← Forum archive

Monks

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Folder
Lat mentioned this in another thread but let's discuss it here. Monks are too strong right now imo.

As was mentioned...4 attacks, best MR, best dodge, cheapest to equip, there's really zero downside to them right now. Their damage per attack is also pretty damn high.

We weren't really seeing monk domination at 25 with oad gear so I'm not sure anything needs to be done, but worth looking at I think.
Cerebrus
Personally, and this isnt because I play monk, but I think their damage sucks. I miss A LOT and hit for under 100 most of the time with a mid 100's rh every now and then, but I do know once 25, they connect more often, so I guess it evens out? lol
Folder
Have you fully blessed whatever weapon you're using? I've been getting hit in pvp for ~120 damage neutral div.
NiteHawk
I'd prefer wiating until we have 25'ers before we make major balance changes.

Monks are far easier to level, but the damage boost they gain per level is lower then other classes. They deal the least damage but obviously have one extra attack which balances them out. They are easier at lower levels then most classes by far due to the above.

They also get the monk hand damage bonus, which obviously is nice at lower levels. If it's too high to start you can always adjust the monk hand bonus per level, it starts off at 8 and ends at 13. It can be adjusted to be whatever. They could start off with a lower bonus, for example.

But yeah, again, need to wait until 25'ers start coming out. Balancing at the moment might be a bit early, though if they are OK at high level but op at lower, then again, hand bonus/etc could be adjusted.
Lateralus
Yea its hard to say right now its prob good to wait.

The reason i brought it up was because i just dont see a counter to them. I think they could stand to lose the wis bonus that would atleast put them in line with other physical combat. right now they out dodge and out hit all which is fine because their damage is a bit low? althought i think 5 attacks and a 2x attack in there puts them above most. on top of that atleast casters can counter the other physical classes but with monk you dont even need to invest in wis because its already there bonus you can just dump all your stats offensive.

again best to wait but at low levels they dominate everything even casters when they only have 10-14wis
NiteHawk
If monks end up being 'ok' at level 25 once we have proper OAD gear in, then we need to look at the way they scale.

Right now for exampe, they start with a +8 weapon bonus and it scales to +13 at level 25. +1 per 4 levels. The idea here would be to scale THIS part down, for example, it could start at +4 weapon bonus instead and scale up to +9. Then the missing +4 would go into staves themselves (so stave weapons would get a boost.). This means that the damage would scale lower but ramp up.

They are MEANT to deal lower damage, because they deal an extra damage. You can claim 'my knight hits for 200 damage, but my monk only deals 150 damage!'. You cannot say that exactly because its 200x4=800, vs 150x5=750. Pretty similar though (but still... overall monks SHOULD do lower damage with 5 attacks in exchange for hitting more often.)

The other solution to help this along is to either make them dodge more, or have a better hitrate, but not both. I am mixed onto what would be better though to keep if that would be the case. Or the actual AGI gain can be changed. Maybe they don't even need a bonus because they have amazing MR etc.

Or maybe they need lower overall damage. But I feel like the damage is not so much the issue here?

I think overall MONKS will have to be balanced, maybe we should do it sooner than later. I don't really know yet, I'm trying to avoid this right now but tons of people are playing monks and I assume it is obviously because they are decent characters to use. Technically I think some classes (druids for example) are better, though there is more to micro manage with them.)

I'm also not sure why people aren't playing zerkers like they were pre-wipe. They haven't changed at all, they are still powerhouses anyways. I think for example, people have hyped up Monks and instead of playing for themselves, they just go with monks and think 'BEST IS BEST'. Don't get me wrong, they are a good class, but I do think it got out of hand with people picking them just from word of mouth.


P.S. I dont' think removing their wis bonus is good. That's the only thing that makes them more unique than other classes. Otherwise they are just another fighter class that gets dominated by spells. I think other mechanics on them should be changed so they stay a unique type of fighter.
daedroth
I prefer monk because I like defence over offence, mainly because when I am levelling I am doing other stuff (reading, watching something, supervising kids). With monks I do not need to worry so much about alt dying because I was sidetracked and I'm sitting on a spawn spot. I have noticed though that there are a LOT of monks running around... That usually means people have decided their the shitz (kinda like old rok lings). Their also less focused on gear (in my opinion anyway) and I'm a cheap bastage <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Drasp
My barb will, eventually, level up.

eventually.

Will say, made a monk to see what all the rage was about. Leveling at low levels is surprisingly easier.

Say, can barbarians be given the skill "astrophysics"? It doesn't have to do anything, but might make me feel better about being an idiot barbarian.
NiteHawk
My barb will, eventually, level up.

eventually.

Will say, made a monk to see what all the rage was about. Leveling at low levels is surprisingly easier.

Say, can barbarians be given the skill "astrophysics"? It doesn't have to do anything, but might make me feel better about being an idiot barbarian.


