along the lines of "x is reeling from defeat"
Remove pk immunity/remove pk exp loss.
a level 25 can suicide kill a boss that can figuratively drop level 25 equipment. a level 7 cant die to a mosquito without being penalized for it. i don't think much else needs said about it.
personally i dont pk levelers because if i did, its 100x more likely theyll pk my leveler aswell. id rather eliminate the downward spiral.
pking is part of the game so it need to be available. however, it is being left as a grieving tool. i dont think pkers roam the earth to grief people, but dropping 40 minutes of exp sucks for everyone. some peoople only play an hour or two a night. pks are devastating like that.
What terron said.
No exp loss on PKing, and i even daresay no loss of items or gold. Death sickness is enough.
I'd just put, for "punishment" sake, a slight change in description after being pk'ed, something along the lines of "x is reeling from defeat"
That's another option, aka no PK immunity but no PK XP loss. I know this sounds terrible when I say it, but there needs to be a 'oh shit' feeling when a PKer I know that often kills passes, (and I know this as I do level on my own or with my lady). I think SOMETHING needs to be to be removed for PKing to still be somewhat worth it and fun. Items for sure, thats what SB'ing is about, theres so much abuse that can occur with no item loss (scales, etc) that would require major changes, but I think it is fine as it is. I think gold is OKAY to lose as well. If you remove all three, you make PKing kind of worthless.
I kind of feel if we do this we should maybe add 20 or 25 mil XP to all classes too. Maybe this is wrong thinking and leveling is fine as it is though.
Regardless, could work.
I think it's not a terrible idea to get rid of XP loss (keep gold and item loss, as you said it does need to be scary). Please don't add 25mil xp to lvling though lol.
I don't really pk, but here is my tuppence worth.
The game needs risk/reward.
There needs to be some kind of risk while you are out levelling (excluding the beasty your levelling on) and pkers need some kind of reward for their kill.
Remove the risk/reward factor and the game will become terribly boring.
Levellers already have more protection than they had in old rok and anyone who needs more protection than what is already in place probably needs a wet nurse (I do not think they would stay long anyway).
Anyone play Fallout 2 online? If you died there, you did not lose experience (I think) but you lost everything you had on you (if you were in a random map location - if you weren't you COULD run back to your body but then the person/thing that killed you could be waiting or likely would have looted your body anyway). Damn game was brutal, but lots of people play(ed) it.
It is fun to survive a pk attempt, it is fun to pk someone, it is fun to win in a fight.
Dying to a pker is a learning experience (or not - depends on the person <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> ).
Also, my son, one day you too will have your own 25ther (if you don't have already), then you can track down your pker (and their levelling alts) and go for revenge!
The game needs risk/reward.
There needs to be some kind of risk while you are out levelling (excluding the beasty your levelling on) and pkers need some kind of reward for their kill.
Remove the risk/reward factor and the game will become terribly boring.
Levellers already have more protection than they had in old rok and anyone who needs more protection than what is already in place probably needs a wet nurse (I do not think they would stay long anyway).
Anyone play Fallout 2 online? If you died there, you did not lose experience (I think) but you lost everything you had on you (if you were in a random map location - if you weren't you COULD run back to your body but then the person/thing that killed you could be waiting or likely would have looted your body anyway). Damn game was brutal, but lots of people play(ed) it.
It is fun to survive a pk attempt, it is fun to pk someone, it is fun to win in a fight.
Dying to a pker is a learning experience (or not - depends on the person <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> ).
Also, my son, one day you too will have your own 25ther (if you don't have already), then you can track down your pker (and their levelling alts) and go for revenge!
I'm guessing a lvl difference has been discussed, but just in case it hasn't, what about a +/- 3 lvl pk limit. Lvl 25 could only go after 22+, I'm sure people will just deck certain toons at each threshold to get their pk jollys off, but again that's a lot of work. I personally don't care PK or not PK I was just trying to meet in the middle.
OR
Or what about an option to select at the toon creation screen of you want to be PvP or not, if you select yes, game stays the same, if you select no can you give them like a 15% exp reduction. If you select no PvP that can NEVER be changed on that toon, to prevent people lvling nonpk then changing PK at 25.
OR
Or what about an option to select at the toon creation screen of you want to be PvP or not, if you select yes, game stays the same, if you select no can you give them like a 15% exp reduction. If you select no PvP that can NEVER be changed on that toon, to prevent people lvling nonpk then changing PK at 25.
I agree with Folder. Leveling is a slow hog as it is.
Perhaps then, make exp losses worse if you die to NPCs (you ninny!) and non-existent if you die to players. This might actually even help people fighting more (which is fun).
Perhaps then, make exp losses worse if you die to NPCs (you ninny!) and non-existent if you die to players. This might actually even help people fighting more (which is fun).
I agree with Folder. Leveling is a slow hog as it is.
