Race Stat Changes
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
So, you are talking about nerfing stats, adding end to the lil folk (DE, Gnome, Lings) and taking away from the bigger folk (Horcs and Dwarfs)?
Isnt that the opposite of balancing?
Only thing Dwarves have going for them is HPs and Horcs Str, neither class can dodge so really need both. Wouldn't it be easier to balance damage, I mean do we want pvp interaction or people getting rounded before they even know they were attacked?
I have a Ling minstrel that lasts longer in a fight then most of my zerker's, ninjas and slayers. Its dmg output is comparable to all of those classes except the slayers, minus flurry and RH of course, but if you hit and dodge more those attacks dont matter, have to be alive to land them.
Just one example of a class/race that fits well and I'm just thinking maybe that's why some class/races do better if they are matched up properly, like a horc priest should suck.
Just my 2 cents
Isnt that the opposite of balancing?
Only thing Dwarves have going for them is HPs and Horcs Str, neither class can dodge so really need both. Wouldn't it be easier to balance damage, I mean do we want pvp interaction or people getting rounded before they even know they were attacked?
I have a Ling minstrel that lasts longer in a fight then most of my zerker's, ninjas and slayers. Its dmg output is comparable to all of those classes except the slayers, minus flurry and RH of course, but if you hit and dodge more those attacks dont matter, have to be alive to land them.
Just one example of a class/race that fits well and I'm just thinking maybe that's why some class/races do better if they are matched up properly, like a horc priest should suck.
Just my 2 cents
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15EUNEHza_TEiL4Qw-RofGVNX1mcBPQ0T9Ri8pB3EfXA/edit?usp=sharing
Fucking around based on your values and mine, maybe that would be better on what is there now?
I thought your original proposal better... The fighter races side of spectrum seem to work ok and don't need changing imo... On the balance/magic races side, Ling/gnome could use a buff cos of how important HP is in the game and Elf/DE (possibly Hum and HE) could use corresponding buffs also to ensure they aren't made useless by the Ling/gnome buffs.
My 2 cents on thoughts shared by others:
1. I kind of agree with Lat's comment that INT just isn't as important to overall gameplay as other stats (not saying it should be, but we need to be realistic that giving a -1/+1 INT change isn't that game-changing for a race)
2. I disagree with Eld's spreadsheet comment that a 24int gnome could be an OP Mage cos tbh I'd prolly still not want to use it cos it dies too easily in both pvp and pve (if I had to use such a gnome I'd still +1 End or Agi if possible rather than Int).... I do agree with Eld's observation that buffing gnomes without buffing elves could leave elves more overshadowed
3. I disagree with NH's comment that he kept Goblins wisdom low otherwise they would make OP Druids... Even if you gave Gobs max 20 wis (and they actually had enough allocation points to make a Druid with max Wis/Agi/Str/End), the way you have done the morph scaling formula and its high dependence on wis rather than base stats makes me doubt they would overshadow the Elementals at 24 wis... I'm guessing they'd only come out at around 28-29 Str and 24ish Agi in cat morph which isn't great compared to Eles for the same HP.
Basically I suspect there are probably 2 fundamental issues that have cause need to rebalance races more drastically from the values largely used in RoK:
1. Potion cooldown in EO means HP matters most in any group fight / OAD party cos it allows you to hold on till priest can heal. Veterans likely won't care about getting max Int for an extra 8-16 damage per blast when u can quite easily die b4 being able to use it.
2. Introduction of races like Elemental alongside morph formulas that focus only on their advantages make them the premier race for Druids... They are also currently top choice for mages imo (due to importance of HP) ... All of this has resulted in need for entire MR system changes and now rebalancing of overshadowed races etc just to try and deal with outliers like these.
Perhaps an easier fix would be to (a) close the End gap as you originally intended to make HP considerations less pronounced and (b) then to look at how you can fix acute issues that cause imbalance such as Elemental race or Druid morph scaling formula.
Horc is your strongest possible melee fighter with the highest end, horc needs the lowest possible magic resis, compared to Drake at 12 wis, they should be switched
Gnome: +1 Agl seems fine. I think they should be a bit more dodgy.
Goblin: I think are fine the way they are. Their INT should be somewhere between Horc/Human, 15 INT is meh - I just do not see them being that dumb.
Dark Elf: +1 End seems fine... in this game they are the physical elfs, so it makes sense.
Hafling: Undecided, I think they should be fragile, but I also think they need something.
Humans: I think should have 13 CHR baseline that doesnt cost points, but you cant put any lower. They really need something, and that would not be over powering.
