PVP Dodge/Hitrate/Damage/HP
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
probably just monk in general. highest MR bonus for melee class, extra stam, highest potential damage output, highest dodge.
In terms of changes, when something is changed you can't expect everyone to change on the dime either. The next patch will give most low end races, which should include most spell caster races, a boost, while decreasing damage on those heavy DPS classes that are hitting like machines. But expecting the problem to fix itself within a week is not going to happen as people need to see and realize there are other options out there.
Saurians could be taken a look at but for now I want to hold off as there's ALOT of changes.
I 'am' changing up the damage a little on spells on to too. I think the variance is a little strong when it comes to some spells, so some spells might have an overall average boosted by a few points rather than max (I'm talking about 3-6 damage for the most case). I think the max damage is overall OK. but a degree of 5 changes instead of 7 would be OK on beam for example. Generally sorcs and necros should be what knights and bards are in the spell department.
I'm also giving spell caster classes lower end damage rather then their damage being non existent. For example a level 25 necromancer with 20 strength on div will do 108-150 damage with a dagger. It's still lower than other classes, and you won't see many 20 strength necros, but it's not useless and may come up with some interesting builds. Sorcs have the a little lower modifier but obviously they wont' do as much because they can only use staves, so you might be looking at -25 damage less on the above numbers, though it might be around the same/just under with the POWER spell.
A cleric with 20 str will prob do around 97-136 damage. which is still low, but it's better then their original 71-100 which is non existant damage. Obviously it's probably still better to go with spells as pierce rate is often higher than dodge rate though.
Generally I'm trying to make physical damage not completely useless in high STR situations, though regardless I don't see them going much more then this because they SHOULDN'T be anywhere near what a knight or barb can do (and obviously they are NOT even with the above numbers.)
I didn't feel there was a reason to gimp the damage modifier per class THAT much just because, because most classes can't pick STR and INT with other things too without gimping themselves too hard so I'm trying to close the gap a little.
Saurians could be taken a look at but for now I want to hold off as there's ALOT of changes.
I 'am' changing up the damage a little on spells on to too. I think the variance is a little strong when it comes to some spells, so some spells might have an overall average boosted by a few points rather than max (I'm talking about 3-6 damage for the most case). I think the max damage is overall OK. but a degree of 5 changes instead of 7 would be OK on beam for example. Generally sorcs and necros should be what knights and bards are in the spell department.
I'm also giving spell caster classes lower end damage rather then their damage being non existent. For example a level 25 necromancer with 20 strength on div will do 108-150 damage with a dagger. It's still lower than other classes, and you won't see many 20 strength necros, but it's not useless and may come up with some interesting builds. Sorcs have the a little lower modifier but obviously they wont' do as much because they can only use staves, so you might be looking at -25 damage less on the above numbers, though it might be around the same/just under with the POWER spell.
A cleric with 20 str will prob do around 97-136 damage. which is still low, but it's better then their original 71-100 which is non existant damage. Obviously it's probably still better to go with spells as pierce rate is often higher than dodge rate though.
Generally I'm trying to make physical damage not completely useless in high STR situations, though regardless I don't see them going much more then this because they SHOULDN'T be anywhere near what a knight or barb can do (and obviously they are NOT even with the above numbers.)
I didn't feel there was a reason to gimp the damage modifier per class THAT much just because, because most classes can't pick STR and INT with other things too without gimping themselves too hard so I'm trying to close the gap a little.
Slayers are trash 1v1. Repeatedly having neutral div ninjas going 3/5 every round.
Slayers are not trash. Perhaps you just don't like the combination you have chosen or should try another race/class combination. Slayers are great, it's just that they have counters. Can't blame bad luck on the class. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Nighthawk, does this mean that casters are getting a damage nerf or if this ONLY for physical dmg on casters?
Nighthawk, does this mean that casters are getting a damage nerf or if this ONLY for physical dmg on casters?
if spell damage is being lowered the inaffect rate definitely needs changed.
last night we started a baby party all level 1's, during which my mage(sorceress) was owning most killshots etc but by the time we left bullfrogs and the level 4 mobs, i basically did 1 hit per 11 casts on beggars bandits etc. it was so bad i actually counted. from levels 8 to 12 i only successfully cast 7 beams out of 76 attempts 0 were fizzles. then on we went to shadow assassins with a steady rate of 3 successes out of 20, my sorceress fell behind an entire level to the assassin, nearly 2 levels, which is ironic as seeing the assassin missed exp on a few KS for moving off square. by the time the party was level 15 and trying to equip up for level 15 i was still 62332 exp short of level 14. after i pointed it out , multiple clannies just said u must have went afk 30x , this irritated me so i logged on my monk to sit afk for reals.
