← Forum archive

Prefix/Suffix. How to do it (MK II)

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
Let's discuss this again as I want to add it. Part of the reason for armor balancing will be because of this.

First off, I think to make the game unique all items can be effected by this. However only certain items will have maximum variation on prefix/suffix. Things like boots/gloves that are coming in shouldn't be any more then a small amount of HP/Mana, etc rather then anything fancy.

------

Second off, the ways to get prefix/suffix. Many different ways:
1. Random on drops, like humming.
2. Using the new disenchant system, you'll be able to 'reroll' your prefix/suffix on items or add new ones. Though the better the gear, the more better disenchant items you'll need. It's very simplistic disenchant system though (I.E. Purple Dust 100% disenchant chance = Level 25 Purple item disenchant)
3. Like 2., but maybe you get to pick your prefix/suffix at a very very high cost. I don't like this idea so much as it makes trading far less 'interesting'.

Right now I am in favor of 1. and 2. for how to obtain them. The disenchant system will prob be in AFTER the update too, fairly soon.

-----

Next, complexity. This doesn't mean it needs to be complicated.

There are many things prefix or suffixes can do, and we need to figure out first what kinda system we want, how many prefix/suffixes can be added, and all the prefix/suffix names. Once we hash something out we should make a nice little google sheet and start writing ideas.

First off what will prefix vs suffix entail. I assume they SHOULD be different. I think maybe prefixes will be more simplistic and you can have multiple, then only ONE suffix that is greater. A prefix could be a HP boost, MP boost, etc. A suffix could be a small stat boost (0.1 for example, it would add up with gear.) or maybe a DIVINITY % boost (though maybe div boosts should be a smaller prefix boost instead, this is up for discussion.)

I think though we should defo have scales. I.E. if the max HP boost is 20HP per gear, then it could range from 1-20HP. You could even have NEGATIVES. For example, if you get a HP prefix, it could range from -20 to 20 instead of 1-20HP. I don't think it's really needed though I am bringing it up.

-----

For the item name, I assume it would change depending maybe on what is on it and what prefix/suffixes are on a item. For example on a weapon and if divinity is a prefix and agi is a suffix, it could be like 'Fiery Iron Dagger of Agility'. If a divinity is a suffix (aka the main booster) Could be Iron Dagger of Fire, etc. I don't think all prefixes should be added, maybe only the BIGGEST one unless we can make names to 'mix' some, (or some prefix give 'sets of bonuses' rather then one bonus'. I.E. 'life' could be both HP and MP. etc)

Anyways, let's discuss moar.
S0mveraa
That sounds amazing, I'm wondering how it'd work for neutral chars, will there be a damage bonus pre/suffix that would effect them too?

I like number one btw, random is the way to go.
Terron
i think it should be random on drops up to X modifiers, then 1 major prefix and suffix added via enchanting, then up to 3 more minor modifications available with the corresponding humming level and enchant level with some randomness.

example: i kill a cultist recruiter. it drops a soft hum 4 mod item.

Tainted Cap (0/2):

Base Item: Tainted Cap
mod 1
mod 2
mod 3
mod 4
this item has an open prefix slot available:
this item has an open suffix slot available:
this item has 2 open generic sockets available:

When the item is completely outfitted it would have the name Prefix Tainted Cap of Suffix (2/2) .

basically its a variation of everything matters and its a good way a person could actually find and build up lower tier items to be very good even without them having the "highest ac".

with a bit of luck on those enchants and the random modifiers it could be worth the drop in ac. this also allows players to build equips and do some stuff solo.
Terron
in rebuttal to adding div damage to items: i dont think this is needed

i think a better idea is to boost max embers to 10% and give us long term crafting and build up options to upgrade them from 1 to 8%. nines and tens would be event, high oad, mystery auction type stuff.

maybe even slightly less powerful multiple div embers(think a special enchanted item or unique "focus" item to convert energy.)

example you convert an 8% ember to a dual 4% (converting will always round down 7% would become a dual 3) could be completely random, or even focused by placing 2 smaller 2% embers in with the craft. example: 8% ember is converted into a 4% water 4% fire ember by placing a 2% fire and 2%water ember in the craft formula.


over and out.
Miach
Im in favor of any of these ideas. I like adding variety to the game.

I would want some way to put something on my existing items while sifting through drops for new enchantments.
Kruell
I like a combination of 1 and 2. Make random drops but give people a way to "roll the dice" to get something they prefer. I think this would promote people keeping unusual combinations and open up trading/collecting.

I would probably hold off on double prefix at first but that really depends on how you want to game to develop. If you hold that back for later it can be rolled out as an expansion update without overriding whatever people have built up at that point.