Perhaps then, make exp losses worse if you die to NPCs (you ninny!) and non-existent if you die to players. This might actually even help people fighting more (which is fun).
That might be a good idea. Leave it for NPCs and then remove it for PVP. I don't mind removing it completely too (as it was said that a level 20 for example if they are in a OAD and die they lose XP but a level 25 does not in an OAD.)
Talking about the whole nonPK characters that Rox brought up, it's not a good idea because people will abuse it. You can make nonPK chars to run OADs or keys in and laugh as no one can kill you in key areas. Immune chars stealing things etc. Too much stuff to actually change to make it work and you'd either have to have them die anyways in areas or block them from entering. Then block them from picking up specific items, etc. It's a big hassle though I think.
I don't think we should limit it by level as well (i.e. 3 level variance max). I feel like it would be pretty boring as we already raised it to level 16, I think it's a good level around to learn that PKing is a fair thing in this game and you have enough HP to normally avoid 25'ers even if they get a hit off on you unless your exhausted. (which is a tactic).
We could raise the default drop rate to 50% too but I don't know if this is really needed. 33% on default is probably OK, just bringing it up for some comments.
I think the best option here is to either remove it completely, or remove it on PK only. Leave gold and item drops. If ya'll had to pick, what one would be better?
Remove it on PK only.
dieing to a monster is already bad enough. raising the exp loss on that makes it stupid. you will literally be saying "if a pker hits you, stand still so you don't drop 5 mil exp to a monster while trying to run away"
all it does is reduce solo training efforts because RNG kills you sometimes. oh no respawn pops outta the ground and the 2 monsters hit you 9x in a row. there goes 40 minutes. oh no some faggot drug 5 monsters on you there goes another 40 minutes. oh no lag spike there goes 40 minutes. oh no my remote link dropped there goes 40 minutes. oh no random disconnect ther....... you get the picture.
if exp loss is so important, make level 25s have to continually gain exp to stay above exp or they get permanent penalties.
all it does is reduce solo training efforts because RNG kills you sometimes. oh no respawn pops outta the ground and the 2 monsters hit you 9x in a row. there goes 40 minutes. oh no some faggot drug 5 monsters on you there goes another 40 minutes. oh no lag spike there goes 40 minutes. oh no my remote link dropped there goes 40 minutes. oh no random disconnect ther....... you get the picture.
if exp loss is so important, make level 25s have to continually gain exp to stay above exp or they get permanent penalties.
gg wp.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />
Some people simply ain't cut out for PvP games.
Removing XP loss on PvP is totally fine I think. I don't see the need to remove it for PvE deaths as those are very rare already.
Piddy isn't wrong but he's exaggerating. A death is, at most, what? 2mil xp? That's not 40 minutes unless you are lvling in all the wrong ways.
Some people simply ain't cut out for PvP games.
Removing XP loss on PvP is totally fine I think. I don't see the need to remove it for PvE deaths as those are very rare already.
Piddy isn't wrong but he's exaggerating. A death is, at most, what? 2mil xp? That's not 40 minutes unless you are lvling in all the wrong ways.
I think getting pk'ed should still result in a lost of exp. Maybe the amount loss at the moment is too much? We can possibly rework the exp lost between death by mob vs pk'ed.
There's always arenas to level in. They give less exp, but you won't have the threat of getting pk'ed. Maybe even change it so if you die in arenas you don't lose exp. If people are afraid of losing exp leveling outside, go in the arena. Another option is to join a guild and level in a party. The risk/reward needs to remain if you want to level outside.
This is the real issue, being hunted and not getting killed. The threat of always having a PK trying to kill you when you level, it's unbearable. The spooky event sounded cool, but getting hunted in the graveyard each time you step out of the town is ridiculous. You know the only way to avoid getting sick or stressed? Just quiting. Because there is nothing you can do about it.
There's always arenas to level in. They give less exp, but you won't have the threat of getting pk'ed. Maybe even change it so if you die in arenas you don't lose exp. If people are afraid of losing exp leveling outside, go in the arena. Another option is to join a guild and level in a party. The risk/reward needs to remain if you want to level outside.
gg wp.
Thats the issue, you think new players know all the best ways to level? Do you honestly think that losing 2 million exp isnt a big deal? No because you already have fking 25ers and people to protect you when you level. It's a joke that you think it's not a big deal. If you arent an established player, then yes you may be leveling in the wrong ways. Where is the guide to tell me exactly where to level and what to level on? Also, how to do that WITHOUT GETTING PKD or attacked? You are so out of touch with actual new players.
There is literally a whole wiki page dedicated to most of the mobs in-game and listing their div and level. There's a bunch of other useful information on the wiki for quests and equipment. Use that info to help you gear up and level.