Horcs/Dwarves: I think are fine the way they are. I think the proposed changes would make them meh. Dwarves are decent, but they are not OP the way they are. Horcs already fair poorly vs sauria in physical combat, taking away their STR would make that even worse (esp. With AGL changes upcoming).
Idea on Horcs though... rename them orcs or add in orcs as a race and set the horcs somewhere in between human and orcs and have orcs use the horcs stats right now.
Goblin: I think are fine the way they are. Their INT should be somewhere between Horc/Human, 15 INT is meh - I just do not see them being that dumb.
Dark Elf: +1 End seems fine... in this game they are the physical elfs, so it makes sense.
Hafling: Undecided, I think they should be fragile, but I also think they need something.
Humans: I think should have 13 CHR baseline that doesnt cost points, but you cant put any lower. They really need something, and that would not be over powering.
Horcs/Dwarves: I think are fine the way they are. I think the proposed changes would make them meh. Dwarves are decent, but they are not OP the way they are. Horcs already fair poorly vs sauria in physical combat, taking away their STR would make that even worse (esp. With AGL changes upcoming).
Idea on Horcs though... rename them orcs or add in orcs as a race and set the horcs somewhere in between human and orcs and have orcs use the horcs stats right now.
2. Introduction of races like Elemental alongside morph formulas that focus only on their advantages make them the premier race for Druids... They are also currently top choice for mages imo (due to importance of HP) ... All of this has resulted in need for entire MR system changes and now rebalancing of overshadowed races etc just to try and deal with outliers like these.
Perhaps an easier fix would be to (a) close the End gap as you originally intended to make HP considerations less pronounced and (b) then to look at how you can fix acute issues that cause imbalance such as Elemental race or Druid morph scaling formula.
Yeah Druids need to be looked at in general, mainly their formulas/etc.
I will state that, for enchanters:
1. There are about 70 enchanters in the game at the moment.
2. 59% are gnomes. 22% are elves, 8% are elementals, 6% are halflings. Rest are scattered races.
A lot of people, at least on discord, disagree that gnomes are useless in any case.
---
Gnome: +1 Agl seems fine. I think they should be a bit more dodgy.
Goblin: I think are fine the way they are. Their INT should be somewhere between Horc/Human, 15 INT is meh - I just do not see them being that dumb.
Dark Elf: +1 End seems fine... in this game they are the physical elfs, so it makes sense.
The thing is goblins are literally overshadowing dark-elves.
Right now its:
DE: 20 22 18 20 20 16
Gob: 19 22 20 17 17 14
But with the MR bonus it's more like:
DE: 20 22 18 20 20 16
Gob: 19 22 20 17 20 14
Meaning you lose one str, in favor of two end. Int has a impact but not so much on paladins etc. The MR bonus is probably to high in general, anyways.
---
So, you are talking about nerfing stats, adding end to the lil folk (DE, Gnome, Lings) and taking away from the bigger folk (Horcs and Dwarfs)?
Isnt that the opposite of balancing?
Only thing Dwarves have going for them is HPs and Horcs Str, neither class can dodge so really need both. Wouldn't it be easier to balance damage, I mean do we want pvp interaction or people getting rounded before they even know they were attacked?
Actually the reason for dropping Dwarves to 22END is that some chars sit at 1450-1480HP. That's a bit crazy. It also helps fix the gap but on the other way (for example, instead of 18 end to 23 end, its 17 end to 22 end.) They (right now) are -3 str for MR pretty much.
Dropping the half-orc STR was something I'm playing with, it's not a set in stone thing. The thing is though if you bump up damage or lower damage, you'll accidentally make other races gain an advantage or disadvantage without wanting to do that. Same reason why just bumping up END wouldn't work, as other races would also benefit from it, making the effects of the change not so good. My issue is that 25 STR HO's are 'really' difficult to balance. 25 STR also makes some derpy high damage when you factor in multipliers, which is a problem.
I would think that with these changes though AGI would need alot less impact of a change too, anyways.
But the only races that I am proposing atm are De and Lings atm.. I mean with lings you're still gonna be sitting around 960HP vs 1200HP-1225HP on average.
Right now 25 str HO slayers deal 762 max with a 4% ember, dwing, and a radiant dagger. 748 max with a brill. Not factoring in some reduction with armor but it's not that much lost. Dunno about that. The loss of the STR would be about 28-30 damage removed from it.
Not to go totally off topic but I think some of this stems from int not having a huge impact. I think its the reason we are seeing dwarf clerics and paladins do so well the healing amount and even damage amount isnt that huge per point. I mean you can get +180-240hp and at 17int compared to 20int and only lose what 30-40 healing hp on aid? maybe 10-12hp on a paladin per heal?
