← Forum archive

The current "meta" for endgame PvP

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Folder
First off this is not a condemnation of anyone using these tactics, they are viable and part of current gameplay. I have some opinions and I'm wondering how other people feel about this too...

Over the last week Silh/Defiance/Stasis have had some great PvP fights and it's been quite fun. That said the current "meta", if you will, for large-scale pvp fights consists of 2 things:

1) Group Fade
I've brought this up before! Fading your entire group is the current strategy for large fights. It denies the ability to click attack, denies the ability to see who the party leader is of course you can't see everyone that is in a room. It forces macros to be made, and forces attacks to be typed out in the meantime. It is incredibly strong and the initial advantage it gives is huge.

The problem? It doesn't wear off on hostile actions. So the final product is 2 6man groups (or more!) all swinging away at each other while faded. The gameplay feels odd and, as I have said before, will be a crippling disadvantage for anyone on a future tablet/mobile client.

Proposed solution: Fade breaks on hostile actions. Keep it viable for a surprise attack, but don't let people fight it out for X minutes at a time while invisible.

2) Ghosting (running back after death)
As it stands now running back to fights after death is very easy to do, even in dreads where there are traps. It is almost to the point of trivializing kills, especially in small scale fights where it takes a number of rounds to drop someone. In 3v3, for example, the first dead person may be back before anyone else dies.

Proposed solution: "Respawn" timer for level 25s. Upon death you can not move for...20 seconds? Not sure on exact time. Long enough to have an impact but not long enough to be terribly annoying. Maybe have it only go into effect if killed by another player?

Yes, you can get around this timer by having multiple alts camped at a location. That's a different topic though.

What do you guys think? Again this is not any sort of condemnation for using these tactics, especially since we use them too. I'm trying to improve overall gameplay here and these things bother me - they don't feel right.
daedroth
1) Fade: I already posted on Fade. I do not like it. I think attacking should break the effect. It just makes the combats silly.

2) Zombie Attack: An alternative solution would be "injuries" or "weakened state". Some games have this. Basically you can run back to the fight after being templed, but until you are inactive for X amount of time you have a -2 to all stats (or some such - could be capped at X amount of injuries). And have it accrue.
Honzo

The problem? It doesn't wear off on hostile actions. So the final product is 2 6man groups (or more!) all swinging away at each other while faded. The gameplay feels odd and, as I have said before, will be a crippling disadvantage for anyone on a future tablet/mobile client.

Proposed solution: Fade breaks on hostile actions. Keep it viable for a surprise attack, but don't let people fight it out for X minutes at a time while invisible.


Proposed solution: "Respawn" timer for level 25s. Upon death you can not move for...20 seconds? Not sure on exact time. Long enough to have an impact but not long enough to be terribly annoying. Maybe have it only go into effect if killed by another player?


These are both interesting ideas.
I agree with the Fade thing. I just dont see any reason to have complete hidden battles. Even conceptually it sounds insane and very unfun. Id like to at LEAST have a way to know who is in the room lmao. I've not been in the invisible wars but it seems like a good idea to prevent them from happening yet still giving strategic use to the spell.

Respawn timer? Interesting idea but I don't think that'd ever happen. It just comes with problems of its own like you said. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Terron
searching or spotting should just be passive, a % chance to break hide/fade/autosneak. that way everytime a hidden character enters square it may be revealed. perhaps spot % = to half of your intelligence. (the only foreseeable problem is with backstabs but that should be changed to a lower multiplier * remaining stam anyway. like 2.0x damage and all stamina used. a much simpler 1 and done per round)

i think the physical stamina draining search should remain aswell and work on fade.
Folder
1) Fade: I already posted on Fade. I do not like it. I think attacking should break the effect. It just makes the combats silly.

2) Zombie Attack: An alternative solution would be "injuries" or "weakened state". Some games have this. Basically you can run back to the fight after being templed, but until you are inactive for X amount of time you have a -2 to all stats (or some such - could be capped at X amount of injuries). And have it accrue.


Didn't think of an injury/weakened state. That could work as well! Just trying to think of something to discourage all of us from running back to the same fight in an endless stream.

Not sure how I feel about chance to be spotted, I think that's what search is for now. Perhaps having search find faded people?
Folder
As in a dispel magic type of thing? If you cast it on a square with someone Faded it will expose them? Could be a cool idea.
CGI
Either a room effect or targeted effect, then should disable re-fade for set amount of time.

Another option is anti-fade should be added to fairiefire if it isn't part of the spell already.
NiteHawk
FF could be an anti-fade tactic, thats a good idea. Having it effect everyone is too extreme and ruins fade completely if you want some other propositions in place, like stopping on an hostile action.

