← Forum archive

pk ideas thread

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
post


What I am saying though is, I get the EXP thing, but theres no way I could leave the EXP cap right at level 25. It would have to be 5 or 10% over cap. Losing your level simply from one death to me is very weird design. I however get your idea otherwise. So I.E. If your level 25 exp is 200mil, then your cap would be 210-220mil.

Could even go as far as after a certain number of kills, they become a murderer and can not reenter town until they die?

Also disallowing someone to enter until they die is weird as well . It would have to be both either time based or when they die.

It also prevents people from moving freely. Unless the difference would be instead that they can be PK'd anywhere for X amount of minutes rather then barred. Because they'll be locked in one area. Killing one person then getting locked to 50 squares because of the way the towns are setup would feel slow, very slow and boring.
Ardrahz
i feel we just need a fun way to spark PKK interest
If he kills more than 3 ppl an our, make it an event, he cant safely log, bcast get made. 1st to kill gets 1-5pp?
there are ways to abuse THAT
but you see where im going
Finding way to promote fighting back. Because as it stands, there is no reason to bother with it
and if person can survive 10mins we will say? they get 1-5 pp
NiteHawk
There was also something about a criminal system that you said, but mixed in with the EXP loss or a risk of losing SB'd gear (lets say 5% when your a criminal per item) for example. That might be too extreme though, but I'm throwing everything here to spark discussion and ideas. Generally pking multiple times would make you a criminal for X time. Dying while you are a criminal will remove you from being a criminal but you'd lose EXP or the other idea was any gear on you SB or not has a chance to drop 5% putting risk on the PKer. Obviously people would freak out about losing something they just bought for huge amount of PP etc so I don't exactly feel thats = to a couple mill XP though. Losing XP would be better. But throwing ideas out there for people to discuss.
maverickhatter
I would agree with turning it into an event or hit list for pp. that actually sounds amazing. I would hate to have anyone lose exp for a level after grinding so hard to hit 25 cause that is grueling. I would favor anything that brings more event like opportunities to the game.
NiteHawk
Someone was claiming they did something similar in NM where at max level you'd lose XP and it hurt the game a huge deal, just throwing that out there too, not sure how valid it is, maybe someone can talk about it as I see NM similar to ROK and it's good to get info if a similar game has done it.
Lateralus
Someone was claiming they did something similar in NM where at max level you'd lose XP and it hurt the game a huge deal, just throwing that out there too, not sure how valid it is, maybe someone can talk about it as I see NM similar to ROK and it's good to get info if a similar game has done it.



It ruined pvp and then slowly ruined the game. You did lose exp to every level not just if a lower level killed you but yea I'd be very careful about that.

I think a good first step is reducing exp loss to deaths if the player is higher level than you. You still loose good equipment and have to walk back.
Miach
A few hardcore PvP games I've played introduced criminal status where if caught you had to buy back your gear from a jailer.

While that was interesting it wasn't fun. Instead I suggest:

Pay a fee of gold based on the extremity if your criminal status. Think elder scrolls getting caught by a guard with bounty in your head. You have to pay it.

Bounty variable accumulates over time, takes way longer to go away than to gain.

Example: gain 5k bounty per kill, bounty diminishes at 1k per hour. Person who kills the criminal gets 10% of the bounty as reward and criminal goes to jail instead of temple respawn. To get out of jail the bounty must reach zero or be paid by the criminal.

I am fully in favor of the above system and it can be tweaked if the suggested amounts of bounty are too high or too low.
anthriel
There was also something about a criminal system that you said, but mixed in with the EXP loss or a risk of losing SB'd gear (lets say 5% when your a criminal per item) for example. That might be too extreme though, but I'm throwing everything here to spark discussion and ideas. Generally pking multiple times would make you a criminal for X time. Dying while you are a criminal will remove you from being a criminal but you'd lose EXP or the other idea was any gear on you SB or not has a chance to drop 5% putting risk on the PKer. Obviously people would freak out about losing something they just bought for huge amount of PP etc so I don't exactly feel thats = to a couple mill XP though. Losing XP would be better. But throwing ideas out there for people to discuss.


Agree that there would have to be some penalty/risk to dying as a 25er if there was criminal system that was to work in relation to deterring excessive PKing... otherwise it's pointless ... Heck if no consequence to dying then. id Pk someone and then let the nearest mob kill me so I could just re-enter town quickly... Not that I really have any a reason to enter town except that the game map doesn't leave alternative for me to get around the world except by going through towns like bit/turen/linwood/canopia.