We lowered the amount healed because it ended up being infinity fights when it was higher. It's more around 18HP for heal though, which (to me) is not too bad.
I'm not sure where you get this dwarf paladin/cleric thing being a thing though. Out of the created clerics, 28 are dwarf. (which is actually surprising.) I get that you have to factor in some things but even with the numbers 158 are elves, 82 are freaking gnomes, 48 are HE, 100 are human, 30 are lings, 73 are elemental, 12 are DE. 28 dwarves.
To me, 40HP per aid is a pretty good amount specially as your not comparing min/max int values of some races. Physical damage is literally 6-10 damage per point too, so it's quite similar, and seems to be good. Could be a little higher but not by much.
For paladins, 95 are dwarves, 95 are elf, 6 are elemental, 29 are DE, 68 are ling, 40 HE, 92 human. Paladins I can understand as you never really max INT out I would assume though still on elves/etc it is higher overall from what I can see. 18HP more per heal isn't that bad to me either.
When it comes to blasting, if max damage with about 10% div is around 198 damage with burst and 23 int, that means 17 int is at around 150 damage, and 20 int is 174. Again, could do with small tweaks, but it's not really far off. I'm not against/for giving gnomes a +1 yet but the other solution is to tweak INT as you say so it impacts a litle more per int point, thus giving something similar. The higher INT goes, the harder it is to balance if you guys feel that int is not enough per point.
... The thing is goblins are literally overshadowing dark-elves.
Right now its:
DE: 20 22 18 20 20 16
Gob: 19 22 20 17 17 14
But with the MR bonus it's more like:
DE: 20 22 18 20 20 16
Gob: 19 22 20 17 20 14
Meaning you lose one str, in favor of two end. Int has a impact but not so much on paladins etc. The MR bonus is probably to high in general, anyways.
But if you give the DE +1 END then they wont be.
But if you give the DE +1 END then they wont be.
I think just lowering the bonus to 15% instead of 20% would be enough if we give DE +1 end yeah. People aren't factoring in stat allocation, which DE's are better at too for paladins/etc. With lower wisdom, you don't need to give them as many allocation points, thus they can't be 'as good' for classes that require many stats. If the wisdom was increased, you'd give them 2-3 allocation points too, thus making them too equal/similar. So I think it's actually OK as it is with just giving DE a +1 and lowering the racial MR bonus on gobins to 15%.
Based on max wis and the changes, its 36.5% hitrate with HE and 39% hitrate with Goblins, so fairly similar with the bonus. 20% puts it exactly the same at 36.5 hitrate though. The benifit though is if you don't put max wisdom, which you often don't, obviously goblins end up being better, which is OK in that scenario.
P.S. Put both proposes here: <a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15EUNEHza_TEiL4Qw-RofGVNX1mcBPQ0T9Ri8pB3EfXA/edit#gid=0">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... edit#gid=0</a>
There's also a possibility of if you remove the max end you could bump all END by lets say 10-30HP too with the above.
There's also a possibility of if you remove the max end you could bump all END by lets say 10-30HP too with the above.
On agi you need to set a top and bottom value
Human i thought was the baseline for all stats , this is depending on what you set as a baseline.
Ie 24 str is current top and 18 str is lowest
So agi needs some kind of adjustment cause horc is 19 agi human is the baseline at 20 agi it's no contest with orc 22 end and 23 str.
Therefor you need to set one with lowest agi horc in this example, could be 18 agi ,, as compared to ling 18 str
Either way to balance the human baseline 20 agi then some class or classes need adjusted down for agi
Ling would be top agi. So lowest str and end, horc would be highest str and end with lowest agi, it should not be 19 cause human is 20, 1 point diffetence
All others would have to fall in between as the average player character for dammage, agi, magic resis etc
Just thoughts take it or whichever.
Edit, the highest end class would be mainly melee, there for it needs the lowest magic resis, Drake is currently 12 wis and 20 end orc is 14 wis and 22 end, that's 2 end points with better magic resis and highest str
Edit 2, chr is a catch all for leftover points, if it would make HP and ot mp higher might be something
Could make min require for classes?
Human i thought was the baseline for all stats , this is depending on what you set as a baseline.
Ie 24 str is current top and 18 str is lowest
So agi needs some kind of adjustment cause horc is 19 agi human is the baseline at 20 agi it's no contest with orc 22 end and 23 str.
