Guilds Redux
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
You know what id do? Make those big oads non pvp areas. Drop goes to the inventory of the person dealt the most damage. Similar way, make a couple of world bosses, once a week, killabe within 10-15 mins (assuming the 90% player base hitting them) with prices to the top 3 - top 5 damage dealers, and a little something for the lucky killshot.
I mean, if we want fairness , justice and equal opportinities for all, thats a way to start.
As for pvp , there are so many ways possible , to organise a solid competition that will also benefit guild dedication. Class moshes, race moshes,3v3 - 5v5 clan event, a great colliseum tournament perhaps? with record keeping , scoreboards, weekly/monthy competitions etc. I ve seen other modern muds doin this kind of system and they are succesfull. Having a system like this, we wont have to close the guilds, as numbers will not lead to overpower, still , guild competition will be there - on scoreboards with transparency, equal chances and ..some luck. Just a thought, cheers
I mean, if we want fairness , justice and equal opportinities for all, thats a way to start.
As for pvp , there are so many ways possible , to organise a solid competition that will also benefit guild dedication. Class moshes, race moshes,3v3 - 5v5 clan event, a great colliseum tournament perhaps? with record keeping , scoreboards, weekly/monthy competitions etc. I ve seen other modern muds doin this kind of system and they are succesfull. Having a system like this, we wont have to close the guilds, as numbers will not lead to overpower, still , guild competition will be there - on scoreboards with transparency, equal chances and ..some luck. Just a thought, cheers
that sounds like minstrel/ saurian zerk partnerships until the end of days
as far as i see it, keys favor big guilds. death sickness favors big guilds. healing and potion decay favors big guilds.
I never understood why the logoff timer after death. Glad that's gone now. That was a mechanic that incentivized big guilds in indirect ways since it penalized small groups or solo players. Healing and Potion decay also incentivizes big guilds in PVP since bigger groups can distribute the burden. Lowering healing potion amounts incentivizes people to join a guild in the first place since many monsters do more damage per round while leveling than pots can recoup.
I'm all for justice and equality of opportunity, but we don't want to make things equally crappy. Making the item go to those who get kill shot is an idea, but not for everything. In fact, this would make people refuse to take healing or support classes to OaDs. I don't think we need more issues with that. Transparency is a great thing though. Leader-boards might solve a bunch of issues. One of the things we have now is people trolling others by making false claims which ends up causing unrelated issues because people cry foul. Right now we have a few players who act in ways that bring the whole game down. Remove guilds from the game and you will still have these players causing issues. We need to fix it so bad actors and adult children can't ruin the game for everyone.
Seta keys are a prime example of big guild friendly design considering it is unlimited people for each key and the room is kill to pass so people can't drop steal if they leave one alligator alive. Refinery and Dreadlands are guild friendly but can be disrupted by a coordinated effort (steal just one component of the key). Shiv key is a free for all considering one smart person can take the key from an overwhelming force (drop stealing is bad, mkay). The Dragons though surprisingly aren't so much guild friendly. Even a small number of determined adversaries can stymie a guild from getting scales. Admittedly, stopping others isn't as satisfying as completing yourself... but still it is a good mechanic.
These places came about due to an overriding philosophy of X+Y=Z for an area. We need more F=Q and A+C-7=D areas and monsters. Roamers are great. I love roamers as long as they aren't too powerful. Roamers shouldn't drop stuff equal to top OaDs though unless it is a HUGELY LONG span between spawns. NH has put some great tools for builders in play though so hopefully some new type stuff will be hitting the game.
To me, the guild problems we have now are a symptom and not an actual illness. I think Discord is more corrosive to this game than guild structure at the moment. Still, the all powerful creator will need to decide the direction he needs to go. Maybe a few "ever changing mazes of mystery" that don't require a key but do require the running of a changing gauntlet will shake things up.
i mean those were needed additions for fair fights, but like 1/75 fights was ever fair to begin with.
what the game needs is incentives for smaller guilds and a pve way to eliminate guilds from oad races. this is so it cant be a cluster of 18v5v3
oad spawns at 7. 4 key (1) bosses spawn all over the realm. guilds fight npcs for 4 keys some pvp action heavily big guilded, but unlikely to have 4 branches of 1 guild win 4 keys.
Key (1)s open the oad so u can bring in 5 people and rush your self to one of the two key(2) bosses. thus eliminating 2 guilds from contention with either fair fights or no fighting whatsoever.
lastly, the remaining 2 teams head to the final key(3) boss making 1 team the victor. that team wins key (3) and gets to go to the real oad.
edit it would be possible to code a guild soulbind so keys could be dropstolen or so guilds with more than 1 key couldnt likely ambush you twice
what the game needs is incentives for smaller guilds and a pve way to eliminate guilds from oad races. this is so it cant be a cluster of 18v5v3
oad spawns at 7. 4 key (1) bosses spawn all over the realm. guilds fight npcs for 4 keys some pvp action heavily big guilded, but unlikely to have 4 branches of 1 guild win 4 keys.
Key (1)s open the oad so u can bring in 5 people and rush your self to one of the two key(2) bosses. thus eliminating 2 guilds from contention with either fair fights or no fighting whatsoever.
lastly, the remaining 2 teams head to the final key(3) boss making 1 team the victor. that team wins key (3) and gets to go to the real oad.
edit it would be possible to code a guild soulbind so keys could be dropstolen or so guilds with more than 1 key couldnt likely ambush you twice
If the shoe was on the other foot and Silhouette was back on their A-Game, Empire would be the ones calling for change. Again.
I see alot of selfish posting about how it's not the larger Guilds problem, it IS the bigger guilds problem for not coming up with a system together to help everyone and not just themselves. Sure keep it how it is for those Empire who still need gear for all their 50 25ers.