I get what folder is saying about the power structure of games like this and I'm not trying to overhaul 99.9% of it... I just think there needs to be a small chink in the 25er's immortal/consequenceless dying that allows people a way to fight back and cause them to think twice about trying for a PK... Otherwise what happens when all the existing players have finished levelling a 25er of every class and there are no new players coming up because it's too intimidating...Who do you kill then? Sounds like a dead game (ie glorified chat room) by then and it's probably too late at that stage to fix it. Basically the main reason we are having this entire discussion at all is because of low player base and the existing system (esp as time goes by) will just make it harder for new players to climb the power structure and with not much reward for them (ie even if they can finally reach 25 club they will likely find they can't kill the ppl that used to kill them who are no longer levelling and must now only just pass it forward to even more newbies - repeating the cycle)

If exp loss in unpalatable as a punishment then my only other suggestion (ie the only other thing that might meaningfully impact a 25er) would be to lose X PP if killed by a sub-25er (lore wise this fits too as u literally lose prestige) ... However I like this idea somewhat less than my previous suggestion because it's a less natural fix and open to more abuse... Eg as was mentioned in the previous posts about the suggestion of losing gold, it doesn't have any bite it if you have zero PP (unless you allow accounts to go negative but then ppl will probably just create new accounts and move all their crits over in order to at least get back to zero etc)

I mean another quite effective solution (which I offer only in jest to illustrate the imbalance of power in a newbie's perception) would probably be for PKers to extort 'protection money' from newbie levellers to leave them alone.... But of course this would make EO similar to the mafia and even more super unfriendly to newbies joining us.

I don't know anymore. I feel too invested in this already. Of course existing players who have worked hard to get 25ers want to keep/hold every shred of power that they can... But if it's too imbalanced vs new player then I feel that isn't good for any of us who want longevity of game and larger playerbase either. So hopefully my contributions here have given players and NH some things to consider from a new player perspective. Thanks to all who actually took the time to read my long posts and give careful consideration to them.
daedroth
...Pay a fee of gold based on the extremity if your criminal status. Think elder scrolls getting caught by a guard with bounty in your head. You have to pay it.

Bounty variable accumulates over time, takes way longer to go away than to gain.

Example: gain 5k bounty per kill, bounty diminishes at 1k per hour. Person who kills the criminal gets 10% of the bounty as reward and criminal goes to jail instead of temple respawn. To get out of jail the bounty must reach zero or be paid by the criminal...


Thats pretty much what I said a page or more back.
Except it was only jail if no money on the criminal.
REVENGE IS MINE!
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />

Ps.
Making the Pker lose exp... doesnt work. Characters do not lose levels, you lose exp until 25th aye, but you cannot actually go back in levels. So how would it work? Only 25th can go back a level? Then as NH says you would need to increase the max exp a 25ther can hold. It also costs a lot to level to 25th, although you could look at that as the "risk of pking".
The Dropping soulbound stuff... seems like a bad idea to me. How would it work? Reason why it COULD make sense is your God is peeved you are going around killing people... however then you would really need to expand on the whole religion thing, I mean I am sure Fire god would like you kiling Night/Ice divs right? Nah... I do not like that.
You would need a piety rating? Donation to the church to increase and stuff... meh... too much hassle.
Soulbound should be soulbound if not then it should apply to everyone.
Plus it has the potential of being used as a free unsb scroll <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Be a pain to make it work like that but still do-able.
Then what about clan fights/events?
You would also need to have it so that it only worked on a pker (as in the initiated an attack against a non pker, and if you can check that someone initiated an attack like that, then surely you could use a criminal system then... but, I did say I wouldnt post again...).
anthriel
Since the risk of un-levelling 25ers was too unpalatable for most, I think I've come up with a new idea that seems to combine many of the suggestions already on this thread and should hopefully achieve the aims that most suggest would be good for the game.

Basically it's to introduce an "Assassin Credential" item into the game. Here is how it would work:

1. All 25ers are restricted to X Number of PKs of sub-25ers in a 24hr period. X should be enough to allow normal 25ers to kill insolent people and drop stealers etc. If you try to kill more than X sub-25ers a message appears saying "You feel that this action would raise the attention of the Assassins Guild"
2. There is a new NPC (eg in linwood sewers) called "Assassin guild officer" or something who sells an item "assassins credtential" that effectively lets you continue killing more than X sub-25ers when equipped.
3. The "assassin credentials" would need to cost enough (either pp or gold) to introduce a legitimate risk to those wanting to PK sub-25ers 'excessively'.
4. The credentials cannot be soul bound and will drop 100% of time when killed by any other player (25er or sub-25er). The intended victim, defending guild mates or PKKers who are successful in killing off the PKer can then sell the fallen PKers credentials to cash in for a reward (perhaps for the cost of the credentials in the first place)
5. Credentials can be stored in vault etc for events/key battles etc... PKers only need to carry them when out on the hunt for kills over the X number.