Therefor you need to set one with lowest agi horc in this example, could be 18 agi ,, as compared to ling 18 str
Either way to balance the human baseline 20 agi then some class or classes need adjusted down for agi
Ling would be top agi. So lowest str and end, horc would be highest str and end with lowest agi, it should not be 19 cause human is 20, 1 point diffetence
All others would have to fall in between as the average player character for dammage, agi, magic resis etc
Just thoughts take it or whichever.
Edit, the highest end class would be mainly melee, there for it needs the lowest magic resis, Drake is currently 12 wis and 20 end orc is 14 wis and 22 end, that's 2 end points with better magic resis and highest str
Edit 2, chr is a catch all for leftover points, if it would make HP and ot mp higher might be something
Could make min require for classes?
I don't want to readd min requirements for classes again no. I think it kind of ruins the whole 'do what you want to do' thing.
In defense of orc MR, Saurians esp are claimed to be better, and the bonus value makes little difference with such low MR anyways. Raising Drakes makes them on par with saurians, which would be too much IMO since drakes get some differences that saurians do not get.
In defense of orc MR, Saurians esp are claimed to be better, and the bonus value makes little difference with such low MR anyways. Raising Drakes makes them on par with saurians, which would be too much IMO since drakes get some differences that saurians do not get.
P.S. Put both proposes here: <a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15EUNEHza_TEiL4Qw-RofGVNX1mcBPQ0T9Ri8pB3EfXA/edit#gid=0">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... edit#gid=0</a>
There's also a possibility of if you remove the max end you could bump all END by lets say 10-30HP too with the above.
Not a great fan of either proposal tbh and think both are worse than your original one. If you implemented either of these I think you would have to offer free race changes as part of respec or ppl r gonna feel ripped off. Here are some quick reasons why off the top of my head:
[list]
1. Raising Ling End while either leaving Elf End the same largely disrupts the currently fair Elf vs Ling choice for Bards/Rangers and possibly Pallys too (It is currently an End vs Agi tradeoff that your proposals would shift in favour of Lings)
2. I don't think either proposal actually fixes gnomes.... Giving them +1 Agi helps a little bit for their survival (but not nearly as much as +1 End would) and +1 INT is nice to have but almost useless for overall playability (cos u can still die easily b4 using it leaving your party majorly disadvantaged). I do feel they actually need the +1 End to be more viable. You quote stats that majority of chanters are gnome but I reckon a lot of those are chars created when ppl were newer to EO still having perceptions of Rok... I think most with gnome chanter now prolly would do Ele or Elf given their time again (I certainly would - having now gotten more experience play testing EO and realising the importance of HP in group fights and OAD parties)...Most newer chanters/sorcs i see being made by veteran players are not gnomes methinks.
3.Horcs hit little enough as it is and will do so even less post Agi update... They are fine as is and nerfing their strength is not needed.
[/list:u]
As a side note in response to your previous post quoting race % breakdowns of current 25er classes, I would caution against reading too much into this info as it is likely inaccurate to identifying actual trends of which races are best for a class.... This is cos a lot of ppl make their first few 25ers of races/class combos they think we're good in Rok (eg ling guard, gnome chant, human/helf elder, goblin slayer etc) and then realise later in the end-game that these builds are total duds in the current EO and shelve em.... This is actually really common occurrence for 1st/2nd chars and is a discouragement for lots of newbs (some of which I know have stopped playing instead of bothering to persevere making yet another char of same class they originally wanted, just to be competitive)....which is why I have previously suggested that it would be very helpful to introduce some in-game way to change race as part of realloc process to take away some of this strain on balancing races perfectly etc.
[list]
1. Raising Ling End while either leaving Elf End the same largely disrupts the currently fair Elf vs Ling choice for Bards/Rangers and possibly Pallys too (It is currently an End vs Agi tradeoff that your proposals would shift in favour of Lings)
2. I don't think either proposal actually fixes gnomes.... Giving them +1 Agi helps a little bit for their survival (but not nearly as much as +1 End would) and +1 INT is nice to have but almost useless for overall playability (cos u can still die easily b4 using it leaving your party majorly disadvantaged). I do feel they actually need the +1 End to be more viable. You quote stats that majority of chanters are gnome but I reckon a lot of those are chars created when ppl were newer to EO still having perceptions of Rok... I think most with gnome chanter now prolly would do Ele or Elf given their time again (I certainly would - having now gotten more experience play testing EO and realising the importance of HP in group fights and OAD parties)...Most newer chanters/sorcs i see being made by veteran players are not gnomes methinks.
3.Horcs hit little enough as it is and will do so even less post Agi update... They are fine as is and nerfing their strength is not needed.
[/list:u]
1. If we base it off this
Halfling 18 23 18 20 20 22
Elf 18 22 18 22 21 22
I see a use for both in different scenarios, which i think is fine.