For the game as a whole, changes need to be made. As an Empire game as a whole, keep it how it is until Silhouette take back charge for 6 months and then revert back when Empire regain strength.
My opinion is just do something that YOU feel would benefit the game, too many bias opinions come from debates and it' a joke. If Ember was to just go offline they would be PMing you daily to just delete Guilds lol.
I gave up on this game for some mass irl issues i have to deal with but before i left and for some time i have said delete Guilds. Make people work together rather than against. This doesn't mean you can't PK. This means you can freely get a team or teams together and take out keys/OADS TOGETHER for a change instead of one Guild dominating for a period of time the switching to ther other big Guild once burnt out.
Sure you guys might like the power switch but the smaller Guilds have never gained ground or even been able to get OAD gear. Those guys have to grind it out for Gold and hope something pops up on AH. That's not fair at all.
(You is referring to NiteHawk)
I see alot of selfish posting about how it's not the larger Guilds problem, it IS the bigger guilds problem for not coming up with a system together to help everyone and not just themselves. Sure keep it how it is for those Empire who still need gear for all their 50 25ers.
For the game as a whole, changes need to be made. As an Empire game as a whole, keep it how it is until Silhouette take back charge for 6 months and then revert back when Empire regain strength.
My opinion is just do something that YOU feel would benefit the game, too many bias opinions come from debates and it' a joke. If Ember was to just go offline they would be PMing you daily to just delete Guilds lol.
I gave up on this game for some mass irl issues i have to deal with but before i left and for some time i have said delete Guilds. Make people work together rather than against. This doesn't mean you can't PK. This means you can freely get a team or teams together and take out keys/OADS TOGETHER for a change instead of one Guild dominating for a period of time the switching to ther other big Guild once burnt out.
Sure you guys might like the power switch but the smaller Guilds have never gained ground or even been able to get OAD gear. Those guys have to grind it out for Gold and hope something pops up on AH. That's not fair at all.
(You is referring to NiteHawk)
What is the current player base? I've heard different numbers. I'm not talking about most online at one time, I mean how many people regularly play this game at least once a week. I've seen some pretty ridiculous numbers thrown up to explain why X guild is bad. Most of the time the numbers aren't even close to reality. If we have 50 people playing the game, then a guild of 25+ would be a horrible thing. If we have 100+ playing then a guild of 25+ isn't much. Barring social issues such as personal dislike and hatred, people will gravitate towards "poles" in the community. If Guilds are removed, then the entire mechanics for facilitating/controlling player interaction moves to Discord and a large part of game play leaves the control of game staff. Relinquishing the social aspect of a game into the control of another entity makes the game not only dependent upon that entity, but also makes it likley that the social aspect will surplant the game itself. In short, if you log on to spend time with people why bother to log into the game if you can do the same from Discord?
Limiting the size of guilds is a viable, and possibly necessary, step for the game. It should be based though on what is best for code balance and structure than any social engineering or enablement. Using a binary theory, we can assume there will always be two large guilds as humans tend to group together against a common enemy. We can assume there will always be a few small guilds on the periphery as well as people who keep certain characters guildless. This is where being old and having studied psychology comes in handy.
I seem to remember that World of Warcraft used to have a server capacity of 2500 people. Their guilds were capped at 999 people. If everyone in game joined a "mega-guild" then there would be 2 major and one minor guild. The reality was different with WoW because it combined all aspects of game play allowing for smaller guilds to complete raids as well as mechanics for solo players to enjoy the content. What ended up happening is each server had a "mega" guild and dozens of smaller guilds. For WoW, it wasn't about forcing people into smaller guilds that created the diversity, it was a diverity of content that allowed for the growth of individuals and specialty guilds.
If Ember used the same formula that would be a maximum of roughly 40% of the population in one guild. We aren't talking about everyone being online at the same time, this would be the number of people who play the game total. Some can only play for a few hours a week. Others can play for 8+ hours a day. What would end up happening is the major guilds would have dominant "timezones" and there would be times when smaller guilds could either compete against or frustrate the larger guilds. It's entirely plausible that 3 different "mega" guilds appear to cover the time the server is up while smaller guilds stay spread out.
I agree that ultimately it is up to NiteHawk since he is the creator and the person with the clearest vision of what he wants to accomplish. Maybe the game isn't what it was intended to be. Maybe major changes need to be made to the core game structure to get it there. I tend to think in the terms of what is missing. I prefer to take a scalpal to a problem and not a chainsaw. I've been part of games where the chainsaw method was chosen and ultimately the game suffered due to it. I don't want to see those mistakes repeated here.
The easiest thing to do is to listen to those who complain the longest or loudest and do what they say. You often see people threaten to leave a game if X isn't changed. I tend to ultimately ignore those people. To me, those who don't talk much but quietly go about playing the game are the ones who need to be kept happy. Unfortunately, as life has shown us, those people do not often speak out. It is very hard to find out what these people like or dislike unless you actually play the game with them and draw them into discussions.
Limiting the size of guilds is a viable, and possibly necessary, step for the game. It should be based though on what is best for code balance and structure than any social engineering or enablement. Using a binary theory, we can assume there will always be two large guilds as humans tend to group together against a common enemy. We can assume there will always be a few small guilds on the periphery as well as people who keep certain characters guildless. This is where being old and having studied psychology comes in handy.
I seem to remember that World of Warcraft used to have a server capacity of 2500 people. Their guilds were capped at 999 people. If everyone in game joined a "mega-guild" then there would be 2 major and one minor guild. The reality was different with WoW because it combined all aspects of game play allowing for smaller guilds to complete raids as well as mechanics for solo players to enjoy the content. What ended up happening is each server had a "mega" guild and dozens of smaller guilds. For WoW, it wasn't about forcing people into smaller guilds that created the diversity, it was a diverity of content that allowed for the growth of individuals and specialty guilds.