Yeah it is due to the monk damage, I probably need to adjust it to scale differently with same end game damage results. Thing is I suppose, that items are locked, it isn't like ROK, so having a rather high base value to start with might be too much.
Honzo
Toe be quite fair I think that the +2 agi thing being taken away would solve everything. Like I posted in the other thread, they kind of just get everything and it's all for free. Just normalize their Agi like every other character and they would still be powerhouses. The MR is at 15% right? The second highest is sorc at 12% then cleric at 8% right? I don't see why Monks have more magic resist than ACTUAL spell casters. Why not take it down a notch to 10% and take away the +2 effective agi? boom, problem solved. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> Or at least seems like it would be a very good starting point. I also like the idea of lowering their starting dmg and pushing it in to staves if need be, but dmg doesn't seem to be the problem like you said. ^_^
Just my 2c! If you did those changes and needed something else to compensate, why not add a neat leveling ability like "Meditate". It could allow you to heal X amount over X seconds and exhaust all your stamina for the round.
Atticuz
No idea where i should post this, so I am putting here

I want it to be known I am not whinging but rather looking for an answer

I don't know how it is for other Ninja's but man I feel useless in PVP and i'll show an example.

You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
Lightning stands in front of Mystrina!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
Lightning stands in front of Mystrina!
You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 44 points of damage!
A shadow golem attacks you with its shadow fists and misses!
Lightning stands in front of Mystrina!
You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 53 points of damage!
You launch into a ROUNDHOUSE KICK against Lightning and miss!

round 1 97 damage in two hits

You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs some of the blow for 54 points of damage!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 47 points of damage!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!

round 2 101 damage in two hits

You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs some of the blow for 64 points of damage!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!

Round 3 64 damage in one hit

You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his shield deflects half of the blow for 55 points of damage!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 50 points of damage!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!

Round 4 105 damage in 2 hits

You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!
You attack Lightning with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 55 points of damage!
You attack Lightning with your void staff and miss!

Round 5 55 damage in one hit

Lightning attacks you with his void blade, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 126 points of damage!
Lightning attacks you with his void blade and misses!
Lightning attacks you with his void blade and misses!
A shadow golem attacks you with its shadow fists for 56 points of damage!
Lightning attacks you with his void blade for 159 points of damage!

He was afk so he only got one round in before the enchanter blew me up

I assume the damage is normal as I was against Div and he probably had a stoneskin from the enchanter he was chilling with.

It's the hit rate I am confused about.
I have 23 agi, he is a Halfling and therefore probably has 24 ( I dont know as he gave a douchebag of an answer when asked)

Is this is normal? (as in how you planned high agi pvp fights to go)
I feel this happen alot in PVP where i am pretty much useless.
If this is supposed to be this way (as in one or two hits a round) ill shut my mouth and move on.
NiteHawk
Again, you can't give 5 rounds of testing and say this is for all PVP.

But yeah, it will be around 38% hit rate against a ling. I'd need more examples and proper data rather then 5 rounds, doesn't cut it at all. Solo 1vs1 are going to be generally longer because when you get a proper party I feel the hit rate overall is pretty good for good 4-6 vs 4-6 fights. In general it's either going to be generally that solo is balanced and parties are going to be wacko in damage (aka everyone dies) or solo will be tougher to kill but in parties it's more balanced. At the moment I'd think it's the latter overall and does require you to team up at least in a small group.

With rates for that too he can get lucky, he can get armor absorbs, etc etc that don't happen in other rounds. And yeah, fighting against div is normally bad overall for your health. You'd probably want to stick to minimum neutral when testing.
Atticuz
Righto

So he got lucky 5 rounds in a row and either absorbed or deflected all my blows, man Atticuz must have a hidden stat for just being the most unluckiest Ninja in game

So what you are saying is make a Halfling everything or only PVP with a Ninja when in a team fight?

But seriously if you like i can post all my fights here and you will see Atticuz feels more like Lee Sin the Blind Monk
daedroth
Righto

So he got lucky 5 rounds in a row and either absorbed or deflected all my blows, man Atticuz must have a hidden stat for just being the most unluckiest Ninja in game

So what you are saying is make a Halfling everything or only PVP with a Ninja when in a team fight?

But seriously if you like i can post all my fights here and you will see Atticuz feels more like Lee Sin the Blind Monk


You hit my chanter pretty damn consistently (90ac with SS, 22agl). You had div aye, but that does not affect hit-rate (well to my knowledge)... I never kept the log, but I did not see you miss much.
daedroth
That is interesting

I am more then willing to get some testing going, if anyone is up for it


I am far too fat and lazy for that <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> But I am curious and want to test some stuff... I just need to be in the right mood. Right now I am far too busy trying to level 4 alts; I can't decide which one I want most to get to 25th.