1b./2. Issue right now is if you add END to gnomes, you have to add it to elf to compensate. But then you gotta also add end to all the other races like HE, Human, etc too to compensate because there's a bit of issue with it. My intentions are not to give everyone an END boost. Survivability is an issue sure, but I was intending on going the other way by setting the max end to 22 and then changing it so its similar to 18-23 end (aka 17 to 22 end). But that's still up in the air.
Halfling 18 23 17 20 20 22
Elf 18 22 18 21 21 22
Back on this, that's the current stats. With one end, more wis/int, and one less agi, to me elves shadow lings. Giving both END, it results in the exact same thing really/issue as we have now where (to me) elves are better in most ways. Nothing is set on stone yet though obviously, still looking into trial and error on stuff.
3. Yeah I am not sure about the HO thing as well, just was making facts about damage though and issues it brings up in the previous post. 25 str is fairly high, still a problem regardless as no other race really does this.
As a side note in response to your previous post quoting race % breakdowns of current 25er classes, I would caution against reading too much into this info as it is likely inaccurate to identifying actual trends of which races are best for a class.... This is cos a lot of ppl make their first few 25ers of races/class combos they think we're good in Rok (eg ling guard, gnome chant, human/helf elder, goblin slayer etc) and then realise later in the end-game that these builds are total duds in the current EO and shelve em.... This is actually really common occurrence for 1st/2nd chars and is a discouragement for lots of newbs (some of which I know have stopped playing instead of bothering to persevere making yet another char of same class they originally wanted, just to be competitive)....which is why I have previously suggested that it would be very helpful to introduce some in-game way to change race as part of realloc process to take away some of this strain on balancing races perfectly etc.
Alot of people on discord apparently disagreed with the notion that gnomes are not used. Would like people to actually post bout it though too. So I'm just stating it. I'm also stating that at least half of those gnomes aren't so old either. I'm not staying you are wrong about how enchanters work though, just stating info I've seen.
You won't be able to change race ever, balance is part of the game. If people are upset it's a shame, but it is what it is. We'll have to get new people in place of that. We haven't really been advertising and probably won't be until we're more settled.
+++
Edit: There's a third proposal up thats similar to the first to show the example of what I mean. The issue is HE/Humans etc get a boost too and I don't think they need a END boost. But without it, elves/etc are higher. But I think it might be too much and bringing them too close to physical based races.
I don't overly mind the changes to Gnomes, I guess. I mean, they're the smallest race. Even smaller than lings, so it made sense that they'd have the lowest hp out of all of the races. But they're also magical creatures, meant to be the ones that stand behind the lines, protected by the stronger, larger races, while keeping everyone else alive or slamming the enemies with massive magical damage. I don't really see Gnomes as glass cannons. I see them as having to be played strategically. While I'm not a huge fan of an End boost, I don't mind the Int boost because that means those lil Gnomes become even better magical battlers.
As for the rest of the races:
Elves are decent but I do prefer Gnomes over them for Caster types. However I prefer Elves over other races when making Rangers. I'm not really certain they need adjusting but if you're adjusting Gnomes then these would probably have to be adjusted otherwise they wouldn't stand out as a worthwhile race to play.
Dark Elves I have one. I don't play her much at all. I think it's not a very good/great race compared to others and I'm still wishing I'd made my Necro Gnome instead. She's okay but I think if she were a different race she could be much better. Dark Elves definitely need something. It's not that they suck but they feel as though they're overshadowed by every other race. I'd kind of like to see them get a boost to damage at night or something, in all honesty. I mean, they're Dark Elves. Dark. Elves. They need something so that they become a viable race to play for more than just a novelty of 'lets try DE's as x and see how it goes' kind of thing.
Half Elves are a mixed race and as such should reflect both races with regards to stats. I can't say they're amazing but they're not bad overall.
Humans are, as they always are, that middle ground of not great and yet not terrible. A 'Jack of All Trades and Master of None' type of class imo. I typically don't play humans because there are better races that can do the job. Though I would make one for, say, RP purposes.
Goblins. I LOVE my Gobby Ninja. Goblins are a fun race and instead of putting a +1 to agi I went and gave her more Wis to counter magey types. She's great and I love her. Not sure how I feel about proposed changes to her race, tbh lol. I kind of like Gobbies as they are now <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Half Orcs are....well. They should be kind of dumb. But if you reduce Wis too much you'll make them glass cannons when it comes to battling magey types, whether it's PvP or PvE and then I'm not sure if players would really bother with them, given how much they miss. And, let me tell ya. They miss. A lot. lol
Saurians are not too bad. My Barb is one and she does just fine PvE (which is my main game-play style). I don't really feel that she needs anything to make her better, stat wise. She hits well, dodges well, and is a good all around battle type race.