If Ember used the same formula that would be a maximum of roughly 40% of the population in one guild. We aren't talking about everyone being online at the same time, this would be the number of people who play the game total. Some can only play for a few hours a week. Others can play for 8+ hours a day. What would end up happening is the major guilds would have dominant "timezones" and there would be times when smaller guilds could either compete against or frustrate the larger guilds. It's entirely plausible that 3 different "mega" guilds appear to cover the time the server is up while smaller guilds stay spread out.
I agree that ultimately it is up to NiteHawk since he is the creator and the person with the clearest vision of what he wants to accomplish. Maybe the game isn't what it was intended to be. Maybe major changes need to be made to the core game structure to get it there. I tend to think in the terms of what is missing. I prefer to take a scalpal to a problem and not a chainsaw. I've been part of games where the chainsaw method was chosen and ultimately the game suffered due to it. I don't want to see those mistakes repeated here.
The easiest thing to do is to listen to those who complain the longest or loudest and do what they say. You often see people threaten to leave a game if X isn't changed. I tend to ultimately ignore those people. To me, those who don't talk much but quietly go about playing the game are the ones who need to be kept happy. Unfortunately, as life has shown us, those people do not often speak out. It is very hard to find out what these people like or dislike unless you actually play the game with them and draw them into discussions.
Pots being overly high caused solo fights to be a problem. It's still a problem, just 'less of a problem'.. Monster damage does need to be adjusted though to be lower in leveling areas I'd say. Potion/Heal decay can be tweaked and it's mostly a test, but IMO endless fights are also really annoying. You shouldn't have to mash your keyboard for 10-15 minutes and you can't really 'up damage' without causing problems elsewhere. It's a tough balance to do. We can make the pot decay alot slower, heal decay slower, remove it from one, etc. But there needs to be an ends to all fights rather then a stalemate in group fights, and its hard to both balance it for solo/group because of it. Yeah, 12vs3 means that the players are outnumbered will have a tougher time, I understand where people are coming from with that with the potion/heal decay/etc, but IMO the problem isn't that to me, the problem is why those numbers swelled up on one side to begin with. GRANTED, it will happen sometimes, but we've have full guilds leave because of it (Most of Tormented for example left due to being overrun by the big boys that was the dominate power), so I assume when the 'numbers matter' this is often the problem.
Again we can tweak the decays though as we want it, we'll see how it goes. Pots/MP were split and if we don't have a decay, I don't see why pots should be split again either, as no decay generally means no losing mana as one mana pot is pretty much going to heal any MP decay you get in combat. AKA why even have MP if MP doesn't matter. (and the gold issue, I mean, use drinks and food. If you wanna save some time vs gold, that's on you.)
The logoff timer after death was to prevent people from logging in another toon right after dying 3 times. So X with 20 level 25'ers could cycle through 20 toons which was pretty much just like zombing. Though it's more resolved by using account sickness anyways.Death sickness is here to stay. Zombing is a dumb mechanic of the game and I don't care for it.
--------
I do agree with more incentives to being a small guild, we'll see about that too if we go that route. It's tough to say the current player base. It varies alot, last week we had 28-30 online and that was uncommon for awhile, then other times its around 20. I would say theres probably 50-65 actually active players, and alot of dead accounts. Though maybe it's alittle more then that.
Anyways, I'm still listening mostly right now. Just throwing some facts about some things. Again things can be balanced as I agree with some but some things are in to help.
Yeah that is byfar a huge issue IMO. I really hope more people get into this, as it's needed.
Yeah there is an issue with this too. Dropstolen/attacking guilds several times. Maybe should be a limit/etc. There are also some issues with certain keys that need to be fixed too. I never was a fan of being able to ambush someone mid OAD. I think it's lame, I tell that to the builders all the time. The fight if anything should occur near the start of the OAD, not when someone has prepared a party, pots, and been in 40 minutes of an OAD only to have their hard work stripped in two seconds because of a large guild. Though yeah, there are issues obviously that 'keys' are a problem too. Though maybe things like having more keys spawn at the same time will make it so at least certain guilds will at least get 'something'. It's tough to say. Instances are another thing but it might make PVP 'too' boring, aka no pvp at all.
I think the PVP is good but maybe it needs to be more fair, stupid things that come into mind would be limiting the amount of per guild players in a room etc. I don't think that would really resolve it 100% though would 'help'.
Again we can tweak the decays though as we want it, we'll see how it goes. Pots/MP were split and if we don't have a decay, I don't see why pots should be split again either, as no decay generally means no losing mana as one mana pot is pretty much going to heal any MP decay you get in combat. AKA why even have MP if MP doesn't matter. (and the gold issue, I mean, use drinks and food. If you wanna save some time vs gold, that's on you.)
The logoff timer after death was to prevent people from logging in another toon right after dying 3 times. So X with 20 level 25'ers could cycle through 20 toons which was pretty much just like zombing. Though it's more resolved by using account sickness anyways.Death sickness is here to stay. Zombing is a dumb mechanic of the game and I don't care for it.
--------
I do agree with more incentives to being a small guild, we'll see about that too if we go that route. It's tough to say the current player base. It varies alot, last week we had 28-30 online and that was uncommon for awhile, then other times its around 20. I would say theres probably 50-65 actually active players, and alot of dead accounts. Though maybe it's alittle more then that.
Anyways, I'm still listening mostly right now. Just throwing some facts about some things. Again things can be balanced as I agree with some but some things are in to help.
