← Forum archive

PVP Dodge/Hitrate/Damage/HP

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Folder
For fairness sake I think using 23 agi for lings is better since 24 is +1.

Besides that though this isn't JUST about lings, it's any higher agi race. Was just using lings for my examples. Also for the record I'm not a fan of any 19 agi race having an awful hit rate, that's not the solution here.
NiteHawk
For fairness sake I think using 23 agi for lings is better since 24 is +1.

Besides that though this isn't JUST about lings, it's any higher agi race. Was just using lings for my examples. Also for the record I'm not a fan of any 19 agi race having an awful hit rate, that's not the solution here.


Yeah true my bad. 8) But basing it off the highest damage vs highest agi. Though I guess that should be considered 25 str then too.
NiteHawk
23 agi now.



HO DW attacking Ling with shield:
Not DW = 16.81 attacks to kill
DW = 15.26 attacks to kill.

HO DW attacking Ling with no shield:
Not DW = 15.9 attacks to kill
DW = 14 attacks to kill.

Ling attacking HO with shield:
Not DW = 20.35 attacks to kill
DW = 18.65 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO without shield:
Not DW = 19 attacks to kill
DW = 17.4 attacks to kill


Even bigger differ, one round on average more, and even at the highest variables, (lets say two non DW'ing characters... the HO would be something like 12.8-20.8, to lings 18.35-22.35 type deal.) I can obviously see why Lings (or lower agi chars) would never win in alot of cases.
NiteHawk
This is current HP formula: (END-7)*3*LVL*ClassBonus (for reference)

So this is my new test:

Per AGI = 2.75% instead of 2.0%
New HP formula = (END+1)*2*LVL*ClassBonus

HO HP 23 END: 1320HP
LING HP 17 END: 990HP


HO DW attacking Ling with shield:
Not DW = 20.01 attacks to kill
DW = 18.27 attacks to kill.

HO DW attacking Ling with no shield:
Not DW = 18.35 attacks to kill
DW = 17.55 attacks to kill.


Ling attacking HO with shield:
Not DW = 19.15 attacks to kill
DW = 17.55 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO without shield:
Not DW = 17.88 attacks to kill
DW = 16.4 attacks to kill


----

In this scenario lings look a little better. However, HO obviously have the random chance. It will again, look more like this:

HO DW attacking Ling with shield:
Not DW = 16.01-24.01 attacks to kill
DW = 14.27-22.27 attacks to kill.

HO DW attacking Ling with no shield:
Not DW = 14.35-22.35 attacks to kill
DW = 13.55-21.55 attacks to kill.


Ling attacking HO with shield:
Not DW = 17.15-21.15 attacks to kill
DW = 15.55-19.55 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO without shield:
Not DW = 15.88-19.88 attacks to kill
DW = 14.4-18.4 attacks to kill

----

This means that in some cases, because of high random and high damage, you will win.. Or you pick a less random race (like lings) and don't do those 'extreme's but instead are more 'safe'. Lings will be the better 'average' while HO's would be better at 'WTF moments'. Once this is actually sorted we might want to look at time to kill on average but that's another topic. Changing that as a whole doesn't effect the AGI rates or anything. Should be OK I think as it is though..


If the above is too much then 2.5% brings it the other way where HO's are a little better but I feel that higher AGI should be more reliable while lower AGI high STR should be random. 2.6% brings them to be the 'same' though, which could work.

P.S. The charisma bonus is added per level away from this formula based on the other post I made. But ignored for now.
Folder
I like where we are headed now. Orcs should have the edge in melee over a ling, mathematically speaking. I don't think we want them to be directly equal because, well yeah, orcs are melee ONLY. They should be a bit scarier than weaker races, I just think it was disproportionate.

Those last numbers make them very equal it seems like? Maybe favor it back towards the orc/dwarf/whatever a little more?
NiteHawk
2.3% per AGI then?

But 2.3% puts them a little higher then.

HO DW attacking Ling with shield:
Not DW = 18.84 attacks to kill
DW = 17.21 attacks to kill.