Drakeblood I can't say much on since I only just made one and haven't played her yet. I made her a ranger. We'll see how she does against magey types since she's got the base 10 wis lol. Could be good, could be bad. We'll see <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Anyways, I probably didn't give too much useful information but there's my assessment anyways.
As for the rest of the races:
Elves are decent but I do prefer Gnomes over them for Caster types. However I prefer Elves over other races when making Rangers. I'm not really certain they need adjusting but if you're adjusting Gnomes then these would probably have to be adjusted otherwise they wouldn't stand out as a worthwhile race to play.
Dark Elves I have one. I don't play her much at all. I think it's not a very good/great race compared to others and I'm still wishing I'd made my Necro Gnome instead. She's okay but I think if she were a different race she could be much better. Dark Elves definitely need something. It's not that they suck but they feel as though they're overshadowed by every other race. I'd kind of like to see them get a boost to damage at night or something, in all honesty. I mean, they're Dark Elves. Dark. Elves. They need something so that they become a viable race to play for more than just a novelty of 'lets try DE's as x and see how it goes' kind of thing.
Half Elves are a mixed race and as such should reflect both races with regards to stats. I can't say they're amazing but they're not bad overall.
Humans are, as they always are, that middle ground of not great and yet not terrible. A 'Jack of All Trades and Master of None' type of class imo. I typically don't play humans because there are better races that can do the job. Though I would make one for, say, RP purposes.
Goblins. I LOVE my Gobby Ninja. Goblins are a fun race and instead of putting a +1 to agi I went and gave her more Wis to counter magey types. She's great and I love her. Not sure how I feel about proposed changes to her race, tbh lol. I kind of like Gobbies as they are now <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Half Orcs are....well. They should be kind of dumb. But if you reduce Wis too much you'll make them glass cannons when it comes to battling magey types, whether it's PvP or PvE and then I'm not sure if players would really bother with them, given how much they miss. And, let me tell ya. They miss. A lot. lol
Saurians are not too bad. My Barb is one and she does just fine PvE (which is my main game-play style). I don't really feel that she needs anything to make her better, stat wise. She hits well, dodges well, and is a good all around battle type race.
Drakeblood I can't say much on since I only just made one and haven't played her yet. I made her a ranger. We'll see how she does against magey types since she's got the base 10 wis lol. Could be good, could be bad. We'll see <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Anyways, I probably didn't give too much useful information but there's my assessment anyways.
Half Orcs are....well. They should be kind of dumb. But if you reduce Wis too much you'll make them glass cannons when it comes to battling magey types, whether it's PvP or PvE and then I'm not sure if players would really bother with them, given how much they miss. And, let me tell ya. They miss. A lot. lol
They are supposed to be. It's the reason on being good against spells but heavy HP/Str and being a magic. Otherwise theres 0 point in using magic classes if all races were immune to it. Pick one of the mid races with good MR and moderate strength/hp otherwise.
Goblins.Not sure how I feel about proposed changes to her race, tbh lol. I kind of like Gobbies as they are now <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Yeah nerfs hurt, everyone rages over them but for the sake of balance things do need to change here and there. 5% loss to MR bonus isn't that much loss though. cause it's not a full 5%, its 5% based on your Wis. You lose a couple percent which still puts them as the goto if you don't max out wis, which you often rarely do. Even 10% instead of 15% is about 41% hit rate with magic which might be OK too, tbh. They still get a 10 damage reduction on any spells though.
This is how it looks like now:
DE: (give or take a half a percent either way on some randomness chance)
15 Wis: 51% hit rate.
16 wis: 48% hit rate.
17 wis: 45% hit rate.
18 wis 42% hit rate.
19 wis: 39% hit rate.
20 wis: 36% hit rate.
Goblin with 15%:
14 wis: 49% hit rate.
15 wis: 45% hit rate
16 wis: 42% hit rate.
17 wis: 38% hit rate.
Goblin with 10%:
14 wis: 52% hit rate.
15 wis: 48% hit rate
16 wis: 44% hit rate.
17 wis: 41% hit rate.
I feel like 15% is OK though, but just throwing these values for people to comment on it.
I'll probably get a /pat for this, but I agree with Lavelia.
If anything needs changing in gnomes (which i doubt, as i believe, without hard facts though, that they are widely played), then giving them +1int makes more sense in the grand scheme of things. RP and tactically wise.