The easiest thing to do is to listen to those who complain the longest or loudest and do what they say. You often see people threaten to leave a game if X isn't changed. I tend to ultimately ignore those people. To me, those who don't talk much but quietly go about playing the game are the ones who need to be kept happy. Unfortunately, as life has shown us, those people do not often speak out. It is very hard to find out what these people like or dislike unless you actually play the game with them and draw them into discussions.
Yeah that is byfar a huge issue IMO. I really hope more people get into this, as it's needed.
edit it would be possible to code a guild soulbind so keys could be dropstolen or so guilds with more than 1 key couldnt likely ambush you twice
Yeah there is an issue with this too. Dropstolen/attacking guilds several times. Maybe should be a limit/etc. There are also some issues with certain keys that need to be fixed too. I never was a fan of being able to ambush someone mid OAD. I think it's lame, I tell that to the builders all the time. The fight if anything should occur near the start of the OAD, not when someone has prepared a party, pots, and been in 40 minutes of an OAD only to have their hard work stripped in two seconds because of a large guild. Though yeah, there are issues obviously that 'keys' are a problem too. Though maybe things like having more keys spawn at the same time will make it so at least certain guilds will at least get 'something'. It's tough to say. Instances are another thing but it might make PVP 'too' boring, aka no pvp at all.
I think the PVP is good but maybe it needs to be more fair, stupid things that come into mind would be limiting the amount of per guild players in a room etc. I don't think that would really resolve it 100% though would 'help'.
death sickness is a shit mechanic to combat zombying. since it affects more. shaky connections, classes dont all suck while sick etc. you want no zombies just lock accounts out of oad areas for 1 hr after 3 deaths. ive already seen death sickness fail because clerics run back and back and back and back and just shoot 1 heal on themselves to survive the npcs enroute and 3 on a friend mid battle over and over 20x while chain dying. its, 1, 2, 3 strikes you're out in the old ball game....(cntrol crystals already do this, it isnt a new thing)
also tormented quit? what...they all left and started empire and took all the members. thats like sayin defiance quit. same players for the most part, just moved on and renamed. look every side has had people quit. silh had 80 people on discord lol they all gone man, be it trolls, pkers, boredom, content whatever. they just stopped playin. some leave the channel now and then, others found home with our meme channels etc. but doesnt matter they dont play ember.
took too long really. there will just be discords with 10 allied guilds(as stated to me). will deteriorate over a long period of time, when the leadership stops playing and the playerpool sees newer "actives" and we get alot more players. problem is thats gunna be awhile.
edit: chris there isnt even many oads that take over 10 minutes. of the few that allow ambushing mid oad, you have to realise the ambushing guild "wasted" an oad from a previous day. ambushing is probably the funnest part of the game. i agree its like a guild lost an oad then ambushes another guild to change it to a loss for someone else, but it is the funnest parts of the game for most of the people playing. ambushing also results in both guilds failing the oad anyway. +1 for server longevity. it does suck that 1 side has to be griefed to accomplish it, however, if oads worked the way they are supposed to the guilds would fail the bosses 50%.
also tormented quit? what...they all left and started empire and took all the members. thats like sayin defiance quit. same players for the most part, just moved on and renamed. look every side has had people quit. silh had 80 people on discord lol they all gone man, be it trolls, pkers, boredom, content whatever. they just stopped playin. some leave the channel now and then, others found home with our meme channels etc. but doesnt matter they dont play ember.
took too long really. there will just be discords with 10 allied guilds(as stated to me). will deteriorate over a long period of time, when the leadership stops playing and the playerpool sees newer "actives" and we get alot more players. problem is thats gunna be awhile.
edit: chris there isnt even many oads that take over 10 minutes. of the few that allow ambushing mid oad, you have to realise the ambushing guild "wasted" an oad from a previous day. ambushing is probably the funnest part of the game. i agree its like a guild lost an oad then ambushes another guild to change it to a loss for someone else, but it is the funnest parts of the game for most of the people playing. ambushing also results in both guilds failing the oad anyway. +1 for server longevity. it does suck that 1 side has to be griefed to accomplish it, however, if oads worked the way they are supposed to the guilds would fail the bosses 50%.
I had a wall of text typed out with examples. Then I remembered most people don't read that much. I'll just say this. It's not guilds, it's toxic players. We need to learn not to keep preaching hatred and drama. Other guilds aren't evil cheaters. Discord is of the Devil.... nuf said
some of the players arent as toxic as they are perceived. some of the shit-talking is their way of relaxing.(this is pretty much the same as a drunken fool in a bar) shit talking has been the legacy of the mud world since the mid 90s when the 2nd generation of cpu mudders took over. now people do go too far with it sometimes, like the #silhcodes ruse or the staffcheat crap, but all in all i think its not even the trolling that does the most damage. its the whining. ive done it so as everyone else. people have off days.
guy trolls and 15-20 people have to troll staff to "punish" 1 troll. when all thats done is actually punishing the staff by having to hear you rant at them for days on end sometimes. mystery auction prime example.
as much as id love to see no guilds or smaller guild i just dont see it as a way to retain players atm and itll just make every casual player on both sides play even less. i think we need to diversify oads, make them harder, make people need equipment to take the tougher oads. divinity guilds are an option to merge the split playerbase, divinity events also. maybe even have a super continent where 25ers can go to a world thats 2x as hard and 1 less party member but with 2x hum rate (for the oads) would we risk it? yep
guy trolls and 15-20 people have to troll staff to "punish" 1 troll. when all thats done is actually punishing the staff by having to hear you rant at them for days on end sometimes. mystery auction prime example.
as much as id love to see no guilds or smaller guild i just dont see it as a way to retain players atm and itll just make every casual player on both sides play even less. i think we need to diversify oads, make them harder, make people need equipment to take the tougher oads. divinity guilds are an option to merge the split playerbase, divinity events also. maybe even have a super continent where 25ers can go to a world thats 2x as hard and 1 less party member but with 2x hum rate (for the oads) would we risk it? yep
I saw something a few nights back and didn't want to post immediately as I didn't want to make it appear that I was calling specific people or guilds out. In Global Chat someone was complaining about getting "steamrolled" trying to capture a control crystal. Their complaint was that their 2 people didn't have a chance to win against 5 defenders. They ended their complaint with a statement "I can't wait until guilds are broken up."