Diablo 2 had a pretty good system of this and many other games including WoW use it. There are dozens of examples and templates that can be used to build a system here. Balancing fun, challenge, and power will be the hard part. Some "key" combinations could rename the weapon/armor into something completely new (build up Lore).
----

Some of these other suggestions and ideas are good too. It is possible to use different methods introduced over time. We could even have item "sockets" where embers and other special items can be stacked. (Think FF7)

I'm trying to think of things that can be done over time and compounded so there are development updates that drive the future of the game instead of allowing it to plateau or stagnate.
Wripper
we could add sockets to items too and allow us to put embers in, so say I put a night ember in my weapon that could add "night damage" to my weapon may have it do a tick like crimson weapons?

but I like the idea of random boss drops having prefixes and just giving the ability to "change" a prefix/suffix item with enchanting not adding

my 2 cents
Inverno
Pretty good. Remember my Diablo days lol.

Go for options 1 and 2.

Dunno if adding brute stats (str, agi,end,wis,int,chr) can unbalance the game.

What about a new class with disenchant skill? A skill that need to be trained over time to get better afixes/suffixes? Can be a new role in Ember economy.
Ohko
I think having 1 prefix/suffix to start off with will be simpler. We can always in the future increase the prefix to 2. I also like idea #1 and #2, not so much #3. For some mods, you can have some that boost say +25MP but have a -15HP and some just a +10MP. They can be both "common" modes, but rarer mods will not have the negative effect.
Lateralus
Think 1 and 2 are a good start and can add 3 down the road.

I think it’s more fun to have a enchanter type profession that has this spell book of enchantments they can put on items but it becomes over complicated very quick trying to decide what each spell is worth material wise so prob better to leave that off for now but maybe in the future.


You could still make a profession out of it and have diff levels etc

For example at the start you can only enchant greens then blues then purple as your skill level goes up. Also as you skill level goes up you have a better chance to produce a tier 2 or tier 3 enchantment on an item.

For balancing reasons I suggest we just target weapons and body armors.

Just my quick take will add more later.
NiteHawk
I think sockets are a bit too complex. If we''re doing something like that I'd prefer it just being even level based or rarity based. There are some good ideas here. I did eventually want more embers, but that's up for another chat and it will probably work with one or two of the passive skills you can get.

Anyways, it could be one prefix/one suffix with a few minors on items. Let's start with the minor bonuses if we go this route (which seems like a good idea).

Minor bonuses could be like humming, except we also include HP, MP, and maybe MR? I would think that every item dropped would have a chance PER bonus type so we can make it interesting. These bonuses shouldn't be able to be rerolled and aren't part of prefix/suffix.

This means items could have like:
15% chance for AC (hum)
15% chance for HP
15% chance for MP
15% chance for MR

The gem would be to get items that have all bonuses, obviously. and then prefix/suffix would either be a random dice or maybe also part of the drop chance too. That wouldn't be a terrible idea. We just need to know all minor bonuses and the amount. and what value each is to be considered worthwhile. Maybe MR too. So these are random drops only, lets give items more value to farm the same/etc.

------

Then we also need to know what prefix/suffix we want. Don't worry about the boost to stats. I have an idea for this it won't be overpowered but will be worth while for everyone. So prefix/suffixes could be a bunch of things, including exp boost, gold boost, damage to classes or races, monster damage banes on types, male/female boosts, stat boosts, armor boosts, divinity boosts, hp/mp/mr, chance to boost certain spell types or skills, etc. We can prob start with one bonus per prefix or suffix and should really think what should be what.

I.E. Prefixes:
Against Race/Class Damage Boosts
Monster Bane Boosts
Male/Female Boosts
Divinity boosts

Suffixes:
Stat boosts
Armor Boosts
HP/MP/MR
Skill/Spell bonuses
EXP/GOLD boosts

I'm not sure what would go where or what boosts we should have obv. just making ideas here.

Base: Dagger
Prefix/Suffix: Burnning Dagger Of Power
Prefix: 1% night damage bonus
Suffix: +0.1 to str


Prefix/Suffix: Ghostly Dagger of Life
Prefix: 10% damage to undead mobs.
Suffix: +20HP


:shrug: need to define the prefix/suffixes. Or maybe instead of a prefix/suffix, just one suffix that can give multiple bonuses.