As lavelia said, sure they will still be frail, but they are supposed to be like that, it will be their tradeoff. Hell, get a Guardian in front of the gnome, they are there for that.
If anything needs changing in gnomes (which i doubt, as i believe, without hard facts though, that they are widely played), then giving them +1int makes more sense in the grand scheme of things. RP and tactically wise.
As lavelia said, sure they will still be frail, but they are supposed to be like that, it will be their tradeoff. Hell, get a Guardian in front of the gnome, they are there for that.
If we do a restat, then all char would need to be changed so the 25 str horc can be reset
You won't be able to change race ever, balance is part of the game. If people are upset it's a shame, but it is what it is. We'll have to get new people in place of that. We haven't really been advertising and probably won't be until we're more settled.
I'm not sure why you would adopt such a stance re never allowing race changes, especially in the case of allowing some end-game way for new players to correct character creation mistakes made when they were new (perhaps you have good reasons you havent explained) ... In any case I wanted to give you feedback that the perceived attitude behind your above comment seems discouraging. I've been suggesting all along that EO's issue isnt as much "player attraction through advertising" as it is "player retention through game dynamics" (which you largely have more control over than advertising). But basically it seems to me like you are saying you dont give a damn about retaining players, you just care about replacing them with new ones (who may then quit anyway later)....which seems rather short sighted for a game developer and doesnt really inspire me to go grind out some more 25ers or interact with new players who are likely part of a revolving door.
Also, the forums and discord are not exactly representative of the entire community who play your game. The large majority of players active on forums and EO discord tavern seem to me to be from 1 guild. The large majority of active staff (at the time of this post) appear to be from 1 guild. Many of these players seem to be from an "in-crowd" community of close-knit Rok alumni. I suspect therefore the large majority of your interactions/surveys of "player opinion" come from a particular sub-community of players within the larger community (and you appear to give the suggestions of these players more weight/consideration). I have tried to be a voice that thinks outside this box to help EO with fresh/different ideas, but i tire of what seems to usually be a fruitless/unwanted task.... And your above "i dont really care if ppl quit" sentiments make me feel that although you have created a game that is a big improvement over Rok, it still has Rok's unhelpful feel of a game that is designed largely to cater for the gratification of the "in-crowd"/staff rather than for the gratification of the entire playerbase.
Good luck with the advertising campaign. Good luck with player retention. I may log in occasionally to interact with the community of friends made in EO, but the gameplay doesnt really interest me much anymore and (now) neither does trying to help it improve by suggesting ideas or critical feedback.
Sorry for the aside from the main topic (its likely the last time i bother) - Peace all
I can see how some people would be upset that their races got nerfed or other races got buffed but I agree balancing is part of the game.
I mean as we go through the classes for the most part they are getting buffed and we are not allowing class changes.
That said I kinda think it it would be a good idea to keep the race changes minimal if possible.
Less we change less people have to be upset about.
I think maybe tossing halfling +agi and gnome an +int buffs them and keeps the races unique.
Maybe tossing a pool point or two on dark elves.
Orcs are great slayers, cavs but with agi change they will lose a bit of power. I can see the 12 wis but think they should keep str.
Dwarfs are in the same boat although idk why they should get the -10 spell reduction they already have 20wis and 23end which makes them impossible for casters so I say rid that.
Maybe give human and half elf ability for +2 but at a cost.
That's my take imo. I really don't think things are too far off. After thinking about it the last few days and looking at people's arguments I think it makes sense.
I mean as we go through the classes for the most part they are getting buffed and we are not allowing class changes.
That said I kinda think it it would be a good idea to keep the race changes minimal if possible.
Less we change less people have to be upset about.
I think maybe tossing halfling +agi and gnome an +int buffs them and keeps the races unique.
Maybe tossing a pool point or two on dark elves.
Orcs are great slayers, cavs but with agi change they will lose a bit of power. I can see the 12 wis but think they should keep str.
Dwarfs are in the same boat although idk why they should get the -10 spell reduction they already have 20wis and 23end which makes them impossible for casters so I say rid that.
Maybe give human and half elf ability for +2 but at a cost.
That's my take imo. I really don't think things are too far off. After thinking about it the last few days and looking at people's arguments I think it makes sense.
You won't be able to change race ever, balance is part of the game. If people are upset it's a shame, but it is what it is. We'll have to get new people in place of that. We haven't really been advertising and probably won't be until we're more settled.