this is the 5th time i've tried a sorcerer ive hated it and just reallocated for my gold back then deleted. (i tried a dwarf and goblin first, i just blamed the inaffects on 17 int.) i know that if i tough it out itll get better at lvl 20. but the thing is i dont want to kill level 4 monsters til level 8 then kill level 8 mobs to 15 then struggle on level 15 mobs til i finally get level 20. just to have a decent success rate.
cleric tends to be very similar to mage, ray is op then once u leave frogs and mosquitos it sucks, then u grind on the lumbering bear to level 10. then i run my ass off to GY and heal kill 5-6 undead with cure/heal and im level 16 <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> kill a few more and 17 then grind mode sets in. i usually stop at 17 cuz the risk vs gain isnt worth it theres always stacks of enemies sitting in GY constantly. luckily, for reasons unexplained to me, none of these pkers like to share pks with their own friends and always attack me alone. in which case i run to town and log for my next quick pop on for an undead kill.
may seem wierd to you but id rather cast heal for 55 53 52 on undead than use ray and do 89 unaffect unaffect all day.
sorcerers is only successful 2 ways small steady bursts and immensely powerful spells, or the glass cannon theory doesn't hold up and u might aswell just play a barbarian. in this case the small steady bursts is healing undead and the immensely powerful spells are roundhouse, fury, and backstab. so for me a mage isnt spectacular to play. im starting to believe the only reason they are trained is for brill scrolls and pvp events against horcs/saurians.
last night we started a baby party all level 1's, during which my mage(sorceress) was owning most killshots etc but by the time we left bullfrogs and the level 4 mobs, i basically did 1 hit per 11 casts on beggars bandits etc. it was so bad i actually counted. from levels 8 to 12 i only successfully cast 7 beams out of 76 attempts 0 were fizzles. then on we went to shadow assassins with a steady rate of 3 successes out of 20, my sorceress fell behind an entire level to the assassin, nearly 2 levels, which is ironic as seeing the assassin missed exp on a few KS for moving off square. by the time the party was level 15 and trying to equip up for level 15 i was still 62332 exp short of level 14. after i pointed it out , multiple clannies just said u must have went afk 30x , this irritated me so i logged on my monk to sit afk for reals.
this is the 5th time i've tried a sorcerer ive hated it and just reallocated for my gold back then deleted. (i tried a dwarf and goblin first, i just blamed the inaffects on 17 int.) i know that if i tough it out itll get better at lvl 20. but the thing is i dont want to kill level 4 monsters til level 8 then kill level 8 mobs to 15 then struggle on level 15 mobs til i finally get level 20. just to have a decent success rate.
cleric tends to be very similar to mage, ray is op then once u leave frogs and mosquitos it sucks, then u grind on the lumbering bear to level 10. then i run my ass off to GY and heal kill 5-6 undead with cure/heal and im level 16 <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> kill a few more and 17 then grind mode sets in. i usually stop at 17 cuz the risk vs gain isnt worth it theres always stacks of enemies sitting in GY constantly. luckily, for reasons unexplained to me, none of these pkers like to share pks with their own friends and always attack me alone. in which case i run to town and log for my next quick pop on for an undead kill.
may seem wierd to you but id rather cast heal for 55 53 52 on undead than use ray and do 89 unaffect unaffect all day.
sorcerers is only successful 2 ways small steady bursts and immensely powerful spells, or the glass cannon theory doesn't hold up and u might aswell just play a barbarian. in this case the small steady bursts is healing undead and the immensely powerful spells are roundhouse, fury, and backstab. so for me a mage isnt spectacular to play. im starting to believe the only reason they are trained is for brill scrolls and pvp events against horcs/saurians.
Keep in mind in that group we were killing shadow assassins very early. They are...level 20? our group was killing them at lvl12-13 so the unaffect/miss rate was high.
yes the unaffect rate should be higher on a lvl 20 monster when staring down a lvl 13 but how did the melee classes hit so much easier?
im assuming level has more to do with mobs MR than it does dexterity but i dunno
im assuming level has more to do with mobs MR than it does dexterity but i dunno
Yeah I don't know that formula tbh. It may well be imbalanced. I leveled a sorc to 15 on lvl appropriate mobs and it was quite easy iirc (but that was also 23 int).
if spell damage is being lowered the inaffect rate definitely needs changed.
I 'am' changing up the damage a little on spells on to too. I think the variance is a little strong when it comes to some spells, so some spells might have an overall average boosted by a few points rather than max (I'm talking about 3-6 damage for the most case).