Like I said, join a guild and if you do get pked ask them to go hunt down those big bad pkers like Tyrargo. Sorry if I digress. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />
for levels 22+, a death currently takes around 12-15 minutes to make back the exp. that is make it back.
in reality it took you 15m to make the exp, you die. now 15m to get back to where you were before death. thats half an hour already.
if monster death exp loss was increased? 40 minutes was a fair assessment.
none of this changes the fact that i can suicide a boss on a level 25er for purple equips and die 400x with no penalty whatsoever while being a leveler you drop exp.
here's reasons why you shouldn't penalize levelers:
-training sucks
-nothing to really do until 25
-oads/bosses have limited space(noone lets you bring levelers)
-group training is soo much more beneficial (some people wont put in any effort at all to solo train, and would rather log off)
-these implements are a double edged sword for solo expers (die more often to mobs/pkers/life)
-some of the oad timers are at very horrible times for people with real life stuff to do (like school/children)
-i didnt log on from March-September myself because of having about 45 minutes per day of free time (pointless)
people are trying to put in the 50-75 or so hours to be actually able to play the game as a 25er. the timer shouldnt get longer each time you die...
in reality it took you 15m to make the exp, you die. now 15m to get back to where you were before death. thats half an hour already.
if monster death exp loss was increased? 40 minutes was a fair assessment.
none of this changes the fact that i can suicide a boss on a level 25er for purple equips and die 400x with no penalty whatsoever while being a leveler you drop exp.
here's reasons why you shouldn't penalize levelers:
-training sucks
-nothing to really do until 25
-oads/bosses have limited space(noone lets you bring levelers)
-group training is soo much more beneficial (some people wont put in any effort at all to solo train, and would rather log off)
-these implements are a double edged sword for solo expers (die more often to mobs/pkers/life)
-some of the oad timers are at very horrible times for people with real life stuff to do (like school/children)
-i didnt log on from March-September myself because of having about 45 minutes per day of free time (pointless)
people are trying to put in the 50-75 or so hours to be actually able to play the game as a 25er. the timer shouldnt get longer each time you die...
Ah, yes, must just be me and my friends that have issues. But yea, dismiss anything I say, because obviously I am not an established player, so who cares? Just keep on with those same 20 players and im sure the game will really thrive.....
What a great experience the game is leveling in arenas which cut the exp by 50% and is a boring AF grind, also no undead (so how do i level a cleric or pally?).
Like I said, it's only the actions of a few that ruined the entire game for me. Many helpful players along the way and I was grateful to those people. But some are just cancer and made everyone I play with quit (sorry if that gets me upset, I was having fun up until I was grieved anytime i went to level). Those players are likely why no new players will stick around, at least what i've found in my personal experience with friends and coworkers.
@folder
> That's not 40 minutes unless you are lvling in all the wrong ways.
Thats the issue, you think new players know all the best ways to level? Do you honestly think that losing 2 million exp isnt a big deal? No because you already have fking 25ers and people to protect you when you level. It's a joke that you think it's not a big deal. If you arent an established player, then yes you may be leveling in the wrong ways. Where is the guide to tell me exactly where to level and what to level on? Also, how to do that WITHOUT GETTING PKD or attacked? You are so out of touch with actual new players.
I do not advocate leveling in arenas ever, they are pretty terrible. I'm sorry the game was ruined by PKing, but it really is part of the core gameplay. You can get past the point where you easily die if you stick with it a bit. Find a guild, make friends, level in groups. The game should not have to hand you XP on a platter - it is always going to be a game based on PvP. If you simply don't like that, I'm sorry, but there are other games better suited to you.
There are no huge secrets to leveling. You pretty much just hit stuff that's higher level than you and slowly rake in the XP. And no, I do not think losing 2mil XP is omg rage quit inducing. 2mil XP, once you are high enough level that your penalty is actually 2mil XP, is 15 minutes solo. That's not optimizing group exp with buffs in the top secret leveling spot, that's just going out on your own and hitting stuff.
I dunno man, everyone has been PKd in this game. It's how it works and you either get past it and join in later or you just don't like PvP and you won't enjoy this game. Sorry if you don't like that, but again that is core gameplay. Friend/Guild up. Get that XP and then fuckin fight back. It's actually fun.
.
Cydon you say 4 other people you know IRL have quit could I get there account names or emails (or if not possible maybe their characters they played)? I'd like to talk to them as well and see their stats for some information on where they stopped/etc, pretty much data. Would be helpful. Feel free to PM me the details.
In terms of NPC XP loss, I wouldn't raise it. ATM max is 1.5mil, then 750k, then 325k, if you die in a row. I'd totally be fine removing XP loss completely if that's an issue though too. But for sure it seems like PVP XP loss should be removed. PVE is debatable.
Right now I'm not sure of a real system to avoid people hunting/stalking an excessive amount of time though. It's hard to police and this is a first step in trying to make the issue more bearable.