I can see fade stopping on an action that triggers the combat timer, however, only on your end. This is going to require some code fixes though since the combat timer doesn't define what's hostile and whats not really. I don't think it needs to go any more past this, otherwise you gimp the use of fade completely. It should not be searched out, it is not a searchable action, I.E. hiding.

---

Ghosting is an issue but the 20 second delay won't solve anything. Weakened states normally work fine though.

Normally with weakened states, PVP would inflict a longer timer (including pets), and PVE would have a far less impact. For example, in PVE it would last 30 seconds only. In PVP it might last 2 minutes, maybe more, depends on what we can agree is a better time. I have an idea though.

If you zombie, your stats will continue to get worse until your character is completely worthless and even if it is on field, you'd die like a brick.

In PVP:
1st death: 2 minute timer and -2 to all stats.
2nd death: 5 minute timer and -4 to all stats.
3rd death: 10 minute timer and -6 to all stats.
4th death and up: 10 (or 15) minute timer and -20 to all stats.

This obviously won't help if people switch characters to PVP. I don't know what to do in that case but eventually they will run out of characters to use that aren't in a weakend state. You would actually have to be on for the set time above for it to reset, you can't just log off for 10 minutes and come back.

PVE doesn't need to do anything serious, I'd say always 30 seconds but increase the stats each time. It's not a big deal though whatever we do on the PVE side long as its short so let's not dwaddle about it.

The times can be changed depending on how everyone feels is acceptable.
Folder
I like weakened state, and yea definitely agree that this is about PvP not PvE so the penalty needn't be as severe. 30 seconds is fine for PvE imo.

Your proposed timers/stat debuffs sound like a fine starting point to me. I htink -2 sounds like it's enough of a compromise that maybe people will want to run back, but they'll be making a sacrifice to do so.

Re: switching alts. Shrug, whatever I guess. I've never thought of a good solution to this one but it's not really a huge deal (maybe will be after this tho lol).

Re: fade. I'm not sure that a druid would realistically be combating a group of 6 faded people. If you sit out of morph to cast FF you're just asking to get wrecked. I think it's a fine idea and I can see it going in, but fade stopping on an action is the better solution to the group fade fights.
Terron
i was just considering a "search" as a listen and spot check.

fact is fade should just be a cloak of invisibility and immediately end if you get attacked or attack someone or get searched out, because invisible or not a lizard could smell you and elves would hear you. (monsters shouldnt detect you)

the feariefire thing would work if feariefire lasted as long as a torch, or a longer duration for higher int possibly(not really used on the class because of point issues). either way it ends up some coding issues.


lastly, after reading these forums almost everyone complains there isnt enough pk(fighting) in general, i don't see how deaths gimping stats temporarily is going to help that, its only benefiting those who play copious amounts of time and train extra alts.
when the game is larger in the future people wont run across the map in 25 seconds like they do now. and when theres more adequate bossing options later, players wont be able to hit every spawn, they will be choosing A or B or even C. eliminating potential fights in the process. gimp death stats just ensures its a 1 and done more than a cat fight to the death 9 times. it may even the odds so to speak atm, but thats a definite drop in the fun meter later on.
Folder
I think the problem with ghosting is that there's no real downside to dying. It's sometimes actually better to die because you can run back together. I feel people would actively try harder to stay alive if death meant more than it does now.

For me it's not about evening any odds, it's about improving gameplay quality. But I started this to hear opinions so let's have em!
NiteHawk
i was just considering a "search" as a listen and spot check.

fact is fade should just be a cloak of invisibility and immediately end if you get attacked or attack someone or get searched out, because invisible or not a lizard could smell you and elves would hear you. (monsters shouldnt detect you)

the feariefire thing would work if feariefire lasted as long as a torch, or a longer duration for higher int possibly(not really used on the class because of point issues). either way it ends up some coding issues.


lastly, after reading these forums almost everyone complains there isnt enough pk(fighting) in general, i don't see how deaths gimping stats temporarily is going to help that, its only benefiting those who play copious amounts of time and train extra alts.
when the game is larger in the future people wont run across the map in 25 seconds like they do now. and when theres more adequate bossing options later, players wont be able to hit every spawn, they will be choosing A or B or even C. eliminating potential fights in the process. gimp death stats just ensures its a 1 and done more than a cat fight to the death 9 times. it may even the odds so to speak atm, but thats a definite drop in the fun meter later on.


I don't mind adjusting values to be less effecting etc in the future if it's needed though, but we are looking at the current time. Everything can be adjusted.
daedroth
Is the problem with fade basically if you make it so that when you attack you become visible, it also affects if you are attacked? As in monsters infravision/search will find a faded person - and this is not wanted?
If that is the case would it be possible give fade a + to the chance of avoiding being found (make the + so high it would be impossible to find the people faded - so that the people faded would never be found) but the spell will still break when they attack?
Another option: just take the name literally, it is named "fade", not invisibility, and make it searchable (which has already been proposed). Not so keen on that one though.