SO apparently, 5 v 2 is now a guild problem. 5 people constitute a super guild and must be stopped. At what point do we just call this bullshit and tell people to grow up? I hear this often in even 2v1 fights of people complaining about a guild because they are outnumbered. Are we saying the game needs to be tuned into a 1v1 battle system? This seems like the only solution if you never want to be outnumbered. I get it when you are outnumbered it sucks. I've fought 5v1 odds before and it does suck. The difference is I was adult enough to realize that my mistake was in not gathering a group to take on the 5 before engaging them. I don't blame game mechanics for not allowing me to become a super character and fight 5 people all by myself.
An event a few nights ago was 2v1 and the solo person beat the other 2 due to strategy and luck. This game isn't always about numbers but it IS always about using your brains. If you chose to enter into a battle you know you will be outnumbered, don't complain and demand the system change when you get beat. Be smart, find friends, use strategy, and quit demanding the game change to accommodate you when you fail.
It appears there are many people who want this game stripped down to be a cakewalk where they can play it and never have to worry about every getting beaten or have their feelings hurt. I suggest one of the many facebook games such as Farville2 or Solitaire if competition and strategy are outside of your abilities. This constant demand to remove guilds will never end as long as people are coddled when they get their feelings hurt. Once guilds are gone, people will demand parties be removed. Once parties are gone, one person per square seems the next step. Do people even realize the definition of Muti-User Dungeon? I could understand the complaints if there was logic to it. What I don't understand is the "I got beat by a party of people cause I can't stand up to a group solo. Groups should be outlawed!"
SO apparently, 5 v 2 is now a guild problem. 5 people constitute a super guild and must be stopped. At what point do we just call this bullshit and tell people to grow up? I hear this often in even 2v1 fights of people complaining about a guild because they are outnumbered. Are we saying the game needs to be tuned into a 1v1 battle system? This seems like the only solution if you never want to be outnumbered. I get it when you are outnumbered it sucks. I've fought 5v1 odds before and it does suck. The difference is I was adult enough to realize that my mistake was in not gathering a group to take on the 5 before engaging them. I don't blame game mechanics for not allowing me to become a super character and fight 5 people all by myself.
An event a few nights ago was 2v1 and the solo person beat the other 2 due to strategy and luck. This game isn't always about numbers but it IS always about using your brains. If you chose to enter into a battle you know you will be outnumbered, don't complain and demand the system change when you get beat. Be smart, find friends, use strategy, and quit demanding the game change to accommodate you when you fail.
It appears there are many people who want this game stripped down to be a cakewalk where they can play it and never have to worry about every getting beaten or have their feelings hurt. I suggest one of the many facebook games such as Farville2 or Solitaire if competition and strategy are outside of your abilities. This constant demand to remove guilds will never end as long as people are coddled when they get their feelings hurt. Once guilds are gone, people will demand parties be removed. Once parties are gone, one person per square seems the next step. Do people even realize the definition of Muti-User Dungeon? I could understand the complaints if there was logic to it. What I don't understand is the "I got beat by a party of people cause I can't stand up to a group solo. Groups should be outlawed!"
... blah blah blah ...
Totally agree with what you say.
It sucks when you get outnumbered and slaughtered, but meh, suck it up, it is a game, win some lose some and all that.
As for the farmville bit, I think I've said something like that when people where bitching about the pvp (pk) aspect of the game.
I now just laugh at the bitching (and keep my bitching to myself - or at least clan chat, where we cry and hug in our safe space).
dont think the guild problems are numbers problems. its more like symantics. theres as close to 0% chance to win outnumbered as you can get in this game. its not a numbers problem because both guilds have around the same numbers. your problem(if u call it a problem) is that 90% of your full time players are in 1 guild, and 90% of your casuals are in the other and they rarely get the higher portion active at the same time. imo it should have been expected to happen. dunno how it comes as a surprise the people who hang out day in day out are in the same guild.
do you punish empire for being active? or do u punish silh for being casual? thats what this reads like.
could run some oads where the key boss(NPC) sells 1 (guildbound)key per guild(could also sell a max number of keys). then you go in and run it or fight it out evenly or whatever. or hell run every oad like this. buy in or dont. its your choice,numbers will ALWAYS be even if u actually try. this is positive reinforcement for smaller guilds as they dont have to fight 3v12, they might even poach a couple members who arent prime 5 in their current establishment.
do you punish empire for being active? or do u punish silh for being casual? thats what this reads like.
could run some oads where the key boss(NPC) sells 1 (guildbound)key per guild(could also sell a max number of keys). then you go in and run it or fight it out evenly or whatever. or hell run every oad like this. buy in or dont. its your choice,numbers will ALWAYS be even if u actually try. this is positive reinforcement for smaller guilds as they dont have to fight 3v12, they might even poach a couple members who arent prime 5 in their current establishment.
I saw something a few nights back and didn't want to post immediately as I didn't want to make it appear that I was calling specific people or guilds out. In Global Chat someone was complaining about getting "steamrolled" trying to capture a control crystal. Their complaint was that their 2 people didn't have a chance to win against 5 defenders. They ended their complaint with a statement "I can't wait until guilds are broken up."