HO DW attacking Ling with no shield:
Not DW = 17.27 attacks to kill
DW = 16.53 attacks to kill.


Ling attacking HO with shield:
Not DW = 19.85 attacks to kill
DW = 18.19 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO without shield:
Not DW = 18.54 attacks to kill
DW = 16.99 attacks to kill


Overall seems better, You got to remember though that half orcs will sometimes get those better hits and kill the ling fast, or not at all. It's a chance and all that, even though the average is XX, the actual min/max rounds is larger for HOs.
daedroth
Out of curiosity. If there is going to be drastic changes to the END/AGL/STR formulas, will there be another free stat respec?
NiteHawk
Out of curiosity. If there is going to be drastic changes to the END/AGL/STR formulas, will there be another free stat respec?


This really isnt' a drastic change, so no.

END HP modifies automatically. I highly doubt anyone would modify their END because of this. STR isn't being changed overall that would matter.
Styx
Pally suck, I have yet to see a 200 hit with div so how you basing damage with 200 and I do have a dwaf. 21 str 20 agi, I should have human hit rate at least

Btw a pally can't fight and heal then finish the fight as easy as you think in pve cause I tried that and got owned.

You need to rethink strategy

Orc berserker I've seen just do multiple flurry until it dies? And pally can't hit the side of a barn?

Maybe that's why they just make orc zerkers now?
NiteHawk
Pally suck, I have yet to see a 200 hit with div so how you basing damage with 200 and I do have a dwaf. 21 str 20 agi, I should have human hit rate at least

Btw a pally can't fight and heal then finish the fight as easy as you think in pve cause I tried that and got owned.

You need to rethink strategy

Orc berserker I've seen just do multiple flurry until it dies? And pally can't hit the side of a barn?

Maybe that's why they just make orc zerkers now?


Pallies with a OAD weapon, which the best one isn't out yet, would do 151-203, so yeah under 200. A zerker with 21 str would do 176-237.

Zerkers can do three in a row and it resets.

Pally/etc all have the same hit rate modifier. zerkers do have a dodge rate negative though.


I do think zerkers and cavaliers have too high of a damage modifier though. Mainly because they will be often using higher STR classes and they get a large bonus as it is.
NiteHawk
This is current with 21 STR if OAD weapons were here:
Knight:171-231
Assassins BS: 656 with DW.
Barb: 176-237 DW MAX: 261
Pally: 151-203

25 STR (HO +1):
Knight:203-274
Assassins BS: 781 with DW.
Barb: 209-283 DW MAX: 311
Pally:179-242 (obviously a HO pally is eh)


This is also a slight issue. Obviously they cannot heal but they can pick the high STR races with no issues.
Might be better if it was:

Knight:163-220
Assassins BS: 635 with DW.
Barb: 166-224 DW MAX: 246
Pally: 151-203

25 STR (HO +1):
Knight:194-262
Assassins BS: 756 with DW.
Barb: 197-266 DW MAX: 293
Pally:179-242 (obviously a HO pally again)


The only race I could see that needs modifying after this is druids, which would get somewhere between pally/knight. Remember that barbs get the rage bonus too.

Says?
Folder
This is current with 21 STR if OAD weapons were here:
Knight:171-231
Assassins BS: 656 with DW.
Barb: 176-237 DW MAX: 261
Pally: 151-203

25 STR (HO +1):
Knight:203-274
Assassins BS: 781 with DW.
Barb: 209-283 DW MAX: 311
Pally:179-242 (obviously a HO pally is eh)


This is also a slight issue. Obviously they cannot heal but they can pick the high STR races with no issues.
Might be better if it was:

Knight:163-220
Assassins BS: 635 with DW.
Barb: 166-224 DW MAX: 246
Pally: 151-203

25 STR (HO +1):
Knight:194-262
Assassins BS: 756 with DW.
Barb: 197-266 DW MAX: 293
Pally:179-242 (obviously a HO pally again)


The only race I could see that needs modifying after this is druids, which would get somewhere between pally/knight. Remember that barbs get the rage bonus too.