Harass your clannies into it! All in the name of science, I am sure they will understand.
Thi
Dat Lightning, dodging even when grabbing a cup of coffee, badass.

P. S. You did not get a douchebag reply from me, I'm in no way obliged to comply with your request to know my stats. Here's my reply "that's a trade secret". Next time I might give you a douchebag reply, like "suck it up and post on the forums, QQ", see hows that different?
Atticuz
Dat Lightning, dodging even when grabbing a cup of coffee, badass.

P. S. You did not get a douchebag reply from me, I'm in no way obliged to comply with your request to know my stats. Here's my reply "that's a trade secret". Next time I might give you a douchebag reply, like "suck it up and post on the forums, QQ", see hows that different?



Different opinions of douchebaggery i guess

When trying to get as much data as i can i am met with the above, sounds pretty douchebag to me.

Are you not also curious tho?

If you ask your clan mates more then half can raise their hand and say they whomped me in a fight, just feels really off whenever i engage in PVP
Thi
Dat Lightning, dodging even when grabbing a cup of coffee, badass.

P. S. You did not get a douchebag reply from me, I'm in no way obliged to comply with your request to know my stats. Here's my reply "that's a trade secret". Next time I might give you a douchebag reply, like "suck it up and post on the forums, QQ", see hows that different?



Different opinions of douchebaggery i guess

Are you not also curious tho?

If you ask your clan mates more then half can raise their hand and say they whomped me in a fight, just feels really off whenever i engage in PVP

I'd more or so say you have a wrong concept of what a douchebag is.

As for your monk losing too often, our guild has so many casters that most of the fights you die in 1 round so it's hard to say, I've hardly had fights with you that a caster wasn't present.

As I told you, I had Div and stoneskin up plus I'm a ling so, on most rounds you got at least 2 hits in, where I usually only get 1, but the chanter ate you.

Having said that, you had a hit rate of 40% which is not bad by all means, but I had AC enough to deflect plenty of hits.

The only thing I think needs looking at is Div bonuses, as I told Chris before I belive they are too hard, meaning fighting against Div is an auto-loss, specially versus classes like ninjas, slayers and zerkers that gets bonus damage multiplied over.
NiteHawk
Eh let's keep it on topic.

So he got lucky 5 rounds in a row and either absorbed or deflected all my blows, man Atticuz must have a hidden stat for just being the most unluckiest Ninja in game

So what you are saying is make a Halfling everything or only PVP with a Ninja when in a team fight?


Base overall is 40% when AGi is the same (and no class bonuses). That goes for all classes, not just monks. And yeah, it can be luck. If it's not 100% on everything, it CAN be luck. If your fighting a paladin against div he also has a spell that reduces damage against div, so you'd be even worse off if that was the case there in terms of damage.

If it's 38% hit rate for example, or around, then yeah, there are chances that you'll do horrible, and do good. 38% is probably around 2/4 hit rate, just under ON average. Shield absorbing, again, another random luck. It's probably around 40% overall with armor and a shield, but again, it's the draw of the luck. Surely you understand that 38% is more the average on your hit rate against a 24 agi ling. I.E. out of 10000 attacks, 3800 of them will be hits, the rest will be misses. This doesn't mean that you'll always hit 2 per round too. Some rounds you could do higher, some rounds you can do lower. But the final hit value with 10000 attacks will typically be around 3800 hits.


Not sure why you also state about everyone being lings now, which makes no sense either. 19 vs 20 agi would be exactly the same as fighting someone 23 vs 24 agi. Obviously not including class bonuses, but that is maybe another agi point on top. But on the extremes, which is probably 19 agi vs 24 agi, It would be 50% hit rate vs 30% hit rate. (24 agi would hit the 19 agi 50% of the time, while other way around it would be 30% of the time.) The difference here is, the strength and power of lower AGI classes typically that make the classes more 'random' but bigger payoffs when they work... Each AGI point is about 2% but a little more for monks for dodging, a little less on zerkers for dodging, and a little more hit rate for knights.

And yes, one fight of 5 rounds gives absolutely no testing data at all. What you need is several fights, several different classes, races, and other people testing. People generally need to help out here and give feedback, not just one person. Even if the data is 'I think AGI is fine'.

Heres a good example of a 1 to 100 dice roll 10000 times, you can see gaps of missing (more so since its 38% hit rate) and some grouped hits, it would be same to how your character would work against 24 agi.

<a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1eOMEtANpFP58UcDW_8_hgXA9wCdRMCDx1hh8T_Rns7E/edit?usp=sharing">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing</a>




In terms of divinity bonuses, they could be looked at yeah. But in ROK it was pretty much a set 15% as well and no one really fretted. Hence why I went with that, though we can change it up if people feel it has to be.

Auto-loss? Nah, just very hard. It typically was meant to be though.