SO apparently, 5 v 2 is now a guild problem. 5 people constitute a super guild and must be stopped. At what point do we just call this bullshit and tell people to grow up? I hear this often in even 2v1 fights of people complaining about a guild because they are outnumbered. Are we saying the game needs to be tuned into a 1v1 battle system? This seems like the only solution if you never want to be outnumbered. I get it when you are outnumbered it sucks. I've fought 5v1 odds before and it does suck. The difference is I was adult enough to realize that my mistake was in not gathering a group to take on the 5 before engaging them. I don't blame game mechanics for not allowing me to become a super character and fight 5 people all by myself.
An event a few nights ago was 2v1 and the solo person beat the other 2 due to strategy and luck. This game isn't always about numbers but it IS always about using your brains. If you chose to enter into a battle you know you will be outnumbered, don't complain and demand the system change when you get beat. Be smart, find friends, use strategy, and quit demanding the game change to accommodate you when you fail.
It appears there are many people who want this game stripped down to be a cakewalk where they can play it and never have to worry about every getting beaten or have their feelings hurt. I suggest one of the many facebook games such as Farville2 or Solitaire if competition and strategy are outside of your abilities. This constant demand to remove guilds will never end as long as people are coddled when they get their feelings hurt. Once guilds are gone, people will demand parties be removed. Once parties are gone, one person per square seems the next step. Do people even realize the definition of Muti-User Dungeon? I could understand the complaints if there was logic to it. What I don't understand is the "I got beat by a party of people cause I can't stand up to a group solo. Groups should be outlawed!"
With respect, I feel that this is a mis-representation of the issue and yet another (intentional or unintentional) smokescreen to the real issues that needs addressing. The real issue isn’t that guilds are bad and should be thrown out entirely. The issue is that there is no counterbalance to the “bigger numbers are always better” dynamic which incentivises those who want to win to always try to outnumber.... and basically ppl quickly realise that “outnumbering” is THE proven strategy that wins the entire game (it let’s you exp fastest, get the best items fastest, have the most social interaction etc etc and there is absolutely no drawback.... even greed doesn’t stop a guild from adding more and more ppl cos most players quickly learn that you either put up with earning slowly within a superguild or don’t earn at all because you get crushed by the superguilds)
And because “bigger numbers” is undisputedly the easiest/most-successful way to play-to-win the game, it naturally leads to superguilds forming and that creates a divided player base that is more likely to be hostile/toxic to the other faction (because they are self sufficient within their faction or embittered that the other faction is more self sufficient than theirs) rather than a player base that has healthy competition and diplomacy/respect. Now I’m not saying that individual players don’t need to curtail their own toxic behaviour and promote respect etc but let’s not pretend the current bi-factional system doesn’t contribute a large portion towards the toxicity that has put off many players.
Basically imho a healthier guild system would incentivise people to think more about guilding with a smaller group of likeminded ppl while still engaging in healthy competition and diplomacy with the rest of the community. Yes some of the issues can be solved by build design. But until you have some way to curtail “bigger numbers is always better”, then to some degree the guild system will be boring/broken. Imagine a professional sport tournament that doesn’t have any caps on the amount of players on the roster! Eventually instead of having say 20 teams in a tournament they will start merging etc etc until I have 2 super teams with mega rosters and most players sitting disgruntled on the bench etc.... boring and uncompetitive result ensues. This is why salary caps and roster limits exist in sports. I’m not saying that we need to implement hard caps. But we do at least need some incentives etc such to counterbalance the “bigger numbers is always better” truism so that the EO guild system doesn’t remain boring/uncompetitive. Peace.
Basically imho a healthier guild system would incentivise people to think more about guilding with a smaller group of likeminded ppl while still engaging in healthy competition and diplomacy with the rest of the community. Yes some of the issues can be solved by build design. But until you have some way to curtail “bigger numbers is always better”, then to some degree the guild system will be boring/broken. Imagine a professional sport tournament that doesn’t have any caps on the amount of players on the roster! Eventually instead of having say 20 teams in a tournament they will start merging etc etc until I have 2 super teams with mega rosters and most players sitting disgruntled on the bench etc.... boring and uncompetitive result ensues. This is why salary caps and roster limits exist in sports. I’m not saying that we need to implement hard caps. But we do at least need some incentives etc such to counterbalance the “bigger numbers is always better” truism so that the EO guild system doesn’t remain boring/uncompetitive. Peace.
Cheers.
Guild Embers... more content... different content... minigames... different pathways to top gear.... All good things. I'm just starting to get upset because it's the same 3 or 4 people who are always crying even when they have even numbers. If it isn't an argument about numbers, it's an argument about gear. I don't think there is a solution to make everyone happy because I think some people will never be happy. At Thanny tonight it was 6v7 and it still turned into drama in global chat. There always has to be someone who screams because they get beat. Maybe one of the reasons why it's hard to keep builders is because when they do work hard to put something in game players can do nothing but complain about it. I can imagine how Nitehawk feels... working his butt off and he has 20 people telling him they know how to do it better.
i counted 10 v 4 v 3 at thanny. but considering silh only had 3 people on entirely im going to recommend an abacus for you. these numbers arent bad regardless. the oad is just bad design. endless zombies, no way to kill healers really, boss dont even do threatening damage. truth is i shouldnt have to go into an oad with 3 people and kill 8 people and have to face those 8 people over and over and over. on a simple boss like thanny if u die u should just be done with an acct lockout.
game shouldnt ever be 80% healers everywhere either. when 9/14 players in 1 group are all healers the concept is dumb. heal decay should be changed to guild healer decay. more than 3 healers of the same guild in a general vicinity to each other u start dropping heal efficiency drastically.
game shouldnt ever be 80% healers everywhere either. when 9/14 players in 1 group are all healers the concept is dumb. heal decay should be changed to guild healer decay. more than 3 healers of the same guild in a general vicinity to each other u start dropping heal efficiency drastically.
i counted 10 v 4 v 3 at thanny. but considering silh only had 3 people on entirely im going to recommend an abacus for you. these numbers arent bad regardless. the oad is just bad design. endless zombies, no way to kill healers really, boss dont even do threatening damage. truth is i shouldnt have to go into an oad with 3 people and kill 8 people and have to face those 8 people over and over and over. on a simple boss like thanny if u die u should just be done with an acct lockout.
game shouldnt ever be 80% healers everywhere either. when 9/14 players in 1 group are all healers the concept is dumb. heal decay should be changed to guild healer decay. more than 3 healers of the same guild in a general vicinity to each other u start dropping heal efficiency drastically.