The changing people thing (as oppossed to ghosting): Is it possible to lock the account for 10 seconds or some such? Have the alt that logged off not in the game but "ghosted".
Going by what NH has said in the other thread about logging, that may not be possible.
Vindal
I also don't like the fade mechanic at all, but its hard to say what can be done to improve it. Making yourself appear when attacking/attacked makes the spell borderline worthless, maybe yeah you can be faded but with a -agi or something?

Personally, ghosting or alt switching doesn't bother me, but I wouldn't be opposed to a stat loss on death either to make it more bothersome. M If there was going to be any changes alt changing etc. it should be to stop character transfers between an account. A single person should be able to go back and forth between all 10 25ers if they got em. They leveled it, they earned it. They can bring them to battle. But account sharing, transferring 25ers to lowbies, and moving characters between people before an event/key/oad is a ruiner for me. An hour lockout after transferring isn't long enough, should be a week or more.
CGI
Maybe give Necros the anti-face spell?

ABC casts solidify at XYZ, making them reappear. XXs timer before you can be faded again.
daedroth
But account sharing, transferring 25ers to lowbies, and moving characters between people before an event/key/oad is a ruiner for me. An hour lockout after transferring isn't long enough, should be a week or more.


It does seem a little short, but I think a week is too long. A day maybe? That way you wouldn't be able to prepare for impromptu moshes/events. However there could be a counter in place for that when a character has been transferred THEN it cannot be transferred again for a week.
Could even be brutal and put a limit on how many times a character can be transferred (total limit or time based).

I am not so bothered about account sharing, as long as people do not complain if their "friend" steals all their gear or whatever. You should know/guess at the risks involved peeps.
Honzo
I also don't like the fade mechanic at all, but its hard to say what can be done to improve it. Making yourself appear when attacking/attacked makes the spell borderline worthless, maybe yeah you can be faded but with a -agi or something?

Personally, ghosting or alt switching doesn't bother me, but I wouldn't be opposed to a stat loss on death either to make it more bothersome. M If there was going to be any changes alt changing etc. it should be to stop character transfers between an account. A single person should be able to go back and forth between all 10 25ers if they got em. They leveled it, they earned it. They can bring them to battle. But account sharing, transferring 25ers to lowbies, and moving characters between people before an event/key/oad is a ruiner for me. An hour lockout after transferring isn't long enough, should be a week or more.



Not sure about a -agi but break on attack does seem like a good idea to me, personally. As far as the account sharing issue goes, I think it's a problem myself but I can see where it is "part of the game." Trading characters seems to be part of the commerce as well as "leveling jobs." I think a day is too short too. I suggested 7 days in the past and it -did not- go over well with like..anyone really. lol. Unsure what to do about it, but I think that being able to loan people chars etc. to do things kind of stinks. That being said, I can't even begin to judge how many events we would have really had if people hadn't. There was a couple of yall(I could probably name you off, it's so few) that went on crazy leveling sprees and already have tons of 25's though! Not sure what their opinion would be on this. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />

Maybe give Necros the anti-face spell?

ABC casts solidify at XYZ, making them reappear. XXs timer before you can be faded again.


Interesting idea but idk about a new spell..maybe tacked on to Wither and nerf the dmg bonus some?
JadeFalcon
When a 25er dies, he should be given a 15m "aura of defeat", basically a spell giving -2 on every stat.

That will make death "count", decreasing "returns to battle", without being overly onerous.
Folder
Making anti-fade spells is overcomplicating imo. What's the purpose of fade? To me it's to move around undetected and gain a surprise attack, it's not to fight forever while invisible. It doesn't make sense lore-wise or gameplay-wise, to me at least. I think the initial surprise attack still makes the spell worthwhile, but maybe that's just me. Staying faded with a stat loss sounds sucky to me, especially since it can't be cancelled.

About account sharing - hrmm. A week seems quite long. Is this really a problem you think? I don't even remember the last time I transferred an alt, I think it's probably been 3-4 weeks. I know of one guildie who transferred an alt to a friend recently, but that's 1 alt over the course of weeks. Maybe it's more prevalent elsewhere. Anyways a week seems unnecessarily long if you'd like to be able to help a friend or complete a leveling job or whatever.

Still think a stat loss on death is good, just don't make it so extreme that the first death means you can't possibly go back.

Logging multiple alts - shrug. It's a thing but not game breaking, at least not atm. You're generally at a disadvantage if you are logging in on your own in group fights, it's already risky enough imo.