Dagger of Life
+15HP
+30MP

Dagger of the Giant
+10HP
+0.1STR
+2AC

etc. Though we're start with basic ones for sure. I'm not 100% on just one though, but it might be easier to balance.
Terron
sockets are easy you craft a gem with enchanting then CTRL and drag it lol. i know u got the ability to code this(embers work)

dont use embers for more shit its bad enough 80% of new characters are neutral. gunna be even more after div agi bonus/penalty is brought into the game
NiteHawk
sockets are easy you craft a gem with enchanting then CTRL and drag it lol. i know u got the ability to code this(embers work)

dont use embers for more shit its bad enough 80% of new characters are neutral. gunna be even more after div agi bonus/penalty is brought into the game


IMO it's dumb to go neutral if you want to kill certain characters that can't go neutral divinity based.

Sockets suck. I'd rather just output the stats. Embers really aren't sockets, theres no fancy GUI to deal with them. It's a number/string var.
Terron
its your game do what u want, but everyone is going neutral for a reason. this also isnt my first rodeo. you will want armor and weapon mods to hit more playtime then just some fancy 15% when an item falls.

sockets are just mods that arent rolled when the item falls. gives players a reason to play the game outside of 6 boss spawns and key fights. they can build a few mods on a craftable that they want. most mods can be left random.

see the general idea here is to get people to PLAY the game. not just poke their ass in at 7am 12pm 2pm 4pm and 7pm.
anthriel
its your game do what u want, but everyone is going neutral for a reason. this also isnt my first rodeo. you will want armor and weapon mods to hit more playtime then just some fancy 15% when an item falls.

sockets are just mods that arent rolled when the item falls. gives players a reason to play the game outside of 6 boss spawns and key fights. they can build a few mods on a craftable that they want. most mods can be left random.

see the general idea here is to get people to PLAY the game. not just poke their ass in at 7am 12pm 2pm 4pm and 7pm.


Terron does raise a good point that somewhat delves into the wider discussion about the nature of the oading system etc. If access to prefix/suffix bonuses could be dropped by any mob (eg an enchant dust that drops like embers do) maybe It would motivate more general play by players (eg leveling, questing etc).... but I do agree that random drops of prefix/suffix bonuses on oad items are not going to motivate me to OAD more (at stupid hours for my Timezone) or want to grind out same OAD over and over more (too monotonous/repetitive and only accessible to super-guilds due to keys & spread out spawn times etc). At best I would try and buy the new items from AH. But if the prefix/suffix bonuses were somehow craftable or able to be slowly worked towards then it would give much more incentive to play more and work towards them for ppl who are casual players, in bad oad Timezones, or don’t want to join a super-guild factional warmachine. Peace.
Terron
i mean the reason hack n slash/mmo rpgs work is that you kill things alot. diablo 2 you could do boss runs in 30 seconds at times, or a couple minutes on poorer equipped stuff.

even if we had 10 oads next week and got this system inplace its literally only 10 rolls per day, if they even drop, and not everyone can enjoy it. thats the big one. i can log on an mmo and pick plants, farm gems, kill monsters for mats, kill bosses for rarer stuff, and use all that to progress an alt through crafting or something.

Hold my beer, im about to mud for 7 minutes its seta time... <---this isnt keeping people interested
Kruell
When I just said sockets I was being general and didn't mean a GUI exactly. An ember fills a "socket" on an item. Having another type of modification that works like an ember is what I was suggesting. Having the crafting system work to "reroll' a prefix though is a good idea and would work well if, like embers, certain items are universal drops. This way players don't have to farm the OaD but can instead roam the world doing things and still get a chance to gain what they want.

As to having more "embers" affecting neutral divinity gameplay, good. While neutral div has it's bonus, there should be more drawback to playing neutral. Still, I do think there needs to be something neutral can do that divinity can't but that's another issue.

Using a prefix for a variable boost to different abilities or bonuses would be great. Systems that make people trade off between bonuses makes people think. You don't have 100 ninja's in a mosh all swinging the same thing. I'm sure people would play with an item that wasn't the top slot to have modifiers that are more useful. Making the suffix the "hard stat" modifier would simplify the system and allow people to strive for the combination they desire most. Maybe even throw in a suffix that raises the minimum or maximum damage by a step (similar to hum). A weapon "of Devastation" could even be a +1 over its base form.

Code some suffix/prefix that along with a bonus they have a negative. Something like a Axe of Fumbling that gives you a negative to hit but a bonus to damage. Not sure how well that would go over on a dagger though so might not be the best example.

You could always code it that the suffix is rolled first and if a "legendary" quality is selected then no prefix is assigned but the unique quality is applied to the name/ability.

Please have a suffix or prefix that gives a blocking boost or add a base chance.
Terron
neutrals should be non event only (excluding moshes , class events , trivia)

mods and abilities on items as a whole is a grand idea. i just dont like the limiting to "pick 1 2 or 3" when the game needs more to do, outside of oads. amulets the same way, need to be dozens of options on every character and multiple ways to achieve most of that content, or the game is just stale.