I'm not sure why you would adopt such a stance re never allowing race changes, especially in the case of allowing some end-game way for new players to correct character creation mistakes made when they were new (perhaps you have good reasons you havent explained) ... In any case I wanted to give you feedback that the perceived attitude behind your above comment seems discouraging. I've been suggesting all along that EO's issue isnt as much "player attraction through advertising" as it is "player retention through game dynamics" (which you largely have more control over than advertising). But basically it seems to me like you are saying you dont give a damn about retaining players, you just care about replacing them with new ones (who may then quit anyway later)....which seems rather short sighted for a game developer and doesnt really inspire me to go grind out some more 25ers or interact with new players who are likely part of a revolving door.
Also, the forums and discord are not exactly representative of the entire community who play your game. The large majority of players active on forums and EO discord tavern seem to me to be from 1 guild. The large majority of active staff (at the time of this post) appear to be from 1 guild. Many of these players seem to be from an "in-crowd" community of close-knit Rok alumni. I suspect therefore the large majority of your interactions/surveys of "player opinion" come from a particular sub-community of players within the larger community (and you appear to give the suggestions of these players more weight/consideration). I have tried to be a voice that thinks outside this box to help EO with fresh/different ideas, but i tire of what seems to usually be a fruitless/unwanted task.... And your above "i dont really care if ppl quit" sentiments make me feel that although you have created a game that is a big improvement over Rok, it still has Rok's unhelpful feel of a game that is designed largely to cater for the gratification of the "in-crowd"/staff rather than for the gratification of the entire playerbase.
Good luck with the advertising campaign. Good luck with player retention. I may log in occasionally to interact with the community of friends made in EO, but the gameplay doesnt really interest me much anymore and (now) neither does trying to help it improve by suggesting ideas or critical feedback.
Sorry for the aside from the main topic (its likely the last time i bother) - Peace all
In the past I've argued for allowing race changes, but i can see why Nitehawk has said it's off the table.
You risk everyone having the same cookie cutter style characters.
I think it's a noble aim to try and get the races balanced so there's several worthwhile choices for classes, rather than risking every character being the same combination.
I do agree there's lots of people who make mistakes with their early alts (myself included) and it's very discouraging to have the feeling of having wasted several weeks levelling and equipping a character you don't like, especially if it ties up a name you want to keep.
I still complain about my shitty dwarf slayer to this day, but i have no desire to level a replacement.
I've argued for a while we need more help on the roller for people, including a "suggested stats" option, or maybe even a warning if someone tries to create a character of an unusual combination, or fails to use all their allocation points.
Guilds also need to help out newbies by giving them advice before they invest a lot of time into an alt.
Secondly, I really hope you continue to contribute Anthriel, I actually really enjoy reading your input. Even if i sometimes disagree with you, what you say is usually well thought out and provokes a good discussion about game mechanics and the direction of the game. If anything I wish you'd apply to staff as I think you'd potentially be a really good addition.
Thirdly, I can see what you're saying about a lot of the discussion on discord/forums comes from Silhouette members, but discord/the forums are open to everyone to contribute ideas.
If Nitehawk wants feedback on potential changes then where else can he get it other than asking on the forums and on discord? I believe he also broadcasted a link to the forum page. If other guilds don't contribute to the discussion then how is that his/our fault? :/
We're also not making suggestions based on benefiting us, we're trying to make suggestions to improve the game.
For instance I recommended nerfing dwarf End and 2 of my characters are dwarves (including my main DPS alt, and the character I'm levelling right now).
I recommended nerfing orc str despite there being several orc mains in my guild and despite me really wanting an orc slayer.
I also have a history of recommending things (that have been implemented) that are bad for my guild.
I've also recommended several things that i knew would severely piss off some of my guild members (lol obscuration potions).
It's in everyone's interests for the game to be improved and for the general game experience to be enjoyable for everyone.
Applications to join staff are still open, if anyone wants to give up their own time in order to help the game then please make a serious application to staff.
Lastly, it's often a detriment rather than a benefit to a guild to have staff members for the following reasons:
-If you're involved in the testing/building of an OAD area you can't run it for a certain period after it launches
-If you're event staff then your guild has one less person (i.e. you) for any event you run.
-If you become warden then you have to cut ties from your clan
-You have less time to play the game because you have to contribute on the staff side of things
-Any loop holes you see a guild member mention (lumbering bears giving high xp, certain monsters giving too much gold, etc.) you have a duty to mention/get fixed
Being staff really doesn't benefit your normal guild in any way, I can honestly say at no point has my staff status had any benefit to Silhouette whatsoever and in fact it's harmed the guild a lot more than it's helped.
Honestly, Silhouette has lost more good members to Staff than any other guild, but it's been for the betterment of the game.
(i'd add to what Eld wrote that just because many of us might come from the same clan, that does not mean we agree on everything - and we dont)