Says?


In my experience so far, yeah pally damage is lower but I think it's fine. They have so much more utility than the others and their defense is way higher. I feel the damage tradeoff is fair. IMO if pallys were to do more damage we'd let them use 2H, but we've had that discussion before. As is they are tankier and do lower damage, it doesn't feel bad to me.

Not sure on druids, I have no experience myself beyond lv23. Fighting them they do not seem very strong, but that's not great input.

edit: imma beat this to death. I'll say this forever and ever lol, guards being penalized for guarding is bleh. They don't feel strong and I'd guess more people don't use them because of this. It's not their damage output, it's the fact that when you guard you take more damage so it creates this weird situation where you don't really want to guard so often. I feel it every time I take my guard out to pvp or do a boss, and it doesn't feel good. My guard is benched most of the time because of this, not the damage or heal output.
NiteHawk
Knights/Barbs damage was based on knights having nothing before hand and barbs having negative agi. Both are different now and I think they are both useful. Both often are in higher str races, so you'll always output more DPS. The DPS is far to high on them, so a little nerf would help balance things out now that everythings more balanced/sorted.

Druids actually are OK, based on the fact that they don't start off with 24-25 STR too, so ends up being okay, not touching them. The biggest two are knights/barbs, and then slayers getting a slight nerf too but very minimal.

My final values are:

STR 21:
Pallies: 151-203 (Same, just here for comparison)
Knight 161-217 *will be able to use two handers that will boost around 5% in future but have unique things*
Barb: 163-220, DW 179-247 Max
Assassin: 406-565 BS, DW 447-621 Max

STR 25:
Pallies: 179-242 (Obv half orc pallies arent' a thing)
Knight 191-258
Barb: 194-262, DW 213-289 Max
Assassin: 484-672 BS, DW 532-740 Max


These changes along with the other changes should hopefully balance out the races a little more, while zerkers/assassins still lead the DPS group, its not by the huge gap that it shouldn't be currently. (well assassins still hurt like hell though.. 8))

Pallies /guard, I still don't know. Maybe the AGI nerf can be removed but it than be aimed towards magic still doing a little more piercing as it is now.
Folder
Where are druids and ninjas on there, out of curiosity?

We really need some more lvl25 weapons ingame, it hurts some classes pretty bad..like druids.
NiteHawk
Where are druids and ninjas on there, out of curiosity?

We really need some more lvl25 weapons ingame, it hurts some classes pretty bad..like druids.


A druid with 41 str which is average I'd think would be at 163-229.. This was changed though recently. It was about -8 damage less before but I put them in the middle now.


Ninjas
21 STR: 151-181
25 STR: 179-215
Folder
Dang ninjas seem pretty low on there. I realize RH has its place to balance that out but not sure it actually makes up the difference in practice.

Ehhh sorry, derailing.
NiteHawk
Dang ninjas seem pretty low on there. I realize RH has its place to balance that out but not sure it actually makes up the difference in practice.

Ehhh sorry, derailing.


x5 hits.
If you were to equate it with others even without RH

Ninja
215x5=1075

Knight
242x4=968

Obviously you 'have' to hit more so it's a little harder, but the damage to me is enough. The values generally had nothing to do with RH.
NiteHawk
So far:

-Minor tweaks to damage on some classes.
-Tweaks to HP formula (more HP on less END)
-Dodge is 2.3% instead of 2.0%
-/protect has no AGI nerf, but still has a magic nerf (atm)
-/track takes no turns.
-Minor changes to smite (already IG)
-Div bonus starts at 10%, max is 15%.
Thi
Well, shouldn't Guardians and Cavaliers have a similar damage range since they serve similar purposes with one being pvp oriented and the other pve oriented?

I feel cavaliers are too strong right now because they provide a lot of utility with Taunt and Shield Bash, plus HP bonus and still do VERY good damage.