Hopefully this seems to achieve most of the aims previously raised:
- it adds risk to PKer and a way/incentive to meaningfully fight back as a victim or with 25er alts/guild help
- it facilitates a PKK system and rewards for doing so, while acting as a natural deterrent/risk to excessive PK harassment of newbies
- its an effective vehicle to facilitate the 'fine' or 'transfer of gold' from the fallen PKer to the PKKer that so many suggested
- it seems to fit lore-wise

If you like the idea then the main issues to nut out are what is an appropriate X limit and what is an appropriate cost for the credentials. Look forward to hearing any suggestions that may be able to tweak/improve upon this base suggestion.
Reaper
I didn't read all of this thread, but it feels like it is getting out of hand. Just keep the crap like it is but do the lesser exp loss after so many. Keep the 3 limit per hour, or even lessen it to 2. Whatever. Pking is hard enough as it is with how much health people get. Landing 2 backstabs doesn't happen that often.

Edit:

I mean if pking gets overly complicated with jail and bounties and crap I just won't play anymore. Pking is why I loved RoK and this. If it becomes some big ordeal I'd rather just not bother with it. If it is what the community wants then by all means. It's just not for me.
Miach
I'm still a fan of my bounty system I suggested. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
daedroth
I'm still a fan of my bounty system I suggested. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />


Yeh, your idea, check page 7 mate <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
I mentioned a crime/bounty system, NH mentioned a possible problem to the crime/bounty system there, I tried to counter argue (feel free to add to it).

Also... what about thieves for when they rob someone? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Kidding, I'm kidding! That would be a nightmare to implement, in a semi realistic way, within the bounds of the programming (the robbed would need to see the thief, gold robbed/person robbed would need to be tallied etc).

Originally Anthriel idea sounded decent, then I thought about it more. Pk'ers should be allowed to pk without having to pay a fee first (if it was considered an Assassin Guild thing, then there would need to be repercussions from the guild, as in assassins being sent to kill the rule breaker... eh... that would be fun but may make the thing overly complex).
I also thought along the same lines of Reaper. I rarely ever pk and it would take a lot of effort to get me annoyed about being pkd, but there are some people who play largely for the pk aspect of the game. If you make pk'ing too restrictive then they will leave, which is as bad as newbies (or those with an aversion of being pkd) leave.
Someone who will leave because of the pking aspect probably wouldn't stay that long anyway (as someone else said). Once the new player has played for a bit, they will toughen up and start to see the challenge of avoiding being pkd.
Some of the most memorable experiences I have had have been through the pvp aspect - either because I died really stupidly or because I won against the odds.
Who also can forget the pages you sometimes receive from irate people you have just pwnd?
Also remember, once you are 25th, you can go for payback (believe it or not, you might actually start pking as well... I never thought I would pk when I first started).
Anyway, enough ramblings.

And yeh I still like THE bounty/criminal system <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />
anthriel
I'm still a fan of my bounty system I suggested. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />


The idea seems ok but I probably still just dont understand how it works properly because it seems to be open to abuse.

Like under the system you suggested, what is stopping a PKer who repeatedly kills his friend from accumulating a large bounty and then having his friend log a 25er to kill him back so that they can split the 10% of the gold they get as reward? If the money is system generated (ie comes from no-where) then this is what i foresee happening...

That's why i suggested the Assassin Credential... its not so much a fee for PKing as Deadroth put it... its more like a mechanism to ensure the reward/bounty/fine for getting PKKed (which is effectively paid upfront) is coming out of the PKer's account rather than system-generated cash that can be farmed/abused... therefore PKer has incentive not to die.. and PKKer has incentive to kill him

Happy for you to clarify your idea if you cbb Miach. In any case i would love to see some sort of risk for PKers and incentive for PKKers introduced to make the game more interesting
daedroth
I'm still a fan of my bounty system I suggested. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />


The idea seems ok but I probably still just dont understand how it works properly because it seems to be open to abuse.

Like under the system you suggested, what is stopping a PKer who repeatedly kills his friend from accumulating a large bounty and then having his friend log a 25er to kill him back so that they can split the 10% of the gold they get as reward? If the money is system generated (ie comes from no-where) then this is what i foresee happening...

That's why i suggested the Assassin Credential... its not so much a fee for PKing as Deadroth put it... its more like a mechanism to ensure its more like a mechanism to ensure the reward/bounty/fine for getting PKKed (which is effectively paid upfront) is coming out of the PKer's account ...


Well the bounty one I proposed on page 7, the fine/bounty came from the pker, but off course it is only if the pker is killed before the fine/bounty disappeared.
JadeFalcon
All these ideas suck, except for the under 25er to stop losing exp after repeatedly being pked.


this
Reaper
All these ideas suck, except for the under 25er to stop losing exp after repeatedly being pked.


this


That