8)
Not lowered. Not sure where you got that.
Honestly, I've seen no issues with uneffect when its comes to mob combat though either. If you having unaffect issues leveling, switch mobs. There are alot more mobs with low wisdom then monsters with low AGI. Not all mobs will be suited to each. For example, undead works good with clerics/pallies.
im not saying its highly problematic to stay on lumbering bears(usually hit them steady at 12+) etc until you are level 15, the fact is if you try to power level a mage it is all unaffects, mind you melee characters do miss quite a bit more aswell, its just not nearly as much when compared to magic. like my lvl 14 goblin sorc for instance ran to GY and had unnaffected 4 waterskins worth of mana in a row going with div bonus. maybe i should have used orbs and went 100000 in debt. that was one i just blamed on 17 int, i later deleted and went gnome to test and it was the same bs. it isnt a problem because getting to 20 is so relatively short in general.
im not saying anything has to be changed at all. just as it sits for me id much rather train a 2nd 3rd 4th 5th even a 6th monk opposed to a mage. once i have every good race of monk and cover the divs i don't need a mage anyway, or anything else for that matter. is what it is.
im not saying anything has to be changed at all. just as it sits for me id much rather train a 2nd 3rd 4th 5th even a 6th monk opposed to a mage. once i have every good race of monk and cover the divs i don't need a mage anyway, or anything else for that matter. is what it is.
lvl 14 goblin sorc
ran to GY
unnaffected
funny
about the same as:
Half orc
level 12
Hits 40% of the time.
wait no it isnt.
about the same as:
Half orc
level 12
Hits 40% of the time.
wait no it isnt.
Yeah. Graveyard is a level 21-23 area I think. You will die and stuggle alot there. Specially with lower int, 17 INT isn't terrible but its not good either. You'd have to pick targets more specifically.
At level 15 with 17 int against a level 24 monster with 15 wis (rotting dead for example in the graveyard) you'd have a unaffect rate of 70%.
At level 21 its about 55%.
If you had more int i.e. 22int, its around 58% at level 15, and then 35% at level 21.
I'd say it is a little high when it comes to monsters but regardless you'll stuggle in GY at such low levels.
At level 15 with 17 int against a level 24 monster with 15 wis (rotting dead for example in the graveyard) you'd have a unaffect rate of 70%.
At level 21 its about 55%.
If you had more int i.e. 22int, its around 58% at level 15, and then 35% at level 21.
I'd say it is a little high when it comes to monsters but regardless you'll stuggle in GY at such low levels.
unaffect rates are worse than i even imagined, no wonder noone strays off the elf/gnomes.
as if fizzles and lower damage weren't enough to make you play a staple, you have to unaffect more to...
magic should be more steady than melee, seeing you have to deal with mana. i dont see how a character with the worst possible agility can hit.(not sure if its just because its a 19) Characters and monsters have MR for free, physical resistance im assuming is armor? if anything. which isnt free. a lvl 14 killing a lvl 20 monster should just have modified damage(lower hits) seems too many things going against that 1 int stat, preventing any sort of build options out of normal. more reason to use my monks.
i gotta ask, Bro, why are there even character options if they all suck? atleast just lock all the sh!t ones and give a noob a heads up.
as if fizzles and lower damage weren't enough to make you play a staple, you have to unaffect more to...
magic should be more steady than melee, seeing you have to deal with mana. i dont see how a character with the worst possible agility can hit.(not sure if its just because its a 19) Characters and monsters have MR for free, physical resistance im assuming is armor? if anything. which isnt free. a lvl 14 killing a lvl 20 monster should just have modified damage(lower hits) seems too many things going against that 1 int stat, preventing any sort of build options out of normal. more reason to use my monks.
i gotta ask, Bro, why are there even character options if they all suck? atleast just lock all the sh!t ones and give a noob a heads up.
unaffect rates are worse than i even imagined, no wonder noone strays off the elf/gnomes.
as if fizzles and lower damage weren't enough to make you play a staple, you have to unaffect more to...
magic should be more steady than melee, seeing you have to deal with mana. i dont see how a character with the worst possible agility can hit.(not sure if its just because its a 19) Characters and monsters have MR for free, physical resistance im assuming is armor? if anything. which isnt free. a lvl 14 killing a lvl 20 monster should just have modified damage(lower hits) seems too many things going against that 1 int stat, preventing any sort of build options out of normal. more reason to use my monks.
i gotta ask, Bro, why are there even character options if they all suck? atleast just lock all the sh!t ones and give a noob a heads up.