As to the numbers, I tried to account for people switching characters so I may have missed one. Empire only had 7 people with a couple character swaps. Everyone at guild events is accounted for. Carnage and Silh seemed to have 8 but I think 2 were just character swaps. You may have been mistaken because a few of the Carnage members were actually former Empire. Either way, it was close numbers and actually a fun fight. Thanny moved around a lot this time and the changing rooms made it interesting instead of him sticking to the same 2 or 3 squares. The drama in general after was uncalled for though. That wasn't just one clan.
Thanny I think was designed for PVP action. People running back in isn't a major issue because of sickness. On other bosses and especially at dragon it can be a pain, but sickness always catches up. There are only a few OaDs you can zombie at (excluding keys) so that isn't a huge issue. I see it as a lot like the dropstealing issue. It is something that will happen but it isn't something that can't be accounted for and countered in some way. To me, a bigger issue is people running back in towns/shops/safe squares and only jumping out to get a few swings off before running again. Different people will see different issues as more important or problematic. I feel zombies isn't a major issue because 5 deaths and you can't even make it out of town again. At 3 deaths your stats are so diminished that you are ineffective. Also... if you think the monsters in the tomb aren't a threat you haven't been hit by the murderous spirits yet.
As for the guild heal decay, it is an interesting idea. When you have so many healers, one can simply sit out healing long enough for the pvp timer to expire if he's burning his mana too much. I can't think of a fair way coding such a thing would work. It would also complicate OaDs. Imagine facing the guild heal decay if you are running a priest/guard/mini/elder/brig party. I get that we want fair competition but we don't want to make the game play so complicated that people get frustrated at having to do calculus for an optimal party. I'd love to see an effective counter for a priest other than hoping they run out of potions (or numbers). The problem is that if we weaken priests any more they won't have any role in game. Already I've seen minstrels and guardians both fill in for priests in events and oads. Also, the reason so many people take healers to Thanny is the mirror rooms. That isn't a good representation of party distribution or a good boss area to try to judge strengths or weaknesses.
Still, I think we may be getting off topic a little and also beating a dead horse. It is what it is. No matter what is done or isn't, someone won't be happy. We already have people saying parties are too much. I think some people just have to find a reason for their not always being on top.
sickness does shit to a healer, they heal 7 damage less, get hit 2.25% more. this is the integral problem to zombies. if a dpser dies he gets worse if a healer dies it doesn't.
the objective imo is to encourage pvp. currently allowing zombies at all makes attempting outnumbered pointless. were as if i being 3 v9 and sneak attack and kill 4 or 5 stragglers and they got locked out theres always a chance for success. you would see smaller groups try more often.
guild heal decay wouldnt complicate oads...u bring 4+ healers? lol the oads last 10m and are piss easy unless ur trying a 5 man oad with 3 people. ringleader is harder
the objective imo is to encourage pvp. currently allowing zombies at all makes attempting outnumbered pointless. were as if i being 3 v9 and sneak attack and kill 4 or 5 stragglers and they got locked out theres always a chance for success. you would see smaller groups try more often.
guild heal decay wouldnt complicate oads...u bring 4+ healers? lol the oads last 10m and are piss easy unless ur trying a 5 man oad with 3 people. ringleader is harder
Would it actually be possible for death sickness instead of affecting stats, actually have it affect the end result (skill, spell, attack). So stats don't lower but the effectiveness of what you do does. I think it would be terribly icky to implement.
As for numbers and equipment whining, while I agree with you Kruell, you seem to have a lopsided view of it, because I am presuming you don't mean Empire, try to be all inclusive, because it is not a single clan restricted phenomena.
I say this, whining about numbers or gear is kinda lame, your equipment will get better and the numbers thing fluctuates, why not just say good fight and move on eh? You can always whine in clan chat.
The people screaming drama in global is also not restricted to one clan.
The problem with shit talk is everyone's definition of it is a little different. No harm in it, as long as it is kept civil (but again the civility definition varies from person to person). Basically it looks like there will always be drama unless the people who feel they are being targetted/troll'ed just ignore, and the people who are targetting/trolling just stop. Good luck fighting human nature though.
Why can't we all just hug instead? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cry.gif" alt=":cry:" title="Crying or Very Sad" />
Another option for guilds:
I think I have said before: Good/Evil. Cliche I know but...
Complications to this... OAD's etc. Too much of a reform on this one, but quite a lot of scope. I see it like this though. Certain areas/creatures/oads are "evil"
If you are "evil", you cannot do the "evil" stuff, those creatures cannot attack you and you cannot attack them. Same with "good". "Neutral" places/creatures/oad would be a free for all. This would have worked until neutral div was introduced. I guess neutral div can choose a side and get stuck with it.
Options:
A way to change your side through quests.
Nations:
Sorta like above but a national choice. OADS/areas/places etc could be kept the same. Then control crystal domination can have even more meaning. This way you can have nation restricted events/oads etc. I guess the Kingdom of Alderarra vs rebel scum?