Monsters have no MR bonus, it's just based off their wisdom. Physical resistance is armor yeah.
I'd say it's important to have at least 20 int for most cases, as of now, yeah.
Nothing is locked. Nothing will be locked though either.
The actual unaffect rates might need looking at, but yeah, INT is both unaffect and power, it's important when your a spell caster.
I'm not even sure what your talking about with the level 14 kiling a level 20 monster. What monster are you implying? What character?
Only modified damage for int? That's not going to happen, sorry. It's INT vs WIS generally.
its really not worth doing anything, u can hop in a party and skip all of it in an hour or two.
i like to solo train, it isnt nearly as appealing on mage.
hopefully, the wiki will be completed soon and i can read on there that a 17 int mage will suck, which is almost implied, just the level of suck isnt explained. i like rare and odd characters, but at the same time they need to be semi use-able. the grind has no bearing on me, i played a mud that requires 5 billion ish exp for max level at a rate of 4-12m per hour based on class and monster exp. this one seems almost too fast for relative stuff to do.
so anyway, i will stop wasting your time so you can implement.
i like to solo train, it isnt nearly as appealing on mage.
hopefully, the wiki will be completed soon and i can read on there that a 17 int mage will suck, which is almost implied, just the level of suck isnt explained. i like rare and odd characters, but at the same time they need to be semi use-able. the grind has no bearing on me, i played a mud that requires 5 billion ish exp for max level at a rate of 4-12m per hour based on class and monster exp. this one seems almost too fast for relative stuff to do.
so anyway, i will stop wasting your time so you can implement.
Are slayer Backstabs hit rate the same as a regular hit for all classes?
I get what Adra is saying I have a 23 agi and 22 agi slayer and the win rate versus other fighting classes is subpar, but I haven't put enough testing into this, but the feeling I had was because I had to hit 3 Backstabs most of the time to kill players on neutral Div and that meant 3 clean hits, I was left with the impression that absorbs were being the problem since 1/3 Backstabs were being absorbed and doing shit for damage, I will test it some more later.
I get what Adra is saying I have a 23 agi and 22 agi slayer and the win rate versus other fighting classes is subpar, but I haven't put enough testing into this, but the feeling I had was because I had to hit 3 Backstabs most of the time to kill players on neutral Div and that meant 3 clean hits, I was left with the impression that absorbs were being the problem since 1/3 Backstabs were being absorbed and doing shit for damage, I will test it some more later.
In terms of the actual INT decrease per for unaffects, it should probably be lower then it is when it goes for unaffects. Wisdom is overall fine cause otherwise it would mean everyone would have increased wis at lower wis levels which we don't want. High wisdom = hard time breaking it. But the damage loss I think is fine as it is.
But I mean, theres going to be better characters then a goblin for it. Just like why you wouldn't use a gnome for combat classes either.
They are the same hit rate yeah.
But saying that you have to hide and backstab is lower damage is eh. If your hit rate is 50%, it's 50% with 5 attacks, or 500 attacks. the average hit rate doesn't change.
On top of that you aren't simply getting 2x damage, you get 4x or around 4.5x DWing.
But I mean, theres going to be better characters then a goblin for it. Just like why you wouldn't use a gnome for combat classes either.
Are slayer Backstabs hit rate the same as a regular hit for all classes?
I get what Audra is saying I have a 23 agi and 22 agi slayer and the win rate versus other fighting classes is subpar, but I haven't put enough testing into this, but the feeling I had was because I had to hit 3 Backstabs most of the time to kill players on neutral Div and that meant 3 clean hits, I was left with the impression that absorbs were being the problem since 1/3 Backstabs were being absorbed and doing shit for damage, I will test it some more later.
They are the same hit rate yeah.
But saying that you have to hide and backstab is lower damage is eh. If your hit rate is 50%, it's 50% with 5 attacks, or 500 attacks. the average hit rate doesn't change.
On top of that you aren't simply getting 2x damage, you get 4x or around 4.5x DWing.
I will do some testing tonight but I think every 4-5 rounds stabing you lose a round versus other classes that don't move.
Anyway I have a lot of impressions over why they could be losing but I'm not entirely sure on anything honestly.
Anyway I have a lot of impressions over why they could be losing but I'm not entirely sure on anything honestly.
I will do some testing tonight but I think every 4-5 rounds stabing you lose a round versus other classes that don't move.
Anyway I have a lot of impressions over why they could be losing but I'm not entirely sure on anything honestly.
You are also doing more damage overall for compensation of slowness though.
I'd wait until the changes are in effect for things too though, theres a hefty amount of changes coming.