The problem with either idea is likely friends will join friends, and then you have the guild thing all over again anyway, except a person is actually more restricted in their choice. You don't like person X who is in clan A or person Y who is in clan B, tough luck.
Guild Vaults: I guess you buy your own vault in the guild?
Loot division/storing will be fun.
Random Ideas:
OADS/Events/creature killing against your nation/alignment gets you special points and you can spend them in guild shop?
OAD's etc could give you points instead of an item or both?
Control crystal capture for points?
Gold donations to your side for points (and then remove points from creature killing?)?
This would mean that even if you cannot participate in OADS etc you can still end up getting decent gear.
The paragon system:
Sorta my good vs evil idea. Good/evil areas/creatures/oads restricted for the appropriate alignment (basically whichever one you have most paragon points in).
Although wasn't the paragon system changed to a single points thingy?
Anyway, if you gain too much points of either good or evil you could end up becoming unable to do either. This would make you actually choose a side. As in, if you get 100 good points, you can no longer do evil oads/quests, get 100 of good and evil and you can do neither.
I am rambling now, please forgive me. Back to sheep prawn.
As for numbers and equipment whining, while I agree with you Kruell, you seem to have a lopsided view of it, because I am presuming you don't mean Empire, try to be all inclusive, because it is not a single clan restricted phenomena.
I say this, whining about numbers or gear is kinda lame, your equipment will get better and the numbers thing fluctuates, why not just say good fight and move on eh? You can always whine in clan chat.
The people screaming drama in global is also not restricted to one clan.
The problem with shit talk is everyone's definition of it is a little different. No harm in it, as long as it is kept civil (but again the civility definition varies from person to person). Basically it looks like there will always be drama unless the people who feel they are being targetted/troll'ed just ignore, and the people who are targetting/trolling just stop. Good luck fighting human nature though.
Why can't we all just hug instead? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cry.gif" alt=":cry:" title="Crying or Very Sad" />
Another option for guilds:
I think I have said before: Good/Evil. Cliche I know but...
Complications to this... OAD's etc. Too much of a reform on this one, but quite a lot of scope. I see it like this though. Certain areas/creatures/oads are "evil"
If you are "evil", you cannot do the "evil" stuff, those creatures cannot attack you and you cannot attack them. Same with "good". "Neutral" places/creatures/oad would be a free for all. This would have worked until neutral div was introduced. I guess neutral div can choose a side and get stuck with it.
Options:
A way to change your side through quests.
Nations:
Sorta like above but a national choice. OADS/areas/places etc could be kept the same. Then control crystal domination can have even more meaning. This way you can have nation restricted events/oads etc. I guess the Kingdom of Alderarra vs rebel scum?
The problem with either idea is likely friends will join friends, and then you have the guild thing all over again anyway, except a person is actually more restricted in their choice. You don't like person X who is in clan A or person Y who is in clan B, tough luck.
Guild Vaults: I guess you buy your own vault in the guild?
Loot division/storing will be fun.
Random Ideas:
OADS/Events/creature killing against your nation/alignment gets you special points and you can spend them in guild shop?
OAD's etc could give you points instead of an item or both?
Control crystal capture for points?
Gold donations to your side for points (and then remove points from creature killing?)?
This would mean that even if you cannot participate in OADS etc you can still end up getting decent gear.
The paragon system:
Sorta my good vs evil idea. Good/evil areas/creatures/oads restricted for the appropriate alignment (basically whichever one you have most paragon points in).
Although wasn't the paragon system changed to a single points thingy?
Anyway, if you gain too much points of either good or evil you could end up becoming unable to do either. This would make you actually choose a side. As in, if you get 100 good points, you can no longer do evil oads/quests, get 100 of good and evil and you can do neither.
I am rambling now, please forgive me. Back to sheep prawn.
I'm just starting to get upset because it's the same 3 or 4 people who are always crying even when they have even numbers. If it isn't an argument about numbers, it's an argument about gear. I don't think there is a solution to make everyone happy because I think some people will never be happy.
Yep no game can keep everyone happy. But my observation is the current system keeps a lot of ppl (probably more than not) somewhat unhappy.
The irony is that your arguments are generally all ones I’ve had thrown at me before by Silh players defending their right to dominate in the past. The current incarnation of vocal criers are unhappy cos they get dominated. And most of these are newer players who joined after the era of Silh dominting the game via numbers (I’m guessing most old Silh are either now awol or won’t cry cos it would be hypocritical for them to do so after telling other ppl to essentially “man up, cupcakes” for so long while Silh were the most numerous). Now these newer players have joined the game and are experiencing (at the hands of Empire) the same domination by a more numerous more established group that many older Empire players experienced at the hands of Silh. And that’s the sad thing - the abused son has grown into an abusive father. The cycle has continued (just with a different face) and more new blood is getting chewed up and spat out by it.
But even within the dominating faction im guessing there’s probably also a whole bunch of silently crying ppl who would rather earn faster or do their own thing or avoid some annoying ppl in their superguild without leaving the rest that they do like etc.... but they know they won’t ever progress (or will even find themselves persecuted) if they try to leave and go solo/small. These are probably some of the hidden, ‘quiet-achieivng’ players you have previously mentioned.
So basically the current guild system means you have a lot of sub-happy ppl. The only people ‘happy’ are those either play for reasons other than wanting to win, or those who are ‘winning’ by being on the dominating (usually most numerous) faction and who are senior/active enough within that faction to earn well from that. I believe this group represents a minority of the potential active playerbase.
So just as I advocated to Silh when they were championing the current (broken) system, the reason for change is not to please everyone but to find ways to please more people and keep them playing. Especially changes that help retain newer players and re-engages now disinterested veterans so that the active playerbase for the game will actually grow. Peace.